Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you like to be an 'old fashioned' housewife?

287 replies

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 12:56

Or a househusband (though we're mainly women on here). And I suspect that most men would say no...

I was reading the ultra processed foods thread, and it struck me (as it often does) that working families are so pushed for time in this era that preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner from scratch is nigh on impossible (and that is the basic premise of what a UPF is; its something you couldnt prepare in your own kitchen). I'm not talking about removing that opportunity, nor harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home (though I think that, whilst women's rights have thankfully progressed massively in the work place, they've not progressed so much in the home/society at large; some bygone views/expectations of women persist. I think, for example, running the house and organising children are still largely female pursuits...). It strikes me that having the 'healthy' ideal lifestyle of cooking from scratch, exercising and spending quality time raising children is a pipe dream when both parents have no choice but to work full time.

I know its complex, and theres a bigger picture (interested to hear thoughts thereof too). I'm just curious (I'm not a researcher! Genuinely just interested) to hear honest takes (few women would be happy to publicly admit in RL that 'running the home', whilst their husband earned, would be their preferred choice to working). Do you think the opportunity for one parent to be at home full time should be a choice available to us all (as it once, generally, was)?

YABU - I want to work, its not just necessity.
YANBU - I'd prefer to be at home, running the show full time.

OP posts:
donothing · 07/03/2024 23:56

My grandma was the stereotypical 1950s housewife.,She gave up work when she got married, had 2 kids and never went back. She lived a very boring life and was the least interesting of my grandparents. She'd just got no interesting things to talk about

So no. It wouldn't be for me

ExPostFacto · 07/03/2024 23:06

SheerLucks · 07/03/2024 22:42

We live in a city in the south east. My Mum passed away in 2022 and always maintained the opinion that property prices started to rise exponentially in the 80s because both parents started to work.

So before, mortgage lenders would lend a percentage of one person's income but were now able to lend way much more on a joint mortgage with two people working, and so on until we've reached the ridiculous situation we're in now.

I think she actually had a really good point.

As PP have pointed out, women have always worked, and a quick Google highlights other major factors. Such as the baby boomers all coming of age.

BIWO · 07/03/2024 22:56

Whenever I see this 'topic' I can only relate to this via my late Mother. She was a SAHM until I reached the age of 10 (I was born in 1964) - I was the youngest and had two older brothers who were 2 and 5 years older. In that time my late Father earned enough income to pay the mortgage to pay on his own salary. My Mother went to work PT as they realised his private pension was going to be PP. Even 50+ years ago this was a pipe dream and if you go back to Edwardian era you will find alot of women had to work with children,

SheerLucks · 07/03/2024 22:42

We live in a city in the south east. My Mum passed away in 2022 and always maintained the opinion that property prices started to rise exponentially in the 80s because both parents started to work.

So before, mortgage lenders would lend a percentage of one person's income but were now able to lend way much more on a joint mortgage with two people working, and so on until we've reached the ridiculous situation we're in now.

I think she actually had a really good point.

DelurkingAJ · 07/03/2024 22:40

Another one who was utterly miserable by the end of maternity leave. We discussed DH being a SAHD but he wasn’t keen so we both work FT. But we’re in the privileged position of earning good money and so the DC have the same childminder now they did a decade ago when I went back to work. And a cleaner and money for good food that can be cooked fairly quickly.

My DGM was an object lesson in why some women shouldn’t be forced to stay home. She was primarily miserable and resentful and unfulfilled despite DGP being in her own admission the best possible husband.

Nottodaty · 07/03/2024 22:33

Like it has already been mentioned my Gran (on both sides worked, my Mum and aunties all worked. It may have been in many cases not best jobs and usually low pay. Between us we have a few nurses & teachers very valuable and needed! To us it’s fairly normal to be working - some part time, I have a cousin who both work reduced hours.

We have a friend who recently suffered a heart attack - he works bloody hard, His wife has been a SAHM raising the two children and during their marriage he has asked for her to return to work so he could take a step back - she said no. Both the children are at uni now and she still refuses. He is counting down the years in the hope he can retire.

People need to do what works for them though without judgement while raising a young family. At some point though I think financially the other person has to work in some capacity.

