Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why (if MN is to be believed) parents so bad at disciplining their kids?

63 replies

NoNailsPls · 07/03/2024 16:46

Is it because the parents themselves are rule breakers/entitled/hate authority?

Or is it because they can't fathom their kids have faults and so even if they're proven to be a problem the parents back the kids up instead of the school? (I've seen this myself and can't understand the logic....)

(Inspired by the locked toilet thread)

Are the grandparents actually to blame? What happened at what time to make this generation of parents so ineffectual?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hagchic · 08/03/2024 11:20

I think children reflect our society.

Our society has changed hugely - it is more fractured, we share fewer values and are more in conflict with each other - particularly online.

We all want the best for our children, so it's getting more competitive - and this can make us all selfish in the way we try and ensure our children get ahead.

Adult behaviour out in public can be very poor role modelling for children. Children are made more aware through media of all sorts about the problems of the world and this country - it is pushed straight at them.

Children are doing the best they can in the circumstances they live in. I think all adults need to be doing what they can to help them all (as a group) rather than constantly nitpick and criticise what is often normal developmental behaviour for children.

CultOfRamen · 08/03/2024 11:03

Octavia64 · 07/03/2024 19:01

It can be quite hard to get a teen to do stuff.

The teens in my school who have vandalised the toilets/sexually assaulted people/stolen money etc are generally in with a bad crowd and often on and sometimes dealing drugs.

Giving parents more confidence isn't going to solve that.

None of this is new, kids have been sexually assaulted in schools since schooling began.
theft, physical violence and bullying have occurred in every generation.
modern generations are more inclined to tell grown ups about it, which I believe is a good thing.

so sick of people whinging about badly behaved kids.
this generation is the most empathic, accepting, creative and innovative yet.

the access to information we have now just highlights the ends of the spectrum in everything

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/03/2024 10:49

Unfortunately for children there is a it of a fear around setting boundaries and a lack of understanding of what attachment and relationship health actually is regarding bringing up children. So many just don't know how to self soothe and self regulate which contributes to ongoing anxiety.

Mnk711 · 08/03/2024 09:29

Helfs · 07/03/2024 21:09

There are many ways to control a violent teen. Most local authorities provide NVR training for this very reason.

Your friend sounds like an abhorrent person. Kicking her child out of the home where he then fell into gangs (most likely due to having no one else) and is now in prison. Disgusting

@Helfs I agree on the kicking out, I wouldn't have done it but it was a very challenging situation where the kid was being violent to his siblings and his mum despite trying to get help from various authorities couldn't control him. She ultimately felt she had to protect her other children. I dont agree with her actions as i say but I dont see how she could have stopped his behaviour. I'd be interested to looking into methods of NVR - I'm a parent of small children so haven't yet looked into handling teenagers. My research is all about threenagers and big little feelings at the moment.

Helfs · 08/03/2024 07:51

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 08/03/2024 01:11

Do you genuinely think kids are better behaved nowadays? I was a teacher for over 20 years - I can assure you they’re not.

I don’t have the data so can’t say either way, I’m merely asking for someone who is making a big assertion to back those views up.

Anecdotal evidence isn’t very valid

Usernamewassavedsuccessfully · 08/03/2024 05:47

I work in the kind of school where children threaten violence towards each other and we have CCTV. It's a primary school.
When I started teaching in the 90s and there was an issue with a child, parents were mostly supportive. Now, fewer are. They are much more likely to back their child over staff and we now have a huge number of children who know they are untouchable. We can put in every kind of restorative conversation and positive behaviour management strategy but if parents don't think their child should have boundaries or consequences, we've got little hope.

Elephantswillnever · 08/03/2024 05:41

People don’t seem to discipline children these days. Two of my children are in primary over the last couple of weeks one of them had a water bottle repeatedly thrown at the back of their head/ neck. In another class a child kept hitting mines with a pen by attempting to stab it into her arm. In both cases teachers politely and repeatedly asked offenders to stop but there seems to be no consequences or physical intervention. I complained the heads response was to ask child who’d been hit from behind with a water bottle what he’d done to upset the thrower? All incidents get written up as a tit for tat so there is no bullying apparently.

Personally I’d of removed items after first time and gotten an apology and then separated children for the rest of the time. It’s how I’d intervene at home if dc were hurting each other.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 08/03/2024 05:31

It’s about balance. Too permissive - they think they can get away with whatever they like as there are no boundaries or consequences.

Too authoritarian, the child loses respect and resents the parents and acts out.

Like most things in life there’s a middle ground. You show children respect as a thinking, feeling being as opposed to the ‘’I’m big, you’re small so do as I say’’ attitude that parents used to employ.

I think it’s gone full circle now, parents aren’t as harsh but neither can they be arsed to set any boundaries or expectations, so you have a new generation of entitled kids

phoenixrosehere · 08/03/2024 05:24

I was a childcare provider for over a decade and then had my first child four years later. I now have three children, two boys and a girl (9,6, 4 mo).

