Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 07/03/2024 22:10

I would not pay any extra money.

It is in your children's best interests to experience and learn that people can and do (even themselves) live a more frugal lifestyle and are still happy and wonderful.
Your children have the basics, good food, medical treatment, a safe home, transport, education and there is nothing wrong with them experiencing that their father is poorer than you.

You could try spending much more time doing free activiities while the kids are with you. Equip your children with the mindset to find something interesting to do when they are bored and have not much money. Then, when at their Dad's place, they might be more satisfied. Are they asking for what he can't afford? Are they acting entitled and making him feel useless?

I would not be giving your ex any more money.
You could create a monster. Worse still, you could feed into your own children's expectation for unnecessary luxury and set them up for feeling like failures as adults if they do not achieve financial success similar to you.

Ultimately, your children should respect and love their Dad regardless of whether he treats them to expensive past times.

They need to know reality or they will grow up ignorant of how to entertain themselves and unable to be secure with less.

MawkishRomantic · 07/03/2024 22:01

If there was a huge discrepancy in lifestyle, so for example you as the father with millions, and them the non resident with no money living on universal credit and working part time.
Surely they might be able to go back to court for a better settlement.

My BIL pays a huge settlement for his first wife, and then separate support for the children. She does not have to work and is quite affluent, as the house is also paid for.

MrsKeats · 07/03/2024 21:59

It's not your job to boost the self-esteem of your ex.
How come they are having other children if they can't afford the kids they have and pay no maintenance? Ridiculous.

TruthorDie · 07/03/2024 21:53

@Notcms what are the credentials exactly of this therapist? As a family therapist l see what they said as a massive over-step and rather unprofessional.

BungleandGeorge · 07/03/2024 21:50

Fingeronthebutton · 07/03/2024 21:39

I find it odd that you refer to your children’s father as non resident parent
I think those 3 words say more about you than any financial difficulties.

Where does it say the NRP is a father? I thought NRP was used to deliberately avoid stating which parent

Pumpkinpie1 · 07/03/2024 21:47

It’s not your responsibility that Ex now has another child and is struggling financially.
I think you need to stay firm and not be guilted into paying extra.
The Therapist sounds gullible

RedLeicesterRedLeicester · 07/03/2024 21:45

What a head fuck!
I honestly wouldn’t. It’s totally backwards. The fact that you are not claiming for them seems just about fair as you are high earner but do not think that means you hand over cash for lifestyle activities.
They already have one scooter club, that’s enough!

KTheGrey · 07/03/2024 21:40

NRP is cheeky, and I would take anything a therapist told me to do with money with a pinch of salt. The therapist should be focused on the kids' mental health and welfare, not the NRP's reluctance to provide materially for their DC 4 days in the month. It seems v improvident to have another child if they can't afford 4 days a month with the ones they already have.

Fingeronthebutton · 07/03/2024 21:39

I find it odd that you refer to your children’s father as non resident parent
I think those 3 words say more about you than any financial difficulties.

LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 07/03/2024 21:35

Wigtopia · 07/03/2024 19:00

This was exactly my thought. Many of my childhood memories are of being at home and making “dens” out of chairs tables and blankets or other activities like playing, baking or crafting at home/ playing in the garden, having a picnic in the garden/ visiting the local park. Or a combination of craft and nature - collecting fallen leaves or petals and making mixed media “art” using the nature as well as drawing and painting. It mostly looked like a mess, but was good fun! Also making “perfume” by collecting some rose petals from the garden and mixing with water!!!

I am not sure why the activities have to be paid for, and even less sure why they should be paid for by someone else!!!

Yes! I remember the rose petals perfume as well!! Great times

JudgeJ · 07/03/2024 21:30

DinnaeFashYersel · 07/03/2024 13:39

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc

Based on this info - Non RP is a CF

In two days with the NRP how much time is available for the 'nice things'?

CJsGoldfish · 07/03/2024 21:26

His self esteem is no longer my issue. I can’t control what job he does, how many hours he works, how much he earns or how he spends his money. Or how many other children he has. Therefore I cannot be held accountable for his self esteem.” - also, assuming you are a woman and be a man, I would question whether they would be suggesting the same if the sexes were reversed as I don’t think they would ever suggest a man should be responsible for a woman’s self esteem after divorce
I'm not so sure because I'm wondering if the therapist actually said those words. There a lot of points that seemed to have gone unnoticed that have me wondering if that is simply how the 'advice' was taken.
There are also many, many posts on MN that demonstrate how beaten down some women become when tied to controlling men who use their money and their dominance to pretty much get what they want.
So, if the advice were different if the sexes were reversed, I could absolutely understand why when viewing it in that MN context.
There was a post where 'foodbanks' were mentioned and the 'secretiveness' seems to be a sore point but if someone has left a relationship where every move was controlled, the freedom to NOT share information with someone who has always used it against you must be considered.
I'm also one who rolls my eyes at those who go on to have a 'new' family without being able to support the one they already have but I can also see someone who may have 'lost' their children through the court to someone who bullied them into 'giving up' due to lack of financial resources or the lack of strength to 'fight' them

Of course, I have no idea about the truth of this situation or who is or isn't male or female but I can absolutely see why the advice may differ based on this. Personally, I think there are enough seemingly ambiguous comments from the OP that makes me wonder whether there IS more there is to this situation. I don't really think it matters though, and I'm not asking, because depending on WHO the OP is and what the complexities of the situation are, the OPs response may be crafted to evoke the response they want 🤷‍♀️

Think about the tickets. On the surface, seems like a lovely idea. Applying another context such as outlined above, totally different. Controlling. STILL manipulating the situation.

