Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you like to be an 'old fashioned' housewife?

287 replies

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 12:56

Or a househusband (though we're mainly women on here). And I suspect that most men would say no...

I was reading the ultra processed foods thread, and it struck me (as it often does) that working families are so pushed for time in this era that preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner from scratch is nigh on impossible (and that is the basic premise of what a UPF is; its something you couldnt prepare in your own kitchen). I'm not talking about removing that opportunity, nor harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home (though I think that, whilst women's rights have thankfully progressed massively in the work place, they've not progressed so much in the home/society at large; some bygone views/expectations of women persist. I think, for example, running the house and organising children are still largely female pursuits...). It strikes me that having the 'healthy' ideal lifestyle of cooking from scratch, exercising and spending quality time raising children is a pipe dream when both parents have no choice but to work full time.

I know its complex, and theres a bigger picture (interested to hear thoughts thereof too). I'm just curious (I'm not a researcher! Genuinely just interested) to hear honest takes (few women would be happy to publicly admit in RL that 'running the home', whilst their husband earned, would be their preferred choice to working). Do you think the opportunity for one parent to be at home full time should be a choice available to us all (as it once, generally, was)?

YABU - I want to work, its not just necessity.
YANBU - I'd prefer to be at home, running the show full time.

OP posts:
Olderthanthetrees · 07/03/2024 15:50

I think the ideal is to have one parent working when dc are under age of seven and after that it’s great if one parent can work three days a week or two parents have one day off a week.

Elphamouche · 07/03/2024 15:49

No I love my jobs. If we won the lottery I could go part time. (One is currently full time and the other is 0 hour contract but varies between 8-40 hours depending on the week).

DH would give up his full time job, and keep the 0 hours (same as what I do), he’s been there 20 years and it’s a HUGE part of our lives so it’s more than work. We would both be more picky on what bits we did though.

DH would absolutely be a house husband (keeping the 0 hours though, we’ll never give that up) and I’ve genuinely been trying to work out if that’s possible. It’s completely not, financially we both have to work, full time + second jobs. More so because I’m now on maternity leave.

Being a housewife is not for me, going part time and having more time to spend as a family, doing the odd bits round the house, absolutely. But full time at home, all the cleaning/cooking/washing etc. not a chance. He’s much better at it than me and would enjoy it more.

Revelatio · 07/03/2024 15:48

We both work full time but have meals cooked from scratch every night. It doesn’t have to take hours!

If one of us stayed home I honestly don’t know what we’d do all day? We could get rid of the cleaner, but they only come for 2hrs a week. Everything thing else just seems to slot in. We spent most weekends outside the home so it doesn’t really get messy and we definitely don’t do any chores at the weekend.

Samlewis96 · 07/03/2024 15:42

SailingStormyWaters · 07/03/2024 14:42

Yes, a million times.
I went back to work part time when my son was just 5 months old and it nearly killed me. I was so envious of the other mums at the parenting groups who didn't work. When l wasn't at work l was always out and about with my son, I have such lovely memories. Work was just a massive inconvenience and l remember going on trips to the farm and then having to rush off to work, whilst my friends could just sit around having a coffee.
I can't understand women who say they are bored at home, you don't have to spend every minute cleaning and cooking, why can't you just enjoy your children? I think women who are bored at home are the types that never go anywhere or do anything, couch potatoes.

Or maybe they can't afford to do anything that costs money if they dont work? I suppose it might be nice if you have a decent amount of money coming into the house. Not so much if all you can afford is to walk to local park or library

CaramelMac · 07/03/2024 15:42

There was an interesting programme on the BBC a while ago called ‘back in time for dinner’ and if I remember correctly they talked about how the invention of home freezers and frozen food made it easier for women to go out to work.

SnapdragonToadflax · 07/03/2024 15:34

I found maternity leave hideously boring but also massively stressful. I am not cut out to be a housewife.

Thank fuck I was born in the 1980s and not the 1880s.

Beezknees · 07/03/2024 15:24

I'd never want to be a housewife. I want to earn my own money.

notacooldad · 07/03/2024 15:24

No I wouldn't wasnt to be a house wife in the trad sense of the word.
Even when the kids were little I didn't want it.

I was reading the ultra processed foods thread, and it struck me (as it often does) that working families are so pushed for time in this era that preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner from scratch is nigh on impossible (and that is the basic premise of what a UPF is; its something you couldnt prepare in your own kitchen)

To me this is utter BS. With a little thought it is easy ( IMO obviously) to prepare 3xmeals a day that don't include UPF. I have been doing it for 27 years. I am not saying that I never eat them. Of course I do, i like ice cream, I like a drink of Whiskey now and then but things like sausauges and meat are bought from the local butcher and doesn't have 10 different ingredients in. There is no need to buy fruit flavoured yougurts. A huge tub of Greek Yogurt with chopped apple, banana or whatver suffices for breakfast. You don't need to be a housewife to eat well.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 07/03/2024 15:22

telestrations · 07/03/2024 15:14

There's a lot to be said for it and a lot of the problems we face now would or could be solved by having an adult in each household dedicated to the welfare of the home and everyone in it.

Personally I wouldn't give up my current work to do it, it's too well rewarded and would not sense, and will in fact afford my DH to be SAHP for the early years.

My mother was that adult, dedicated to the wellbeing of everyone in the family. Unfortunately, it proved to be terrible for her own wellbeing.

For a lot of people, the dedicated focus on home and family would be too narrow, and leave them without much of an identity beyond their home & family. Of course, paid work isn't the only solution to that - investing significant time in a hobby or in volunteering etc might have the same effect, but then, they are no longer solely focused on the home and the family anyway.

If people are happy with home/family being the main/sole focus of their lives, then fair enough. For lots of people, though, it would feel like something was missing.

Tisfortired · 07/03/2024 15:21

I’ve been doing it for 3 months now (quit job on ML) and have been looking for another job for about 2 weeks. That tells you all you need to know about how I feel about being a SAHM.

I miss having my own money. I miss my commute reading/podcast time. I miss challenging myself mentally and speaking to other adults on topics other than weaning and sleep.

I am looking for PT though as I worked FT after having my first child 10 years ago up until now and the grind wore me down big time.

Bobskeleton · 07/03/2024 15:21

No no no no no no no no no no. And another no from me 😄

Yes there are many a day I'm tired and feel I'm being pushed to my limit, and I'm not a particularly house proud/Delia Smith/earth mother person type of person but the juggle is hard.

I work part time, and it is my lifeline at times. It enables me to have my independence and personal growth. It is also very helpful at keeping that roof over my families head.

I love my children and my husband but I also love myself and need to keep something for myself. To put it simply, I'd go coo coo if I was a SAHM. (But those that choose that life are free to from mine or anyone else's judgement)

BigFatLiar · 07/03/2024 15:21

In the day few had cars, even fewer more than one. Refrigerators were also uncommon so most houses had a cool pantry where food was kept. You shopped most days especially in warmer weather as food went off, no supermarkets so down the high street going shop to shop. In colder weather you had to set the fire and keep it going. Washing machines were also uncommon so you did the washing by hand and hung it out to dry or took it in a bus to the wash house. For cleaning carpets you'd life the carpet and hang it over a rope and beat it.

It was a lot of work. Even today I think I'd struggle without a fridge/freezer and supermarket. High Street grocers and butchers in the evening, without a supermarket they'd be manic on a Saturday.

ru53 · 07/03/2024 15:18

My ideal would be both of us working part time and taking care of DC part time. Financially not viable. Would like to have more time with DC but know I would be full of resentment if I gave up my career completely.

JamSandle · 07/03/2024 15:16

On the flip side my mum was a stay at home mum until my sibling and I went to secondary school. She was the best, just amazing. And she did enjoy it. But I know she found returning to work very difficult. She had to do jobs far below her experience and skill level and I know she really loved her career days in the city.

DinnaeFashYersel · 07/03/2024 15:16

Desecratedcoconut · 07/03/2024 14:22

Fucking hell, really? I mean, there's a whole world of interests and hobbies out there and books to read and things to see and people to meet and you think that people would, in the absence of work, give that up to make hoover lines in the carpet?

Yet there's loads of threads on here with women washing the kitchen floor and hoovering multiple times a day, deep cleaning the loo daily and the whole house twice a week and they all seem very keen on washing their duvets a lot too.