From what I’ve seen and experienced myself, I haven’t seen this massive difference people are talking about. From what I remember as a kid myself, there were always parents who were ridiculously permissive or strict about disciplining their children Gentle parenting is not permissive parenting but people often talk about them interchangeably and some parents think they are the same. The only major differences I notice is that:

  1. People are more aware of other parents’ parenting, lenient or not, and can openly judge and voice due to SM and will believe that most parents are a certain way even if they don’t see that in their own environment.
  2. Parents are looking more at the way they themselves were parented, the effects it had on them and choosing to do things differently and seek out other parenting methods.
  3. There is more performative parenting on SM and people will applaud those who are like them even if the parenting is questionable or even damaging.

Children without parental supervision are doing the same things that I remember other children doing as a child. I do notice that too many parents have not taught children to be aware of their surroundings and to make space for others, but since many adults of various ages don’t do this anyway, I can’t expect the children to know or be taught themselves.

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 08/03/2024 05:09

Bex5490 · 07/03/2024 20:23

This.

Every generation gets old and suddenly thinks everyone younger is far worse than they were.

Data and statistics do not support this hypothesis.

And MN is not a an accurate barometer of how successful parenting is. Mum’s rarely make threads to say ‘Just wanted to let everyone know that I’m doing a great job of raising my kids, they are perfect and we’re all so happy.’

People post more for support and advice when things aren’t going great. 🤷🏽‍♀️

The facts in the first paragraph are true. However the behaviour in secondaries now is far far worse. I went to a bog standard comp in a rough part of a big city in the 80s but it wasn’t as feral as some of the behaviour you get in my kids’ comp today and that’s partly because of the total lack of support from parents and complete loss of respect for teachers.

Maddiemum34 · 08/03/2024 05:03

I believe discipline is important in directing your kids in a certain good direction..and knowing if they stray there are consequences and no leeway to talk there way out of it..my 3 kids are well mannered and polite..it was hard but i know theyll be better for it in the future and if a slight discomfort to put them on the road to being good is needed i will always discipline mine with punishment

sawnotseen · 08/03/2024 04:56

Agree with @pjani . I'm in my 50s with young adult children. I grew up in an affluent London suburb and never wanted for anything. My parents were firm but fayr.
My adults kids were much better behaved than me and my school cohort were. Our behaviour at school and outside of, was far worse. We went to pubs at 14, I was in central London a few times a week at 16.
Girl in my o level class was pregnant. We all did drugs, it was the acid house era. And left school at 16. My parents were, and still are, great parents. My kids both have great jobs, one after uni, one after an apprenticeship.
When I was 18 I was in Australia (I am London born and bred).
My kids hardly drink, don't do drugs, go to the gym (that wasn't heard of when I was 18!) and they live a much more healthy, self aware life than me and their dad did at their age.

LaWench · 08/03/2024 04:23

A lot of the gentle parenting is weak and ineffectual parenting.

My parents were the opposite, super strict, my way or the highway/ children should be seen and not heard etc. I hated this, particularly "because I said so". The child isn't learning anything other than to blindly follow rules.

I'm stricter imposed more boundaries than most parents in my children's classes however I've always explained why. They will do as say because they understand why.
DH and I have been on the same page since they were born which has been essential. I'm not perfect and neither are DC but I do have compliant and easy going kids because I said no a lot when they were small and always followed through on consequences, this was mixed with discussion and praise for good behaviour. I will apologise to them when I'm wrong, something my parents never did.

TerrifiedOfNoise · 08/03/2024 03:34

Ariona · 07/03/2024 19:35

I can't believe this. I think you have this the other way around!

@Ariona ot depends where you went to school but having been to a pretty average (good for the area) comp in the midlands in the noighties and now been teaching for over a decade I concur with this.

what had really changed for schools/society is the expectation that you reform children instead of just disciplining them out of the system. Some parents were always lax and others strict but I do think parents were more hands off in the past and now they helicopter too much and that impacts on the children’s confidence and independence as well as driving teachers mad because every positive or negative reward or sanction leads to conversation with the parent whether or not it’s necessary. In the past, for instance, if a teacher said well done to you for your work in class it was up to you whether or not to tell your parents about it, but now the points are online and the parents are watching and monitoring them al the time.

rickyrickygrimes · 08/03/2024 02:04

I’m 51 now so born in 1972. Growing up, as someone said up thread, adults were pretty strict. Parents, teachers, friends parents, relatives, pretty much every adult we came into contact with, were strict about behaviour. They generally wouldn't think twice about telling a child off or disciplining a child that was behaving badly. Adults acted like adults and did grown up things, kids were kids and did children’s things - then grew up and became adults. And the two words were quite separate.

that seems to have changed massively. A lot of my friends are not particularly strict with their children, they seem to want to be closer, more friendly and open with them. They listen to them, they take their opinions into account, they take them (too) seriously. And I think adults hold onto ‘childish’ behaviour a lot longer these days - in the way they dress, colour their hair, the music they listen to, the food they eat, the way they behave in public.