To be clear, I don't know what the true situation is and it may well be just as it appears. A CF just after money. The dismissive "it would be different if the NRP is a women" "women are saints, men are shit" posts just annoy me because they're usually used to minimise or justify certain situations

JamieEddolls · 07/03/2024 21:25

Following

Jamie Eddolls

Weedoormatnomore · 07/03/2024 21:24

You are not being unreasonable you have the kids 12 out of 14 days and don't claim anything from the other parent. Sounds like they are just trying to get money of you. I wound ignore the therapist an stop seeing them. You had tried to pay for stuff and they where not happy about it. If the kids are happy just spending time at home with the other parent that's all that matters.

JPGR · 07/03/2024 21:24

Why are you bothering with mediation. You are divorced and have both moved on. It’s just dragging it out unnecessarily. They are remarried or with someone else with another kid. They shouldn’t be relying on you.

Winter2020 · 07/03/2024 21:23

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 07/03/2024 17:39

I think it’s interesting that OP has hidden her sex, and the sex of the NRP. I wonder why that might be?

You do sound a bit snarky & controlling OP. Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC.

Edited

Quote: "Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC."

You mean "how they spend YOUR money"?

and no. OP doesn't have to give the every other weekend parent money to spend how they like - whether that parent is mum or dad. (or other mum/other dad makes no difference).

Wotsits99 · 07/03/2024 21:22

Perhaps also a change of therapist?!

Wotsits99 · 07/03/2024 21:21

Times are hard at the moment for everyone.

But the important thing is that the children have time with you. Not ice-creams, and bought stuff.

I wouldn't worry. You are divorced, it has been decided. If my kids went to their grandparents for a weekend I might give the grandparents some money towards food. £20, or something.

I guess you could consider that.

Bruisername · 07/03/2024 21:18

The next time finances are raised I would reiterate that it was decided by the court and if any change is expected it needs to be discussed in court and not with the therapist. If therapist persists ask them what qualifications they have in financial mediation

it sounds like a hellish situation. How long have you been divorced?

Notcms · 07/03/2024 21:12

@Cornishclio
A therapist told me that in our first joint session.
I told them that our finances were settled in court and I would discuss it no further.

Other parent kept coming back to the issue and I was asked to 'have a think about it' by the therapist.

@YireosDodeAver
No the other parents career was not affected by our relationship - they have always chosen to work in the field they do, and never chosen to progress a career.

@ReindeerLamp No the NRP was offered more contact, 50:50 if wanted, but it was them who decided 2 nights per fortnight.
Yes it is possible they are working every hour they can.

BTW this isn't being driven by the children, they are happy to do films, read books, cooking/baking, crafts, park, riding bikes and have hours of screen time - which is fine by me as long as they are happy.

OP posts:
PringPring · 07/03/2024 21:10

I wouldn't offer cash/money.

I think you offering to pay for tickets or activities and them being refused is telling. If it's mentioned in future by the therapist I'd just reiterate you've offered to pay for events and activities and the nrp has declined. 🤷

The nrp is a two parent household. At least one of the adults works. They only have your DC's two days a fortnight. There's no reason you should be handing over cash! Does the therapist realise you could be claiming maintenance and aren't?!

I'd stop worrying about this tbh.

If the kids ask you, or mention they'd like to do something while there say you're happy to arrange tickets/book stuff for them and the rest of the nrp household. TBH though surely most kids wouldn't think to ask you to? It's a very odd situation.

Cornishclio · 07/03/2024 21:01

YANBU and I doubt a professional told you that. Did that come via NRP? It is not for you to help their self esteem by giving them cash instead of tickets to the cinema etc which I would not do either. You already do not claim CMS so that is your contribution to the NRP who has another partner and a new child.

Mumof2teens79 · 07/03/2024 20:54

I can see that there would be a self esteem issue for the NRP
But I don't see how that's for you to fox by giving them money.
It's fine for them to say, actually when you give us food or tickets that makes us feel.shit so please stop....its not OK to say but please give us the cash so I can feel good about myself.

YireosDodeAver · 07/03/2024 20:52

It depends if the reason for the NRP being a minimum wage earner is connected to decisions or events that happened during the time you were together.

If without their relationship with you they would have had a good shot at developing a well-paid career then that would be a good reason for there to be a modest amount of support. It's difficult to reboot a stalled career after decades where you didn't need to.

ReindeerLamp · 07/03/2024 20:50

Just for some context...did/does NRP want to be RP? Do they feel that you pushed to be RP to ensure you didn't have to pay maintenance?

I appreciate you don't know much about NRP work, but the assumption here is that they could work more but choose not to? Is it possible that they are working all the hours they can (potentially full time) around their other childcare responsibilities?

Was there any accusations of control in the relationship/during the divorce? If so I can see why they're turning down theatre tickets etc.

Doesn't sound like you're under any obligation to actually pay NRP anything anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread