Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it’s ok for my DD to walk school?

315 replies

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 07/03/2024 20:13

I have been offered a job but my 9 year old DD (soon to be 10) would need to walk to school alone. It is a mile away. I would need to leave the house at 7.30 to get to work but the out of hours club provided by school doesn’t open until 8. I am a single parent and do not know anyone who would be able to pick her up from our house and drop her off at school. I have a 14 year old DD also who is super sensible but goes to a different school so she would be looking after him until he has to walk to school. Her school is in the opposite direction so she can’t walk her halfway or anything.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SpringSprungALeak · 09/03/2024 22:15

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 08/03/2024 19:21

I had to decline the job. Heartbroken 💔

@alwaysgonnaloveyou

oh, why did you do that? Was it just DD's commute one day a week? Or other reasons??

SpringSprungALeak · 09/03/2024 22:13

muddyford · 08/03/2024 06:35

I presume there are footpaths and streetlights? Would cycling be a possibility?

@muddyford I'd be fine with her walking, but no way would I allow her to cycle. Better/safer in her feet!!

TheSnowyOwl · 09/03/2024 14:46

No wonder we have so many young adults who are incapable of looking after themselves given so many think a Y5 can’t walk a mile without having their hand held.

candyisdandybutliquorisquicker · 09/03/2024 14:46

LessOfMe99 · 07/03/2024 20:20

  • 14 yr old is only just old enough to be responsible for themself in this scenario- not fair to make them responsible for a 10 year old.

You think a 14 year old is only just old enough to get themselves ready for school and lock a door behind them?

Bellsandthistle · 09/03/2024 14:44

VivaDixie · 09/03/2024 14:23

I actually doubt she has declined the job because of MN. This thread had fairly balanced views either way. But we will never know as the responses are snippy one liners with no engagement and no way of knowing whats what.

I didn't see any 'slapping down' too. Just posters answering the questions as per the initial request.

What “snippy one liners” are you referring to?

VivaDixie · 09/03/2024 14:23

I actually doubt she has declined the job because of MN. This thread had fairly balanced views either way. But we will never know as the responses are snippy one liners with no engagement and no way of knowing whats what.

I didn't see any 'slapping down' too. Just posters answering the questions as per the initial request.

Bellsandthistle · 09/03/2024 13:50

VivaDixie · 08/03/2024 21:20

Goodness this thread is exhausting - there is no real engagement from the OP, as I said earlier - a decent informative OP followed by snippy one liners and refusal to answer relevant questions etc. I am starting to wonder if this is all about the drama......

Is it not feasible to you that a mother working hard to improve her children’s lives and who got smacked down repeatedly by overly precious and privileged posters informing her she was being irresponsible and should simply find another job or change her hours doesn’t want to ‘engage’ much?
This is sadly pretty typical for mumsnet and does make you realise how detached from reality many people responding to these posts are.
Now she’s gone and declined the job.
I hope those posters feel appropriately self-righteous… 😒

Helfs · 09/03/2024 07:39

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 08/03/2024 19:21

I had to decline the job. Heartbroken 💔

Why? Honestly it’s fine. People on MN are weirdly ott about this

Catopia · 09/03/2024 07:20

Secondaryappealhelp · 07/03/2024 20:19

It's too young for me. I'm considering this with my youngest in September as oldest has a secondary place they need a lift to leaving at 8, youngest needs to be at school by 8.45 so DH won't be back in time from school drop to get him there (roughly 25min drive each way hopefully but can be longer) and I work so if I don't want to reduce days an option is we leave him at home and ask a friend to call on their way to school (unlikely as will be making a detour) or we leave him at home to walk. I really don't think he's old enough and so I've crossed it off the options!

Or you drop him at the friend or childminder's house en route so that he's not on his own.
Or you take him to school first on the way to the secondary school and he goes to breakfast club.

OP - I think you either need another plan - like you drop her at a friend's house and friend's parent does the school run - or you need to negotiate your hours with this job if you are going to take it I'm afraid. 9 is too young - not necessarily because they aren't sensible, but because they are a vulnerable target to people who might not have good intentions, particularly if walking the same route at the same time every day.

consideringachange · 09/03/2024 06:21

Just for perspective OP this would be normal in central Paris where we live. The average UK attitude is more cautious but the UK is unusual in this respect. My (just) 9 year old walks to lots of local things on his own.

Natsku · 09/03/2024 06:15

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 21:26

I really hope you haven't declined the job because of the negative comments, it is perfectly normal and acceptable even in the UK for a 9, nearly 10 year old child to walk to school alone every day, let alone just once a week.

No. It really really isn't normal. Or acceptable. It was in the 80's when lots of kids were walking.

If I saw or knew of a child that age walking alone to school along busy roads on their own, I would flag it as a safeguarding issue.

You could flag it as a safeguarding issue but unless they're walking along fast country roads with no footpath, or have to cross a busy dual carriageway or similar (or there's SEN involved), then SS will not be interested because its not actually a safeguarding issue, because 9 year olds are perfectly capable of walking a mile alone if they are taught road safety properly.

Natsku · 09/03/2024 06:12

PansyOatZebra · 08/03/2024 21:15

I think it’s the distance for me.

I was a 5 minute walk from my primary school and I think 9/10 years is fine for that but 1 mile seems too far.

1 mile is a 20 minute walk, that's not far at all!

AliceMcK · 08/03/2024 23:18

Kalevala · 08/03/2024 22:25

Call the school (that's offered you the job) back first thing in the morning, say you were very concerned about your own school drop offs, but have managed to work something out, so would love to take the job, if it's still an option!

Yes, please do this OP. Don't give up this opportunity!

This, please op. There is a way round this.

Currently we struggle with drop offs so we have to find a work around, we leave our 9 & 6yo at school at 8.30, we could send them into breakfast club but they want to hang around with their friends. School rules are not to leave children before the gates open 8.45 but most of the parents there know us and are happy to watch them, the older one dosnt need supervision but I like knowing the younger one dose have it, my 9yo would happily stay with her sister but I ask parents I know to keep an eye on her. On speaking to another parent one day she offered that we just drop at her house, she’s walking her 2 to school anyway so said just shove them through her front door and our 9yos can walk if they want and she can walk the two 6yos.

one day I had to leave earlier than usual, my 6yo was off sick so i dropped my 9yo further away from school, she wanted to walk, she’d had practise last year walking with her sister and it was a straight walk to the school, one fairly busy road that’s suppose to have a lollipop person, I told her if there wasn’t one as is more often the case she had to wait for another parent and ask to cross with them. The crossing is right outside school. Some of my 9yo Yr5 DDs friends have been walking since beginning of year 4 but they live a lot closer to the school than us.

StarDolphins · 08/03/2024 22:28

Y5 for 1 day a week is absolutely fine imo. She’s nearly 10. There are 8/9 year olds walking to school near me.

How does she feel about it?

Kalevala · 08/03/2024 22:25

Call the school (that's offered you the job) back first thing in the morning, say you were very concerned about your own school drop offs, but have managed to work something out, so would love to take the job, if it's still an option!

Yes, please do this OP. Don't give up this opportunity!

456pickupsticks · 08/03/2024 22:12

Absolutely fine for a 9 year old to walk to school alone one day a week! It's summer, it's light from 7am, school will ring you if she doesn't turn up. I've not heard of a school which doesn't allow year 6 children to walk alone, so you're only 6 months off what's considered the norm anyway. [As you've not indicated you've got concerns for her actual safety - would be a different answer if you'd said you did]
My only concern would be if she's used to the route and used to walking, but that's easily fixed by walking the route to school in prep (if grandparents are doing the rest of the day, then this may be something to ask them to do too).

Yes there are other things you could consider too (as per other posters, asking if a friends parents would have her for an hour before school, taxis, pocket money for older sibling to walk her to breakfast club, etc).

Call the school (that's offered you the job) back first thing in the morning, say you were very concerned about your own school drop offs, but have managed to work something out, so would love to take the job, if it's still an option!

I know several local parents here who have similar arrangements around 'I will take both girls to school if you drop Bessy off here an hour before school' and 'I'll bring both girls to ours for a bit, and drop them both off at Ballet'. If you're able to offer something in return this will probably be great for another parent who can't finish in time for after school club!

Kalevala · 08/03/2024 21:59

SlipperyFish11 · 08/03/2024 21:13

No, but they're more likely to walk with friends at that age or catch a bus.

They walked with friends when my teenager was 9/10. Some of the walk may have been alone for children living further out but there were many others walking as you got closer. Adults around with younger children too. It's not a lone child walking all the way to school with no-one around.

TheSnowyOwl · 08/03/2024 21:59

potato57 · 08/03/2024 09:04

Red flag if the job won't let you start a half hour late for one day for a year or two. It's going to be the kind of culture that doesn't value their staff at all, and you'll be doing unpaid overtime and out of hours favours because it's an "emergency" and having to compromise on which annual leave days you have before you know it. I've worked in places like that and they aren't happy if your kid is sick and you have to leave early, they forbid staff from leaving the building at all if there's a deadline no matter how long it takes, etc.

It’s a school. It’s not a red flag for a school to expect teachers to work during teaching hours and have the school holidays as annual leave.

MigGirl · 08/03/2024 21:52

I would book her into breakfast club and get her to walk in on her own. DS was doing this in year 6 (because he wanted to and it wasn't cool for me to drop him off) and in our area they alow year 4 children to leave on their own with parents permission as we used to be a middle school area and all middle school children year 5&6 would be going to school and home on their own. Often more than a mile away.

And to be honest I would have thought it to young before we moved here. But then when DD started primary and I found they let the years 4 home on their own I was a bit 😳. But it was getting them ready for middle school in year 5. And I just wasn't used to it as hadn't grown up with middle schools. It's actually perfectly fine and totally normal round here.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 08/03/2024 21:41

SlipperyFish11 · 08/03/2024 21:13

No, but they're more likely to walk with friends at that age or catch a bus.

I guess, it depends where you live. I grew up in London where kids travel all over the city for secondary school and often alone. I don’t think being on the bus is any help anyway - the vast majority of unpleasant experiences my friends and I had were on public transport, or being followed by someone getting off the same tube/bus stop.

AliceMcK · 08/03/2024 21:40

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 08/03/2024 19:21

I had to decline the job. Heartbroken 💔

Sorry to hear that. I was going to say it is very common around here for children 9 and even younger to walk to and from school.

My 9yo hasn’t needed to walk home on her home yet but I’ve let her walk to a friends together most weeks. We live further away from school than most so our journey is a bit longer. She dose walk home from the local pool when I take my youngest, it’s a small walk and she crosses 2 small roads. She walks home at the same time as the closest school kicks out so there are lots of kids and parents around. My DH is home so she rings the ring doorbell and waves to let him know she’s home and he messages me while I’m at the pool.

When my oldest started walking home in year 6 we got her an apple phone so we could track it. We looked at an apple tag but DH was due an upgrade so we could give DD his old phone.

Kalevala · 08/03/2024 21:39

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 21:26

I really hope you haven't declined the job because of the negative comments, it is perfectly normal and acceptable even in the UK for a 9, nearly 10 year old child to walk to school alone every day, let alone just once a week.

No. It really really isn't normal. Or acceptable. It was in the 80's when lots of kids were walking.

If I saw or knew of a child that age walking alone to school along busy roads on their own, I would flag it as a safeguarding issue.

It's very normal in my town. It was very normal when my teen was that age too.

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 21:26

I really hope you haven't declined the job because of the negative comments, it is perfectly normal and acceptable even in the UK for a 9, nearly 10 year old child to walk to school alone every day, let alone just once a week.

No. It really really isn't normal. Or acceptable. It was in the 80's when lots of kids were walking.

If I saw or knew of a child that age walking alone to school along busy roads on their own, I would flag it as a safeguarding issue.

CatamaranViper · 08/03/2024 21:21

It's the norm around here where I live for kids to walk to school themselves from the very end of yr 4 and definitely in middle school. But we live in a town so most of the kids live locally and they all walk down together (almost like a walking bus).

If there are no other kids walking, I'd be worried and probably say no.

VivaDixie · 08/03/2024 21:20

Goodness this thread is exhausting - there is no real engagement from the OP, as I said earlier - a decent informative OP followed by snippy one liners and refusal to answer relevant questions etc. I am starting to wonder if this is all about the drama......

Swipe left for the next trending thread