Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be scared when kids leave full-time education

532 replies

spanieleyes22 · 07/03/2024 13:32

So I'm currently eligible for Universal Credit with 2 children over 16 but in full-time education. But when the youngest turns 20 I believe I won't be eligible for it any more. I don't know how I'm going to pay my rent or survive without it. They will still be living with me and will be in university (hopefully). What do people do when this happens.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 11:14

Plenty of single mothers claim nothing from the state

Nothing? Ok, I’m not disagreeing with you; a minority of wealthy single parents might be in a position to pay for private education, healthcare and not claim even child benefit.

That doesn’t affect the fact that single mothers who have to support children for 18 years on one wage are economically disadvantaged.

Most of this thread is dripping in veiled contempt for anyone in receipt of benefits. Tories love to promote the idea that anyone in the unfortunate position of needing state support is lazy and it’s their fault for making the wrong choices…they should have tried harder! It’s ignorant.

But wait, what if she lived in a third world country with no welfare system at all? Well she doesn’t Confused

Workworkandmoreworknow · 11/03/2024 10:55

Single mothers are disadvantaged and I have no issue with them being assisted by the state

to be clear, there is no such thing as a 'single mother's benefit' and plenty of single mothers receive nothing at all from the state.

SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 09:40

The UK governments have been shitting on the working classes for decades and here we are. Nearly half the population reliant on benefits to afford to eat and have a home.

But sure let’s point at the small man working their balls off full time and tell them it’s their fault, they should work harder like people in South Korea?

What a laughable thing to say.

SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 09:23

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 11/03/2024 09:01

"I can’t think of any developed countries that have NO social welfare systems or programmes"

over half the world has no social welfare

in terms of developed countries, the lowest spend is South Korea and Chile - spending under half of what the US does

If we’re talking about developed countries then yes they all have welfare systems.

What point are you making? You don’t agree with welfare systems?

The poster that declared they don’t use public money appears to resent anyone in this country doing so.

Single mothers are disadvantaged and I have no issue with them being assisted by the state. The children of single parent families are disadvantaged and they should be assisted more by the state whilst in full time education in my view.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 11/03/2024 09:01

SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 08:21

I can’t think of any developed countries that have NO social welfare systems or programmes. If we’re talking about the US then yes public spending on welfare is low but exists. This has resulted in massive inequalities in wealth distribution and not something to aspire to. Parts of the US (one of the richest countries in the world) have people living in slum towns.

Interestingly, Nordic countries who have the most extensive welfare systems and spend the highest percentage on public services and welfare are flourishing economically, and statistically the population’s mental health is rated healthiest in the world.

I’m happy for some of my taxes to be spent on disadvantaged sections of society.

I would like to see more state financial assistance for young adults in further education. University education should not be a privilege for the wealthy but that’s where we’re heading. University is simply out of reach for some people.
The gap between rich and poor has never been so vast.

We’re at crisis point with mental health issues amongst the younger generations hardly helped by the public attitude of “Fuck them when they leave school- they can study and earn their own money and sleep on someone’s floor if their parent can’t support them…Im not (as a member of society) working to support them”
Ditto the elderly and disabled..

I'm depressed by a lot of the “I’m all right Jack” attitudes on this thread.

"I can’t think of any developed countries that have NO social welfare systems or programmes"

over half the world has no social welfare

in terms of developed countries, the lowest spend is South Korea and Chile - spending under half of what the US does

SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 08:21

LiterallyOnFire · 11/03/2024 07:49

The person you are quoting has repeatedly said they live somewhere that doesn’t have any sort of welfare benefits hence paying for their healthcare etc.

No, s/he said they "came from" a country without those things. They live in the UK. Which is why I commented as I did.

I can’t think of any developed countries that have NO social welfare systems or programmes. If we’re talking about the US then yes public spending on welfare is low but exists. This has resulted in massive inequalities in wealth distribution and not something to aspire to. Parts of the US (one of the richest countries in the world) have people living in slum towns.

Interestingly, Nordic countries who have the most extensive welfare systems and spend the highest percentage on public services and welfare are flourishing economically, and statistically the population’s mental health is rated healthiest in the world.

I’m happy for some of my taxes to be spent on disadvantaged sections of society.

I would like to see more state financial assistance for young adults in further education. University education should not be a privilege for the wealthy but that’s where we’re heading. University is simply out of reach for some people.
The gap between rich and poor has never been so vast.