MClair · 07/03/2024 15:15

Not for me, I need the fulfilment of work, though would volunteer if I could afford to. The women in my life have always worked as they have had to due to economic factors so the idea of a stay at home Mum is quite alien to me. I wanted to make sure I got an education and a profession so that I could do a fulfilling job. I found times when I wasn’t workingquite hard psychologically and feel much better when working. I was relieved to get back to work after maternity leave. Like everything in life we all individuals and have different psychological needs andmotivations in life.

telestrations · 07/03/2024 15:14

There's a lot to be said for it and a lot of the problems we face now would or could be solved by having an adult in each household dedicated to the welfare of the home and everyone in it.

Personally I wouldn't give up my current work to do it, it's too well rewarded and would not sense, and will in fact afford my DH to be SAHP for the early years.

JamSandle · 07/03/2024 15:13

I really like earning my own money and wouldn't want to be dependent on someone else for that.

I understand the appeal of keeping the home and raising the kids, but I couldn't sacrifice my financial freedom.

Katemax82 · 07/03/2024 15:12

I hate not being able to be at home, keeping on top of things. It's a shit show

WarningOfGails · 07/03/2024 15:11

The results of your vote are really interesting! You might find some alignment with the campaign group MAHM, OP. I do too, although they are too socially conservative and not sufficiently inclusive for it all to chime with me.

gannett · 07/03/2024 15:11

Being a traditional SAHM is my worst nightmare as I want no part of child-rearing and as little part of cleaning/housekeeping as possible.

I'm also very glad I have the opportunity to work, especially in an industry I'm passionate about, and build up my financial independence. Being financially dependent on anyone would feel like jumping out of a plane with no parachute to me.

At the same time I do think capitalism has done a number on us, if we think the only other option for fulfilment is through work (especially if you work for someone else). I don't think hard work is a virtue in and of itself. I'm lucky enough to be in a career and a role that I'm fulfilled by and that tallies with my interests, but I'm not so naive to think that's the norm. The fetishisation of a hard work ethic has come at the expense of work-life balance and sense of community for too many.

Leisure has almost become a dirty word but to me it's synonymous with freedom and that's the point of the one life we have. More power to the SAHPs who are living the life they genuinely want to live, I guess.

And I truly don't understand all the "what do you DO all day" faux-surprise. If I didn't work I could fill every day 100 times over, and not with bloody cleaning nerdery like Mrs Hinch. There are so many books to read, films to watch, music to hear, things to learn. I'd be able to really devote time to fighting for causes I believe in rather than fitting it in around work. There's SO MUCH to do and see in this world. Given the time and money I cannot believe anyone would ever be bored.

Houseplanter · 07/03/2024 15:10

SpringleDingle · 07/03/2024 14:53

The idea is great! I love to bake, I like to cook, I love to walk. In real life I'd be bored shitless. I had 3 months garden leave over lockdown between jobs and I nearly went doolally. MY job gets me down but it's better than being idle!

Idle?

I don't think many busy sahms would agree, and I certainly don't

IncompleteSenten · 07/03/2024 15:09

She's not asking someone to do it for free.
Is it ok to give someone employment? Yes. Of course it is.

ohatefiftyfor · 07/03/2024 15:07

BeaRF75 · 07/03/2024 13:11

Dear Lord, no! I've no children but, even if I didn't work, I certainly wouldn't be wasting my time cooking, cleaning, doing laundry, decorating etc etc. Life really is too short for all that stuff. So I'll do the bare minimum to survive, shared with the other half, and outsource the rest.

So it's ok for someone else to do your boring work for you? Got it

ohatefiftyfor · 07/03/2024 15:07

Littlemisscapable · 07/03/2024 13:11

Oh no..I would be so bored..I love cooking and housework but for that to be my entire identity while everyone else in the household was doing their own thing ...no thanks. Yes I agree with you though...cooking is very time-consuming and even grocery shopping takes time..surely the ideal is a situation where our working lives and communities could facilitate shopping and cooking time ? Shorter hours and more local quality reasonably priced shops...

Erm, just because someone isn't in paid employment doesn't mean cooking and cleaning would be their sole identity 🤣