Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you like to be an 'old fashioned' housewife?

287 replies

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 12:56

Or a househusband (though we're mainly women on here). And I suspect that most men would say no...

I was reading the ultra processed foods thread, and it struck me (as it often does) that working families are so pushed for time in this era that preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner from scratch is nigh on impossible (and that is the basic premise of what a UPF is; its something you couldnt prepare in your own kitchen). I'm not talking about removing that opportunity, nor harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home (though I think that, whilst women's rights have thankfully progressed massively in the work place, they've not progressed so much in the home/society at large; some bygone views/expectations of women persist. I think, for example, running the house and organising children are still largely female pursuits...). It strikes me that having the 'healthy' ideal lifestyle of cooking from scratch, exercising and spending quality time raising children is a pipe dream when both parents have no choice but to work full time.

I know its complex, and theres a bigger picture (interested to hear thoughts thereof too). I'm just curious (I'm not a researcher! Genuinely just interested) to hear honest takes (few women would be happy to publicly admit in RL that 'running the home', whilst their husband earned, would be their preferred choice to working). Do you think the opportunity for one parent to be at home full time should be a choice available to us all (as it once, generally, was)?

YABU - I want to work, its not just necessity.
YANBU - I'd prefer to be at home, running the show full time.

OP posts:
BatildaBII · 07/03/2024 19:19

No, because financial dependence on men creates a terrible dynamic for most women, enables exploitation and abuse, and leaves women with no escape options. Even with a 'decent man' it does not lead to fair and healthy relationships. Talking to women of earlier generations, looking at the legal situation they were in with things like marital rape and assets, or reading autobiographies or even fiction from that (i.e. any earlier) time period, or from women who have left such set ups in religious communities in the US gives the lie to the cupcakes and crafting anti-feminist propaganda.

We are all over-worked. Men and women should both be able to work part-time without sacrificing career progress.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 19:16

Fuck no

nutbrownhare15 · 07/03/2024 19:15

I do think about it sometimes. But ultimately I think I'd be bored lonely and unfulfilled. It also really depends on your choice of partner. So many men are financially abusive or don't value housework/accuse partners of doing nothing all day or decide that if they are the only one earning that means they get to do naff all at home even on weekends. Which makes the housewife role much closer to 24/7.

ABwithAnItch · 07/03/2024 19:03

Fck no. I have ADD so I am terrible in situations where there is no real structure. I hate cleaning and chores like laundry. Cooking is ok but I find it tiresome on a daily basis. I was essentially a SAHM for 14 months after DD was born and was absolutely dreadful at it. The only thing I don’t like about working is when stress spills into family life. My job often has deadlines resulting in long hours and late nights. Sometimes I wish I had a well paying, like, civil service job that was strictly 9-5.

Musomama1 · 07/03/2024 18:55

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 13:08

😂
I think thats maybe an urban myth. Though I understand valium were considered very moreish!

For me, leaving my job was an antidepressant 😉

But aren't more people on antidepressants now than back then?

In any case I can understand the isolation making old fashioned housewives depressed, but having a smartphone these days where you can meet friends, find groups, stay in touch makes a crucial difference imo.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/03/2024 18:54

I was a SAHP for 5 years - no choice at the time, we were living overseas and nurseries were non existent. But I was quite happy with it and enjoyed the time with dds when they were babies and toddlers. Dh worked extremely long hours, 6 days a week and could do very little to help, but in the circs I didn’t expect him to.

redfacebigdisgrace · 07/03/2024 18:51

No, done it for a few years and it wasn’t for me. Not a fan of cooking and cleaning. Like to use my brain in different ways.

Temuaddiction · 07/03/2024 18:48

Wouldn't mind

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 07/03/2024 18:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

DinnaeFashYersel · 07/03/2024 18:17

harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home

My mother worked
My grandmothers worked

I've done my family tree. All the women worked. They were all working class and poor. They couldn't afford a working age adult not to be working.

Phiy43 · 07/03/2024 18:14

I work 2 days a week with a generous annual leave allowance too and find is the best balance for us. I enjoy my job but enables me to be kind or be like a full time mum/housewife as well. Have worked 3 days to full time and found life much more stressful and alot had to give at home. I don’t really see myself as an unpaid caregiver as my DH and I see ourselves as a team so share all our finances

DryIce · 07/03/2024 18:08

Realistically though, this question isnt "should all families have the option to have a parent at home", but "should women be viewed by society as natural unpaid caregivers".

I can see that it would work in some couples to have a balanced discussion and reach an agreed outcome, sure. But overall it seems once women could work, they did in large numbers so no i would not like to go back to a time where women's options were so limited

Fizbosshoes · 07/03/2024 18:03

Depends how old fashioned you mean...?
2 generations ago people probably didn't have a car, washing machine, tumble dryer, dishwasher, microwave, air fryer, freezer etc. Fewer formal childcare settings. And no supermarket deliveries..possibly no supermarkets...

...so shopping, laundry, cooking and cleaning would take a far greater portion of the day than anyone staying at home today. The term housewife meant doing all the stuff in the house....which a lot of people don't do, even if they're at home so it's not really a comparison.

I doubt there's many people today, going on foot to a market, butcher, baker etc daily and then going home to prepare a meal, sweep the floor, hand-wash clothes etc...and neither does it sound remotely appealing!

Neither of my grandmother's went out to work due to illness/disability but both were wc.

redalex261 · 07/03/2024 18:00

I have never done the housewife bit except during maternity leave. My sister stopped work after her first child (had two) and became a SAHM. Oldest is 27 - never returned to work. Chose to do this as BIL is SE And works erratic and demanding hours.

Her house is a palace, always immaculate, most food home cooked, fabulous baker etc. Her husband does dishes every night but really no other housework. He does heavy gardening, DIY, bins etc.

Has time for hobbies etc. and she forgets working women can’t always fit in a wee lunch or rustle up something delish every night in a pristine kitchen. She’s happy as larry in her life. Helps that BIL is a gem, all monies shared, nice lifestyle, holidays etc. Daresay if he was a shit would not be at all nice.

Very occasionally she grumbles about being taken for granted, but uncommon. I sometimes wish I could do the same, but I do think I would miss working (but never when surveying dish mountain at 6.30pm after working all day).

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 17:57

NoCloudsAllowed · 07/03/2024 17:52

All apple pie and sweetness until your dh starts sleeping around/beating you/gambling/going AWOL. And you're completely dependent on him for £££ so you can't complain too much.

Fuck that.

I think that's a less likely scenario than it once was. Our house for example is jointly owned, and I have my own savings. If my husband was to suddenly change character it would be him getting turfed out on his ear!

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 07/03/2024 17:52

All apple pie and sweetness until your dh starts sleeping around/beating you/gambling/going AWOL. And you're completely dependent on him for £££ so you can't complain too much.

Fuck that.

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 17:52

dottiedodah · 07/03/2024 17:32

I think the term "old fashioned housewife" is a bit of a myth .In reality many WC women worked ,and many MC ones were probably a bit bored at home especially as the children got older .Now it would be a complete non starter as most people need 2 wages with the high cost of living .Also many who have slaved away to get their degree wont want it to go to waste

By old fashioned I was referring purely to the term housewife; I single quoted it because the word itself is considered old fashioned/passé.

OP posts:
FreebieWallopFridge · 07/03/2024 17:50

Honestly? I think that wages should be high enough that running a house for an average family in average housing and in an average area should be affordable on one salary. And that the way the workforce operates should accommodate that approach in terms of hiring practices and flexibility once in employment.

But utopia does not exist and in practice that just doesn’t and can’t work.

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 17:47

I think the term "old fashioned housewife" is a bit of a myth .In reality many WC women worked

Yes, both my grandmothers worked full time when my parents were kids - and my parents were born in the 1940s. My mum's mum worked in factories and my dad's mum was a book-keeper for a trade union.

ButterflyTable · 07/03/2024 17:45

I think if I had a community around me like my Grandmother did that’d be different. We have certain expenses (Private school) if we didn’t have those for the next 9 years then who knows!

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 17:44

WithACatLikeTread · 07/03/2024 13:00

Weren't most of them on antidepressants?

Antidepressants are much more commonly prescribed for women now than they were then.

However, I don't think the use of antidepressants either now in the 1950s is actually connected to whether women work or whether they stay at home - I think it's a lot more about whether they feel they have a choice in the matter and whether they have the support of their partner and how their finances are etc.

I'm sure there are plenty of women (and indeed men) who work full-time today who would much rather be at work running the household - and I'm sure there were also plenty back in the days of being 'housewives' who would much rather have been working in a paid job.

I also suspect that the housewives who had equal access to the family finances and equal decision-making power in the relationship were a lot happier than the ones who were given a small 'housekeeping allowance' and had to justify every penny spent to their husbands.

I have a very good degree and I'm absolutely a feminist. I also don't have any kids. But if staying at home and being solely responsible for the cooking, housework etc was a viable option financially, I'd definitely take it. I hate housework if I have to do it AND go to work every day, but I'm fine with it when it's the one thing I have to do. I also don't get bored at home because if I've got Radio 4, audiobooks and the telly to accompany whatever task I'm doing, I'm all good. It's only really when I'm at work that I'm ever bored. I really like cooking and I'd love to be able to pop out during the day and buy veg and fresh meat/fish from individual shops a couple of times a week.

However, I wouldn't want to have to ask my partner for money or justify anything I'd spent on myself. I'd hate that. So without my own income, that would be an issue.

Oneearringlost · 07/03/2024 17:32

WithACatLikeTread · 07/03/2024 13:00

Weren't most of them on antidepressants?

Diazepam, actually!

dottiedodah · 07/03/2024 17:32

I think the term "old fashioned housewife" is a bit of a myth .In reality many WC women worked ,and many MC ones were probably a bit bored at home especially as the children got older .Now it would be a complete non starter as most people need 2 wages with the high cost of living .Also many who have slaved away to get their degree wont want it to go to waste

SomersetTart · 07/03/2024 17:26

Unless you have a particular love of repetitive, tedious, thankless, unpaid manual work in a socially isolated environment, 'running the home' is a ball ache.

VampireWeekday · 07/03/2024 17:12

No I would hate it. I love spending time with my children but I hate housework and house keeping. But I would love to be married to someone who stayed at home full time. To come home from work to a lovely home cooked meal, house sparkling clean, children happy and contented from all day with a parent. I would be happy to work part time too with another parent working part time, so that we both get half the week at home and half at work.