Idk I feel like my peers didn’t want to turn into their parents - so they went too far in the other direction 🤷‍♀️ I understand not wanting to be as strict and repressive as previous generations, but the way some of their kids talk to them is shocking. And these are generally well off, middle class parents allowing this, and acting like teenagers themselves.

sae3005010 · 08/03/2024 01:56

My generation having kids is getting most of the blame (I'm 23 with 3 kids) because the world has adapted to gentle parenting. If you don't do gentle parenting you're a horrible parent and it's abusive. I didn't adapt to gentle parent. I'm lenient, I don't mind them having sweets, chocolate and screentime but I will not let you disrespect or speak to other children with disrespect. I believe learning occurs outside the classroom so yes I will take my kids on holiday during term time and I let them stay off when they're ill but apart from that, they don't get to stay off and slack at home. I don't care about grades, I care that you're trying. If you allow your kids to slack and disrespect you and others, they will. "I'm tired of repeating myself" well sorry but that's what you signed up to by having kids. I repeat myself 100 times a day and will continue doing so until my kids learn good behavior and respect!

homezookeeper · 08/03/2024 01:48

Lone parent living in a terraced house with a child with suspected PDA has tied my hands. She's 12, shouts, screams blue bloody murder, physically kicks, punches and slaps me. I often think that if we were in a detached house then she could scream herself out given any tiny problem like she does, but then I could also really fucking shout back to reinforce how unacceptable her behaviour is, which I can't ever do. The only time my voice volume adjusts is when she hits me really hard and I react to that. Sick of being covered in bruises. Sick of the panic she induces in me. I'd never lay a finger on her but I’m her punching bag. School, social services, everything I've tried to get help with has shut the door in my face. So woohoo, abuse every day. I have CPTSD partially caused by her father who fucked off 4 years ago. At some point I’m going to break. Also partially from the severe child abuse I was put through.
You try so hard and this is what you get.

crumblingschools · 08/03/2024 01:30

If I got told off at school my parents would back the school ( as long as school was being reasonable, and a telling off very rarely happened 😇)

If a child gets told off at school now the parent is more likely to come into the school and complain and the children know this and act accordingly.

Many parents expect schools to teach children manners and other social skills that they themselves have failed to teach their children

coxesorangepippin · 08/03/2024 01:26

What always strike some is that we as parents we question our parenting. We actually question what we're doing, is it right? Should we be firmer? Less strict?? More strict?? Etc. etc.

Our parents never did that. Ever.

We tie ourselves up in knots over it.

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 08/03/2024 01:14

Parenting has in general become far more permissive. I’m endlessly astounded at the way kids are allowed to talk to their parents - and treat them! Even small things like walking out of the classroom at the end of the day, throwing their bags at their mums and demanding a snack. No manners, no thank you, nothing. Baffles me every time.

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 08/03/2024 01:11

Helfs · 07/03/2024 19:12

Are they? I’d love to see your data sources for that (outside of the odd daily mail link that is)

Do you genuinely think kids are better behaved nowadays? I was a teacher for over 20 years - I can assure you they’re not.

PoorLittleEngland · 08/03/2024 01:09

I’m definitely a lot more easy going with my kids than my parents were with me. I still retain the authority to put my foot down if needs be, but I let a lot of stuff go that my parents wouldn’t have accepted. But both of my DC are a lot closer to me than I was to my parents. They’re affectionate and want to hang out with me, and we have a laugh. I remember being a teen and my parents seeming like strangers almost, I couldn’t relate to them at all. I’m honest with my kids and they know I’m not perfect, but they both say they have the best mum in the world. Which I disagree with but as long as they think so 😂. So I don’t think being heavy handed is necessarily the best way forward,

Disneydatknee88 · 08/03/2024 00:08

It's not that I don't discipline my kids, I just choose my battles. My parents were very strict and it was their way or the highway. We have open discussions and compromise in this house. Not just "because I say so". We have set boundaries and rules. Mostly based around respect for each other. My teen can come and go as he pleases but still checks in with us first if he goes anywhere out of respect. If we say no for any reason, we discuss why and compromise something else. My DD is still young and works better with positive reinforcement to get her to do stuff. My kids are really lovely. They don't give me much trouble. I truly belive this is because we are not strict with them. Strict parents equals kids that learn to be good liars.

purpleme12 · 07/03/2024 23:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

While my child has not had an experience like yours I agree you only hear people saying these comments about children or parents not disciplining from people who have compliant children/children who become compliant from discipline/consequences.

Not every child is compliant and not every child is defiant.

Everyone often thinks oh my child wouldn't do that cos I wouldn't let them
If they did this then their child wouldn't do that.

And yet that person has a completely different child so they wouldn't know

Really annoys me

Yourethebeerthief · 07/03/2024 23:04

Giveupnow · 07/03/2024 19:18

Mine are only small but I lack confidence. I’ve read all the books but just feel like I don’t know what I’m doing. It’s hard and I’m lost. I have no help. There’s not really anywhere to turn.

Parenting is hard. And it's so different now than it used to be. I think this woman hits the nail on the head.

www.instagram.com/reel/C4LN1Eqr-iy/?igsh=MXA2MDQ1MzQwdXR5dA==

Add more cars on the streets and technology and social media into the mix, and there's a lot to contend with now when raising children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread