Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car regret - AIBU

83 replies

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:12

I am aware that right now I'll probably get bashed for seeming like a spoilt brat. But I've got bloody car regret.

I just sold my Range Rover Evoque. I'd had it 5 years. I absolutely loved the car for its height and size and all the standard features that came with the car. However, my insurance had gone up drastically at the time of renewal due to the increase in thefts of range rovers and it felt unjustifiable to pay it. It had also been having some problems recently too. And I also no longer needed a diesel. It wasn't doing the car any good with mainly city driving and I was sick of the dpf warning light coming on every month and having to pointlessly drive for miles to clear it!

Whilst the evoque was in a garage having a repair - not dpf related this time - and I was without a car, on a whim I decided to car shop and out of desperation I purchased a new car so I could be back on the road asap.

I've gone for a used ŠKODA Karoq. It is absolutely lovely. So much car for the money. And is a like for like on specification of previous cars I’ve owned. And is a petrol which is absolutely better suited for the minimal miles I cover these days. I checked the ncap score before I purchased which is 5 stars. However, in the time I've been driving around in it I feel so low on the road compared to my evoque and other suvs I have owned, and feel I just made a quick decision without thinking it through. Whenever I park up next to other suvs I panic at the thought of ever having an accident in the ŠKODA and start imagining one of those bigger cars doing some damage. I'm aware how ridiculous I sound but I do suffer with anxiety and ended up down a rabbit hole when I checked the ncap score in more detail and even though it scores 5 stars, the child protection on a Karoq is slightly lower than other suvs and even smaller hatchbacks I’ve owned in my younger years. The Karoq is roughly 79% while others are at 85% and above. I typically in recent years have gone for suv style cars for their size, height and feeling more protected and I’ve come to love crossover and suv vehicles on the whole.

I've had a Nissan qashqui before and a rav4 and I parked up next to a qashqui today and it looked huge and higher in comparison and just instantly regretted not getting another quashqui as I equally loved my qashqui - it was just a tad small in the boot.

I am aware I sound absolutely ridiculous and spoilt. I am extremely grateful to be in a position to be able to drive and have a car - one that I love too (Karoq) - but I can’t shake off the feeling of worry that my children are less protected in this car than other cars I’ve owned in the past, which is stealing the enjoyment from the car.

The kids love the car and were so excited to pick it up. But every time I put them in it I just feel guilty thinking what if something bad happened? I’d blame myself for being so quick to jump without searching for the safest car possible for our family.

Please talk me down from my stupidity. Surely I am being unreasonable here? Any ŠKODA Karoq owners here who can share some positive stories so that I can start enjoying our new car and not feeling anxious and regretful every time I drive us somewhere in it.

TIA

OP posts:
RoseNy · 07/03/2024 14:36

if I was to run in to a pedestrian or another vehicle from head on, the car will brake itself after a warning to tell me I am too close to another car/person if that makes sense.

Do you drive with your eyes closed?

PlipPlopChoo · 07/03/2024 14:35

Slightly off topic but I do not think there should be these massive SUVs on the road. There is a huge imbalance between them and smaller cars.

Tax should be done on vehicle weight rather than emissions.

Untethered · 07/03/2024 14:29

I am an incredibly sensible driver and always have been so I feel even without having that extra function on the ŠKODA that I am a reasonably safe driver when it comes to others.

If you’re incredibly sensible then relax, you’re safe.

I don’t worry about my safety at all because I’m a good driver with 20+ years experience.

It’s ok to be scared sometimes, fear keeps you safe.

ClockworkDisaster · 07/03/2024 14:28

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:36

@ClockworkDisaster thank you, these are the kinds of answers I was hoping for to ease me of my anxiety and concerns. Not those who think I'm upset because I don't have the biggest and best car lol.

Useful information for me to bare in mind. Thanks very much.

You’re welcome. The best thing you can do to keep yourself safe is to make sure your own driving is spot on and you drive defensively. So many accidents could be avoided if people look further ahead and keep their bubble of space around themselves.

if might be worth you getting some advanced driving lessons to help with your anxiety? A lot of them are volunteer run so the costs are pretty low.

aquarimum · 07/03/2024 14:26

If you're worried about safety, sign up for an IAM or RoSPA advanced driving course, don't buy tanks that are actively more dangerous for other road users.

Superscientist · 07/03/2024 14:23

When I was in my 2nd trimester my partner tried to avoid a car that pulled in front of him on the motorway. He missed the car but collided with the central reservation 2 possibly 3 times. They struggled to find a safe anchor point to tow our car off the motorway the external body work was gone. There wasn't a single panel that wasn't severely damaged. If you saw it you would be surprised that it hadn't needed to be turned into a convertible to get us out. We did get out. We walked out and were able to make our own way to a and e.
Inside the car the only signs that it had been in an accident were the deflated airbags.
I had a bruised sternum and possibly a broken rib and we both had mild whiplash. Our daughter was completely unharmed.

In the nicest of ways you are anxious over something that doesn't warrant your anxiety.... Which is of course are the topics that anxiety likes best!

The only people you need to be worried about in a crash are those not in the car provided all passengers and animals are wearing seat belts or restraints.

Something else to consider, there was a more or less piece recently that found that co2 emissions, without changing the number of electric and hybrid cars on the market, would be 30% lower if there hadn't been the huge increase in the proportion of SUVs on the roads!

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 14:08

@cocunut i am sorry you feel that way. I can assure you whenever I have been in cars the size of my previous rav4 or cars as small as my previous corsa pre children - I have always been a safe driver.

I don't think bigger cars are the problem. I think it's more who is behind the wheel. This is the worrying thing - when you have someone in a large suv that drives carelessly. This is kind of where my anxiety stems from. Now I'm in a lower vehicle I worry about these kinds of people hitting my car when my kids are in it - A big suv with a big idiotic driver in it. Since having kids I just feel I notice crazy drivers everywhere. Either that or there is more crazy drivers than ever.

I see your point though.

OP posts:
cocunut · 07/03/2024 14:01

I totally understand what you mean about having to adjust to a different driving position, but I must admit you are being slightly ridiculous. I drive a fiat 500 and large cars like your SUV constantly bully me into the side of the road. People in bigger cars tend to say “it’s safer” when actually you are the problem… nobody needs a car that large unless you are on a working farm or live rurally and actually need a 4x4. I totally don’t see the point in these huge cars that don’t even have 4wd!!

Untethered · 07/03/2024 13:55

Moanranger · 07/03/2024 13:30

I come from the horsey/countryside world and we just LAUGH & LAUGH at the numpties who drive Range Rovers - POS, basically.
I have been driving a ŠKODA Yeti for 10 years as I need it to tow a horse trailer & up to 1100kg of horses. Brilliant, and probably a third of the price of a LR, many of which have a very limited towing capacity.
Skoda is part of VW, so you get VW engineering for a reduced price as it is not a prestige brand.
Girlie, I suggest you actually learn something about vehicles, not just whether they are pretty.

Girlie 🫢

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:52

@Excited101 one is rear facing.

The ncap test is based on a 6 and 10 year old in a car seat. That's where the score came from.

Yes and no - started sertraline but haven't been able to attend CBT unfortunately. My previous counsellor went on sick leave and new counsellor couldn't fit me in at suitable hours. I need to explore it again for sure.

OP posts:
misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:50

@Branster

I want to keep my new car. I don't want to dash out and buy a bigger car purely because I am anxious. Anxiety is horrendous and causes the sufferer to avoid situations purely because they are anxious. If I was to go buy a bigger car tomorrow it would be a decision based on anxiety and my anxiety would win. I love this new car and want to enjoy it without anxiety stealing the pleasure of it.

Also I'll reiterate regarding other road users: this ŠKODA has a braking system that will avoid a potential collision head on. So if I was to hit another road user or pedestrian it would brake after giving me warning messages to tell me I am about to crash. So I do have less concerns about the damage I could cause to another road user because the safety for other road users is fantastic on this car. It's just the score is lower for child protection. That's my worry. That's not to say that it couldn't happen - me hitting someone else - but combine the cars features with myself as a sensible driver, the chances of me causing damage to anyone else is reasonably low. My concern is more if someone hit me such as pulling out or driving too close from behind - because there are so many careless drivers about and that is what makes me feel vulnerable, if one of those careless drivers happens to be driving a bigger car, what could they possibly do to my children in my car. That mixed with already suffering anxiety has prompted the post.

OP posts:
Excited101 · 07/03/2024 13:46

How old are your children op? If they’re under 6/7 and not in a rear facing car seat then the differences in car is probably totally meaningless. Rear facing is approx 5x safer than forward facing, and you can get seats that rear face up to about 36kg.

are you getting help for your anxiety?

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:39

@akkakk

Thank you for the comparison with regards to safety of a newer ateca and an older Range Rover it puts my mind at ease.

OP posts:
misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:36

@ClockworkDisaster thank you, these are the kinds of answers I was hoping for to ease me of my anxiety and concerns. Not those who think I'm upset because I don't have the biggest and best car lol.

Useful information for me to bare in mind. Thanks very much.

OP posts:
misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:35

@Moanranger

Did you read my post in full?

I didn't buy a Range Rover because it was pretty. I also aren't worried about my ŠKODA because it is a ŠKODA. Truthfully, if I wanted to buy another Range Rover, I could have. I chose not to because I am not going to justify a car needing constant repairs or increasing insurance because it is branded 'luxury'. I am also aware of the VW Audi seat and ŠKODA group. And I feel privileged to be able to own a car on the whole regardless of its status and badge.

In a totally honest answer - visually hands down I love the ŠKODA appearance far more than my Range Rover anyway. This is not my concern.

My post is specifying my concerns about safety because I suffer with anxiety and have fixated myself on worry after reading the ncap score - Not appearance or status. I did expect somebody to call me out on owning a Range Rover, so much so I nearly didn't specify what the previous car was because that doesn't matter.

OP posts:
ClockworkDisaster · 07/03/2024 13:35

Also the NCAP standards change. What is as a 5 star car 20yrs ago would probably score quite badly now as technology has moved on so much and the ‘pass rates’ have changed.

ClockworkDisaster · 07/03/2024 13:33

Tbh crash tests aren’t that realistic. They are only relevant if someone hits you / you hit someone in the exact way that it says in the test. An inch off the same line and the results can vary wildly between models.

for example if you take a 98-11 New Beetle and a 12-18 Beetle and crash them head on, the newer one will come out better. But if you do an overlap head on (which is more likely) then it’s actually the older one which fairs better.

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:30

@Geebray possibly - just got panicked when one element was described as 'weak' in the child protection! This is what anxiety does to a person - fixate on tiny little details.

OP posts:
Moanranger · 07/03/2024 13:30

I come from the horsey/countryside world and we just LAUGH & LAUGH at the numpties who drive Range Rovers - POS, basically.
I have been driving a ŠKODA Yeti for 10 years as I need it to tow a horse trailer & up to 1100kg of horses. Brilliant, and probably a third of the price of a LR, many of which have a very limited towing capacity.
Skoda is part of VW, so you get VW engineering for a reduced price as it is not a prestige brand.
Girlie, I suggest you actually learn something about vehicles, not just whether they are pretty.

Geebray · 07/03/2024 13:29

I think you are focussing far too much on a perceived 6% safety difference.

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:29

@Pancakeorcrepe

See my previous reply to other poster as it will answer your first question.

I think my anxieties are more on somebody hitting us, not me hitting them. Because I know I am a safe driver and the car has some excellent features to automatically brake if I was to get too close to another driver. It's more the kind of lunatics that are on the road, pulling out at junctions or driving too close to the back of the car.

The post is 100% not me me me - I am not a car snob by any means. I've owned 'luxury' vehicles Audis, Range rovers, but also owned seats, Nissan, Toyota and can honestly say the badge does nothing for me. Yes I do believe my anxiety is projecting in to the car. Not that I am upset because my car isn't the biggest. I really love the car.

OP posts:
akkakk · 07/03/2024 13:28

We have a seat Ateca (basically the same car)
It is much safer than the old Range Rover (full size) we also have...

you will be fine!

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 07/03/2024 13:27

OP

Look up 'Euroncap'

re crash/safety ratings!!

The newer the car, more often than not, the safer it is.

So google the safety of car you may want to by

We always look up the safety of cars

DonnasShrugaleros · 07/03/2024 13:25

If you want safety don't buy an SUV

misskellyb · 07/03/2024 13:24

@jimmyhill

Yes actually I do and was relieved that the car has a pedestrian protection braking system and forward collision detection. So if I was to run in to a pedestrian or another vehicle from head on, the car will brake itself after a warning to tell me I am too close to another car/person if that makes sense. I am an incredibly sensible driver and always have been so I feel even without having that extra function on the ŠKODA that I am a reasonably safe driver when it comes to others. I get that accidents can happen regardless of how safe you are, but to answer your question, yes it crosses my mind. But my post isn't about that.

Anxiety is absolutely rubbish.

OP posts: