Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you like to be an 'old fashioned' housewife?

287 replies

SloaneStreetVandal · 07/03/2024 12:56

Or a househusband (though we're mainly women on here). And I suspect that most men would say no...

I was reading the ultra processed foods thread, and it struck me (as it often does) that working families are so pushed for time in this era that preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner from scratch is nigh on impossible (and that is the basic premise of what a UPF is; its something you couldnt prepare in your own kitchen). I'm not talking about removing that opportunity, nor harking back to bygone days when a woman's 'place' was in the home (though I think that, whilst women's rights have thankfully progressed massively in the work place, they've not progressed so much in the home/society at large; some bygone views/expectations of women persist. I think, for example, running the house and organising children are still largely female pursuits...). It strikes me that having the 'healthy' ideal lifestyle of cooking from scratch, exercising and spending quality time raising children is a pipe dream when both parents have no choice but to work full time.

I know its complex, and theres a bigger picture (interested to hear thoughts thereof too). I'm just curious (I'm not a researcher! Genuinely just interested) to hear honest takes (few women would be happy to publicly admit in RL that 'running the home', whilst their husband earned, would be their preferred choice to working). Do you think the opportunity for one parent to be at home full time should be a choice available to us all (as it once, generally, was)?

YABU - I want to work, its not just necessity.
YANBU - I'd prefer to be at home, running the show full time.

OP posts:
Beansmum2 · 08/03/2024 16:36

I built a career and worked till my mid 30s , I’ve been a SAHM ever since - now early 50s . Feel like I’ve had the best of both worlds really . Not sure which way I will go over the next couple of years though

SgtJuneAckland · 08/03/2024 16:35

No thanks, my brain would rot.
We both work full time and don't really use UPFs food is cooked from scratch and I've never bought a jar of sauce or packet mix for a meal in my life, pesto being the exception

Muddywalks34 · 08/03/2024 16:32

I work part time now from home with hours to suit, but I still really class myself as a housewife because I genuinely and completely do run the home. My husband wouldn’t know how to use the new dishwasher (that we have had for 3 years) or the washing machine (that we have had for 10 years). He does work stupidly long hours in a very high stress job which has afforded us a lovely home and lifestyle (that is where his skill set lies). I am very happy to be at home making sure his and my children’s needs are all tended to. When say I run the home this comes down to everything, I organise his car services, I buy his family’s gifts for birthdays/christmas. I make arrangements to meet up with his family or organise to host family events here. I shop, cook, clean, am taxi to our teens, garden, walk the dogs, do all the washing - I basically organise my families life. I like for him to come home on an evening/weekend and completely relax, the only thing he ever does is a bit of pottering in the garden or he occasionally cooks something, this is where my skill set lies and I am very happy with that. We are both very appreciative of how hard the other person works, he could not do my job and I couldn’t do his, but as a team we are very successful. I have never felt the slightest bit of unease in our set up, from a financial point of view his full salary is paid into a joint account, we own our house jointly and outright and our investments are all shared. Each to their own I suppose but I love our traditional set up, I did start working once DC started school but as said it’s very flexible and I work it around home life and my more important priorities, there is no financial need for me to work but by nature I am a very busy person, the children aren’t really dependent on me anymore - my wages are paid directly into the early retirement fund.

Kwasi · 08/03/2024 16:31

I used to be the housewife you describe but had to go to work part time due to the cost of living crisis. I want to make delicious, home cooked meals every day but I don’t have the time or the energy.

thelengthspeoplegoto · 08/03/2024 16:09

Rosesanddaisies1 · 07/03/2024 13:07

Ideally DH and I could afford to both work part time, and evenly share house work and childcare on our days off

Yes, this would be my ideal too.

Wineisgreat · 08/03/2024 16:06

Hell no! I love cooking and gardening and organising etc but I also love my job and being on mat leave has taught me that I need the sense of accomplishment that my job brings me.

Islandgirl68 · 08/03/2024 16:05

I was a stay at home mum. Money was tight, but I would do it again. Miss those days. We just need to stop criticising mums for staying home/working, do what is best for your family.

DottyLottieLou · 08/03/2024 15:59

I was one for 10 years and now I'm retired. Life couldn't be better. Too busy to be bored both times. Life's what you make it.

