Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put DC's keep up to pay for a cleaner?

122 replies

Calculuses · 07/03/2024 11:46

Two sons, early 20s, both have paid £50pw for the last 4 years. I haven't put it up because as they've got older they see to their own food more and sometimes shop and cook for me too.

Both are pretty good at "helping" when asked, they clean the bathroom, do the bins, help in the garden, put the hoover round etc, but they don't do anything regularly. They both work shifts, so that doesn't help.

I used to be a bit of a domestic goddess but for various reasons have lost interest in that and the house isn't looking well cared for. That bothers me, but not enough to do anything about it!

It strikes me that DC probably should pay a bit more, just because that's what happens IRL and if they did I could employ a cleaner. Maybe fortnightly, we can keep on top of bathrooms, hoovering etc it's the "proper" cleaning that doesn't get done.

FWIW I could afford to employ a cleaner without putting the keep up, but feel this is a way to link their contribution to the cost of running the household and they should "feel" the COL itswim. Also, I've never actually spent any of their keep, it's all in a savings account to give back to them when they move out, although they don't know that.

If it is a reasonable idea, how much? Ds1 now earns significantly more than DS2, they were equal when the arrangement started.

OP posts:
lap90 · 09/03/2024 04:45

Just as you say they should pay more which is what happens IRL, which isn't unreasonable, as adults they should be playing a bigger role in home life and not merely 'helping' when asked... shift work or not. It's really not farfetched for an adult to be expected to do this.

PeachCastle · 09/03/2024 03:33

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 12:07

And children aren't cash cows to fund a lifestyle you want to have, nor are they skivvies to take over when you can longer be arsed... Presumably OP also uses electricity and gas, eats food and uses the internet. Saying its to demonstrate cost of living and then chucking the extra money at a cleaner doesn't demonstrate that. It shows oh hey MUM wants a cleaner so now we're paying for it.

They are not children, they are adults. Split all the bills 3 ways between the 3 adults living in the property. Simple and fair. If they don't like it they can move out.

Beautiful3 · 08/03/2024 22:47

I'd increase it to £100 per week, each.

maddiemookins16mum · 08/03/2024 22:09

£50 a week!!!! Is it still 1999!!

Notamum12345577 · 08/03/2024 21:48

Calculuses · 07/03/2024 11:46

Two sons, early 20s, both have paid £50pw for the last 4 years. I haven't put it up because as they've got older they see to their own food more and sometimes shop and cook for me too.

Both are pretty good at "helping" when asked, they clean the bathroom, do the bins, help in the garden, put the hoover round etc, but they don't do anything regularly. They both work shifts, so that doesn't help.

I used to be a bit of a domestic goddess but for various reasons have lost interest in that and the house isn't looking well cared for. That bothers me, but not enough to do anything about it!

It strikes me that DC probably should pay a bit more, just because that's what happens IRL and if they did I could employ a cleaner. Maybe fortnightly, we can keep on top of bathrooms, hoovering etc it's the "proper" cleaning that doesn't get done.

FWIW I could afford to employ a cleaner without putting the keep up, but feel this is a way to link their contribution to the cost of running the household and they should "feel" the COL itswim. Also, I've never actually spent any of their keep, it's all in a savings account to give back to them when they move out, although they don't know that.

If it is a reasonable idea, how much? Ds1 now earns significantly more than DS2, they were equal when the arrangement started.

Obviously it is up to you what you pay, but I was paying £50 pounds a week or more over 20 years ago when I was earning 15k a year. And that seemed a bargain then

coastalhawk · 08/03/2024 20:45

Reasonable. Or could be a choice - either tidy the house more or rent goes up.

Sto123 · 08/03/2024 20:34

Sto123 · 08/03/2024 20:33

We paid 40 a week 20 years ago on new at 15/16 and had to do a lot round the house! It was crap. So I think you're dcs are getting an easy ride!!!

NMW**

Sto123 · 08/03/2024 20:33

We paid 40 a week 20 years ago on new at 15/16 and had to do a lot round the house! It was crap. So I think you're dcs are getting an easy ride!!!

Redpaisley · 08/03/2024 10:40

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 12:32

Overall running costs don't typically include outsourcing the shit you can't be arsed with

A lot of people hire cleaners. Who made you a judge? She is doing a lot and still working so she is not outsourcing the shit she can't be arsed with. She is also saving money her sons are giving them for them.

FinallyFeb · 07/03/2024 17:20

I agree re the savings.

Catza · 07/03/2024 17:18

Calculuses · 07/03/2024 12:27

This is why I've been taking money off them to save for them. They're not great at saving, the more they have the more they'll spend

OP, your kids will never be good at saving unless they 1. have something to save for, 2. have unpredictable income without a safety net and 3. have had a chance to practice regular saving.
I'm afraid you saving their money for them is not going to set them up with any savings skills and as long as they live with you and pay pennies, they won't feel the pressure to save anyway. Please use the money they pay you to offset some of the costs of them living at home. Chances are, they will happily and quickly spend the lump sum you give them when they move out anyway.

