Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be scared when kids leave full-time education

532 replies

spanieleyes22 · 07/03/2024 13:32

So I'm currently eligible for Universal Credit with 2 children over 16 but in full-time education. But when the youngest turns 20 I believe I won't be eligible for it any more. I don't know how I'm going to pay my rent or survive without it. They will still be living with me and will be in university (hopefully). What do people do when this happens.

OP posts:
BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 14:43

She will probably have to go down to a 1 bedroom flat. Two bed flats are rarely that much cheaper than a small 3 bedroom flat.
She is right to feel upset.

ExPostFacto · 08/03/2024 14:39

wombat15 · 08/03/2024 14:16

It is actually nasty to have a go at someone and tell them they are being ridiculous for saying they are contemplating suicide. It's the family home if the family have lived in it for years. I can see why she is upset at the idea that they won't both be able to stay with her in the holidays. Also, not all students will have somewhere else to live in the summer as accommodation is often only for 40 to 42 weeks.

You're mixing up several different things here.
A 'place to stay' and 'own bedrooms' are not the same thing. As I and several other posters have stated. The children can still stay over in a 2 bed-flat. I mean, if the OP feels that strongly about bedrooms she can sleep on the sofa when they visit, and they can have the rooms.
I didn't say it was unfair for OP to be upset, she can feel whatever she likes but the ownership of the family home is a fact. Even if she had no issues with rent the LL could sell up - and then what?

@Jellycatspyjamas I wasn't implying that OP should have known. But she has said a few times she has done 'everything' right. That's simply not true. Not the OP's fault, but she hasn't had a smooth sailing life and suddenly found herself in this position.

@wombat15 You keep accusing people of being nasty and having a go. But we're just pointing out the fact. It's not about what OP has or has not done. It's where she is now. And she is in a good position despite everything that has happened. She doesn't feel that way, because everyone else around her seems so much better off. but she is!

Other posters have weighed in to point out that they never even had a 3 bed, or are having to downsize etc. The whole point of this AIBU is whether OP is being U, and people have shared their own experiences. If OP doesn't like what she's hearing, fine, but they're the facts, the rest of us can't d anything about it. Her friends are not the norm, they are privileged to be able to provide rent free homes, support for their kids to study, etc. OP has raised two high achieving children who are off to uni. She should feel proud, not guilty that she can't offer them more to the extent of a bad impact on her mental health. What good is her being angry, comparing, or us sympathising going to do?

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/03/2024 14:19

Of course, OP didn't do 'everything' right I mean she married a waster who wouldn't pay for his own children. That ruins many women's lives.

Sadly wasters don’t often come with a neon sign on their heads, you find out they’re wasters when you actually need them to step up. Oddly enough women rarely get the choice to just opt out of parenting responsibilities.

wombat15 · 08/03/2024 14:16

ExPostFacto · 08/03/2024 14:06

Well that's not the only thing, she also chose the wrong husband. That aside, people aren't being nasty. They're simply pointing out that the OP has options and has done well given the circumstances. Contemplating suicide over living in a studio - because her grandkids won't be able to stay over is simply ridiculous.
It's 2024. OP's kids aren't guaranteed to reproduce or even stay in the same country to begin with so why all the hand-wringing?

Also the she doesn't have a 'family home'. It's a rental moved to when the kids were teenagers. Which she could be kicked out of at any time anyway. Her children can still stay with her in a 2 bed. They just won't have their own rooms.

OP needs to stop comparing herself to her friends and understand that many others are far less fortunate. It's not a race to the bottom but being a single parent and not buying a house pre-kids has always made things harder.

I'm also guessing that she lives in the Southeast/London or at least near a city, with all these boomerang kids. Very few are returning to the family home in, say a deprived Northern ex-mining town which lacks jobs. Maybe during Covid when remote boomed but that's been pulled back more and more these days.

Edited

It is actually nasty to have a go at someone and tell them they are being ridiculous for saying they are contemplating suicide. It's the family home if the family have lived in it for years. I can see why she is upset at the idea that they won't both be able to stay with her in the holidays. Also, not all students will have somewhere else to live in the summer as accommodation is often only for 40 to 42 weeks.