JaninaDuszejko · 07/03/2024 22:24

DH and I both worked PT when the kids were small and both work FT now they are at secondary school. We have a cleaner but have always eaten home cooked food. It's just about priorities, we love food so we have homemade, someone else might work longer hours or play with their kids more or do more exercise or have a better social life.

Senzafine · 07/03/2024 22:21

Livingtothefull · 07/03/2024 22:15

Women have almost always worked historically. Apart from a tiny privileged elite that didn't have to work - but that applied to men as well as women.

The idea of the stay at home wife is a post-Industrial Revolution concept from the 19th century onwards when it became a status symbol for middle class people that the wife didn't need to work - which applied only to a small minority of women until very recently. And even then a lot of those non-working women were active in the community (when communities were often smaller and closer knit than now) as well as charity work, and were often entrepreneurial.

So those bygone days of leisured housewives were very short and limited indeed, it is all a bit of a myth really. I have to say that being the 'angel in the house' would drive me up the wall. I understand that it may suit some people - but it's not for me, I value being able to work and am so grateful for living at a time when professions aren't closed to me as they were for women in the past.

I wanted to write about women having historically worked but this is so much better put than I could have worked!

I couldn't be a stay at home mum. I became very mentally unwell during maternity leave and it was only going back to work and having that mental and physical space from the day to day of parenting that I started to become better. Plus I like earning my own money, like my job and like being able to contribute financially. I would like to work part time though.

This is just me though. Other mums might love being at home as we're all different!

ExPostFacto · 07/03/2024 22:18

DinnaeFashYersel · 07/03/2024 18:17

harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home

My mother worked
My grandmothers worked

I've done my family tree. All the women worked. They were all working class and poor. They couldn't afford a working age adult not to be working.

Yes the same ignorance is always trotted out on these threads. Poorer women have always worked.
No OP. I didn't study for years only to sit at home cooking and cleaning.
Why the obsession with one parent at home 'full-time', which only perpetuates inequality, compared to both going part-time and doing their fair share?
We fought for a 5 day work week. Why not 4? And then eventually 3... you see where I'm going with this.

But then again I came from a culture where women were expected to quit work and stay home. So we rebelled. The grass is always greener on the other side.

The key here is respect and equal partnership so many women are burnt out 'juggling' because their men refuse to lift a finger. Claiming it's 'women's work'. I don't see how us giving in and quitting is going to solve this.

WandaWonder · 07/03/2024 22:16

taking the sexism aside my first thought is who would pay for it all?, and with only one pay coming in there would possibly not be extra money for all the lifsyle choices we have these days

our lives are generally different to back then children or not

And people use the idea 'women are born to it' but are they really?

Livingtothefull · 07/03/2024 22:15

Women have almost always worked historically. Apart from a tiny privileged elite that didn't have to work - but that applied to men as well as women.

The idea of the stay at home wife is a post-Industrial Revolution concept from the 19th century onwards when it became a status symbol for middle class people that the wife didn't need to work - which applied only to a small minority of women until very recently. And even then a lot of those non-working women were active in the community (when communities were often smaller and closer knit than now) as well as charity work, and were often entrepreneurial.

So those bygone days of leisured housewives were very short and limited indeed, it is all a bit of a myth really. I have to say that being the 'angel in the house' would drive me up the wall. I understand that it may suit some people - but it's not for me, I value being able to work and am so grateful for living at a time when professions aren't closed to me as they were for women in the past.

WandaWonder · 07/03/2024 22:14

WithACatLikeTread · 07/03/2024 13:00

Weren't most of them on antidepressants?

I thought back then it was called Gin

Hugmorecats · 07/03/2024 22:12

Lzybonessah · 07/03/2024 20:21

I am one at the moment. I love it and dont miss work at all. I see friends juggling it all and whilst I admire them for it. I can see how tough it is. My youngest is at nursery 3 days a week and on those days I shop, gym, see friends & relax. So many say they'd be bored (fair enough) but I'm not and neither are the sahms near me. One key factor - we all have money be it through marriage or independent wealth. I have a cleaner/housekeeper twice a week. I don't make meals from scratch - my kids had birds eye fish fingers tonight. I have very little stress in my life and i'm going to enjoy until I decide the time is right to work again.

Who wouldn’t love having three days to themselves, money to go out with and even a cleaner/housekeeper too! I’d not be bored with that set up either.

Mumof2NDers · 07/03/2024 21:03

I’d bloody love it!!

Orangeandgold · 07/03/2024 21:01

No. If I was a housewife I would probably end up starting a business out of boredom. Or becoming an equivalent to the Avon lady.

I don’t find “housework” fulfilling (yes it’s satisfying - but it’s not something I’d do day in and day out without having something else going on).

I get some women or people are suited to doing this full time though. I wouldn’t mind maybe being a housewife for the first part of my children’s lives - or working part time.

MaybeImbad · 07/03/2024 20:59

My mum was a SAHM until I was a young teen. I haven’t had children as I never ever wanted a life spent in the home and that’s all I saw, and is what having children meant to me.

But that’s my view of it - I think my mum was very happy!

Horses for courses.

DuesToTheDirt · 07/03/2024 20:47

Staying home cooking and cleaning would drive me insane.

Lzybonessah · 07/03/2024 20:21

I am one at the moment. I love it and dont miss work at all. I see friends juggling it all and whilst I admire them for it. I can see how tough it is. My youngest is at nursery 3 days a week and on those days I shop, gym, see friends & relax. So many say they'd be bored (fair enough) but I'm not and neither are the sahms near me. One key factor - we all have money be it through marriage or independent wealth. I have a cleaner/housekeeper twice a week. I don't make meals from scratch - my kids had birds eye fish fingers tonight. I have very little stress in my life and i'm going to enjoy until I decide the time is right to work again.

Meowandthen · 07/03/2024 20:11

Rose tinted glasses. Working class women have always worked.

The idea that women should be at home is largely a post war idea as jobs were wanted for men and the women who had been competently doing all kinds of jobs had to make way for returning men.

Running a house was more work in the past as fewer mod cons. Hand washing, and no tumble dryers or dishwashers.

Being a 1950s style housewife is my idea of hell. I’d be on the gin and Valium for sure!

Didimum · 07/03/2024 20:11

It wouldn’t be for me. I love my work and working. I hated maternity leave.

ballroompink · 07/03/2024 19:45

SAHM to school-age children with plenty of disposable income for the aforementioned gym, lunches, galleries, museums and meetups to do as well as the cooking and cleaning: yes.

SAHM to under fives living on an average income: no. On my first mat leave we had so little spare cash and it was so dull. I just felt trapped and lonely (didn't have an easy baby either which didn't help). I couldn't be at home all the time with toddlers.

YankSplaining · 07/03/2024 19:38

@BatildaBII I’ll decide if my own relationship is fair and healthy, thanks.

I find it interesting that a lot (not all) of the people saying no to the topic question feel the need to inform everyone how they’d just hate it, how it’s so inferior, so sexist and bad for women, so mindless and full of drudgery and how no one in their right mind could possibly want to be a SAHM/homemaker. The SAHM answering seem to do a much better job on the whole of keeping their comments limited to their own experience, without heaping negativity and judgement on other people’s situations.

GoodlifeGlow · 07/03/2024 19:37

I’m essentially a housewife and love it I have a low stress life and my husband takes his fair share of chores eg. Cooking dinner, doing bedtimes etc

I actually think as a society the ideal would be for everyone to work part time. Childcare would be covered in school holidays, time to cook from scratch, work out, spend more time with your family/community. I think it would result in a happier, healthier population.

Obviously a fantasy as having two working adults is what has led us to the current level of house prices but if there was an AI reset I think that would be the best option.

YankSplaining · 07/03/2024 19:29

@KreedKafer : “However, I wouldn't want to have to ask my partner for money or justify anything I'd spent on myself. I'd hate that. So without my own income, that would be an issue.”

They do have things like joint bank accounts and credit cards in the UK, don’t they? My twelfth anniversary is in June and I’ve never asked my husband for money in my life, or justified spending money on myself.

Just talking generally, I find it interesting that these conversations seem to always come down to not working versus “careers.” No one ever seems to mention women who don’t have careers so much as they have low-paid jobs that aren’t terribly personally fulfilling.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 07/03/2024 19:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request