Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

it's unacceptable to to mock someone's accent

132 replies

nottooimpressed · 07/03/2024 17:59

I've lived in the UK for almost 30 years and I speak 5 languages fluently. Yet, despite having a top degree from a UK uni and having worked in the UK for decades, I still have a very strong foreign accent and I find the pronunciation of some English words challenging, for example "paw", "wood" etc... My kids (UK born and with perfect British accents) mock me frequently and yesterday, when we talked at dinner and I said something about walking in the "woods" I got mocked again and I exploded. It's not the first time I got upset about it but yesterday I really had enough. I found it so offensive that kids would mock their mother about her foreign accent and pronunciation (the same mother who taught them to read and still helps them with their senior school essays...) and that my British husband did nothing about it and let them do it. I often meet Scottish or Irish people who keep their strong accents despite being in London for decades. It seems acceptable. Why is my accent laughable then? What is acceptable and what is not? Am I too sensitive or are they behaving like little twats? What does it say about my husband?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
anonima · 08/03/2024 14:08

I remember a monolingual work colleague once started making fun of a customer's accent and level of English (after the customer had gone) and my response to him was just "Remind me how many languages you speak again?". Oh just one? Eejit.

NotMyPage · 08/03/2024 14:02

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/03/2024 11:34

This is a time you very dryly say "I taught you how to use the potty so don't criticise my speech" roll your eyes and ignore. Children always think they know everything 🙄😂

I like this approach. It's no use getting upset in front of your cheeky teens. You've got to keep the upper hand and be a bit above it all then they won't find it so funny. They have found your weak spot and are poking as annoying teenagers do. Whenever mine get cheeky with me and act as if I don't know anything important, am old or whatever, I just heartily agree and add something like 'I know I'm ancient, but I love the fact that I'm not GenZ' or 'I love my greying hair, it's sooooo Cottgaecore' or something similarly ridiculous and usually they just cringe and laugh and it is all light hearted.

Could you try flipping it? When they laugh at you saying 'paw' wrongly you just ask them to teach you. Then you keep saying it wrong in lots of different ways and keep going until they get fed up with it and move on. You can add, 'oh, pleeeeease teach me, I really want to learn, let's try again' and you say it exaggeratedly wrong again. You can then conclude by saying 'well I tried my best but it is hopeless, what use is being able to say 'paw' in 5 languages if I cannot pronounce it received pronunciation?' Just exaggerate and annoy them back. It all sounds too serious, it needn't be in your own family.

Blouseybiggal · 08/03/2024 13:45

The main thing is if YOU don’t like it then they should have enough respect not to do it. End of discussion.

notacooldad · 08/03/2024 13:36

Although I am not from a different country I am from a different county from my husband and boys. My accent is significantly different and sometimes I use different words for things.

I get mocked mercilessly from all of them. If you can't beat them join them!
My lads and Dh have a very strong northern accent and when they are dishing it out to me I am straight back at them with stereotypical northern comments such as 'oh shut up and sort your ferret out' 'Back from t' pit I see' and other nonsense.

I know OP, that you said you can't say 'paw' . I can never say 'Shut up' I sound like Joe Dolce when he sings 'Shaddup your face!' ( google, if it is well before your time!!) I get 'What's that mum, Shad.......what?' and so on.

My office has 5 different accents, including American, Scouse and Geordie.
The banter is good natured and everyone cops for it. We all give back what we get.

Are your kids being deliberately malicious and what are they like behaviour wise. Personally as I said I join in and mock back and don't take it as being disrespectful or a personal attack. If you don't want to do that you need to explain rather than explode at them and give them a deep dive as to why you are upset.

PaperDoIIs · 08/03/2024 12:52

@EternalSunshine19 it is that deep when OP doesn't like it, she told her family to stop and they keep doing it.

Would you say the same if they laughed at her for being a woman, or something about her physical appearance, or the colour of her skin?

It's irrelevant what you and your partner do. OP doesn't like it.

brunettemic · 08/03/2024 12:04

Clearly the issue here isn’t your accent, either that or you’re hugely sensitive. Feels more like a build up of things. I don’t live where I’m from and there’s often wordplace banter about accents, including mine.

Blouseybiggal · 08/03/2024 11:57

It’s a very English thing I think to make fun of other people just for not having an English accent.

Blouseybiggal · 08/03/2024 11:56

I feel your pain, OP. I have a regional accent which people where I live find either ‘ cute’ or take the piss. It’s annoying.
So when MY children started doing the same, mimicking or correcting my dialect I sat them down and explained why Indont like it and wouldn’t accept it from them.
I also pointed out that THEIR accents sound odd to me but I don’t make fun of them. Tempting as it is at times…

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 08/03/2024 11:53

@GrouchyKiwi if you listened to a scottish person saying those two names you would hear the difference. scots pronounce their A's as "a" like "a" house, the english seem to pronounce it as "eh" especially if they are upper class

NovemberAutumn · 08/03/2024 11:53

OP I am Australian and people in the UK mimic me or mock me very frequently and I bloody hate it. It's rude and disrespectful.

My older son is 13 and can mimic me absolutely perfectly - THIS I actually love because he is doing it out of love and good humour. The day will come I am sure when he mimics me to be an obnoxious little shit and I absolutely will point out where the line is.

So in short, I sympathise.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 11:53

Usually though OP mocking or teasing within a family can come from a place of love and comfort and in jokes. Perhaps they believe you are expressing faux outrage as part of the same joke. I would raise it as a discussion at a time when it hasn't happened explaining how it upsets and distresses you and that you need to get it off your chest.

If it was a colleague or stranger then yes I would say its definitely wrong to mock but within a family dynamic without knowing whether you are living in an abusive situation and without full facts it may be just teasing and they really don't realise that you mean it when you bite back.

Bruisername · 08/03/2024 11:50

Tbf my French and German accents have been mocked by strangers/friends in the respective countries so I don’t think it’s uniquely a British thing

PurplePansy05 · 08/03/2024 11:46

YADNBU, OP. I am bilingual (well, multilingual like you, but I consider myself bilingual in my two primary languages) and this behaviour annoys the hell out of me. You mostly get it in the UK, it's considered rude in most European countries (and I agree). I am with you wholeheartedly. Only Brits smirk and ridicule foreign names too, this would be incredibly rude and unacceptable in Europe.

GrouchyKiwi · 08/03/2024 11:44

nottooimpressed · 07/03/2024 17:59

I've lived in the UK for almost 30 years and I speak 5 languages fluently. Yet, despite having a top degree from a UK uni and having worked in the UK for decades, I still have a very strong foreign accent and I find the pronunciation of some English words challenging, for example "paw", "wood" etc... My kids (UK born and with perfect British accents) mock me frequently and yesterday, when we talked at dinner and I said something about walking in the "woods" I got mocked again and I exploded. It's not the first time I got upset about it but yesterday I really had enough. I found it so offensive that kids would mock their mother about her foreign accent and pronunciation (the same mother who taught them to read and still helps them with their senior school essays...) and that my British husband did nothing about it and let them do it. I often meet Scottish or Irish people who keep their strong accents despite being in London for decades. It seems acceptable. Why is my accent laughable then? What is acceptable and what is not? Am I too sensitive or are they behaving like little twats? What does it say about my husband?

I agree.

IME you can join in with the joke for a bit, but it gets wearying after years of the same thing and I'm not surprised you find it hurtful and annoying.

My children are much younger than yours and I'm trying to teach them that even if Mum says "black" funny, or asks for a "pin" instead of a "pen" you just act as if you've heard the correct pronunciation.

I've been here 17 years and still can't hear the difference between Ellis and Alice, btw. Wink

TheCadoganArms · 08/03/2024 11:40

I speak basic conversational French, not fluent but I can hold my own and my occasional mangling of words often causes amusement to my French friends. I just use such occasions as a mini lesson and my French friends are happy to hold my hand and walk me through a correct pronunciation.

Bruisername · 08/03/2024 11:35

have you read the OPs posts? She clearly says she laughs along but at times it is disrespectful and belittling

this isn’t just a harmless family joke because she isn’t finding it funny and it doesn’t matter if other people would find it funny. That’s been the defence to offensive banter for years ‘oh lighten up, can’t you take a joke?’ Well she didn’t find it funny this time because she was trying to make a serious point which was completely ignored so they could have a laugh at her pronounciation. It’s time and place.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/03/2024 11:34

This is a time you very dryly say "I taught you how to use the potty so don't criticise my speech" roll your eyes and ignore. Children always think they know everything 🙄😂

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 08/03/2024 11:29

@nottooimpressed can you write down what they say they hear when you are saying the words they laugh at?? using the syllables as they sound

EternalSunshine19 · 08/03/2024 11:22

BMW6 · 07/03/2024 18:04

I've not voted either way because neither is correct.

Joshing about mispronounced words / accents is universal and usually not meant to hurt.

I think you would be happier if you could learn to laugh rather than get angry and upset.

Completely agree. You need to be less sensitive and insecure. There's no such thing as "perfect british accents". Britain has so many regional accents; i'm cockney (born in Whitechapel and grew up in Poplar). My fiancé is from Sunderland and has a Mackem accent. We regularly take the mick out of the way we pronounce words. Its not that deep

NotMyPage · 08/03/2024 11:14

But... we don't know if OP's family always act rudely and without empathy. Just in relation to OP getting annoyed about the kids making fun of her pronunciation. Does OP get as annoyed when her dc make fun about something else related to OP? Because, you know teens... they do like to annoy their parents. So far OP has just said they make fun of her accent she hasn't said they are rude and horrible across the board.

What some of us are pointing out is that having a foreign accent always stand out, there is really not much you can do about this. There will always be people who treat you as if you are stupid or look at you in a perplexed, confused and even horrified way when they realise you are not 'from here'. 😂I don't let this bother me. My kids correct my pronunciation but and sometimes they will make fun of me. If all is well otherwise in the family, people normally withstand this sort of thing. However if OP feel unloved by what may be generally rude and unempathetic children and husband I can understand that she would be fed up. But she hasn't said that her family are like this, just that they find her accent a bit funny.

Brefugee · 08/03/2024 11:10

again, the point being that you don't care. OP does and yet they carry on.

As I said before I'd be speaking a language they don't understand and basically leaving them to fend for themselves (including DH) until they stop it. The lack of respect from her children and the man who apparently loves her is staggering.

Oganesson118 · 08/03/2024 11:09

My accent gets mocked by southern colleagues all the time. I don’t really care. I’m erring on the side of YABU because if it’s meant in jest and the person is not easily offended by it then it’s no different from other friendly teasing.

Brefugee · 08/03/2024 11:07

NotMyPage · 08/03/2024 10:58

Did you read my post before posting this? The bit where I said this

I'm the same and have made peace with perpetually being a foreigner due to my native accent. It certainly doesn't bother me and has taught me to not care so much about what other people think and how they perceive me. I'm happy to be a bit different and get reward with an interesting life that's not in my birth country. Why does it matter so much to you that you have an accent?

Having read my post, how can you ask ‘Do you speak any foreign languages or have an accent? would you just suck it up without being upset?’ I mean it's written right there.

I can't imagine being so wound up by my children teasing me. Tease them back, or explain. If they always act rudely and without empathy including the husband, then OP has bigger problems.

Edited

she does have bigger problems. Well bloody done for spotting what lots of us have been saying for pages now.

If her children, with the support of her DH, are insulting her without any consideration for her feelings - there are huge problems.

And none of the "oh just accept it" bollocks that anyone has posted will cut it.

Laurama91 · 08/03/2024 11:02

I get laughed at at work. Im English and from East yorkshire, I work in South Yorkshire. I tell them its not my fault they can't speak correctly or that they come from the wrong yorkshire. It soon shuts them up.

NotMyPage · 08/03/2024 10:58

Brefugee · 08/03/2024 10:42

OP doesn't have to accept anyone taking the piss out of her language skills/pronunciation.

It isn't gentle fun poking in 2 directions, it is her children (and DH) behaving disrespectfully.

Do you speak any foreign languages or have an accent? would you just suck it up without being upset? (more fool you if the answer is "yes"). As pp say "it's only a joke if everyone is laughing"

Did you read my post before posting this? The bit where I said this

I'm the same and have made peace with perpetually being a foreigner due to my native accent. It certainly doesn't bother me and has taught me to not care so much about what other people think and how they perceive me. I'm happy to be a bit different and get reward with an interesting life that's not in my birth country. Why does it matter so much to you that you have an accent?

Having read my post, how can you ask ‘Do you speak any foreign languages or have an accent? would you just suck it up without being upset?’ I mean it's written right there.

I can't imagine being so wound up by my children teasing me. Tease them back, or explain. If they always act rudely and without empathy including the husband, then OP has bigger problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread