Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Subsidised childcare va care home fees

338 replies

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:24

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:16

Just to be clear - you think the NHS has maintained its efficacy?

I think it has when people are really sick, yes. The real problem is waiting lists for non emergency conditions. I had to wait six months for an outpatient appointment to investigate chest pain but the care I’m getting now has been exemplary. I’m a critical old woman but I can’t fault it.

HolyZarquonsSingingSeals · 07/03/2024 16:24

What makes you think retired people haven't paid tax? Or that many of them don't continue to pay tax after retirement?

Samsond · 07/03/2024 16:22

"Goforitagainandagain · Today 11:58

Only about 15% end up in a care home, though the amount of fretting on these threads you would think it was a lot more"

The thing is though many many more SHOULD be in care homes. A very large proportion of elderly people refuse and insist on staying in their own home, however inappropriate that might be. They then have a fall or something and end up stuck in hospital "bed blocking" because they can't be released home without the care they need. So it's not just a problem for the elderly people themselves. It's a problem for anyone who might need a hospital bed and can't get one because they're all full.

Dorriethelittlewitch · 07/03/2024 16:21

For the vast majority of today's pensioners, university education (or even staying at school past 15/16) was a minority, and largely privileged, pursuit.

This. My dad joined the military aged 15 because his other choices were join the family business (horse trading and occasionally horse stealing) or get a job in a factory. My mum left school at 16 and went to work for the civil service. They coped when she got married but when she had me, no more job. Her brothers all went down the pit at 15. Higher education wasn't an option. In fact I was the first person in my wider family to go to University.

My dad is dead but my mum is still a tax payer.

My inlaws both have degrees and are still tax payers in their 80s. In fact I'd put money on the fact that my fil pays more tax than most posters on this thread. He still does consultancy work aged 82.

Conversely, the tax payer paid for both my degrees but I'm not currently a tax payer.

I don't think the difference between the UK nations helps. We're in Scotland. All 3 to 4 year olds get 1140 hours of free childcare per year regardless of circumstances (if you want it). Doesn't matter what you earn or whether you both work.

As for people wanting to ring fence, I think it's human nature. My dad had come so far from his upbringing that leaving an inheritance for me and his grandchildren was important to him. The thing is, the more you have, the easier it is to hide from the tax man. So trying to prevent all families benefiting from generational wealth will I think be futile. It also doesn't address the fact that they don't have to be dead for you to benefit. My inlaws hand out cash like sweeties to their kids because their needs are minimal and their monthly income is high. House deposits, cars, holidays...

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:20

@ShyMaryEllen How would that work though? You think people would stay & work & pay in some cases the current high taxes for the police. Do we pay CR, road tax, VAT, stamp duty too? That will really help the demographics 😆

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:16

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:13

You think those of us who are older haven’t paid for both? The quality of healthcare is no worse now than it was 40 or 50 years ago and access is the same. The difference is that a lot of us are paying for elective healthcare rather than deteriorate in long queues. If your child was sick I guarantee the care would be timely and excellent.

Just to be clear - you think the NHS has maintained its efficacy?

OP posts:
ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 16:15

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:06

Does that appeal to you?

Do we pay no tax then?

Yes, for things like defence, roads, police - unless you want vigilante-style law enforcement and tollgates on private roads. Things like research into drugs would need to be thought through if you don't want to contribute to funding cures being found that only benefit other people. But if you want everyone to be self-sufficient at every stage of life it will mean dismantling the society we are used to. You may be rich enough to know you self-support regardless of what life throws at you (in which case, why begrudge helping others?) but the vast majority of people are net beneficiaries at various points (eg during childrearing) and net contributors at others (eg between children growing up and later old age).

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:13

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:09

Childcare is expensive, but care homes are eye-wateringly expensive.

Yes and the generation raising young families now will pay for both, have insecure housing, reduced quality and access to healthcare…

You think those of us who are older haven’t paid for both? The quality of healthcare is no worse now than it was 40 or 50 years ago and access is the same. The difference is that a lot of us are paying for elective healthcare rather than deteriorate in long queues. If your child was sick I guarantee the care would be timely and excellent.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:11

ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 16:04

Well, we could scrap the welfare state, so that everyone 'supports their own family' and nobody's old age is 'funded'. Let everyone pay for healthcare, education, child care and care homes. No UC, no child benefit, contributory pensions only and no tax-funded education.

So when people recovered from childbirth they could go straight back to work and pay a wetnurse on top of the maternity fees. If they or the baby got ill, they would pay the doctor and pharmacist if they didn't need hospital, and if they did, that would be an extra charge. With what was left they'd get a nanny, or send the kids to a baby farm until the prep school would take them. After paying until the last child left private university, assuming there were no accrued debts from anyone needing healthcare, people could start saving for older age. With pensions only going to those who've paid for them, there would be no SPA, so most people would be able to work all their lives. Those needing care would either be looked after by their families or pay for self-funded homes with money they'd saved by not spending on their children over the years. Or maybe the state could run to workhouses for the profligate?

SAHPs would have to pay taxes towards the police, roads, defence and so on (all working age adults would make compulsory contributions), as otherwise they would be being 'funded' by workers. They could choose whether to save for their tax bills before giving birth, or their partners could cover it, but there would be no deductions for being part of a couple. No NI though, as that largely funds things that might support other people, and that wouldn't be fair.

Does that appeal to you?

Was that meant for me 🫢

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:09

Hillarious · 07/03/2024 16:01

I'm guessing @VickyEadieofThigh 's parents worked as a team. Her father will have been able to go out to work and pay into the system, because her mother stayed at home for some time to look after the children. Together, they will have paid a substantial amount into the system, and it will have been proportional to what they were earning.

Childcare is expensive, but care homes are eye-wateringly expensive. My MIL had nursing care for five years, paid for by her, until the money ran out. It's possible she did get out more than she paid in, but she wasn't exactly enjoying being quids in on this occasion.

Childcare is expensive, but care homes are eye-wateringly expensive.

Yes and the generation raising young families now will pay for both, have insecure housing, reduced quality and access to healthcare…

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:06

But I also believe that people shouldn’t be able to ring fence their own wealth at the expense of the rest of the population.

What makes you think they can? We fully anticipate funding our care home fees should we need that level of care. We even call our savings The Care Home Fund.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:06

Does that appeal to you?

Do we pay no tax then?

Hillarious · 07/03/2024 16:05

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:03

Five years? That’s at least a quarter of a million @Hillarious.

I guess so, and some of that she paid. We thought she'd be there for a matter of months. What it does illustrate is the amazing job of caring the staff do in care homes.

ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 16:04

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 12:37

I would like everyone to be better supported. I would like to see subsidies that benefit everyone, childcare being one.

But I also believe that people shouldn’t be able to ring fence their own wealth at the expense of the rest of the population.

I would like to see some give and take. I don’t begrudge anyone care in their old age. But I don’t want to be taxed to the nines paying for one generations old age, so they can leave a sum to their family, whilst simultaneously supporting my own family.

Well, we could scrap the welfare state, so that everyone 'supports their own family' and nobody's old age is 'funded'. Let everyone pay for healthcare, education, child care and care homes. No UC, no child benefit, contributory pensions only and no tax-funded education.

So when people recovered from childbirth they could go straight back to work and pay a wetnurse on top of the maternity fees. If they or the baby got ill, they would pay the doctor and pharmacist if they didn't need hospital, and if they did, that would be an extra charge. With what was left they'd get a nanny, or send the kids to a baby farm until the prep school would take them. After paying until the last child left private university, assuming there were no accrued debts from anyone needing healthcare, people could start saving for older age. With pensions only going to those who've paid for them, there would be no SPA, so most people would be able to work all their lives. Those needing care would either be looked after by their families or pay for self-funded homes with money they'd saved by not spending on their children over the years. Or maybe the state could run to workhouses for the profligate?

SAHPs would have to pay taxes towards the police, roads, defence and so on (all working age adults would make compulsory contributions), as otherwise they would be being 'funded' by workers. They could choose whether to save for their tax bills before giving birth, or their partners could cover it, but there would be no deductions for being part of a couple. No NI though, as that largely funds things that might support other people, and that wouldn't be fair.

Does that appeal to you?

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:03

Five years? That’s at least a quarter of a million @Hillarious.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:01

Way to miss the point.

the irony 😆. Honestly do you not have a hobby? I can give you my netflix password if you like.

Hillarious · 07/03/2024 16:01

Helfs · 07/03/2024 12:31

She definitely didn’t pay more in than she took out

I'm guessing @VickyEadieofThigh 's parents worked as a team. Her father will have been able to go out to work and pay into the system, because her mother stayed at home for some time to look after the children. Together, they will have paid a substantial amount into the system, and it will have been proportional to what they were earning.

Childcare is expensive, but care homes are eye-wateringly expensive. My MIL had nursing care for five years, paid for by her, until the money ran out. It's possible she did get out more than she paid in, but she wasn't exactly enjoying being quids in on this occasion.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:00

I think you are ignoring why some people grudge all their savings being spent on care home fees. It's not greed (what else are they going to spend their money on?). There's a huge desire to leave something behind, to help our children and grandchildren, because we are very aware of the difficulties they face funding homes and education. It may be selfish, to want to leave an inheritance to family rather than benefit the wider state, but understandable.

But if housing wasn’t so inflated & wages so low then people wouldn’t need an inheritance to get on the ladder.

Plus it makes it more unequal for those rug don’t have an inheritance.

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 16:00

underthebun · 07/03/2024 15:44

We were all paying the same rate as today’s higher rate workers.

Tax isn’t just income tax though & I don’t believe there’s ever been a generation where every single adult has worked full time their whole lives.

Way to miss the point. I included NI. Maybe look at what I responded to.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 16:00

VestibuleVirgin · 07/03/2024 15:56

Oh, because to me, it comes across as another pop at the 'older generation who live in 7 bedroomed houses in 40 hectares but get every benefit under the sun and expecting more at our expense, and no, pensionerers do not live in poverty wondering whether to eat or heat, who have health needs but cannot access care' type of thread

If that’s the case it’s an even worse prospect for the next generation, whose financial landscape looks even poorer!

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 15:59

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/03/2024 15:56

I think you are ignoring why some people grudge all their savings being spent on care home fees. It's not greed (what else are they going to spend their money on?). There's a huge desire to leave something behind, to help our children and grandchildren, because we are very aware of the difficulties they face funding homes and education. It may be selfish, to want to leave an inheritance to family rather than benefit the wider state, but understandable.

I’m not ignorant to that, and bearing in mind that that’s exactly the scenario I’m in with my own parents who are approaching their 70’s.

OP posts:
VestibuleVirgin · 07/03/2024 15:56

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:26

I’m not moaning - I’m examining the landscape of each generation.

Oh, because to me, it comes across as another pop at the 'older generation who live in 7 bedroomed houses in 40 hectares but get every benefit under the sun and expecting more at our expense, and no, pensionerers do not live in poverty wondering whether to eat or heat, who have health needs but cannot access care' type of thread

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/03/2024 15:56

I think you are ignoring why some people grudge all their savings being spent on care home fees. It's not greed (what else are they going to spend their money on?). There's a huge desire to leave something behind, to help our children and grandchildren, because we are very aware of the difficulties they face funding homes and education. It may be selfish, to want to leave an inheritance to family rather than benefit the wider state, but understandable.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 15:50

underthebun · 07/03/2024 15:46

Yep, you get the "the country's full" folk, who are merrily ignoring the fact that if it's full, it's full with an unsustainably unbalanced demographic and a proportionately shrinking working age population we haven't invested in properly.

I find it so depressing but I guess it’s a reflection of educational standards which is still depressing.

Even without increased life expectancy and increased time between generations, we were going to be screwed.

All that’s is coming is more tax, more cuts to public services, more immigration & more moaning about immigration.

Yes and it does feel deflating knowing we are doing more, for less and actually there’s no real prospect of change and improvement. Despite the uphill struggle things are actually getting worse for us as a whole.

OP posts:
underthebun · 07/03/2024 15:46

Yep, you get the "the country's full" folk, who are merrily ignoring the fact that if it's full, it's full with an unsustainably unbalanced demographic and a proportionately shrinking working age population we haven't invested in properly.

I find it so depressing but I guess it’s a reflection of educational standards which is still depressing.

Even without increased life expectancy and increased time between generations, we were going to be screwed.

All that’s is coming is more tax, more cuts to public services, more immigration & more moaning about immigration.

Swipe left for the next trending thread