Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Subsidised childcare va care home fees

338 replies

MrBanana · 07/03/2024 11:16

Discussing the introduction of 15 free hours for two year olds with friends (which I think is flawed but that’s not the point of this post). Friend 1 said childcare has to be made free. I disagree, there’s no political appetite for that. People of retirement age feel quite strongly that parents should be responsible for their own children. They’re the ones who vote in the largest numbers.

I don’t disagree, but I don’t agree that we somehow have it easier. We are told we have to be responsible for our own children. But we can’t now survive on one salary alone. Childcare is now more expensive and inadequately funded. Everyone I know with a two year old has seen their nursery bill increase in anticipation of the “free hours”
to compensate for it.

But then it struck me that these people are the same people who have “worked all their life” and don’t feel they should have to pay their care home fees and if they do, complain about it being unfair. Healthcare is still free to them, whereas we are finding it increasingly difficult to get a dentist for example.

It just struck me how hypocritical the whole argument is - we are supposed to be responsible for our children, by virtue of them being our children, whilst simultaneously working. But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc.

Im not sure that’s the best structured argument but I hope I've made my point well enough to be understood.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
Helfs · 08/03/2024 17:38

BIossomtoes · 08/03/2024 10:00

Are you really so lacking in intelligence that you can’t see the total irrelevance of what someone earned in the 1970s to their income over the ensuing 45 years? You really are making yourself look incredibly foolish here. I seem to remember you asserting that tax rates were lower in the past too.

When adjusted for inflation they’ve still not paid much into the system have they.

saraclara · 08/03/2024 16:41

@MrBanana it horrifies me that all the health support that was available to me and my small children 30+ years ago has evaporated. Between them my children accessed six monthly paediatric dentist check ups and treatment, speech and language therapy (for a very minor sound production issue), and podiatry (for inherited bunions) all provided, promptly, at the clinic in my very small town. None of those things are available to my DGCs and the clinic is now empty and boarded up.

I'm doing what I can by funding private SALT for the DGD who had far more serious speech and language issues, and with nursery fees. I will continue to help financially where I can as these things crop up.

I just wish these discussions didn't end up (or start) with personal slurs being aimed at my generation. This is a failing of government, not older people. We're the ones (or at least those of us who can afford to) who are trying to financially help our own kids and grandchildren who have been failed by 'austerity'.

HelloDarlingWhatAreYouDoingHere · 08/03/2024 16:34

YANBU

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 16:27

The health service was like this before the Conservatives were voted out last time. There is no reason for it to be as it currently is. I find depressing your assumptions that things can not improve. They can. And many European countries have a far better economy and public services than we do. We need a better government so we can improve the UK.

MrBanana · 08/03/2024 14:05

@Thedance

I am sorry you find it depressing. I don’t believe and hope it doesn’t come across that your generation (assuming that’s who you align to - which your posts suggests you do) haven’t worked hard, or had tough times. My parents are part of the same generation and I have a deep respect and admiration for them.

That said, it’s frustrating when policy seems to be driven by ring fencing wealth, services that supported them whilst they were bringing up young families and for the bulk of their lives aren’t available or aren’t available in the same way. My kids will probably never see an NHS dentist. They’ll likely have to go privately to see a consultant at the hospital or have a lengthy wait. I remember waiting a month to see a paediatrician when I was 12 and it was seen as a long waiting time! The problem is the contributions simply aren’t enough for the demand.

All whilst the parents of young families now are being taxed to the nines and it’s barely worth working because of childcare costs. But if you don’t work you can’t rely on healthcare etc being free and effective.

I agree - there needs to be total reform.

OP posts:
Thedance · 08/03/2024 10:58

I am finding this thread extremely depressing.
I don't understand why we can't agree that both older people and younger people should be supported. It's not a competition into which generation has the hardest time.
I am the first to say we should support children people with young families more . I know it is not easy bring up a family , it never has been!
I desperately want state schools to have more funding and would love it if something like sure start was re introduced to support families with young children. I am in favour of providing support for high quality childcare.
What I won't accept is that people of my generation haven't contributed enough, that we had it easy and don't now deserve support. We honestly didn't have it easy.. And I can't agree that older people shouldn't have financial support towards social care costs . Incidentally I read a recent report that showed less than 20% of over 80s used social care.
A society should be judged on how it supports it's most vulnerable and both the very old and very young come into that category.
This thread which some people seem to have used to create a division in the generations is very sad.

Goforitagainandagain · 08/03/2024 10:36

A lot of women that are probably in their 70s and 80s now paid the married woman's stamp which meant you got no pension as you relied on your husbands pension, something like that. I was a bit young for this as it was abolished fortunately.

Crikeyalmighty · 08/03/2024 10:25

I think as I said before the scandi way of doing things works for me works way better- higher wages, high tax, high services, high pensions- many things covered off by high tax - (no NI, no council tax, cheap childcare etc). It encourages both to work , if able to work , so both entitled to full pensions

One thing that's rarely mentioned is the current female pensioners of 68 plus (I'm 62) - a lot of them simply didn't work or did a bit of part time and hence aren't getting full pensions in their own name- and married couples pension isn't as high as 2 single ones. The women I know who did work of that age range were either real careerists and had an actual 'career' (teachers, doctors etc) or they were really on the bones of their arse - I know few in the middle who worked- and this was a midlands mining town- the idea they all worked hard and all paid 40 years plus tax simply isn't the case with lots of the women- I'm not saying they didn't work hard at home- but lots were not paying tax

Goforitagainandagain · 08/03/2024 10:13

@Helfs do we need to break it down into bite size pieces and gently explain about pay, inflation and tax so that you understand.

Goforitagainandagain · 08/03/2024 10:04

There was rampant inflation in the 70s, I started full time work as a lab technician at 16, in 1974 just over £15 a week, office jobs which a lot of girls did who didn't stay on past O levels were about £14 a week, (not London) PPs £10 a week seems about right for 1972. We got high percent pay rises, sometimes twice a year iirc because of inflation.

BIossomtoes · 08/03/2024 10:00

Helfs · 08/03/2024 09:57

So another person who won’t have paid enough into the system

Are you really so lacking in intelligence that you can’t see the total irrelevance of what someone earned in the 1970s to their income over the ensuing 45 years? You really are making yourself look incredibly foolish here. I seem to remember you asserting that tax rates were lower in the past too.

Thedance · 08/03/2024 09:59

Helfs · 08/03/2024 09:57

So another person who won’t have paid enough into the system

Nonsense. Salary's were low then. Proportionally to income I paid as much if not more than people today. And I still pay tax now 40+ years later.

Helfs · 08/03/2024 09:57

Thedance · 08/03/2024 09:52

When I started work in 1979 my salary was £3000 a year and I was a graduate living in London so it included London weighting .I think that is equivalent to about £15000 today.

Edited

So another person who won’t have paid enough into the system

Thedance · 08/03/2024 09:52

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:29

And what did you earn.

When I started work in 1979 my salary was £3000 a year and I was a graduate living in London so it included London weighting .I think that is equivalent to about £15000 today.

underthebun · 08/03/2024 05:48

@ilovesooty after I recognised the poster I asked them to stop & did the same. I don’t see any value in debating with a certain style of posters. Is that ok with you?

Myotherdogsanoodle · 08/03/2024 02:45

While there are some valid points on here I find they’re undermined by the fact it’s essentially yet another ‘pensioner bashing’ thread. It seems that some of today’s younger generation are fundamentally unaware of what life in general was like for previous generations to an extent that would be laughable were it not so offensive. Thanks to the PPs who’ve tried to explain but I suspect it falls on deaf ears.

ilovesooty · 08/03/2024 00:34

underthebun · 07/03/2024 18:03

And pls don’t @ me anymore, it’s wasting everyone’s time. Like I said you must have more to your life then being infamous on MNs.

Why is it not OK for her to @ you when you're doing it to her?

Soontobe60 · 08/03/2024 00:15

Untethered · 07/03/2024 11:23

So tired of people trying to close down discussion by always crying ageism.

It absolutely IS ageism though. Try replacing ‘older people’ with ‘gay people’ or ‘disabled people’. Older people are not a monolith - come to that, neither are younger people.
But the current cohort of retirement age are complaining about, and want to avoid, being financially responsible for themselves! Most won’t have been paying taxes whilst receiving the benefits we’re now paying for childcare/dentistry etc every retired person I know is financially responsible for themselves. All of them have paid taxes for over 40 years, and don’t receive benefits. In fact, all of us still pay tax as our private pensions take us slightly over the personal tax allowance. Dentist costs aren’t free for pensioners.

1960swhatshappened · 07/03/2024 23:44

Oldsu · 07/03/2024 21:42

Not sure what generation you are talking about but yes when I was growing up in the 50s we did at one time live on one salary my dads but that salary was only enough for my mum, my older sister and myself due to the fact my dad worked 3 jobs 18 hours a day 6 days a week, we never saw him he was either at work or in bed asleep, my mum was nursing my nan in the front room of our council house so she did not work until nan died, when she did we had another sister who was two, in order for mum to work so my dad could drop one of his jobs my little sister went to a child minder, every day my sister and myself (9 and 11) would pick her up after school and look after her until mum came home from work I had a few friends who had to do the same, I don't think that would be allowed now would it.?

As for paying for care homes, DH and I have made arrangements, however it is not inevitable or mandatory that we will need to go into one, none of the older generation in my family my grandparents, or my parents needed to go into one same with my DHs grandparents and parents. If we don't of course the money we have when we die to go to my son and his family

Thank you @Oldsu you have summed up how the real world are !

JassyRadlett · 07/03/2024 22:58

londonmummy1966 · 07/03/2024 22:47

Oh no, totally disagree. Regressive working-age-only taxation is unlikely to solve the conundrum of how to encourage economic activity.

This suggests that wealthy pensioners get away scot free.... if you have a state paid index linked pension of £60K pa (which my DF has) why should you not pay tax on it? What makes you better than the father of 2 pre school DC whose wife is a SAHM and who loses their child benefit whilst the pensioner already gets winter fuel allowance? Especially as the pensioner might well have a mortgage free home whilst the dad of 2 is probably paying high interest or rent?

BBC website today was full of pensioners complaining that the personal allowance freeze combined with the increase in state pension meant that they had to pay tax on their pension and whinging that they didn't benefit from the cut in NIC - because pension income is basically taxed at a lower rate than earned income due to the impact of NIC

I'm not sure you read my post fully - or at all beyond the first paragraph? My suggestion would see the father of two pay less, and the asset rich pensioner pay more. What exactly are you criticising? And what demographic do you think I'm in when you say "what makes you better than"?

And I should have been clearer - I wouldn't abolish income tax altogether, but rather than raise IT I'd probably decrease it for basic rate taxpayers in particular, and shift some of the burden to wealth.

Which the statistics suggest is disproportionately concentrated in increasingly older demographics, so I don't think those wealthy pensioners would get off scot-free either way. In fact, while poorer pensioners would likely be unaffected, the pension- and asset-rich would likely take an increased hit.

I should be very clear that I expect to be one of those pensioners, and I would probably be hit by a wealth tax as things stand... and that's as it should be. But I'd like to see a shift away from taxing income - and therefore largely taxing work - as our default.

londonmummy1966 · 07/03/2024 22:47

Oh no, totally disagree. Regressive working-age-only taxation is unlikely to solve the conundrum of how to encourage economic activity.

This suggests that wealthy pensioners get away scot free.... if you have a state paid index linked pension of £60K pa (which my DF has) why should you not pay tax on it? What makes you better than the father of 2 pre school DC whose wife is a SAHM and who loses their child benefit whilst the pensioner already gets winter fuel allowance? Especially as the pensioner might well have a mortgage free home whilst the dad of 2 is probably paying high interest or rent?

BBC website today was full of pensioners complaining that the personal allowance freeze combined with the increase in state pension meant that they had to pay tax on their pension and whinging that they didn't benefit from the cut in NIC - because pension income is basically taxed at a lower rate than earned income due to the impact of NIC

JassyRadlett · 07/03/2024 22:40

ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 21:11

Well no, I doubt it would work. I wouldn't vote for it. But I don't fret that my taxes might end up funding others.

Either we have a system where people are supported when vulnerable or it's everyone for themselves. Under the current system there will be net winners and losers, but if everyone paid for everything for which they and only they saw benefit I think we would all be much worse off.

I would prefer taxes to rise, and for every adult to be liable (not just those in work), with exemptions for those in education, over retirement age or unable to work because of illness or caring for a sick or disabled child or relative. That way, everyone would be supported when above and below working age, health, education, childcare and elder care would be free, and it wouldn't fall to workers to subsidise those who choose not to work.

Oh no, totally disagree. Regressive working-age-only taxation is unlikely to solve the conundrum of how to encourage economic activity.

With the levels of wealth disparity we have in this country I'm very up for a wealth tax instead. Fewer unintended consequences - those with assets pay; those without assets don't. I'd probably go for a relatively high threshold, especially to start with, rather than something like Norway's with a much lower starting threshold.

Lots of questions in it - do you stop taxing estates and tax the recipients of inheritance for their windfall directly instead? Do
you consider global or just UK assets? But given the generational shift in (mainly but not solely property) wealth, the demographics of landlords, the concentration of wealth (10% of individuals hold nearly half of all the wealth) plus our employment challenges, I'd say we're ripe for a shift in the individual tax burden from work to wealth.

Dorriethelittlewitch · 07/03/2024 22:36

So what would you be taxed on?

Haven't a clue. Tax dh twice? (I'd probably divorce him) Savings?

I presume the poster who suggested it must have some ideas.

underthebun · 07/03/2024 22:24

So what would you be taxed on?

Dorriethelittlewitch · 07/03/2024 22:04

As who are the non workers that aren't in education, over retirement age or unable to work because of illness or caring for a sick or disabled child or relative?

Me! Although I am doing another degree part time but thats mostly for fun because I already have two. I know plenty tbh. Around here it's common for men to work either abroad or offshore and for women not to work at all. The exercise class I go to is full of women who could be earning decent money but aren't, ex social workers, teachers, civil servants and accountants for example.

Drives my Civil Service ex-boss up the wall. He's always been a stick not a carrot type of guy though. If he was running the country, I'd apparently have to chose between returning to work full time or repaying the 2 degrees worth of tuition that the tax payer kindly paid for (with interest obviously).