Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Subsidised childcare va care home fees

338 replies

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:48

Helfs · 07/03/2024 11:45

YANBU

Elderly people who have never paid in as much into the system as todays workforce, expecting their care to be covered by taxing the young whilst also begrudging them subsidized childcare is just plain silliness, let alone hypocrisy.

and for those moaning about the generalizations, on average only 1/3 women worked in the 50s. The current set of ‘elderly’ people are mostly made up of people who never paid into the system and are taking a lot out. Or paid into the system but not much, earning potential for the women who did work was low, and taxes were lower in general so even the men who worked didn’t pay a fraction into the system as todays working ‘young’ do.

Thank you for putting it more eloquently than me.

OP posts:
Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:48

Untethered · 07/03/2024 11:43

Not always the case. Recent threads:

  • a woman who spent a lot of her savings on her flat and holidays, with her daughter (the OP) acknowledging that she would be expected to provide care to her mother if no money left for carers to come in
  • a woman who lives at her daughter’s, refuses to sell her house and lives off her daughter

You do not have to pay for care or provide it for any relatives, you just say no, you are under no obligation at all to pay, if they end up on a park bench so be it.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:46

Moobz · 07/03/2024 11:43

A lot of people won't see them as comparable, having children is a nice to have, paying care home fees never has and never will be a nice to have. Having children is a choice, therefore it's not unthinkable to have to contribute to that cost. Getting old and sick and needing a care home isn't a choice, so I don't think it's something that people happily save for. I'm not saying it's my opinion, I'm just saying how i don't think people see them as comparable.

Yes I agree.

I think that in itself has some flaws. Ultimately we need the next generation to keep working as a population. Look at the issues in China of an aging population. It’s not in anyone’s interests.

OP posts:
Helfs · 07/03/2024 11:45

YANBU

Elderly people who have never paid in as much into the system as todays workforce, expecting their care to be covered by taxing the young whilst also begrudging them subsidized childcare is just plain silliness, let alone hypocrisy.

and for those moaning about the generalizations, on average only 1/3 women worked in the 50s. The current set of ‘elderly’ people are mostly made up of people who never paid into the system and are taking a lot out. Or paid into the system but not much, earning potential for the women who did work was low, and taxes were lower in general so even the men who worked didn’t pay a fraction into the system as todays working ‘young’ do.

Mrsjayy · 07/03/2024 11:45

FuzzyPuffling · 07/03/2024 11:20

Let's lump all "old people" together and moan about them. AGAIN.

I mean it's relentless and mumsnet thinks its "robust" debate or some such pish.

Moobz · 07/03/2024 11:43

A lot of people won't see them as comparable, having children is a nice to have, paying care home fees never has and never will be a nice to have. Having children is a choice, therefore it's not unthinkable to have to contribute to that cost. Getting old and sick and needing a care home isn't a choice, so I don't think it's something that people happily save for. I'm not saying it's my opinion, I'm just saying how i don't think people see them as comparable.

Untethered · 07/03/2024 11:43

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:29

It's the younger people that don't want to see their inheritance go on the care home, they are the ones that benefit, not the person whose house it is.

Not always the case. Recent threads:

  • a woman who spent a lot of her savings on her flat and holidays, with her daughter (the OP) acknowledging that she would be expected to provide care to her mother if no money left for carers to come in
  • a woman who lives at her daughter’s, refuses to sell her house and lives off her daughter
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:43

winterplumage · 07/03/2024 11:42

I don't understand who these elderly curmudgeons are. All the pensioners I know campaigned for free childcare and equal paternity leave in the 1980s and still feel the same about it now.

Excellent. My sort of people 🙌🏻

Conversely I have a friend who despises any of “her taxes” being directed in anyway towards children, but begrudges the prospect of paying for her own care and can’t see the hypocrisy, which is the thought from which this thread evolved.

OP posts:
winterplumage · 07/03/2024 11:42

I don't understand who these elderly curmudgeons are. All the pensioners I know campaigned for free childcare and equal paternity leave in the 1980s and still feel the same about it now.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:42

@cheapskatemum @ohtowinthelottery

I understand that. But you will have benefitted from it for a greater proportion of your life. My kids for example have never seen an NHS dentist and I am at a time where I have far more expenses, because of my dependents, so arguably the need now is greatest.

OP posts:
Randomsabreur · 07/03/2024 11:41

The ridiculous thing is that employment protections last 1 year but childcare subsidies start at/after 2. If someone is on a marginal wage vs cost of childcare they are likely to struggle most in this year. Line up childcare subsidy with (a) actual cost to provide childcare and (b) the end of maternity protections. Then women don't end up having a 3-5 year gap where they are cash richer for staying at home than continuing to work (future investments don't put food on table/pay rent and bills now).

coofffeee · 07/03/2024 11:40

It all has to be paid for somehow, I'm in favour of higher taxes and higher public spending and more favourable polices for parents (I'm childfree myself but we as a society need to be more supportive of parents).

I also think we need a proper look at social care and care homes for the elderly. I do think that many who feel aggrieved about favourable policies for the elderly and their care would also be miffed if everything they expected to inherit from their parents went to providing their care.

It seems some Scandinavian countries do things like this better than us and I would be happy to pay more tax to have a better system that supports everyone, as it is we will end up like the US.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:39

Sonora25 · 07/03/2024 11:34

This whole argument is nonsense anyway “People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children.”

free childcare means more people (especially women!) work and pay taxes which helps fund pensions ane NHS. Literally everywhere in Europe childcare is free or super heavily subsidised. Because these countries know they need women to have more children and economically they need women to be in work! Plus not to mention it means families have more money to spend.

In Italy my friend pays €30 a month!! For a nursery from 8-3pm. Sure it’s not perfect (3pm finish) but it allows her to work 80%. My cousin ij Germany pays €150 a month for a full time nursery place and they get child benefit which is not means tested.

Pregnant then screwed shared some interesting research that showed that subsidised childcare not only paid for itself but because women were earning more, would make the country better off by way of their taxes etc. it’s just there’s not the appetite to make that investment.

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:38

Cyclebabble · 07/03/2024 11:36

From experience childcare in the UK is some of the worst in western Europe and is certainly the most expensive. It is a major block on the progression of women and for productivity in general and we absolutely should do something to address this. I am not sure though that our elderly are doing any better. The care regime for the elderly is shambolic and vastly expensive as well as I have experienced with my own folks. I think we need to address both as we do public services as a whole in the UK.

Absolutely, both are bleak.

I just get frustrated by the argument that your children are your own financial burden, where the same isn’t true of your old age and care needs.

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:37

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:35

I'm sorry but I worked and paid tax 30 years ago and DS was in a nursery, loads of people worked.

Childcare is more expensive and less accessible.
More women work now.
Those that work, work more hours.

The outlook for women working has changed.

OP posts:
Cyclebabble · 07/03/2024 11:36

From experience childcare in the UK is some of the worst in western Europe and is certainly the most expensive. It is a major block on the progression of women and for productivity in general and we absolutely should do something to address this. I am not sure though that our elderly are doing any better. The care regime for the elderly is shambolic and vastly expensive as well as I have experienced with my own folks. I think we need to address both as we do public services as a whole in the UK.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:35

Purplebunnie · 07/03/2024 11:33

"But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc."

Pensioner here. I paid childcare fees 30 years ago, it's nothing new and I had to go to a private dentist over 20 years ago.

The only reason I don't want to pay for a care home if unfortunately that's where I end up is I'd rather my kids had my money

My kids have spied out a nice underpass for me, there's plenty of other people down there to keep me company or I'm going on a world cruise which is cheaper than a care home. I had promised to jump overboard but it's a terrible way to go. I need to think up a new plan so they get the dosh

Edited: PS I have always paid taxes and I still do as I do the odd bit of work here and there

Edited

Bearing in mind my parents of are of this age group. I would far rather they had a good quality of life than try and maximise inheritance for me.

OP posts:
Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:35

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:34

Those not economically productive whilst raising their family.

I'm sorry but I worked and paid tax 30 years ago and DS was in a nursery, loads of people worked.

Sonora25 · 07/03/2024 11:34

This whole argument is nonsense anyway “People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children.”

free childcare means more people (especially women!) work and pay taxes which helps fund pensions ane NHS. Literally everywhere in Europe childcare is free or super heavily subsidised. Because these countries know they need women to have more children and economically they need women to be in work! Plus not to mention it means families have more money to spend.

In Italy my friend pays €30 a month!! For a nursery from 8-3pm. Sure it’s not perfect (3pm finish) but it allows her to work 80%. My cousin ij Germany pays €150 a month for a full time nursery place and they get child benefit which is not means tested.

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:34

SoupDragon · 07/03/2024 11:34

Your posts are absolutely moaning about the "older generation" whilst also implying that the younger generation(s) have it far worse.

That’s your view.

I’m just trying to look at it critically.

OP posts:
MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:34

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:27

Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Who hasn't paid tax? I paid tax. My dentist went private nearly 20 years ago, it's not a new thing.

Those not economically productive whilst raising their family.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 07/03/2024 11:34

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:26

I’m not moaning - I’m examining the landscape of each generation.

Your posts are absolutely moaning about the "older generation" whilst also implying that the younger generation(s) have it far worse.

Randomsabreur · 07/03/2024 11:34

On a cynical social and economic level the point of subsidising childcare is that it is an investment in the future of society - if a child has access to good quality childcare they will be cheaper to educate and more likely to earn more money and pay more taxes once adult...

Elderly care is morally equally important but the future implications of failure isn't more economic cost to society.

This isn't necessarily the right way to look at it but on a societal level if all children get a good education from early years onwards it will cost less so less cost of state, more warmers, more productivity.

Issue is the investment takes a long time to pay off and governments think in max 5 year terms...

Purplebunnie · 07/03/2024 11:33

"But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc."

Pensioner here. I paid childcare fees 30 years ago, it's nothing new and I had to go to a private dentist over 20 years ago.

The only reason I don't want to pay for a care home if unfortunately that's where I end up is I'd rather my kids had my money

My kids have spied out a nice underpass for me, there's plenty of other people down there to keep me company or I'm going on a world cruise which is cheaper than a care home. I had promised to jump overboard but it's a terrible way to go. I need to think up a new plan so they get the dosh

Edited: PS I have always paid taxes and I still do as I do the odd bit of work here and there

Goforitagainandagain · 07/03/2024 11:29

It's the younger people that don't want to see their inheritance go on the care home, they are the ones that benefit, not the person whose house it is.