We’re at crisis point with mental health issues amongst the younger generations hardly helped by the public attitude of “Fuck them when they leave school- they can study and earn their own money and sleep on someone’s floor if their parent can’t support them…Im not (as a member of society) working to support them”
Ditto the elderly and disabled..

I'm depressed by a lot of the “I’m all right Jack” attitudes on this thread.

LiterallyOnFire · 11/03/2024 07:49

The person you are quoting has repeatedly said they live somewhere that doesn’t have any sort of welfare benefits hence paying for their healthcare etc.

No, s/he said they "came from" a country without those things. They live in the UK. Which is why I commented as I did.

HelpIdonotknowwhattodo · 11/03/2024 07:44

Beezknees · 09/03/2024 13:01

No, OP works full time so she will not get those other entitlements. Those things are only for the very poorest in society - those who cannot work or can only work a limited number of hours only earning less than £7k a year. You're showing your ignorance as to how the system actually works. I work full time, get UC and have NEVER received free school meals, dental care or council tax or anything of the like.

I am ignorant when it comes to UC on top of wages. I honestly had no idea you could get them on an average salary. I thought they were just for those on a really low salary. It is good they offer them.

LiterallyOnFire · 11/03/2024 07:14

The person I am qu

NoddyfromToytown · 11/03/2024 06:53

LiterallyOnFire · 11/03/2024 05:17

State schools and NHS are also (a big) part of the welfare state. Don't you use any of it?

You'd think this was a thread about a dosser, considering how many posters want a medal for working and paying tax. OP works and pays tax.

Such an odd thread.

The person you are quoting has repeatedly said they live somewhere that doesn’t have any sort of welfare benefits hence paying for their healthcare etc.

I think the issue with the thread is that OP is refusing to consider any suggestion offered

LiterallyOnFire · 11/03/2024 05:17

wanttogetadvice · 10/03/2024 22:50

@LiterallyOnFire yes we did. For work and fortunately we do not use the welfare system. Yes we pay for everything, including health care and education. We know it can be financially challenging so we work. Just like many other economical immigrants. We are the ones paying for the welfare system here.

State schools and NHS are also (a big) part of the welfare state. Don't you use any of it?

You'd think this was a thread about a dosser, considering how many posters want a medal for working and paying tax. OP works and pays tax.

Such an odd thread.

BenefitWaffle · 10/03/2024 22:59

@wanttogetadvice it is very different visiting family and sleeping on the floor when you have a proper home of your own. This is not the situation for OPs kids when they go to uni.

wanttogetadvice · 10/03/2024 22:58

and we have accommodated full extended families and friends in a one and then two bed house. No one bats an eye lid and every one managed. And guess what, we all had a blast and still remember those times fondly. People who care for you wont mind sleeping on the floor if they had to, so that can spend more time with you. People really need to start spending within their means and cut clothes accordingly.

And the one who said that people do not care for elderly. You cannot be more wrong. We have the strongest family system where children look after their parents because parents spend their lives looking after their children. We do not rely on state support for that.

OP's kids are adults. It's time to have a frank discussion with them.

wanttogetadvice · 10/03/2024 22:50

@LiterallyOnFire yes we did. For work and fortunately we do not use the welfare system. Yes we pay for everything, including health care and education. We know it can be financially challenging so we work. Just like many other economical immigrants. We are the ones paying for the welfare system here.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/03/2024 21:35

lemming40 · 09/03/2024 15:20

Probably should have thought about this before you were only 10 years from retirement. Seems like you will have to continue to work.

Jeez

Ted27 · 10/03/2024 20:13

@BrieAndChilli

I wasn't suggesting that the state should fund 3 bed houses for everyone
My objection is that it seems the solution to the housing crisis seems to be
Single people should house share or live in shoe boxes
Old people should give up their family homes.
Because of what other people think they need.
We all need to cut our cloth. That's partly why I'm still in a wobbly Victorian terrace. But I do object to being told what I need.
The op has several options open to her to enable her to keep her home once the benefits end. It's up to her to decide how to do it.

MississippiAF · 10/03/2024 20:11

Ted27 · 09/03/2024 23:46

@Princessfluffy @PoundlandColumbo

I'm single and live in a very average 3 bed terrace, 2nd bedroom currently occupied part time by my son who is at uni. The third occupied by a 13 year old foster child. Hopefully by the time I am 65 they will both be off doing their own thing.

Do I 'need' my ' extra' bedrooms? Well I do need my living room, kitchen and bathroom which occupy the same footprint. I would still like to have space for my kids and maybe grandkids if they appear to stay. I would be very miserable without my garden. So regardless of whether or not I need it, it's my home and I will be carried out of it my box.
I have a friend who lives in the sort of accommodation it seems many people would like single people to be pushed into. A bed sit room with tiny kitchen and shower room. No outside space.
To me it's suffocatingly small - no room.for a sofa, just a chair, no room for the things that are important to me. No room for visitors. No thanks not for me

Great, as long as you’re not claiming for it. I’m not
working full time so you can have these things

BrieAndChilli · 10/03/2024 19:43

Ted27 · 09/03/2024 23:46

@Princessfluffy @PoundlandColumbo

I'm single and live in a very average 3 bed terrace, 2nd bedroom currently occupied part time by my son who is at uni. The third occupied by a 13 year old foster child. Hopefully by the time I am 65 they will both be off doing their own thing.

Do I 'need' my ' extra' bedrooms? Well I do need my living room, kitchen and bathroom which occupy the same footprint. I would still like to have space for my kids and maybe grandkids if they appear to stay. I would be very miserable without my garden. So regardless of whether or not I need it, it's my home and I will be carried out of it my box.
I have a friend who lives in the sort of accommodation it seems many people would like single people to be pushed into. A bed sit room with tiny kitchen and shower room. No outside space.
To me it's suffocatingly small - no room.for a sofa, just a chair, no room for the things that are important to me. No room for visitors. No thanks not for me

And that’s fine - as long as you find it yourself. We don’t have the resources for the government to be paying for every single person (or couple) to have 3 bedrooms so that they can have spare rooms for occasional guests.

we didn’t buy our house until we were 40. Until then we rented (and 2 boys share a room). We then managed to buy. We both work full time so when the kids leave home we will still be able to afford to live here. If our circumstances change then yes we may have to downsize.

mathanxiety · 10/03/2024 19:26

Ted27 · 10/03/2024 17:15

@mathanxiety

Of course it makes a difference if you own your own home, to many things.
The point is there are countless threads and posts about single people and what other people think they need.
Just because I'm single does not mean I don't have family or friends, children and grandchildren that I would want to accommodate in the future or that living in a shoe box would give me a decent quality of life.

It makes zero financial sense to pay rent for space to accommodate potential future guests.

My adult DCs stay in hotels when they visit for Christmas and other occasions. If my mother ever came to visit, she could have my bed, but everyone else makes their own arrangements for accommodation, and actually it works out well because we don't have the usual house guest problems and they have their own bathroom, comfy bed, proximity to coffee shops in the city, etc, and can meet up with other friends when they're in town.

The inevitable alternative to a three bedroom house that will only be filled for a few months out of the year isn't a 'shoebox' either.

LivelyBlake · 10/03/2024 19:04

Of course in an ideal world the OP should keep renting a 3 bed house so that she can have friends and family and get DC over. But she says she can't afford it once UC stops.

Ted27 · 10/03/2024 17:15

@mathanxiety

Of course it makes a difference if you own your own home, to many things.
The point is there are countless threads and posts about single people and what other people think they need.
Just because I'm single does not mean I don't have family or friends, children and grandchildren that I would want to accommodate in the future or that living in a shoe box would give me a decent quality of life.

Willmafrockfit · 10/03/2024 17:05

halls are generally for the first year only, after that the majority find house shares

Gwenhwyfar · 10/03/2024 16:19

BenefitWaffle · 09/03/2024 14:24

I took all my belongings with me when I went to university and only ever had short visits home afterwards. My mum moved to a much smaller rented place 6 weeks before I left home.
It is doable, but no one would think it was ideal.

My friend's family moved her brother's girlfriend into my friend's room! She still went home, but I think she slept on the sofa or with a friend or something.
As people have noted, halls are usually term time only.

mathanxiety · 10/03/2024 03:26

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 16:08

@mathanxiety I agree it is not the end of the world. But having a dining room really is akin to being able to have 3 bedrooms. It is very different in a 1 bedroom with a sofa bed to sleep on or an air bed. This is what I had to do when visiting my mum and it did mean I became a guest rather than returning home.
I left home at 18 and earned every bit of money I have ever had since then. I know this is not what my middle class peers did and it did make their life easier.

It's open plan with a sitting area and dining area, not big at all. I would have definitely turned a separate dining room into a bedroom, and we would have eaten in the sitting room with plates on our knees. Now that the number still living at home has more than halved, I can't believe we all managed to fit here, but we did.

mathanxiety · 10/03/2024 02:52

It makes a difference if you are living in a home you own or have equity in, @Ted27.

It makes no sense to continue living in a rented home that is too big for your needs.