Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
OnceinaMinion · 07/03/2024 18:00

I think if they can’t have DC that much because they work long hours, but then they don’t, then they just sound like a shit parent, they sound like they could see them much more and choose not to. That’s the issue. The children will realise this.
Contact time is to spend time with DC, it’s nice to do things, but it’s also just to be together.

Catforaheadrest · 07/03/2024 17:47

This sounds batshit

I have SC, and we have 4 overnights every two weeks (EOW plus a weeknight). We’re the lower income household.

Now, we don’t need foodbanks, but I’m racking my brain for the last time we took the SDCs swimming/cinema/etc. our weekends are full of their sports activities and visiting friends and family, parks, walks etc. there’s free entry museums near us.

In fact, I think we’ve been to the cinema once because it was a film I really wanted to see.

We do do the odd “big” family activity, but that’s usually a voucher given at Xmas or for my DH’s birthday etc. But it would have zero effect on the SDC’s welfare or our relationship if we didn’t do “big” things.

Nothing to do with self esteem and all to do with jealousy.

CagneyAndLazy · 07/03/2024 17:46

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 07/03/2024 17:39

I think it’s interesting that OP has hidden her sex, and the sex of the NRP. I wonder why that might be?

You do sound a bit snarky & controlling OP. Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC.

Edited

Because the NRP will be female and on here it has to be the male at fault.

You've designated the OP as 'snarky' so presumably you've decided they're the male.

Cherrysoup · 07/03/2024 17:44

I don’t think they need to do tons of activities every time they see their nrp every two weeks, they’re doing stuff with you. Paying for the new child and the nrp is-imo-bonkers. Kids don’t need to go to expensive/paid for activities every time they see the nrp and yes, frankly, he or she could up their working hours, given the6 now have another child. You’re not asking for cms, so absolno, yo7 shouldn’t be paying for extra stuff when your dc are with the nrp.

Notcms · 07/03/2024 17:43

Lolapusht · 07/03/2024 17:30

Therapist says it's a matter of NRP self esteem and needing to have some say. - so nothing to do with the best interest of the children then!

Lots of children don’t get to do fun things and that’s absolutely fine. Your children get to do the fun things with you during the majority of the time so they’re not really missing out (we don’t do treat things every weekend. We’ll maybe do things that cost mom ey a couple of times a month max).

To recap, 1) you pay for all child related activities even those taking place during NRP contact time 2) you offer and buy tickets but NRP refuses these 3) you send DC with their own money during contact time 4) NRP works but won’t say how much 5) NRP has a new child (do they have a partner? Do they work?) 6) you took food to the NRP when they were struggling and this was seen as controlling.

Unless there is a hugely incredible back story, you are in no way being unreasonable and do not pay anything else!

(Also, what’s “part-full time”?!)

Part-full time is just that I have no idea if actual working hours are part time or full time.
In court case it was said NRP worked long hours and so could not have more than 2 nights per fortnight....but then the kids find out other parent does the school run for the other child so that implies part time hours. It's a mystery.

NRP has a partner yes. They are both parents to the new child. (Who my children adore BTW, and buy birthday, Easter, Xmas cards/gift for 👍🏻).

the only backstory really is the divorce was long & painful, with court orders for both finance and children as we could not agree what was best.

OP posts:
LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 07/03/2024 17:42

If a parent only sees their children 2 week end a month and has no other children-related expenses they can easily entertain them with free activities (crafts, museums, cooking/baking, learn to play chess, scrapbooking, nature trails…).

HoneyWogan · 07/03/2024 17:40

If it were true that the NRP thinks that your children should have a more equal standard of living at both parents' houses, if you were to enable this, surely that would then just clearly underline the vast difference in the standard of living between their own children on those two days per fortnight and that of their new child who lives with them all the time.

So would their logic be that you also need to pay for their child who is nothing to do with you to have the same standard of living? What if they had another child, three more children, twelve more children with their new partner? Are you expected to keep them all in a nice privileged lifestyle as well?

The asking for money to be able to take them to the cinema, theatre etc. and then turning down tickets for those exact activities when offered them free is extremely suspicious. It makes me think of certain homeless people who ask you for money for a sandwich or a Greggs bake or whatever - but then when you ask which kind they'd like and offer to buy it for them, they get angry that you haven't handed over money. A genuine homeless person would be very grateful to be given the chicken salad sandwich or vegan sausage roll that they originally asked you to pay for for them.

I think it's safe to assume that any money you gave would not be going to benefit your children at all. It's just a very transparent ruse - no different from the beggar who wants money for a six-pack of lager or weed but knows they're much more likely to get it if they claim they're desperate for a Happy Meal or two instead.

Anameisaname · 07/03/2024 17:40

@Notcms the NRP self esteem may be a concern for a therapist but it is not your problem.
You've been generous in not wanting maintenance. You've been generous in offering tickets and these were refused. You've been generous in taking the kids for the majority of the time. You've been generous in splitting things 50 50 in the financial order.

The NRP in this case may find the unequal situation difficult to stomach. But just read all the threads in here from women who are having to move to smaller accommodation, smaller incomes, change of lifestyle etc.

It is not your job to solve parenting for the ex as long as the basics and essentials for your kids are taken care of.

If you have a financial order then there's nothing more to say really. If you haven't then get one ASAP!

anonwanton · 07/03/2024 17:39

So, you've offered tickets and opportunities for the ex to do these things with your joint DC and been generous enough to pay for the NRP ticket as well as their new DC? They turn these offers down - why? Do they feel patronised, humiliated, a charity case, controlled? I'm trying to imagine how they've persuaded the less than professional 'professional' that it affects their self esteem. Well, tough.

You need to be clear with the therapist that you have offered these things, that the lack of a CMS claim is like a gift of extra money to the ex already and if they're that hard up why can't they work more or be more imaginative about the activities they do together? It smacks of jealousy to me.

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 07/03/2024 17:39

I think it’s interesting that OP has hidden her sex, and the sex of the NRP. I wonder why that might be?

You do sound a bit snarky & controlling OP. Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC.

Ebeneser · 07/03/2024 17:36

I'd be petty , claim CMS and give that back to them every month 😂

FreebieWallopFridge · 07/03/2024 17:33

I wouldn’t give the NRP money, no. If ‘nice activities’ are the issue, then you should be able to provide said activities. I rather think if you give money directly, not a penny of that would go on the children.

I know you said in your view, it’s a case of ‘beggars can’t be choosers’, but I think it’s more ‘you can’t have your cake and eat it’. They can’t plead poverty while simultaneously turning down the thing they say they can’t do 🤷🏻‍♀️ especially not when it’s 2 days in a fortnight and there’s no clarity about their employment or earnings AND when they done pay CMS.

Perhaps they should use what they would contribute via CMS for the activities they apparently want to do with the children…

MrsPerfect12 · 07/03/2024 17:31

Do not give the non resident parent money. it's complete cheeky! Especially when they've went on to have more children and can't pay for those they have.

id ditch the therapist too.

Yeahno · 07/03/2024 17:31

Change therapist. Your therapist is going in gaslighting territory. Are you paying for this s
Hmm jhit?

Lolapusht · 07/03/2024 17:30

Therapist says it's a matter of NRP self esteem and needing to have some say. - so nothing to do with the best interest of the children then!

Lots of children don’t get to do fun things and that’s absolutely fine. Your children get to do the fun things with you during the majority of the time so they’re not really missing out (we don’t do treat things every weekend. We’ll maybe do things that cost mom ey a couple of times a month max).

To recap, 1) you pay for all child related activities even those taking place during NRP contact time 2) you offer and buy tickets but NRP refuses these 3) you send DC with their own money during contact time 4) NRP works but won’t say how much 5) NRP has a new child (do they have a partner? Do they work?) 6) you took food to the NRP when they were struggling and this was seen as controlling.

Unless there is a hugely incredible back story, you are in no way being unreasonable and do not pay anything else!

(Also, what’s “part-full time”?!)

NotThatWitty · 07/03/2024 17:28

gmgnts · 07/03/2024 17:08

I am astonished that a therapist - especially one appointed by a court - should stray into lecturing one parent about financial matters that have already been decided by the court. It is highly unprofessional and none of their business. I'd be inclined to make a complaint against them.

This.
I imagine that NRP will eventually now say things along the lines of, "Well, you should give me X, so I can do Y with the DC. You have to, the therapist told you."

Personally, I wouldn't give them any money, but if they do try anything along the above then I'd respond with, "Well, free feel to take me back to court to let the judge decide if I should give you money for 4 days a month." I'd then be super petty and put in a CMS claim.

Vod · 07/03/2024 17:28

Roastiesarethebestbit · 07/03/2024 17:23

If there was a fair settlement at the time of divorce, then a clean break is best and there shouldn’t need to be any extra support from you. However, the nrp may feel that they sacrificed their career/supported yours while you were together, and it’s that reason that they are a low earner now. I understand a reluctance to just hand over extra money, but purchasing tickets for events that you have chosen may be perceived to be controlling. Maybe there is a middle ground? Where the children can discuss activities that they would like to do with the nrp and then the children can be allocated a budget to spend with the nrp?

If the NRP would like the financial settlement looked at again, they should do this through an application to the court. It shouldn't come via a therapist who presumably lacks legal qualifications. That's really inappropriate.

RawBloomers · 07/03/2024 17:27

Therapist says it's a matter of NRP self esteem and needing to have some say.

That’s a very different twist. I would probably laugh at this tbh, their self esteem will be mush better served by getting off their arse and doing something for their children than getting handouts from their ex. Then maybe say something along the lines of you attending this for the benefit of the children but that you find it disrespectful and unprofessional for them to try to pretend your ex’s self-esteem is in any way your responsibility.

mydrivingisterrible · 07/03/2024 17:27

Fraaahnces · 07/03/2024 15:37

Stop being so bloody generous! He’s a grabby git and the therapist is deluded. He needs to adult up. His self esteem is absolutely not your responsibility and it isn’t your problem either. This shit would be laughed out of court.

I think "she's" a grabby git. I think the OP is male (not sure though).

OP, it's a difficult one as you obviously want to do best for your DC, but ultimately your DC isn't your responsibility while in the other parents care.
I'm sure your ex didn't ask your say in introducing a new partner, then baby into your child's life etc because their life is separate to yours. In regards to this it's effectively the same. It is the other parents responsibility, not yours. Just make sure your child is happy with you - it's all you can do (otherwise lets be honest you're subsidizing their other child too).

LittleOwl153 · 07/03/2024 17:25

I think I would go back to the therapist and say you have offered tickets/swimming etc and get no response. And also exactly that the therapist thinks you should be offering... I think the response will be eye opening.

Roastiesarethebestbit · 07/03/2024 17:23

If there was a fair settlement at the time of divorce, then a clean break is best and there shouldn’t need to be any extra support from you. However, the nrp may feel that they sacrificed their career/supported yours while you were together, and it’s that reason that they are a low earner now. I understand a reluctance to just hand over extra money, but purchasing tickets for events that you have chosen may be perceived to be controlling. Maybe there is a middle ground? Where the children can discuss activities that they would like to do with the nrp and then the children can be allocated a budget to spend with the nrp?

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/03/2024 17:23

He can work more hours. He apparently chooses not to. Being able to provide treats for his children from his own earnings would do far more for his "self-esteem" than holding his hand out to his ex.

PeryleneGreen · 07/03/2024 17:16

NRP is being ridiculous and petty. If s/he really cared about having nice experiences with the kids, they'd either accept your generous offers of tickets, save up, or use a little imagination and do something fun that doesn't cost much. I'd lose respect for the therapist and take anything else they recommend with a grain of salt.

Starseeking · 07/03/2024 17:14

DC are with you 12 nights out of 14, yet some agency is expecting you to subsidise your EX's lifestyle while they work part-time? Sounds bonkers to me.

SadlyACupOfTeaDoesNotSolveEverything · 07/03/2024 17:08

CuriousGeorge80 · 07/03/2024 17:06

“I’m very happy to start claiming the maintenance I’m entitled to through CMS and then transfer that back to him every month, although I do think it’s easier that he just accepts that I am covering significantly more of the cost of looking after our children than he is or that I am legally required to, and that he takes responsibility for his own position.”

”His self esteem is no longer my issue. I can’t control what job he does, how many hours he works, how much he earns or how he spends his money. Or how many other children he has. Therefore I cannot be held accountable for his self esteem.” - also, assuming you are a woman and be a man, I would question whether they would be suggesting the same if the sexes were reversed as I don’t think they would ever suggest a man should be responsible for a woman’s self esteem after divorce.

This is a very fair and measured response.

Swipe left for the next trending thread