Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
coupebaby · 08/03/2024 13:56

Winter2020 · 07/03/2024 21:23

Quote: "Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC."

You mean "how they spend YOUR money"?

and no. OP doesn't have to give the every other weekend parent money to spend how they like - whether that parent is mum or dad. (or other mum/other dad makes no difference).

I’m glad you said it, this is something that should go without saying but some people seem to choose to act stupid!!! I’ve no idea why @SomethingUniqueThisTime things OP should hand over a single cent of THEIR OWN MONEY to the other parent who has the DC 2 nights out of 14!!! It’s 2 flipping nights and as far as I can see OP (whether make or female makes no odds) should pay for the other parent to treat their kids but he/she has done by offering tickets and even included other partner and child, how can you ask fairer than that??? To call the OP controlling is beyond ridiculous. What sort of self absorbed idiot thinks their ex should hand over cash to allow them to do things with their kids?? I’m actually shocked at comments like what somethinguniquethistime came out with and the fact a “therapist” went along with the ex and suggested this isn’t very professional at all, clearly one sided. Just because one parent can’t afford it that’s not the other’s fault. If the ex works as much as they claim to and not able to take the kids more than they do then surely they’re making enough money to have 20/30 quid every 2 weeks to take their kids to a pool or cinema & buy the treats in pound shop 😏 sounds to me like the ex just wants to pocket an extra few quid every 2 weeks!!

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 08/03/2024 13:23

The self esteem of the NRP is not your concern.

You have gone above and beyond in not claiming any CM and offering discreetly to get tickets for your children on the odd days they are at the NRPs house.

If it was about the children, they would have accepted the tickets, but it's obvious they want you to give them money which is well out of order.

Ignore the therapist.
Some of them may be excellent, but this one does not appear to be the excellent sort.

Your NRP is trying it on.

Hatfrog99 · 08/03/2024 13:04

I have a similar situation apart from my EX refuses to work- I work full time and new DH has a good job. Ex pays nothing and I don’t bother asking for anything, I send kids to him with clothes for weekend and their go Henry cards so if they want any snacks etc from shop they can go get them. I would not however be giving him a single penny and would not even offer tickets - he made a decision to not earn so the fact he doesn’t get to do these things with our DC is his choice and I will not subsidise that choice! I pay for both DC hobbies and we go on holiday a few times a year and do day trips and I work to be able to afford to make these memories if your ex choices to work part time and not have spare income that’s a choice he made so not your problem

Britpop123 · 08/03/2024 12:56

Vonesk · 08/03/2024 12:40

I dont know.
Im not a Lawyer but:
Maybe the Law would say : If you start paying for something youre lumbered for life.
Also ' Are you married'????? Maybe a legal spouse has some obligations??????
Also look at genders.
If you are UNMARRIED and female: OLD ENGLISH LAW states : AN UNMARRIED WOMAN SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THE CHILDREN THAT SHES SEPARATED FROM *
Also : if you are providing CLOTHING ,SHOES SCHOOL BOOKS etc - that should compensate .
Theres another thing: has the non resident parent got a new live- in partner.????

Are you having a stroke?

MILTOBE · 08/03/2024 12:43

Honestly, @Vonesk, I could have sworn you were a lawyer!

Vonesk · 08/03/2024 12:40

I dont know.
Im not a Lawyer but:
Maybe the Law would say : If you start paying for something youre lumbered for life.
Also ' Are you married'????? Maybe a legal spouse has some obligations??????
Also look at genders.
If you are UNMARRIED and female: OLD ENGLISH LAW states : AN UNMARRIED WOMAN SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THE CHILDREN THAT SHES SEPARATED FROM *
Also : if you are providing CLOTHING ,SHOES SCHOOL BOOKS etc - that should compensate .
Theres another thing: has the non resident parent got a new live- in partner.????

Notcms · 08/03/2024 11:53

Thanks all for your comments it has been extremely helpful 👍🏻

OP posts:
Tengreenbottles2 · 08/03/2024 11:37

BTW this isn't being driven by the children, they are happy to do films, read books, cooking/baking, crafts, park, riding bikes and have hours of screen time - which is fine by me as long as they are happy.

There's your answer then. I also remember being perfectly happy spending weekends at my dad's doing nothing in particular.

Maybe when they're old enough (or now, if they're old enough now) slip them a tenner each if they want to do anything and you really think NRP can't afford to do anything with them. But if they're happy then what's the problem?

Heyhoaway · 08/03/2024 08:38

Have you always been the RP since separation? Where does the food bank come into it which prompted the involvement of CAFCASS and family therapy? Did your ex have the children living with them at that point?

You say it's been a long divorce and enough years have passed for them to have a school age child so yours must now be tween/teen age, this sounds more like clashing lifestyle and values than anything, not every family (mine included!) do paid activities every weekend, most of our weekends are spent on general house cleaning/visiting relatives/kids birthday parties/park/shopping, with the odd expensive day out to the zoo or cinema thrown in every now and again. You say they already play in a football team every Saturday morning and have pocket money for sweets so that's plenty for four days a fortnight. If money is tight then their step sibling is experiencing the same lifestyle as your children when they visit. If your children's feedback is already positive about their weekends there then surely that's the focus of the reply back to the therapist.

SilkFloss · 08/03/2024 07:27

Sounds to me as if the nrp is being a cheeky fucker, chancing their arm.
Stick to your guns.

anon4net · 08/03/2024 01:43

It depends on what the non-custodial parent can/can't do. If they can't feed them, then yes, send food. If it's just they can't do big days out, then no. Especially since they have 12 full days to work when they are not with their dc.

PrincessFiorimonde · 08/03/2024 01:34

In summary: you house, feed, clothe and look after your children almost all of the time, and you pay for everything they need and want to do. The NRP has the DC only two days out of 14. Yet a therapist has said that - as well as all the stuff you now pay for - you should also pay for your kids' activities on their two days with the NRP as well, as they will suffer if they're not able to go to the cinema, go swimming, etc. on those days. Meanwhile, there's no suggestion your children are currently lacking food, warmth, bedding, etc. on the two days a fortnight they are with the NRP.

Based on this information, I'm afraid it seems to me that either the therapist who said this is very stupid, or there are some details you haven't posted here, OP.

Redsquirrel5 · 07/03/2024 23:46

Buy them a book on free things to do in the area/tourist info. They could take a second job if only working part time. Supermarket/ bar work etc. My DD has 3 jobs because her career doesn't pay well and isn't regular money so she works in a shop 3 days a week and a restaurant two nights. She doesn't have family yet. If they are working long hours full time then that would be a bit different.I would be annoyed to have tickets thrown back at me and wouldn't give cash. Two nights isn't much. Board games, walks, local games/ park run can all be fun.

FuckityFuckBollocks · 07/03/2024 23:38

The non resident parent has them only 2 days a fortnight and can’t afford to take them out??? What about the park? Or playing at home? Those things are free.

Why are these people meddling with this? I really don’t see the point and think they’ve overstepped the mark.

If the kids were going hungry etc then I’d disagree.

Or is it a case that they only have them two days a week because they can’t afford to?

Mothership4two · 07/03/2024 23:15

I would want clarification from the family therapist exactly what they mean by the childrens lifestyle difference being unfair. Are their living standards detrimental to the children? That's a major concern.

If it is providing leisure activities like going to the cinema and the children are only there two nights in every 14 (assume you mean every other weekend?), then I think it's a non-issue for you (and them). There are plenty of other things they can do with them that are free and give them an enjoyable time.

Child of the 70s here and cinema, swimming, ice skating, etc. were rare treats and 'fun' was generally board games, playing in garden, walks, play park and kite flying with M&D.

Out of interest, why do you have a family therapist mediating now when you are divorced and they have new partner and child (so time must have gone on)?

Alwaystransforming · 07/03/2024 23:14

The whole situation doesn’t make sense.

Post court case therapy recommended by cafcass. Is that post divorce?

Why were cafcass involved? The NRP doesn’t want more days, why did the kids need cafcas or therapy? Or why is there joint therapy going on?

This is post divorce therapy? But the NRP youngest child is old enough to go to school? So did the divorce take absolutely years? Or has therapy been going on years?

You are divorced. The NRP doesn’t want more access. So why is there mediation? There’s clearly more to this. Where did the money go they got in the divorce?

I wouldn’t be giving nrp a penny but this whole thing doesn’t make sense.

RealRubyBee · 07/03/2024 23:11

Notcms · 07/03/2024 12:43

Try to answer Qs.

Post divorce - fair financial settlement was made and both parties happy.

NRP has gone on to another relationship and has a new child.

No idea how many hours they work - but part-full time is what the children are told, and the phone isn't generally answered in working hours.

The professional involved is a family therapist advised by carcass post court case for children.

NRP has met individually several times with the therapist, and in our first joint meeting I was told that I should financially provide for the children while in NRP care.

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc'

I should say everything for the children is paid for by me, no requests are made to the NRP for school stuff or extracurricular activities.

I genuinely can't decide if this is CF, or if IABU.

the issue then would be even if you gave £ amount who's to say it would be used for that purpose ?

Yellowroseblooms · 07/03/2024 23:05

Whether you're a man or a woman, I wouldn't be paying the NRP some sort of life "subsidy" so s/he can work part-time. Presumably the children do more expensive things with you like swimming, cinema etc - you know during the 12 days out of every 14 days that you look after them. So the therapist thinks you should not only look after the children for the bulk of the time without claiming CMS but you should also pay your ex to facilitate the two weekends a month! You would have to pry the money out of my cold dead hands to get it off me. I'd get legal advice because I'm sure that the therapist is talking rubbish.

Nanaof1 · 07/03/2024 23:05

Notcms · 07/03/2024 12:43

Try to answer Qs.

Post divorce - fair financial settlement was made and both parties happy.

NRP has gone on to another relationship and has a new child.

No idea how many hours they work - but part-full time is what the children are told, and the phone isn't generally answered in working hours.

The professional involved is a family therapist advised by carcass post court case for children.

NRP has met individually several times with the therapist, and in our first joint meeting I was told that I should financially provide for the children while in NRP care.

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc'

I should say everything for the children is paid for by me, no requests are made to the NRP for school stuff or extracurricular activities.

I genuinely can't decide if this is CF, or if IABU.

Well, if NRP can not afford to give his elder children a decent lifestyle, they had no business having another child with someone else.

NO, it is NOT your job to support the NRP when they have THEIR children. The NRP can go get a better job, work more hours, get another job. Not just moan about how unfair it is and have some half-witted therapist agree with them. Just because they call themselves a therapist, doesn't make them any good at it, and it sounds like they are not.

It's not your circus and not your clown-car. NRP needs to step up, not whine for you to do more.

Mumof2girls2121 · 07/03/2024 22:56

If your children get the nice things with you who provides for them 85% of the time, there’s nothing wrong with movie night, stories, games, park trips, free stuff when they are with the other parent, if they are a two parent household with another child why should you be supporting their lifestyle it’s ridiculous

Pheasantsmate · 07/03/2024 22:30

Surely the therapist should be focusing on the kids, and not be looking at the wellbeing of the parents.

Although one might suggest that the NRP self esteem might improve if they started providing the bear minimum for their children that CMS mandates, rather than shirking any financial support for their children.

2Hot2Handle · 07/03/2024 22:29

This doesn’t sound right, so I would be asking lots of questions. Might even be worth paying for a couple of hours of solicitor time to understand your rights. However, unless you’ve been legally ordered to provide funds for your children on the weekend they are with the other parent, I would not volunteer it because:

The children are with you for 12 out of 14 days.

Normally a NRP would be expected to contribute financially to support their children

NRP is not being transparent about their finances

NRP is living child-free for 12 out of 14 days and should be working and looking for additional ways to support their life.

I would be willing to respond to the therapist, so that you don’t look difficult, or they start throwing terms like “financially abusive” into the mix. Ask them why they think you should give NRP money when they are capable of working and are not transparent with their income.

Viviennemary · 07/03/2024 22:25

Of course you need to step up and do the best for your children. This not my problem attitude is very selfish

DDDN · 07/03/2024 22:23

@Notcms I agree with @TruthorDie …what kind of Therapist is so focused on money? I would actually have a face2face or email her about this…say you feel she is being biased…also the kids are not even with him for a substantial period of time to allow for a difference of lifestyle to occur! Swimming, cinema etc are normal activities…not ridiculously expensive. It is very clear he just wants an extra passive income. If you do it, it will set a precedent - not good. If you are going to be very generous, then do it because you still have some fondness/loyalty towards him with full understanding the money is not for your children, it is for him, new partner and new kid. Your children already have everything. Although, I would re-assess whether this ‘therapist’ is required any longer and how beneficial she has been for your kids…or the damage she is causing… It is ok to not want to hand your money out even if you have loads of it. The more money you have and save - the more you can provide and save for your children…life happens and you may not always have this income. Equally, life happens and he may earn much more in the future. 2 days!! Does the 2 days include the day of travelling to NRP and the day returning to you? If yes, then not even full 48 hours.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/03/2024 22:19

Notcms · 07/03/2024 12:43

Try to answer Qs.

Post divorce - fair financial settlement was made and both parties happy.

NRP has gone on to another relationship and has a new child.

No idea how many hours they work - but part-full time is what the children are told, and the phone isn't generally answered in working hours.

The professional involved is a family therapist advised by carcass post court case for children.

NRP has met individually several times with the therapist, and in our first joint meeting I was told that I should financially provide for the children while in NRP care.

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc'

I should say everything for the children is paid for by me, no requests are made to the NRP for school stuff or extracurricular activities.

I genuinely can't decide if this is CF, or if IABU.

If the nrp is too poor to afford that they should do free community activities, claim benefits so that they can do swimming etc for free, watch a movie at home or work more hours when they aren't looking after children etc etc.
I'd be very tempted to put in a claim for child maintenance and put it in a savings account just in case you need it for this kind of thing and you can just give it to your kids when they go off to uni