Icystars · 08/03/2024 14:07

I agree. Yes, the state can’t be expected to provide money to her to keep a 3 bed which will only have 1 person in it most of the time, however, I can see why the OP is upset that she can’t continue to provide her children with a bedroom when they come home as that would really upset me too.

ExPostFacto · 08/03/2024 14:06

wombat15 · 08/03/2024 13:45

The only thing OP didn't do "right" given her university education and degree is buy a house when she probably could have done. It's easy to be critical in hindsight but I don't think anyone realised that it would be so difficult in the future if you didn't buy a house back in the 90s. I can totally understand why she is upset that she may not be able to keep the family home so that her children can stay when not at university and think posters who are having a go are being quite nasty.

Well that's not the only thing, she also chose the wrong husband. That aside, people aren't being nasty. They're simply pointing out that the OP has options and has done well given the circumstances. Contemplating suicide over living in a studio - because her grandkids won't be able to stay over is simply ridiculous.
It's 2024. OP's kids aren't guaranteed to reproduce or even stay in the same country to begin with so why all the hand-wringing?

Also the she doesn't have a 'family home'. It's a rental moved to when the kids were teenagers. Which she could be kicked out of at any time anyway. Her children can still stay with her in a 2 bed. They just won't have their own rooms.

OP needs to stop comparing herself to her friends and understand that many others are far less fortunate. It's not a race to the bottom but being a single parent and not buying a house pre-kids has always made things harder.

I'm also guessing that she lives in the Southeast/London or at least near a city, with all these boomerang kids. Very few are returning to the family home in, say a deprived Northern ex-mining town which lacks jobs. Maybe during Covid when remote boomed but that's been pulled back more and more these days.

wombat15 · 08/03/2024 13:45

The only thing OP didn't do "right" given her university education and degree is buy a house when she probably could have done. It's easy to be critical in hindsight but I don't think anyone realised that it would be so difficult in the future if you didn't buy a house back in the 90s. I can totally understand why she is upset that she may not be able to keep the family home so that her children can stay when not at university and think posters who are having a go are being quite nasty.

ExPostFacto · 08/03/2024 13:22

Beezknees · 08/03/2024 11:56

Why do you think info is missing? Many university educated people like teachers, nurses, etc have to rely on UC to help pay the rent if they live in expensive places like the south east. ESPECIALLY if they are single parents, which many women become unfortunately.

Correct - millennials who currently have young children. Not people of the OP's age!
She's 55, with her oldest being at least 20. So OP was in her early thirties when she had children. If she got such a good job after uni why didn't she buy a property?
Of course, OP didn't do 'everything' right I mean she married a waster who wouldn't pay for his own children. That ruins many women's lives.

But I highly doubt that she went to uni as a teen, got a good job, which is the 'traditional' path she implies...

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 12:33

Well done for being sympathetic to a woman struggling. I despair at this place and would NEVER post for any support.

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 12:03

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/03/2024 11:56

At one point she said she might as well just kill herself at 65 if she was going to have to live in a one bedroom flat and not be able to have spare bedrooms and money to help her children and grandchildren out. Which is just melodramatic and ridiculous, and quite frankly offensive to the people who’ve never been eligible for any benefits in the first place and always managed their expectations about the sort of home they can afford to live in. It doesn’t exactly garner sympathy, when many people have pointed out that she has many options if she wants to stay living in a large house - including her adult DC working to help pay for their keep.

Edited

Quite.

My retirement plan is buying a 1-bed flat for my husband and I. Currently saving like hell towards that.

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/03/2024 11:56

Comefromaway · 08/03/2024 11:52

OP was not bellyaching. She was trying to work things out

At one point she said she might as well just kill herself at 65 if she was going to have to live in a one bedroom flat and not be able to have spare bedrooms and money to help her children and grandchildren out. Which is just melodramatic and ridiculous, and quite frankly offensive to the people who’ve never been eligible for any benefits in the first place and always managed their expectations about the sort of home they can afford to live in. It doesn’t exactly garner sympathy, when many people have pointed out that she has many options if she wants to stay living in a large house - including her adult DC working to help pay for their keep.

Beezknees · 08/03/2024 11:56

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 10:36

Ive done everything "right" . Went to uni got a good job worked full time all my life except for a few years when kids were small yet I can't support myself without help from the state.

I have a hard time believing that you're so hard up if you've 'done everything right' - you're 55, university educated with a good, full time job 'all your life'. Some info is clearly missing.

I personally would be more worried about your kids' future with tuition fees, accommodation costs etc = ending up with a massive student loan and you want to charge them rent on top before they're even working?

Presumably you didn't pay tuition fees when you were at uni.

Why do you think info is missing? Many university educated people like teachers, nurses, etc have to rely on UC to help pay the rent if they live in expensive places like the south east. ESPECIALLY if they are single parents, which many women become unfortunately.

Comefromaway · 08/03/2024 11:52

OP was not bellyaching. She was trying to work things out

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 11:45

SmileyClare · 08/03/2024 11:10

You might find it “disturbing” that many middle income earners cannot afford any standard of living and are eligible for benefits. Over 50 % of the UK population are in receipt of benefits.

Nearly half of UC claimants are in work.

Housing costs are now swallowing over 50% of a decent salary in the private rental sector.

Pull your own socks up and educate yourself better.

It's not the fact that working people have to claim benefits, of course I know that. And housing is outrageously expensive while salaries are stagnant. More housing needs to be built urgently and the rental sector needs to be better regulated with more rights for renters.

I was just a bit Hmm at the OP bellyaching about her circumstances which don't sound that bad to me - it's the younger generations that have it much harder, IMO.

Having a free uni degree, a good, full time job for many years, a 3-bed apartment/house and having brought up two kids bright and resourceful enough to go to uni = not doing too badly.

And while I know it isn't easy to manage when paying private rent on an average salary (been there, done that) I'm not sure why she can't manage.

Average salary = maybe £2200 a month after tax.
Just under 50% in rent = maybe £1100 a month. Are bills included or extra?
If extra maybe £600-£800 a month left after rent and bills. No childcare costs.
So yeah not ideal but manageable for a single person.

I've managed with less. My family members currently manage on less. People who have brought up their families in 1-bed flats.

But I admit on those maths she will likely struggle in retirement. She needs to plan now.

SmileyClare · 08/03/2024 11:10

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 10:53

I agree with this. And I find it a bit disturbing that people think of their children as sources of extra benefits Hmm

How can someone uni educated with a good job who benefited from a free education not have managed to sort their life out by their mid to late 50s. Pull your socks up, OP!

You might find it “disturbing” that many middle income earners cannot afford any standard of living and are eligible for benefits. Over 50 % of the UK population are in receipt of benefits.

Nearly half of UC claimants are in work.

Housing costs are now swallowing over 50% of a decent salary in the private rental sector.

Pull your own socks up and educate yourself better.

TheSnootiestFox · 08/03/2024 11:06

Comefromaway · 08/03/2024 10:55

Oh wouldn't it be good if life was perfect. (And there wern't deadbeat dad's around who leave the mum's in this kind of position)

Which is exactly how I felt at around age 45 leaving both my grim marriage and my teaching career practically simultaneously. But, being an adult, I did exactly as a PP said, pulled my socks up, changed career to a much lower paid but more sustainable mental health and family wise job, worked my way up, did extra projects for Brownie Points, and made a new life for me and my boys. It was and still is hard, bloody hard when my mum became ill as I'm an only child, but I did it and I'm nothing special. Everyone has a story to tell, some people like a PP are dealing with disabled kids and disabilities theirselves. A grown woman of 57 with no health issues, a long work history and a university education really should have no problems getting themselves together. To go back to the original point which keeps being missed, it really is a case of earn more or spend less, not respond snappily to those who were in exactly the same position but did something about it.

Comefromaway · 08/03/2024 10:55

Oh wouldn't it be good if life was perfect. (And there wern't deadbeat dad's around who leave the mum's in this kind of position)

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 10:53

PaulGalico1 · 07/03/2024 18:07

I don't know why you feel you can complain because the benefits you received for your children will be taken away once they become adults. Also that you do not think they should contribute. You say 'I did everything right' - you haven't because you won't plan(still time) won't downsize, won't try to earn more. I am 64 and still work so I'm not suggesting things I wouldn't do myself.

I agree with this. And I find it a bit disturbing that people think of their children as sources of extra benefits Hmm

How can someone uni educated with a good job who benefited from a free education not have managed to sort their life out by their mid to late 50s. Pull your socks up, OP!

notreally7 · 08/03/2024 10:36

Ive done everything "right" . Went to uni got a good job worked full time all my life except for a few years when kids were small yet I can't support myself without help from the state.

I have a hard time believing that you're so hard up if you've 'done everything right' - you're 55, university educated with a good, full time job 'all your life'. Some info is clearly missing.

I personally would be more worried about your kids' future with tuition fees, accommodation costs etc = ending up with a massive student loan and you want to charge them rent on top before they're even working?

Presumably you didn't pay tuition fees when you were at uni.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 08/03/2024 10:34

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 08/03/2024 09:20

You've inherited a house, this is not the same situation AT ALL.

Her mum only died 6 weeks ago and house not her’s yet.
The provisions she made were irrespective of that.

TheSnootiestFox · 08/03/2024 10:31

SmileyClare · 08/03/2024 09:37

This has been explained-@TheSnootiestFox was outlining the changes she put it place to increase her earnings on the premise she would use the house proceeds to fund her mother’s residential care.

Dont let that detail stop you piling on though.

Well exactly. Take the house out of the equation and you can still see what I did to make sure that I could cope with the drop in UC once the kids left education. This also had to be actioned quicker than I would have liked as firstborn has decided to go to the AFC which is effectively an apprenticeship at 16, whereas I thought he'd go to college and then join up after that. I knew my UC would halve and his dad would stop paying maintenance the first moment he could. Everyone on benefits with kids with no disabilities knows this will happen. I don't understand how you wake up when the kids are in their 20s and firstly, you are still claiming for them, and secondly why this realisation hasn't already happened. I was asked what I did and replied. I really don't understand the hate as I had still busted a gut at work and studied further to remove the risk of me being completely skint once things changed. I was never expecting to inherit that house and I acted as if I'd be renting all my life, and needed to be able to pay that rent. There's no smugness or snootiness involved, I was asked a question and I answered. If people don't like the answer that's up to them, but I won't be the one struggling to pay my rent in later life. Again, I wish the OP luck in changing her circumstances but honestly it's all perfectly doable.

fleurneige · 08/03/2024 10:06

and tax-free too, if for students.

fleurneige · 08/03/2024 10:06

SmileyClare · 08/03/2024 09:09

It’s a valid suggestion. However it’s not always possible to sublet a rental property. It would need a landlords permission otherwise op can be liable for legal action against her.

Of course, have to go through proper channels. But it is very much a possibility. Term-time only- and freed for holidays if both come home at the same time.

DodgyDynamics · 08/03/2024 09:40

OP this sounds tough.

It must be sad to consider giving your kids’ rooms away if they are at uni. I have two at uni and they occasionally pop back for concerts, to see friends etc (we live in London) and it would be hard not to give them a room. Never mind for the holidays.

The other thing is, uni jobs are not always that easy to find. My daughter and her friends are at uni in a major city and really struggling to find jobs. Supply outstrips demand. I even looked at her CV and job applications to see if I could help but they were fine. She didn’t have luck when back at home either. Despite applying online and walking into lots of shops, cafes and pubs with her CV. It’s often said on here that students should ‘get a job’ but in some areas it’s really not that easy. Esp without lots of relevant experience.

Hope there is some option there for you OP. A cheaper area may be the best option if you can’t downsize.