Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
sleekcat · 07/03/2024 16:44

I do not think the children are suffering by not having all the things you usually buy them for 4 days per month. Unless, of course, they have no food or heating or a place to sleep. Assuming they have those things, then they don't need to be spending money and doing exciting things every weekend. They already have the hobbies you mention and that's enough if the other parent can't afford to sort something. They can play board games at home or go to the park.

Okaaaay · 07/03/2024 16:39

Just my opinion (no real experience) but I think this is CF on the NRP side. You have the children 86% of the time and pay for 95% of their needs (including all clothing, extra curricular stuff, as well as overheads when they are with you). Why on earth should you then subsidise the NRP for the 14% of the time they have their own children.

Practically, if the NRP can’t meet their basic needs (food, heat etc) then maybe there is a conversation to be had (though I strongly believe no legal or other obligation to bridge this gap unless you are accessing child benefit in which case they would be entitled to 14% of that). But for niceties like days out, absolutely not. Don’t agree with the whole ‘the children suffer’ here either - they just learn the realities of life and that includes not everyone being able to afford a paid activity daily. Crikey OP you have been more than generous here. I think the therapist is bonkers. How does having someone subsidise your lifestyle help with self esteem?!

Sonora25 · 07/03/2024 16:39

Bruisername · 07/03/2024 16:33

It’s a bit messed up that the message they are giving their kid is that they need money to have a good time with them

Exactly. If you see your kids only four days a month you have plenty of time to organise and plan low/no cost activities. You can have lots of fun outside of paid stuff.

also is it good for NRP’s self esteem that the other parent has to fund the activities. For their self esteem I would recommend to work more! Even £100 can make a difference to plan a few paid activities.

Hotgirlwinter · 07/03/2024 16:39

Based on everything you’ve said it honestly feels like NRP is just after money.

You already take the lions share of the financial burden of raising children, with no CMS despite it being VERY far from 50/50.

I would continue to offer the occasional cinema ticket or swimming pass etc by way of email a few days / week before “DC said they’d like to see X at the cinema but if you want to take them I’ll give them the money for tickets and treats”

What it sounds like they want is a transfer of cash into their account to do with whatever they want.

No fecking way. Not on 4 nights a month. No chance. As your kids get older you’ll be able to give them a tenner each when they go off for the day then they can do as they choose

Notcms · 07/03/2024 16:37

HollyKnight · 07/03/2024 16:33

How old are the children? I would probably give them spending money to take with them because I would like them to have a good time while they are away, but I would not give cash money directly to the ex.

They take their own money yes 👍🏻 so can buy things they might fancy eg ice cream
If out & about etc

OP posts:
Beezknees · 07/03/2024 16:36

If anything, the NRP should be paying you.

Sonora25 · 07/03/2024 16:35

the kids are only there 2 nights every two weeks? Do they really need cinema/swimming/theatre etc that weekend. NRP can take them to parks, library, playgrounds and other low cost activities. As long as they are fed enough I don’t see why you should provide extra funds.

caringcarer · 07/03/2024 16:35

If you have the DC 12 nights out of 14 and you pay for all uniforms, clothing, haircuts, toiletries, activities I can't really see what NRP needs to pay for. You say they can afford heating and eating but only work part time. Surely the answer is to increase the hours they work. As it is you are not asking the NRP to pay any maintenance for their child. I'd be pointing that out to the therapist. Also if NRP could not afford 1 DC they should have thought a bit more carefully before having a second DC. I suspect the NRP just wants funds to do 'nice things' with both their DC as it seems their other DC never gets to do 'nice things' and they want both their DC to have similar experiences in life. If that's the case it's up to the other DC's to step up and earn more to spend on both their DC. Next the therapist will be telling you it wouldn't be fair for you to leave money to your DC in your will because NRP's other DC will feel left out and have less than their siblings. I'd be furious in your shoes. I'd speak to this family therapist and point out the financial settlement was agreed by the court and the NRP was happy with it at the time. Unless they are disabled they should increase their work hours.

Winter2020 · 07/03/2024 16:35

I think you are trying as best you can e.g. booking the activities.

I can understand why you don't want to hand over a wad of cash as your children still might not do any paid for activities so I think your approach has been fair enough. Perhaps just tell the other parent if they want to do something with the kids (on occasion) you will book it up to x amount but that you won't give them money if they have no plans. There are plenty of families that can't afford to be out at the cinema etc. Unless they get up early to take them to the kids morning showing or find an offer it will cost loads for 5+ people. If they don't earn enough to take all the family to the cinema then they won't be the only ones.

KanyeJohnWestTuna · 07/03/2024 16:34

If you buy tickets that are later refused, then they either want money that can be spent on anything or want to imply that the money they are spending comes from them not you.

FatLarrysBanned · 07/03/2024 16:34

nearlyemptynes · 07/03/2024 14:43

How can a non resident parent claim child benefit? surely if the resident parents income is above the threshold it is not an entitlement?

If the parents are separated either parent can claim chuld benefit as long as they are not over the threshold and there is agreement with the other parent iver who gets the payment. Only one parent can claim so it made sense for my ex to get the £80 odd quid a month as I couldn't claim it being a high earner.

Would be helpful if OP would answer the question about Child Benefit as if not being claimed by OP it sounds like the NRP could claim it and then the issue would resolve itself - 2 children would give the NRP nearly £200 a month, plus the CB for their latest child (unless their new partner is over the new £60k threshold).

Bruisername · 07/03/2024 16:33

It’s a bit messed up that the message they are giving their kid is that they need money to have a good time with them

HollyKnight · 07/03/2024 16:33

How old are the children? I would probably give them spending money to take with them because I would like them to have a good time while they are away, but I would not give cash money directly to the ex.

Noicant · 07/03/2024 16:32

HebburnPokemon · 07/03/2024 16:03

Same.

And NRP is a CF.

Same I’ve assumed male but my view would be the same either way. If you only see your kid 2 out of 14 days and don’t pay CM then why the hell would the rp have to pay you for extras.

coodawoodashooda · 07/03/2024 16:32

Notcms · 07/03/2024 12:43

Try to answer Qs.

Post divorce - fair financial settlement was made and both parties happy.

NRP has gone on to another relationship and has a new child.

No idea how many hours they work - but part-full time is what the children are told, and the phone isn't generally answered in working hours.

The professional involved is a family therapist advised by carcass post court case for children.

NRP has met individually several times with the therapist, and in our first joint meeting I was told that I should financially provide for the children while in NRP care.

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc'

I should say everything for the children is paid for by me, no requests are made to the NRP for school stuff or extracurricular activities.

I genuinely can't decide if this is CF, or if IABU.

Tell the therapist to pay then! What a cf.

Hankunamatata · 07/03/2024 16:31

Tell the therapist you have and the nrp didn't reply

OnceinaMinion · 07/03/2024 16:31

Yes is ex PT because of new baby or is their partner who has the baby?
Because if they are just PT then they need to work more obviously.

Honestly they sound upset in the difference in circumstances but that’s not your problem to solve. You aren’t claiming CS. If you aren’t getting child benefit you could let them, it would only be for a second child for them though? But plenty to do something for the small amount of time they are there?
How old is DC as the younger they are there are plenty of cheaper things to do. Are they only seeing them 2 days in 14 as that seems very little unless there is a good reason (like distance) not to do tea once a week.

SpringleDingle · 07/03/2024 16:28

Yeah - you can tell the therapist to pull the other one as it has bells on!! Your exes self esteem is not your problem. The kids are your problem and you have made generous well intention offers to allow the kids to do fun things with their dad and he turned them down (because his ego!) so you are no longer required to do more. The judge didn't order you to pay spousal maintenance so you are not required to cough up anything. Your ex gets a good deal as he doesn't pay any parenting expenses (uniform, trips, clubs) or maintenance.

I have paid for specific activities for my exH and DD to do together (e.g. a trip to a London show when they went there for the weekend). I ask him if he would like me to get them tickets for X as DD really fancies going and he says yes (or occasionally no). If you start giving him 100quid a month or something that creates a precedent and you'll just end up feeling grumpy when he doesn't do any fun things with them anyway and just pockets the cash

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 07/03/2024 16:27

It’s not really a matter of asking opinions on this. Put the details into the CMS calculator and see what it comes up with.

Wish44 · 07/03/2024 16:26

do your kids have a nice time when they go to NRP? Do they complain about not having money to do things etc?

I would help if they were complaining

Bruisername · 07/03/2024 16:26

im guessing the nrp can’t work more because they are looking after their other child. Which isn’t the ops problem

Zyq · 07/03/2024 16:25

Has the professional ever explained why the first remedy should not be the NRP working more regularly so that they can afford these things for themselves? If the issue is the NRP's self-respect, surely that's infinitely better than taking handouts from. you?

GabriellaMontez · 07/03/2024 16:25

Does the therapist know you don't claim cms?

I think it's beyond belief that they would advise you to continue to fund a nrp.

How does the therapist even know details of your income? You're the rp... you don't owe ex anything. Including details of your income.

Just goes to show how 'professional' some professionals are...

Ibouncetothebeat · 07/03/2024 16:22

Nope! Plenty of time to take on an extra job. I would not be funding their weekends! It’s only 4 days a month! Your children’s “lifestyle” is not going to be affected that much. Plenty of children don’t go to the cinema or swimming with their parents it doesn’t hurt them.

pootlin · 07/03/2024 16:21

Notcms · 07/03/2024 15:26

Thanks all.

I'm questioning myself because we worked previously with the therapist and I really rated them. It's clear NRP has done enough whispers in the ear to get them to think children have an unfair life experience when with NRP.

During the court case cafcass were appointed by the court. As there was food bank involvement at the time I dropped off food....and was called controlling.
I have booked & paid for swimming, theatre etc and when tickets handed over been told no thanks.

Therapist says it's a matter of NRP self esteem and needing to have some say. I feel like it 'beggers cannot be choosers' knowing they were all activities the kids would like - and yes I always buy extra tickets for new child & partner too.

So activities were available - and I pay for the usual soccer clubs for Saturday etc.that we both take the children to on our weekend.

Our finances were shared 50/50 despite the differences in what we brought into the marriage pot, and that I am the RP.

Therapist says it's a matter of NRP self esteem and needing to have some say. I feel like it 'beggers cannot be choosers' knowing they were all activities the kids would like - and yes I always buy extra tickets for new child & partner too.

So this parent chose their pride over doing activities with their child? I bet any money you hand over will NOT be spent on your child.

Don’t fall for the manipulation.