Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Subsidised childcare va care home fees

338 replies

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Helfs · 07/03/2024 13:35

confusedbythesystem · 07/03/2024 13:32

My experience - approaching 60:

I paid the (inflation adjusted) equivalent of £1560 for 2 children in full time childcare in 2001. That's with the reduction of a few free hours (12?) for 4 year old. Northern England. Was almost as much as my salary, but kept working to keep skills up and eventually my pension. Is that very much dissimilar to today?

My teen and young adult children have struggled to get an NHS dentist. Only one currently registered. I've had to move practices, make many calls, go on waiting lists etc to be registered at my current practice. Mostly I find the treatment recommended isn't covered by NHS, so pay privately as well. I can't think of any medical treatment I've had free from the NHS that isn't still available to all age groups now.

Not everyone ends up in a care home, most people would rather avoid them and remain at home. Dementia is the ticking timebomb as the population ages though. My parent has this and from a modest estate of £250,000 (including house) everything bar £14,000 has to be spent on their care/care home. I'm not sure where you're seeing this cohort of elders, queuing up for fully- funded carehomes? Most people have to spend virtually all they have (in this case the assets of two people as one partner in the marriage died before needing care).

There's a need for balance at both ends of life.

I pay that per month for one child in nursery. So it’s very dissimilar

ilovesooty · 07/03/2024 13:34

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

Oh not another one.

As I said on another thread I'm past state pension age and still working. I pay tax on my reduced occupational pension and on my earnings.

I'm not expecting someone else to finance future care I might need. If I need such care I expect to sell my house to pay for it.

confusedbythesystem · 07/03/2024 13:32

My experience - approaching 60:

I paid the (inflation adjusted) equivalent of £1560 for 2 children in full time childcare in 2001. That's with the reduction of a few free hours (12?) for 4 year old. Northern England. Was almost as much as my salary, but kept working to keep skills up and eventually my pension. Is that very much dissimilar to today?

My teen and young adult children have struggled to get an NHS dentist. Only one currently registered. I've had to move practices, make many calls, go on waiting lists etc to be registered at my current practice. Mostly I find the treatment recommended isn't covered by NHS, so pay privately as well. I can't think of any medical treatment I've had free from the NHS that isn't still available to all age groups now.

Not everyone ends up in a care home, most people would rather avoid them and remain at home. Dementia is the ticking timebomb as the population ages though. My parent has this and from a modest estate of £250,000 (including house) everything bar £14,000 has to be spent on their care/care home. I'm not sure where you're seeing this cohort of elders, queuing up for fully- funded carehomes? Most people have to spend virtually all they have (in this case the assets of two people as one partner in the marriage died before needing care).

There's a need for balance at both ends of life.

Sparklfairy · 07/03/2024 13:32

I haven't rtft but the point of "free" childcare was partly to get mothers people back to work. If it wasn't subsidised, there would be more SAHM not paying tax.

Now "old people" Hmm don't pay tax and the government presumably consider them a drain on society, moreso the older they get. Plus there's the cynic in me that the sooner they die, the sooner the government can stop paying their state pension...

BUT there's a significant portion of the female population who have had to reduce their hours or give up work completely to care for their ailing parents. Reducing the amount of tax they pay. The poorest get council funded care homes but have to have next to no savings. But as usual, the squeezed middle are caught in a trap of owning their own home and/or over the savings threshold, who often desperately want to stay in their homes anyway. But care homes are over £1000 a week and very regular carers coming in are pricey too.

Then there's inheritance tax. The government pushed up house prices to the point they're out of reach for FTB until much later in life. But it seems quite short sighted to have to sell that expensive home to put into pockets of private companies.

I wonder if we could find some clever person in government (ha!) who could do the maths of the loss in inheritance tax because of high care fees vs the tax they get from the care homes (and staff?) vs subsidising care home/carer fees for more elderly people and see if there was a better way. I might be way off but where I live there are elderly couples clinging onto £700k+ houses far too big and impractical for them "for their kids", only to have to sell them and for a couple, that's £100k a year in care home fees only lasting 7 years...

TheABC · 07/03/2024 13:30

underthebun · 07/03/2024 12:51

The issue is intergenerational inequality due to housing vs salaries & lack of social housing & then wages with no growth since 2008!!!!

Add a massive tax burden & with public services already underinvested it’s a disaster

This. Housing costs and inflation have eaten away any wriggle room left. Right now, we need to do three things at a societal level in the UK to stop the downward slide:

  • get people back into work. That means making it easier for working parents with cheaper, better wrap around childcare. It pays for itself in the long run, reduces gender inequality and (if you are really efficient), can help the kids by replacing some of the lost sure start services. I'd rather spend a £1,000 a year on a toddler than spend £1,000 a month on his adult self in prison or rehab.
  • get people back into work x 2. Address the mental health crisis that's keeping young people sick and the NHS backlog that's leaving older people injured (hips, knees, eyes etc). Even if they don't work, it frees up a carer's time to do something else.
  • Upskill people. Productivity is too low in this country. Make it cheaper and easier for people to learn new qualifications - this used to be the OU's remit before it decided to charge the same tuition fees as the other universities.

I'd also look into ways to reverse the Brexit barriers and self-harm this bloody government has erected, but that's a long term project.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 13:30

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 12:34

I don't think many of any age group put in as much as they take out, earnings need to be quite high to do that

I can’t remember where I saw it, but the figure of £40k avg income per person was the amount listed as how much you’d need to earn to pay in what an average person takes out in their lifetime

underthebun · 07/03/2024 13:28

@SoEmbarrassed2024 you realise that there is a difference between statistics & anecdotal data?

SoEmbarrassed2024 · 07/03/2024 13:27

It’s true, the current batch of ‘elderly’ either never paid in, or paid so little in its of little significance.

I guess it depends on your definition of 'elderly'. My parents are mid 70s and have worked in full time jobs all their adult lives bar about 5 years in the early 80s when mum was a SAHM.

They are both still working so both continue to pay tax on their earnings and pension. All their friends are working at least part time so also pay tax

I only know of two friends parents who have completely retired, but they also pay tax on their pension

underthebun · 07/03/2024 13:27

Older people who complain generally in the context that their kids will loose inheritance…not because they want the money for themselves

The ones I know who want to protect their inheritance want to help their dc or gc onto the ladder.

mindutopia · 07/03/2024 13:25

I think to an extent both care for ageing parents and care for children have traditionally been 'women's work' but now women are too busy actually working to keep food on the table, so can neither be a carer for a parent nor provide care for their children during the work day. So I think there is a comparison to be made there.

All that said, I think most people - regardless of their age - have a hard time aligning 'benefits to other people' and 'benefits for me'. I know my mum (who happens to be in her 70s), gets quite riled up about a friend receiving state benefits to support the care of her disabled child, while at the same time telling everyone how she has rigged the system to an extent to get the maximum in state pension for herself by using my (long deceased) dad's pension details. This isn't in the UK, so hard to explain, but it's literally the same state fund that funds both.

It's more an 'it's okay for some, mate' kind of mentality that's the issue - and I don't think you have to be 'old' to have that perspective.

HelpNeededBeforeIHaveABreakdown · 07/03/2024 13:23

Wouldn't it be nice to have a society where everyone could be looked after?

JassyRadlett · 07/03/2024 13:21

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/03/2024 12:09

Indeed. "The current cohort" - who the feck ARE these people, please? The only ones I ever hear suggesting they shouldn't have to pay are the people with quite a lot of cash, property wealth, etc. Which is FAR from the majority of elderly people.

Meanwhile, those arguing for free childcare - just how many children should the taxpayer have to subsidise for you, please?

I think the answer to your question is dependent on your answer to "how many taxpayers would you like in the future, please?"

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/03/2024 13:20

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 13:06

How are they also contributing to their grandchildren’s childcare whilst they’re not economically productive?

By like my mother did - doing free childcare of 5 grandchildren over 30 years. She didn't stop doing it until she was in her mid-70s.

1960swhatshappened · 07/03/2024 13:19

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:29

It's the younger people that don't want to see their inheritance go on the care home, they are the ones that benefit, not the person whose house it is.

I can 100% confirm that is the case . Older people who complain generally in the context that their kids will loose inheritance…not because they want the money for themselves. How can you spend your money on luxuries if you are immobile,incontinent,unable to carry out own personal care or have limited Mental Capacity?!!!
Just another goady thread…someone is bored today!

TonTonMacoute · 07/03/2024 13:17

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees

Who are these people? I don't think there is anyone over the age of 60 who doesn't know they will have to pay their own care costs when they get old. Many worry that their spouse will be left homeless to cover care costs.

You are right about appalling child care provision in Britain but mixing this up with old age care, which you clearly know nothing about, is daft.

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 13:15

Pensioners have the same tax free income as everyone else, the thing they don't pay is NI so would not have benefited from the budget this time round, I pay tax on my pension as do a lot of pensioners apart from the very poor pensioners that will be on pension credit. Pensioners are more likely to have investments for income to top up their pension so may also pay tax on those

hangingonfordearlife1 · 07/03/2024 13:15

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:29

It's the younger people that don't want to see their inheritance go on the care home, they are the ones that benefit, not the person whose house it is.

these are the same people that raised their children with the help of free childcare from their parents...whereas our generation have to pay for childcare because grandparents on the whole don't want to look after anyone's kids

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 13:10

FinallyFeb · 07/03/2024 13:06

My DM is early 70’s and paid for childcare as she worked full time as like most families now needed two full time incomes to survive and she’s in a private £1600 per week nursing home.

https://ifs.org.uk/publications/changing-cost-childcare

“the cost of a part-time nursery place for a child under 2 grew by 60% in cash terms between 2010 and 2021 – twice as fast as average earnings, and much higher than the 24% growth in overall prices in the same period.”

i haven’t time to find something for the period you’re discussing but the point is illustrated well above. Childcare costs have risen much faster than earnings.

The changing cost of childcare | Institute for Fiscal Studies

We discuss how the cost of childcare has changed over time, and how it varies across the country and between different types of families.

https://ifs.org.uk/publications/changing-cost-childcare

OP posts:
underthebun · 07/03/2024 13:10

'Old people' most likely cared for their own elderly parents, either sacrificed one parent's salary or paid entirely for childcare fir their own children

This is just nonsense. Old people aren’t some special group where everyone is prudent & responsible.

They are now faced with paying for their own social care as well as their tax dollars going to pay for their grandkids childcare.

And their gc will be working till their 70s despite no increase in healthy life expectancy, I don’t want them for my dc.

FinallyFeb · 07/03/2024 13:07

How are they also contributing to their grandchildren’s childcare whilst they’re not economically productive?

By paying tax on their pension.

FinallyFeb · 07/03/2024 13:06

My DM is early 70’s and paid for childcare as she worked full time as like most families now needed two full time incomes to survive and she’s in a private £1600 per week nursing home.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 13:06

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 13:03

'Old people' most likely cared for their own elderly parents, either sacrificed one parent's salary or paid entirely for childcare fir their own children.They are now faced with paying for their own social care as well as their tax dollars going to pay for their grandkids childcare.
I can see this side!

How are they also contributing to their grandchildren’s childcare whilst they’re not economically productive?

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 13:05

Re investing in childcare:-

The case for investment is irrefutable: 1.7 million women are currently restricted from working more by childcare costs. Investment would unlock £28 billion annually, over four and a half times the net investment required calculated after job creation, consumption and social security savings.

The investment required would pay for itself 4.5x over!

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/116231/pdf/

OP posts:
underthebun · 07/03/2024 13:05

Can we stop using simplistic agist divisiveness and instead focus on the ideas and relative merits of them

I agree but it’s hard to have a healthy debate when many refuse to acknowledge facts.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 13:04

@Ezzee why do you think more mothers don’t work now?