Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why (if MN is to be believed) parents so bad at disciplining their kids?

63 replies

NoNailsPls · 07/03/2024 16:46

Is it because the parents themselves are rule breakers/entitled/hate authority?

Or is it because they can't fathom their kids have faults and so even if they're proven to be a problem the parents back the kids up instead of the school? (I've seen this myself and can't understand the logic....)

(Inspired by the locked toilet thread)

Are the grandparents actually to blame? What happened at what time to make this generation of parents so ineffectual?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 07/03/2024 21:15

I think I gave up thinking about it when I see people write 'it's normal for 2 year olds to destroy the place and write on wallls' type posts

No it isn't!

losthj · 07/03/2024 21:13

Jeez @TheFancyPoet that's harsh.

Child loses parent, other parent tries everything to get them to school and you say?

I'm glad you kept that sort of person out of school? And you should be as well?

That goes against every mothering instinct in me. Awful.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 07/03/2024 21:11

I think sometimes gentle parenting is taken a bit too far so boundaries can be non existent.

But I think generally it comes from a good place and parents trying to do the best for their kids.

LolaSmiles · 07/03/2024 21:11

Lots of parents have moved away from authoritarian approaches to disciplinary, which is a good thing imo.

It is a lot of hard work though to parent authoritatively (boundaries, respect, consistently, acknowledging the child's feelings without giving in) so some parents find it easier to be permissive. It's also a lot of hard work to work on yourself to promote healthier relationships and healthy communication between adult and children. Many people are trying to do this and do a reasonable job.

Permissive parents tend to do a range of these things: lack boundaries when their children are younger, give children age-inappropriate levels of control and responsibility, think their child is their friend, think being a good parent means they make their child happy all the time, doesn't want to be the person who says 'no'. I understand why because this is all easier when they're younger, but there's long term consequences.

EasterJumperyA · 07/03/2024 21:10

I think they turn a blind eye to it.
Ive seen several stand there (one while child threw stone at a cat and car) and not intervene.
Its tricky though as you want the child to realise themself and behave even when you arent there.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 21:09

Mnk711 · 07/03/2024 21:03

I'm absolutely not someone that believes in physical punishment but if you do end up with an out of control violent teen I wonder how you physically are expected to control them? Perhaps in previous generations physical threat even if not generally used kept young people in line more? That said my 70 year old parents both recall going to (separate) schools where the kids ripped the classrooms apart and teachers were either extremely violently authoritarian or hiding under their desks (literally on occasion).

My friend had a very problematic kid who at 16 she eventually had to throw out of the house because she couldn't manage him. She couldn't sanction him in any way or enforce boundaries as he'd just ignore her/snatch back things she tried to take/barge through doors she would try to lock etc. He ended up in a very bad way and is now in prison for life having been ensnared by gangs whilst without a proper home. She has two other well behaved young adults now and brought them up in the same way. I struggle to see what she could have done differently. If you don't fear or respect your parents and you are going through teenage brain remodelling which means you don't experience empathy or love as you should, what can be done to keep them in line? A genuine question rather than a push for corporal punishment, to be clear.

There are many ways to control a violent teen. Most local authorities provide NVR training for this very reason.

Your friend sounds like an abhorrent person. Kicking her child out of the home where he then fell into gangs (most likely due to having no one else) and is now in prison. Disgusting

Mumma2024 · 07/03/2024 21:06

I think an awful lot is placed on modern families. Most families need two, full time working parents. Then there is so many vocal voices about how to raise your kids and that if you do xx you are an awful parent but if you do the opposite you are also an awful parent. The relatively recent rise of technology and social media added a new dynamic that this current generation of parents didn't have experience of or role models on how to manage when they were teen. There's a lack of proper parenting support and a horrible vocal view that firm boundaries and consequences (by some) are touted as abusive.

It's a toxic minefield.

Granted though, we must be doing something right when you look at many of the stats.

fabio12 · 07/03/2024 21:04

I used to get shouted at all the time at school (boarder) and was always picked up on everything; messy, late, forgot homework, looked like I hadn't brushed my hair...on and on from 6 to 16. I have extremely low self esteem as a result and even though I had an expensive education I was thoroughly undermined for 10 formative years of my life and frequently deliberately humiliated in front of my friends.

I would never do that to DC and as a result they are very confident, capable and kind young people.

Mnk711 · 07/03/2024 21:03

I'm absolutely not someone that believes in physical punishment but if you do end up with an out of control violent teen I wonder how you physically are expected to control them? Perhaps in previous generations physical threat even if not generally used kept young people in line more? That said my 70 year old parents both recall going to (separate) schools where the kids ripped the classrooms apart and teachers were either extremely violently authoritarian or hiding under their desks (literally on occasion).

My friend had a very problematic kid who at 16 she eventually had to throw out of the house because she couldn't manage him. She couldn't sanction him in any way or enforce boundaries as he'd just ignore her/snatch back things she tried to take/barge through doors she would try to lock etc. He ended up in a very bad way and is now in prison for life having been ensnared by gangs whilst without a proper home. She has two other well behaved young adults now and brought them up in the same way. I struggle to see what she could have done differently. If you don't fear or respect your parents and you are going through teenage brain remodelling which means you don't experience empathy or love as you should, what can be done to keep them in line? A genuine question rather than a push for corporal punishment, to be clear.

chinupoldchap · 07/03/2024 20:59

When my dc we're younger we had a lot of stick off our parents for being 'harsh' on them for naughty behaviour. Lots of 'oh he's only 3' etc.
Yes he was three but we were strict about behaviour and therefore now have a very well behaved 9 year old. He has asd and adhd and may be an exception to the norm but setting firm boundaries from a young age has worked for us.
I see mums struggling at the school gate getting kicked in the leg by their toddlers and barely blinking an eye. Just picking them up and cuddling them.
I'm all for each to their own and I don't know everyone's circumstances but from my very small world view I do see a lot less discipline. Even schools aren't disciplining like when I was in school, disruptive children are given iPads! (Again not the same everywhere just what I've seen)

mightydolphin · 07/03/2024 20:55

I think a lot of children in Gen Z have had more screen time than previous generations and struggle with paying attention, and this causes bad behaviour in school. Millennials had a fair amount of screen time too, but kids could still play out and kids TV was only on at certain times in the day.

The fact that kids have less time playing outdoors with friends (without their parents watching their every move) has caused kids to be more socially anxious than previous generations.

WinterMorn · 07/03/2024 20:51

Macaroni46 · 07/03/2024 19:09

Maybe we should go back to it (minus the physical punishments) as so many of today's children have no manners or stamina or resilience and are very entitled.

I could not agree more.

DrSpartacular · 07/03/2024 20:49

NoNailsPls · 07/03/2024 20:41

Based on the thread that this was in reference to I meant:

  • not destroying school property
  • not attacking other people
  • not pissing on the floor

What has changed that kids can do these things and the parents instead of being appalled when they hear will stick up for the child and be angry at the school for saying bad things about their kid?

So is this a TAAT?

Still not seeing your AIBU.

Seems you just want to bash mums.

Maryamlouise · 07/03/2024 20:44

I struggle because we are just going through an autism assessment and I feel like we need to find the strategies that work and are supportive and recognise when DS is acting the way he is because he is genuinely really struggling. There are things I choose to ignore that I am sure people judge me for but I try to focus on what is most important behaviour wise and creating a supportive environment. Even though he is young I don't think I could force him to do things he really doesn't want to do (most likely to be if he is having sensory issues) and not sure why I would - by working with him we have a far better relationship and achieve much more than strategies that others (class teachers, GPs) try that mean he just shuts down

CharSiu · 07/03/2024 20:43

People want to be friends with their children which is a big mistake.

NoNailsPls · 07/03/2024 20:41

DrSpartacular · 07/03/2024 19:33

@NoNailsPls Discipline means to teach, so what do you think parents should be teaching their children?

And, what's yours AIBU?

Based on the thread that this was in reference to I meant:

  • not destroying school property
  • not attacking other people
  • not pissing on the floor

What has changed that kids can do these things and the parents instead of being appalled when they hear will stick up for the child and be angry at the school for saying bad things about their kid?

OP posts:
Bex5490 · 07/03/2024 20:23

pjani · 07/03/2024 19:18

This generation of young people drink less, do fewer drugs, fewer teen pregnancies - on all sorts of indicators are a very sensible generation.

I honestly think people forget what kids were like in their own generation. I went to state schools in decent areas and kids smoked in late primary, first girl to get pregnant was 13, etc etc. Kids told teachers to fuck off in class, dropped out at 15, were illiterate. All kinds of stuff.

This.

Every generation gets old and suddenly thinks everyone younger is far worse than they were.

Data and statistics do not support this hypothesis.

And MN is not a an accurate barometer of how successful parenting is. Mum’s rarely make threads to say ‘Just wanted to let everyone know that I’m doing a great job of raising my kids, they are perfect and we’re all so happy.’

People post more for support and advice when things aren’t going great. 🤷🏽‍♀️

Helfs · 07/03/2024 19:36

Ariona · 07/03/2024 19:35

I can't believe this. I think you have this the other way around!

What’s hard to believe? @pjani posted basic facts

Ariona · 07/03/2024 19:35

pjani · 07/03/2024 19:18

This generation of young people drink less, do fewer drugs, fewer teen pregnancies - on all sorts of indicators are a very sensible generation.

I honestly think people forget what kids were like in their own generation. I went to state schools in decent areas and kids smoked in late primary, first girl to get pregnant was 13, etc etc. Kids told teachers to fuck off in class, dropped out at 15, were illiterate. All kinds of stuff.

I can't believe this. I think you have this the other way around!

Cafelattes · 07/03/2024 19:35

Disciplining is harder than not disciplining. It takes mental effort and willpower to stick to your guns in the face of a young child who is upset or angry at your consequences, and to stay calm yourself. It makes me sad to see my child upset even if I know they have to learn the boundaries, the hard way if necessary. I do get why people struggle.

coureur · 07/03/2024 19:35

Well in our experience the parents of the most badly behaved children are themselves utterly feral. They’re the ones who’ll park their (untaxed) pickup (those massive Ranger things) on the pavement, are banned from all the pubs in town, and challenge you to a fight if you even so much as glance at them. Luckily most of their children disappear from school by year 10 but they make life hell for everyone while they are there.

Octavia64 · 07/03/2024 19:33

I worked in a school.

Lots of parents of teens will tell you that "I can't do anything with him, can you try to talk to him".

Some parents of teens will say he would never do that. (We had cctv in many areas for this reason)

Some parents would say "I'm really sorry, he was attacked by another gang member with a knife and now he's impossible".

DrSpartacular · 07/03/2024 19:33

@NoNailsPls Discipline means to teach, so what do you think parents should be teaching their children?

And, what's yours AIBU?

Alwaysgoingforit · 07/03/2024 19:29

Some of the problems stem from the fact that some parents try to be friends with their dc, esp. young teens.
Your friend doesn't tell you to do your homework or be home by 10 o'clock.

TheFancyPoet · 07/03/2024 19:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.