Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
Longdarkcloud · 08/03/2024 20:08

OP is it possible that Ex’s wife resents money spent on your DC and nags Ex about it? She may be complaining about the larger amount spent on groceries once a fortnight etc.
There might also be jealousy because they can’t afford the same standard of living for their own DC rather than the fact that your DC’s standard may be lower — after all it would be scarcely noticeable over a mere 2 days in a different environment.
Seems Ex wants to be compensated for his life choices and to keep his wife happy rather than to be worried about your children’s welfare.

Nextdoor55 · 08/03/2024 20:01

I think the therapist is confused about what being separated means. It means that you are just that, separated, & no longer have responsibility for your ex partner

SchoolQuestionnaire · 08/03/2024 19:41

I’d stop seeing this therapist tbh.

I don’t know if it’s a man or woman but I’m sensing a hint of misogyny here. If the roles were reversed this would not have been said. How often do women with custody of the kids have to practically beg for the minimum. I’m actually quite angry that a ‘professional’ is encouraging this. His self-esteem isn’t your responsibility but I suspect it would improve massively if he got a proper job.

Sleepytiredyawn · 08/03/2024 18:38

Do they just want some extra money and have decided they could get it from you using the children as an excuse. If they have tickets for things sent to them and they say no thanks, but are happy to take money so make their own plans, would they actually do anything with the kids? I’m guessing they won’t want to ask you for money to do a certain activity that week so are expecting a regular payment maybe?

Personally I wouldn’t do it. It sounds like you pay for enough. Activities with the kids don’t need to cost anything and if they really wanted to be able to do some good things with the kids, they could have accepted your tickets.

ThistleTits · 08/03/2024 18:18

@Notcms I don't think you are obliged to provide anything for them whilst they are not in your care.
I don't think it is cf, since the ncp has not requested anything. If they have all they physically and emotionally need at ncp, then 2 days from 14 with no extra activities won't hurt them. Unless you want your children to have an occasional treat whilst not with you, then no don't pay.

amiold · 08/03/2024 18:03

So he wants you to pay for things for kids but decline when you offer it 🤔 how do you know that he would even spend it on the kids?
I'd claim the cms to see what he's actually earning.. could be a pity me party. You could take it off and give him it back each month and tell these "professionals" that you take what you're "entitled" to in order to support the children but give it back to him as a contribution. Unreliable

AuntMarch · 08/03/2024 17:54

I'd be tempted to file a CMS claim if the ex tried to push this. The kids could have that as their spending money when they go there.

Mumof32017 · 08/03/2024 17:30

Hell no, not a chance should you be paying them. They can get off their arse and work more. Lazy person attempting to sponge. This makes me so mad!

Jamesblema · 08/03/2024 17:04

Britpop123 · 08/03/2024 16:34

And if the op is a woman? Would you also decide they are controlling and financially abusive or would their ex be the one at fault?

I’m just wondering why be deliberately vague about genders on a woman’s forum? To gain sympathy. I think the ex is a woman, the OP may or may not be a man.

Britpop123 · 08/03/2024 16:34

Jamesblema · 08/03/2024 16:10

Im wondering why OP is being vague about genders.

Read the OP from the perspective of this being a financially abusive high earning man who has left their ex-wife with very little earning potential, screwed her over financially AND taken her children from her by making her look unable to provide a stable life for the children. Now he’s continuing the controlling behaviour by refusing financial help that he is easily able to give but instead dictating exactly what they should eat and do on the weekends she has her children.

And if the op is a woman? Would you also decide they are controlling and financially abusive or would their ex be the one at fault?

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 16:20

Whether it is a man or a woman my advice is the same. Think of what is best for the children. And that is impossible to tell when we are only hearing one side of the story.
Maybe the other parent is being picky when they reject tickets. Maybe OP is only buying tickets for things they think the children should go to even though they hate those things. Maybe the other parent does not have the money to get transport to the attraction OP has bought tickets for.
It is impossible to know.

Jamesblema · 08/03/2024 16:10

Im wondering why OP is being vague about genders.

Read the OP from the perspective of this being a financially abusive high earning man who has left their ex-wife with very little earning potential, screwed her over financially AND taken her children from her by making her look unable to provide a stable life for the children. Now he’s continuing the controlling behaviour by refusing financial help that he is easily able to give but instead dictating exactly what they should eat and do on the weekends she has her children.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 15:09

HoneyWogan · 08/03/2024 15:05

People often get really arsey when people ask if they've read the thread (or suggest that they do), or at least the OP's posts - often making out that it's deeply unreasonable to expect people to take the trouble to find out the basics of the discussion they're contributing to before they assume, wade in and contribute.

This is why it's important. Otherwise, they're just wasting their own time and everybody else's.

Yes but I assume you meant to tell the person who didn't read the OP'S posts this rather than me who did 🤣

HoneyWogan · 08/03/2024 15:05

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 15:01

Spectacularly misses the point of the thread and assumes it's a non payer 🙄

People often get really arsey when people ask if they've read the thread (or suggest that they do), or at least the OP's posts - often making out that it's deeply unreasonable to expect people to take the trouble to find out the basics of the discussion they're contributing to before they assume, wade in and contribute.

This is why it's important. Otherwise, they're just wasting their own time and everybody else's.

LittleOwl153 · 08/03/2024 15:01

I would put a CMS claim in. Not because you want or need the money, but because that way you will see the other parents income and whether the pleeding poverty is true. If they do pay up, you could hand them the cash back each week to be spend on the kids. But then I'm in a petty mood today - so maybe not the best advice.

The other thing I'd do is ask the kids whether they enjoy the time with NRP. Not in an invasive way or anything nasty.but if they are old enough to buy their own icecreams they are old enough to say if they've been telling the counsellor if they think NRP is too poor to do anything etc. Its likely they are having a normal family time and it's NRP (or NRPs other half) that feel they should have a share of your cash.

Hang on a minute... the new child isn't coming up school age are they? Don't tell me yours go to private school or have expensive hobbies and there is jealousy so they are coming to think you should pay for the new DC to do the same... or does the new child need a bedroom so they need to move and want you to fund a bigger place? As I said before I'd ask the therapist exactly what they - and NRP thinks you should be paying for... it will be eye opening as I'm guessing it is a bit more than a set of cinema tickets every fortnight...

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 15:01

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 14:15

Peronally I would want my own children to have a nice lifestyle at my home and at their fathers. Don't understand why any mother wouldn't.

But of course this is more about the fact that the parents are at war and no one is really arsed about the children (from the vast majority of answers I'm gathering that)

Always astounds me how seemingly sane people get into a battle or get pissed off over money. You can't take it with you. And no one values you more because you're a 'high earner' It's not about the ex partner, it's about YOUR children.

Spectacularly misses the point of the thread and assumes it's a non payer 🙄

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 14:59

I would tell the NRP and or the therapist by not claiming the child maintenance that you would be entitled to claim that you are already in effect donating that amount to the NRP.

I don't see you have any further responsibility to the NRP. The children are presumably happy to just spend the time with the NRP and don't need to be "entertained". As you state you already pay for the clubs they attend when with NRP. NRP even has a new partner and chose to have another child.

The therapist seems to have overstepped a professional line. I would seriously consider whether their action in encouraging this should be reported. And I am usually the last one om here to say anyone should be reported for doing their job.

TheFormidableMrsC · 08/03/2024 14:50

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 14:15

Peronally I would want my own children to have a nice lifestyle at my home and at their fathers. Don't understand why any mother wouldn't.

But of course this is more about the fact that the parents are at war and no one is really arsed about the children (from the vast majority of answers I'm gathering that)

Always astounds me how seemingly sane people get into a battle or get pissed off over money. You can't take it with you. And no one values you more because you're a 'high earner' It's not about the ex partner, it's about YOUR children.

Have you understood the OP?? I don't think you have.

Workawayxx · 08/03/2024 14:36

I'd say you already are subsidising your ex by having the DC 12 out of 14 days, paying for everything they need and asking for no maintenance.

I think someone mentioned this upthread but could you let them take the child benefit for DC if you're a higher earner presumably you can't claim it anyway?

Coconutter24 · 08/03/2024 14:36

“The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc”

Plenty of children don’t get to do these nice things ever and not just for 2 days out of 14. Im sure they do plenty of nice things with you. If NRP wants to do nice things they need to save up for these treats and they are exactly that… treats!! You’ve been more than reasonable offering tickets to things but the fact they turn them down just looks like they want money. Money which should not have to give them. If anything they should be paying you CSM

Justkeeepswimming · 08/03/2024 14:36

Firstly, did you get a clean break order when you divorced?

Secondly - don’t give money directly, put it on a debit card or similar for an account in your name or kids and allow them or him to use for activities; then you can see the transactions to ensure the money is being spent on your kids only.

5YearsLeft · 08/03/2024 14:31

OP -
It genuinely doesn’t matter if you’re a man or a woman. Your ex has moved on, remarried, and has another child. They have made their choices.

You should be moving on as well, and that means no joint therapy, etc. If you already pay for all the children’s expenses and all their clubs, and you’re the RP, and your ex refuses any help unless it’s on his or her terms… just enough. Stop. Don’t engage. Not with them. Not with the therapist. None of it. If your ex wants a different financial settlement, they can take you back to court. I very much doubt this will happen and even if it did, I doubt they’d be successful.

And to get very specific, no, when someone tells you that they want specific things (cinema tickets, etc) but then will only accept cash… I would absolutely refuse. You can use a voucher to go to any movie at any time at usually any one of a chain of theaters.

So please just extricate yourself from this whole situation with them, and stop questioning yourself. Your kids aren’t unhappy, and you shouldn’t be unhappy. Watch the situation just to make sure the ex is not badmouthing you to the children “oh, we can’t go anywhere because your mum/dad doesn’t love you enough to pay,” and otherwise, just ignore it. Good luck.

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 08/03/2024 14:27

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 14:15

Peronally I would want my own children to have a nice lifestyle at my home and at their fathers. Don't understand why any mother wouldn't.

But of course this is more about the fact that the parents are at war and no one is really arsed about the children (from the vast majority of answers I'm gathering that)

Always astounds me how seemingly sane people get into a battle or get pissed off over money. You can't take it with you. And no one values you more because you're a 'high earner' It's not about the ex partner, it's about YOUR children.

Don't be absurd.

The children are fed, warm, clothed and loved by both parents.

If the one who only has them 2 days once a fortnight doesn't take them out, that is their choice.

They get to go out the other 12 days, the resident parent is already letting the other parent have extra money by claiming no maintenance and they've offered to buy tickets for the other parent to take the kids out.

The other parent wants cold hard cash even though they pay nothing to support their own children.

brightyellowflower · 08/03/2024 14:15

Peronally I would want my own children to have a nice lifestyle at my home and at their fathers. Don't understand why any mother wouldn't.

But of course this is more about the fact that the parents are at war and no one is really arsed about the children (from the vast majority of answers I'm gathering that)

Always astounds me how seemingly sane people get into a battle or get pissed off over money. You can't take it with you. And no one values you more because you're a 'high earner' It's not about the ex partner, it's about YOUR children.

TheFlis · 08/03/2024 14:10

The fact that the NRP refuses anything you actually book and pay for proves they are just after the cash and not actually thinking about the best interests of any of their children.