Whatstheword21 · 08/03/2024 15:51

Myself and my husband both work full time. We have 2 small children and 2 pets for context. I am the main earner, but im also the housekeeper, cook, child rearer etc. I do substantially more, however, my husband has been renovating our home for the last 9 years so it is slightly more even when you consider this (I do some, but a lot less that him). We have a nice home, our kids are engaged and we spent all our free time with them, we cook from scratch (with the odd take away/meal out) and have what I would consider a great family life and dynamic. So no, I would not trade this to be a stay at home wife when I feel we have a great balance and all we need with us both working!

spookehtooth · 08/03/2024 11:45

Daylightsavingscrime · 08/03/2024 10:26

Oh god no. The boredom would drive me mad.

It doesn't mean doing nothing. How many professional skills are potentially helpful around the house? It's possible to make a valuable contribution other than bringing cash in. The main tension for me, when I was sole earner wasn't her not bringing money in, it was the complaining & refusing to do her part of the bargain properly 🤷‍♂️

Also creative endeavours that can earn money, but aren't linked strictly or extended time out to train for doing something new. It can work a million different ways

It bothers me how much people falsely associate being economically inactive with laziness. I've done a lot of my learning and professional development during time out of work, I've prioritised savings to allow it over living a fancier lifestyle for this reason. It's easier for a pair to do than solo, like I've done

BigFatLiar · 08/03/2024 10:53

Anyone suspect that part of the reason women were given greater access to work in larger numbers was more about increasing labour supply and lowering wages than equality?

I think the main impetus fir women working was WW1 where women were needed to take over the jobs the men sent to the trenches left. Once they had started working the genie was out of the bottle and many wanted the new found independence. Not helped by the lack of a welfare state where war widows were stuck with no income so needed to work. One of our great grandfather's married his brothers widow after WW1 so hervand the children wouldn't be destitute (I think the workhouse was still an option).

SuffocatingSilence · 08/03/2024 10:31

I have realised that many women don’t care about the gender pay gap or equality. And are passing that down to the next generation, which is depressing as hell.

BrimfulofSasha · 08/03/2024 10:27

The “old fashioned housewife” is a relatively new thing (post war really) women have worked out of the home for millennia. They had to.
I also think it’s easy to look at it through rose tinted glasses. Mothers cooked from scratch because there was no 24 hour Tesco with ready meals and takeaway pizza, they made clothes because there wasn’t next day delivery and clothes were so expensive. Life has become cheap and convenient and throw away. Child rearing a dozen kids bowing 20-50% wouldn’t make it through childhood sounds heartbreaking.
I wouldn’t want traditional where a whole day was spent over a washing dolly and mangle. I wouldn’t want to be a husbands property, I would not want a situation where I had none of my own assets.

I would like more balance though and less commute and running around. I think modern life does give us the opportunity to know our children as their own people more. My DD is my favourite person, we have so much fun together, she is so loved. My fathers father has never told him he loved him.
id take 21st century thanks. Including the flexibility of shared parental leave and dads that share the parenting

Daylightsavingscrime · 08/03/2024 10:26

Oh god no. The boredom would drive me mad.

May487 · 08/03/2024 10:14

I would rather work less hours than I do, in the ideal. I’d still want to work. I think it’s very important to be on an equal footing in your relationship otherwise resentment and expectation starts to come through. Really quite surprised more than half of people when asked anonymously would stay at home though; wow.

Hugmorecats · 08/03/2024 10:00

I think we're all different. My ideal would probably be part-time work, which seems to be a popular choice among parents if they can afford it.

Personally I found maternity leave very stressful in its own way, but then the first time round I had a baby with colic screaming several hours a day and waking to feed every 1-2 hours a night for over a year. The second time round happened to coincide with lockdown, so I had to look after two young children on my own, without any adult company allowed during the looong days, and nowhere to go to escape.

MrsToothyBitch · 08/03/2024 08:55

I would stay at home in a heartbeat. I hate working. I resent every second. It's time away from the people and things I love. I get no satisfaction or fulfillment from it. Not the way I do when I feel content at home. I also have very bad anxiety which is work related (different work places so it's the fact I have to do it at all that does this) so I can truthfully say I don't think it does me any good to work. I go but it honestly feels like I'm deliberately heading towards a burning building every day, against all advice and common sense. I accept that having GAD will always give me something to worry about but I refuse to live like this til I retire and nothing has EVER touched the way it makes me feel about work.

I love my home. I didn't work through lockdown and I loved it. Wasn't bored at all and I can easily fill my days in and out of the house. I resent squashing everything else in round a long work day and a monster commute; even with DH to help, he's full time too. I am dyspraxic and can't cope with disorder - my coping strategy is routine and order so between running the house, working and ensuring we have couple time where I lose out atm is self care. I hate the me I take to work but I have no time to fix her.

If we had children, I want to raise them and actually be with them. My mum was there for me and I honestly thank her all the time for it. I loved it. Again- I can't do it all ... so work should go.

The only thing I like (and obviously we need) is the money- and I'm looking at ways to supplement my income that aren't dependent on wages so I can maybe cut down. DH is also looking at moving roles so we can move stuff around a bit. Truthfully I wouldn't want the whole burden on him and I know circs change so I'd probably be p/t rather than off entirely but eventually I do want to stay home and he'd love me to as well as he knows I'm utterly miserable.

I wish my choice was easier and more acceptable, esp having seen some of the judgemental smuggers on this site. I feel like I'm letting people down by being old fashioned. Especially all the people who saw a high achiever at school and thought I'd soar. Instead I'm a tired, resentful, anxious lump with excess weight and stress induced disordered eating. I am not thankful for the "opportunity" to live this way.

Fizbosshoes · 08/03/2024 07:27

I grew up in the 1980s in a London suburb which I don't consider a mc area. My mum worked pt as a Ta and dinner lady. Almost none of my peers mums were working ft. One classmate had a childminder (although I think it was a fairly informal.arrangement) but there was no breakfast or after school clubs.
Now I do live in a mc area and there are lots of housewives and SAHMs but also a lot nurseries, and wraparound care for parents who are working ft

Pigglyplaystruant99 · 08/03/2024 06:53

I used to think this was the ideal scenario and I did it for a few years but was much happier working (very) part time.

Pigglyplaystruant99 · 08/03/2024 06:52

WithACatLikeTread · 07/03/2024 13:00

Weren't most of them on antidepressants?

They took 'mothers little helpers' = Valium (Diazepam).

MissTrip82 · 08/03/2024 02:04

I don’t really recognise the time you’re referring to? In my working class family women have always worked. It’s never been an option financially to carry an adult of working age. My great grandmother was still working at nearly 80, as she had done throughout her childbearing years whilst having five children (only one of whom
survived to adulthood).

The concept of staying home was invented around the time the middle class was invented. It was a status symbol designed to indicate a man earned so well he could afford
to support non-working adults.

It’s absolutely fine to organise your family as you wish and as you can afford. But I simply don’t recognise this world people seem to think has changed

spookehtooth · 08/03/2024 01:53

It depends on the nature of the agreement and expectations, in principle I would have no problem being a house husband.

The household is the forgotten part of the economy and society, economists have generally considered it not their concern as if somehow everything domestic required for a person to be able to work full time happens automatically, by magic, with zero labour costs. For the father of modern capitalism, Adam Smith, it must have felt like that as he lived at his mum's house only able to write his famous book because she provided a roof over his head and fed him whilst he worked on it

Anyone suspect that part of the reason women were given greater access to work in larger numbers was more about increasing labour supply and lowering wages than equality? The average number of hours labour provided by a household has doubled, yet poverty is still a problem, so much of that extra income goes into paying for labour saving devices, convenient low quality food and paying other people to do jobs that there's no time to do. It's only above an average income it begins to add up

Tatumm · 08/03/2024 01:16

If people want and can afford to SAH OR to work full time, that’s fine, but I don’t see why it has to be extremes. For many, the ideal is to both work part time and share chores. If families live more simple lifestyles and can spend less, part time work becomes more possible.

The trial of the four day working week was a success but our corrupt Tory government 🙄 ignored the positive findings. God forbid that a few hours are freed.

Canuckduck · 08/03/2024 01:00

I was a SAHM for about 5 years when my kids were little. I liked being home with them and I’ve always enjoyed domestic tasks. I love food and cooking, genuinely enjoy grocery shopping and take satisfaction in cleaning and gardening. However I soon was bored when they were at school and returned to work. I work 4 days a week now which is perfect for me.

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 00:43

@SheerLucks House prices started to rise because the Conservatives changed the rules on mortgage lending in the 1980s. Before then lenders by law could only lend fairly modest multiples of salaries. Once the law changed they could offer higher multiples and 100% mortgages. It fuelled house price rises.