Caroparo52 · 07/03/2024 16:27

If you want a cleaner then get a cleaner.
You've said you can afford one.
To me having a cleaner is as essential as having petrol in the car.
You don't need any bollocks excuse reason to justify getting one imo.
By all means ask DC for more money but it's not to pay for the cleaner

Workawayxx · 07/03/2024 16:00

I’d definitely up their keep and link it to needing a cleaner (and spend it on a cleaner rather than saving for them and paying yourself!). The other option is a rota or each person covering certain tasks if they’d rather not pay more. Also, even if they’re on minimum wage, if they work full time, £200 a month is a small % of earnings.

I have a cleaner 2 hrs per week which covers a small 3 bed (no washing or changing sheets). It costs approx £120 a month so I’d say an extra £50 a week each should nearly cover it? I think it’s important they realise they’re adults and need to contribute to keeping the home clean and tidy, not children who “help” when asked.

Fizzadora · 07/03/2024 15:17

Question
Am I being unreasonable to put DC's keep up to pay for a cleaner?
Answer
No - It didn't need four pages of debate.

ShareTheDuvet · 07/03/2024 15:07

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 12:07

And children aren't cash cows to fund a lifestyle you want to have, nor are they skivvies to take over when you can longer be arsed... Presumably OP also uses electricity and gas, eats food and uses the internet. Saying its to demonstrate cost of living and then chucking the extra money at a cleaner doesn't demonstrate that. It shows oh hey MUM wants a cleaner so now we're paying for it.

Why are the kids skivvies?? They all live in the house why shouldn’t they help clean it 🙄

MILTOBE · 07/03/2024 13:53

Why don't you say £200 each (which is so cheap - I bet they spend that on going out) and they split the electricity bill between them? They are the ones using most of the electricity, so you might as well benefit from them paying the bill.

I'd also say the cost of the cleaner should be split between the number of adults in the house.

And don't give them the electricity money back!

makeanddo · 07/03/2024 13:45

Yes I do and actually I have similar issues although neither of mine are living at home and working, they are students. Don't get me wrong, it isn't easy and sometimes it feels easier to just do it yourself. However I am determined that they understand that if they live at home when working they will absolutely be expected to muck in regardless of whether me and DH are working.

PoppingTomorrow · 07/03/2024 13:41

In a few years the girlfriends/wives of these men will be posting on MN complaining that they don't pull their weight around the house

Both are pretty good at "helping" when asked, they clean the bathroom, do the bins, help in the garden, put the hoover round etc, but they don't do anything regularly
Ick ick ick.

ChangedUserName13 · 07/03/2024 13:34

I'm laughing as I paid £50 per Fridays in the month when i lived at home (£200 / £250 a month) when I was earning £13,000 a year - that was 15 years ago

I don't see it as a bad a thing to put the rent up to make the home they're living in nicer - everyone benefits from a cleaner.
And they're still getting somewhere to live without the full cost of moving out

RichardsGear · 07/03/2024 13:28

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 12:28

Nowhere but I wouldn't use money my kids earned to pay for a cleaner because I'd just lost the interest in keeping MY OWN HOME clean

It's either the OP's own home and hers alone, which means the sons should be regarded as lodgers and pay the market rate for that, or it's the family home and the adults in the family contribute financially and do their bit regarding keeping it clean etc.

Calculuses · 07/03/2024 13:22

makeanddo · 07/03/2024 13:15

No I wouldn't 'chuck' my children out because they wouldn't clean the bathroom Hmm. They would be making a decision based on an adult conversation about living in my house.

I'm not really sure why you posted your question because all you seem to have done is make excuses for them!

Fgs get a cleaner but pls dont think raising a man is 'kind to animals' in any way makes up for raising a man who shows a lack of respect for his mother by not even seeing a toilet needs cleaning.

Do you have adult children? Did you clean the toilet when living at home as a young adult?

Obviously I have been a terrible parent, but I don't know any of my peers with adult DC at home who are getting more than a bit of help here and there. Most not even that, boys and girls.

OP posts:
FinallyFeb · 07/03/2024 13:21

It sounds a good idea.
I increase my DC’s ‘rent’ each year.
DC2 is 25 and earns 26k and DC1 is 23 and earns 40k. They both give me £250 per month and there is an understanding that they need to save a significant chunk of their income which they do.

pootlin · 07/03/2024 13:18

Calculuses · 07/03/2024 13:07

The every Sunday thing is part of the problem. The reaosn the teenage chores system doesn't work. They work shifts. They can't have a set day for it.

Funny how they don't forget their shifts but forget their chores, eh? Hmm

Deffo put their rent up.

Xmasbaby11 · 07/03/2024 13:16

I like the idea of asking them which they'd prefer - pay for a cleaner, or do the housework regularly. If they say clean, you could have a trial period, and if it doesn't work, you get a cleaner.

makeanddo · 07/03/2024 13:15

No I wouldn't 'chuck' my children out because they wouldn't clean the bathroom Hmm. They would be making a decision based on an adult conversation about living in my house.

I'm not really sure why you posted your question because all you seem to have done is make excuses for them!

Fgs get a cleaner but pls dont think raising a man is 'kind to animals' in any way makes up for raising a man who shows a lack of respect for his mother by not even seeing a toilet needs cleaning.