Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Subsidised childcare va care home fees

338 replies

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Oldsu · 07/03/2024 21:42

Not sure what generation you are talking about but yes when I was growing up in the 50s we did at one time live on one salary my dads but that salary was only enough for my mum, my older sister and myself due to the fact my dad worked 3 jobs 18 hours a day 6 days a week, we never saw him he was either at work or in bed asleep, my mum was nursing my nan in the front room of our council house so she did not work until nan died, when she did we had another sister who was two, in order for mum to work so my dad could drop one of his jobs my little sister went to a child minder, every day my sister and myself (9 and 11) would pick her up after school and look after her until mum came home from work I had a few friends who had to do the same, I don't think that would be allowed now would it.?

As for paying for care homes, DH and I have made arrangements, however it is not inevitable or mandatory that we will need to go into one, none of the older generation in my family my grandparents, or my parents needed to go into one same with my DHs grandparents and parents. If we don't of course the money we have when we die to go to my son and his family

underthebun · 07/03/2024 21:20

As who are the non workers that aren't in education, over retirement age or unable to work because of illness or caring for a sick or disabled child or relative?

underthebun · 07/03/2024 21:19

But I don't fret that my taxes might end up funding others.

I think most buy into the safety net but something is getting lost where people are feeling like there is no help for them.

I would prefer taxes to rise, and for every adult to be liable (not just those in work), with exemptions for those in education, over retirement age or unable to work because of illness or caring for a sick or disabled child or relative.

You would levy more tax on workers?

ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 21:11

underthebun · 07/03/2024 16:20

@ShyMaryEllen How would that work though? You think people would stay & work & pay in some cases the current high taxes for the police. Do we pay CR, road tax, VAT, stamp duty too? That will really help the demographics 😆

Well no, I doubt it would work. I wouldn't vote for it. But I don't fret that my taxes might end up funding others.

Either we have a system where people are supported when vulnerable or it's everyone for themselves. Under the current system there will be net winners and losers, but if everyone paid for everything for which they and only they saw benefit I think we would all be much worse off.

I would prefer taxes to rise, and for every adult to be liable (not just those in work), with exemptions for those in education, over retirement age or unable to work because of illness or caring for a sick or disabled child or relative. That way, everyone would be supported when above and below working age, health, education, childcare and elder care would be free, and it wouldn't fall to workers to subsidise those who choose not to work.

SpacesNotTabs · 07/03/2024 21:02

I wouldn't, @DragonFly98, I'm really glad that my children were raised by both their parents equally (we both went part time to do our fair share of the childcare), and that now they're grown up I've got a satisfying, decently paid job with good pension provision and I can spend my own money on whatever I want, whenever I want.

echt · 07/03/2024 20:51

But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves!

Based no evidence whatsoever. Well done you, @MrBanana . You wanted a structured argument and threw rule 101 out of the window. Sigh. I blame the teachers.

Oh, and yes, you are moaning. And generalising inappropriately.

Karatema · 07/03/2024 20:37

I reach retirement age this year (no way can I retire - self employed - staff depend on their jobs). The business has been going for more than 30 years so I've definitely paid my taxes and had no free child care, I spent 5 years as a SAHM but, even then I did the occasional PT work for my DH's employer.
I feel I've contributed to my retirement pot so I will be claiming my government pension.
I've told my DC to leave my allergy food lying around if dementia sets in because I don't want them paying out for me like we did for their DGM.

Randomsabreur · 07/03/2024 20:31

Cost of living/childcare is making the situation worse. Assuming the family was surviving with say £10 a week for a rainy day during the unpaid bit of mat leave, when faced with losing that £10/week to pay to go to work it makes it hard to justify leaving the child to be worse off.

Now assume that the cost of working (childcare, travel) is £20/week if say the commute is a bit longer - train fares have gone up. But the "spare" money over both wages was £10, so now the family can't actually pay housing, food, utilities etc... this is where there is no ability to consider the future investment when you've probably already run down savings on mat leave. Going back earlier wouldn't help as childcare cost is generally higher for a younger child.

As for why women's wages are lower - I'd suggest sexism but haven't got an answer...

DragonFly98 · 07/03/2024 20:30

SpacesNotTabs · 07/03/2024 17:34

Don't forget that for lots of women there was no choice, there are plenty of examples of jobs which required you to resign upon marriage or having a child. I have my Mum's dismissal letter from her job at a merchant bank (because she'd had to take too much time off looking after us when we had a run of childhood illnesses), where it reminds her of their reluctance to employ her as a mother of very young children.

The cost of living today needs two salaries because it became normal for women to keep working, that's capitalism. Would you rather we went back to women being expected to stay at home?

Yes I would rather we lived in a society where men worked and earned enough to pay a mortgage while their wife stayed at home and raised the children.

TheSmallAssassin · 07/03/2024 20:06

You are missing the points I am making, @Randomsabreur

Lots of people do balance the cost against losses now, but having a career break for 7 years or so means not only have they missed out on the salary they might have earned for those 7 years and their pension contributions, but also any increase in salary over that time. Then when they go back to work, lots of women end up in jobs where they are earning a lot less than they did pre children, let alone what they might have progressed to and may never get anywhere near their previous earning potential. That's what you really need to balance childcare costs against.

My other question was why is it still likely that women are earning less than our partners? Why are so many of us happy to go into this situation on the back foot?

Randomsabreur · 07/03/2024 19:18

TheSmallAssassin · 07/03/2024 18:53

It might not pay to work in the short term, but you only have to pay for childcare for a relatively short time, you need to balance the cost out against future earnings too (lots of women have to take a lower paid job if they take a complete break) and effects on pension.

I think we also need to look at why is it only the woman's salary that is used for comparison and why do so many women still earn less than their partners before they have children? This always skews the decisions about who is going to go part time/stay at home in favour of the men.

There's a difference between work not paying and paying to work. One is possible to get through short term if there's an end date, one is only possible if you can survive on the other income.

Practically everyone is going to balance the cost of childcare against the lower income... which is likely to be the woman's one, especially for second and subsequent children because by being at home with the children you are directly saving the cost of childcare, balanced against evening and weekend earning potential

JassyRadlett · 07/03/2024 19:15

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 17:59

Where is it then?

Do you really need proportions and ratios explained?

saraclara · 07/03/2024 19:03

I'm 68 and paying tax.

I'm absolutely pro free childcare because I see my daughter and son in law struggle.

And yes, all the savings that my late husband and I accrued are at risk from completely disappearing into my care, just as my mum and my MIL's did (including their houses)

I want at least some of my money and house value to go to my children. I'd be very comfortable with 50:50 to care and to inheritance.

If my DH and I had spent it on the way that many do, on new cars, on the house, on expensive holidays, I'd almost feel better.

In the meantime I'm helping with the cost of my DGDs' childcare.

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 18:55

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:52

so you’ll haven’t paid enough in to cover the cost of what you’ve taken out throughout your life.

Those having children and working now are funding your pension and care if you need it. That’s why it’s silly to begrudge support with childcare, as who do you think suffers if they stop working

I didn’t always earn £10 a week, you silly sausage. That was in 1972. I was a higher rate taxpayer for over 20 years. I paid in plenty.

Nobody’s going to fund any care I need except me. I imagine my house will be sold to pay for it.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 18:54

“House prices are currently sitting at 8.8 times the average earnings, more than doubling since the 1970s, according to new research from House Buyer Bureau”

”The research shows that the average house price throughout the 1970s sat at just £9,277, the equivalent of £68,493 today after adjusting for inflation.”

”In the 1970s and 1980s, real wages growth averaged at 2.9%, but fell to 1.5% in the 1990s and 1.2% in the 2000s.”

TheSmallAssassin · 07/03/2024 18:53

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 18:35

I think a huge issue is that not working is actually something you’re forced into now - because it doesn’t pay to work, rather than a choice. That has a hugely detrimental effect on women.

It might not pay to work in the short term, but you only have to pay for childcare for a relatively short time, you need to balance the cost out against future earnings too (lots of women have to take a lower paid job if they take a complete break) and effects on pension.

I think we also need to look at why is it only the woman's salary that is used for comparison and why do so many women still earn less than their partners before they have children? This always skews the decisions about who is going to go part time/stay at home in favour of the men.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:52

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 18:42

What you earn is of little relevance when the basic rate of income tax + NI is the same as a higher rate tax payer pays now. I think I was paid about a tenner a week. I was really in the money when I hit £1k a year.

so you’ll haven’t paid enough in to cover the cost of what you’ve taken out throughout your life.

Those having children and working now are funding your pension and care if you need it. That’s why it’s silly to begrudge support with childcare, as who do you think suffers if they stop working

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:51

BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 18:37

@Helfs most people back then did not have childcare vouchers and looked after their own parents, unless they had dementia.

Back then childcare costs weren’t more than what most earn

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/03/2024 18:47

3 elderly relatives in this family have been self-funded in their care homes. They had the assets to pay and nobody expected it to be free.

TBH I look on it as something of a ‘luxury’ to be able to self-fund - you can choose the time and place - rather than being at the tender mercies of almost invariably time- and cash-strapped social services.

And I do wish posters wouldn’t judge all older people by the less reasonable ones they happen to know.

BIossomtoes · 07/03/2024 18:42

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:29

And what did you earn.

What you earn is of little relevance when the basic rate of income tax + NI is the same as a higher rate tax payer pays now. I think I was paid about a tenner a week. I was really in the money when I hit £1k a year.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 18:41
  • “This has led to a large rise in the proportion of working-age mothers in paid work: up from 50% in 1975 to 72% in 2015. The rise has been particularly large among lone mothers and mothers of pre-school- and primary-school-age children.
  • Overall, the proportion of couples with children where only one adult works has almost halved (down from 47% in 1975 to 27% in 2015) and the proportion where both work has increased from 49% to 68%.
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 18:39

BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 18:37

@Helfs most people back then did not have childcare vouchers and looked after their own parents, unless they had dementia.

Tax free childcare and free hours operate much like Tesco clubcard savings. They massively inflate the price to compensate. So you pay a reduction of the inflated price.

OP posts:
BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 18:38

@DragonFly98 I was a child in the seventies. My mum and most mums of my friends worked. If you were better off you did not work.

BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 18:37

@Helfs most people back then did not have childcare vouchers and looked after their own parents, unless they had dementia.