Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health support at Uni - social sports clubs would help not just for elite players

138 replies

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

OP posts:
UpsideLeft · 07/03/2024 18:28

Which uni is it ?

It would help if we knew

itsnotallfunandgames · 07/03/2024 18:28

You are right OP. I think I can guess the uni you refer to, and I have a DC at another top uni that doesn't boast top sporting facilities (sold them all off and/or closed them all down due to costs - super, thanks) but is also utterly appalling at mental health support (6 sessions of counselling for the ENTIRE time the student is at university, DC's uni department routinely ignore the support statement and student disability services have no power over the department and are barely able to interact with it). So I emphasise about that horrific feeling of being alone with a desperately unhappy DC living away from home at only 18 yo with no friends and an uninterested uni.

The sports clubs are like that because the uni gives financial subsidies to very sporty students and has to show that throwing money at students and giving them dispensations on the academic timescales/engagement front etc simply because they are good at sport is worthwhile in terms of winning competitions/raised profile etc.

I think you would like the uni to be more interested and supportive of your DC in their mental health, rather than simply setting up a social club for them, so the criticism you are getting is a bit unfair. You need to be raising concerns about your DC's mental health with student support services.

If I have guessed the uni correctly, there is a uni social local walks club on Sundays that is quite low stakes I believe. I would guess community involvement is a bit tricky due to location, but probably there are possibilities if your DC likes animals.

The campaign to make universities have a duty of care for their students would go a long way to making universities more supportive of students' mental health. Sadly, Bristol university have made this essential duty of care take a lot longer to introduce than would have been the case if they had not appealed against it. Universities have 18 yo teenagers living away from home in their accommodation and paying a lot of money for their courses, but the duty of care is currently less than an employer would have if the 18 yo were in employment. The big ones are too big to care and don't have the facilities for mental health support that they should be legally obliged to provide. Departments and faculties should have a legal duty of care not to make students' mental health worse by not providing reasonable adjustments or being obstructive or just careless about reasonable adjustments.

Please can everyone sign petitions and ask MPs to support the move to make universities have a duty of care towards their students.

NewName24 · 07/03/2024 18:14

I agree with what @rbe78 and @rachelvbwho said.
'Universities' don't run teams, clubs and societies, the students do.

I'm pretty surprised to hear of any University that doesn't have several levels of sports teams. My dd is currently at quite a small University, not particularly known for sports and she was saying there are 7 men's football teams.

I’m soooo disappointed as is YP not to have got into any of the sports teams (they were very sporty at school) but the teams only interested in semi pro players Well, didn't he ask about these things when you looked round ?

and I despair of the accommodation is no social area just a cramped kitchen. Such a pity really considering the costs of it all. Ie v.expensive for very poor accommodation and poor quality uni experience

Again, didn't you view them, and ask students who were there, when you were on the tours ?

Stompythedinosaur · 07/03/2024 18:07

At uni the onus is on the adult students to arrange their own social clubs, I think.

Most Student Unions have an officer to help students set a club or society up, so they could do that.

Turtlerunner · 07/03/2024 18:06

Uni worker here & we offer a very high standard of diverse support for student mental health. Some of this involves fitness/sport offerings accessible through various routes inc student counselling. It seems that you're quite dismissive of that though. Has your child even explored that option?

ThePerfectDog · 07/03/2024 18:05

I work at a uni, ours has a lot of social sport though. Seems odd that a university wouldn’t.

Which one is it?

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 18:05

But that’s the thing it is I heard good things about social fun at Nottingham and Loughborough they manage to have top teaching and the social sports for all !!! If they can do it why can’t the so called top uni ??

it just helps get everyone involved and a friendly atmosphere

OP posts:
enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/03/2024 18:02

I think most of the clubs at university are social - they will cater for all abilities. It probably depends on the club, eg a running club will probably be less competitive than an athletics club and if you do something like korfball or climbing it will be about the social side as much as the activity itself.

It's also worth looking at parkruns if your dc can get out of bed for 9am on a Saturday (mine won't :) )

GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 17:58

But how is the teaching? The library and learning resources? The labs and equipment? The careers service? The connections to employers and industry? That's the experience the fees are covering.

Uni is viewed as a place/time to have a lot of fun but it's not a holiday-camp-finishing-school combo that your thread is focusing on.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 17:51

i think that there is the uni experience dream sold to them for a top uni, that really is not there for all and I despair of the accommodation is no social area just a cramped kitchen. Such a pity really considering the costs of it all. Ie v.expensive for very poor accommodation and poor quality uni experience

OP posts:
GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 17:16

The glossy brochure will mainly focus on education and careers, which is what the university is there to deliver, along with support for said education.

Lots of students are enjoying the sports facilities, just not your child. There will be plenty to get involved in that isn't competitive sport if they give it a go. I'm sorry your kid is lonely but this is the right time for them to take charge of their life and make the best of their time at university. No one is going to step in and individually curate their social life.

I'm not unsympathetic. My own nephew nearly dropped out of college because he hadn't found a tribe. His parents weren't ringing the dean to ask them to arrange a Friday night kickabout. He's just turned a corner in the last month by getting into jiu jitsu and making friends that way.

rachelvbwho · 07/03/2024 17:07

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 13:22

Anyone who works in a uni on here ?

Yep.

At mine sports teams, clubs and societies are all run by the students and students union so not the business of the university itself.

We have fun/friendly inter college sports activities as well as the bigger national teams and all of that is facilitated by the SU and college exec teams.

Ultimately the university is a business, it has the 'top class' facilities but has no real involvement in who/how they are being used as long as the right people are being paid.

PermanentTemporary · 07/03/2024 17:02

Getting OUT into community provision! Getting put into it is just what they shouldn't expect...

PermanentTemporary · 07/03/2024 17:02

I'd agree about getting put into community provision like parkrun or local footie if setting a club up themselves is too much.

Or think about volunteering. Nothing improves mental health more. There are often volunteer initiatives for sporty youth to get involved with - maybe supporting people with disabilities for example. There will be lots of adverts up for this kind of thing. They will need to find it themselves though - it genuinely isn't the university's job to find or even organise sport sessions for students.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 16:54

I hear the PP say it’s not the Uni admin team’s issue as they are already stressed. But it’s under the University name so would expect the Uni to work with each other as they advertise in the glossy brochures about sports facilities and student social satisfaction scores????

OP posts:
taxguru · 07/03/2024 16:31

YANBU. Where my son went, they didn't even have a casual/fun football club! They had the official Uni teams of varying abilities (all being very good ability) and the "fun" club was still formal, i.e. on a full size pitch, with referees and linesman, full 90 minutes, etc., and played against the "fun" team of other Unis in some kind of "fun" league. Son went a few times and said it was nothing like "fun" at all. Even their 5-a-side "club" played formal games against other Unis!!

He'd expected, with it being a college Uni, that there'd be inter-college footie games, but they didn't do that either!

I think, as others have said, the sports clubs do tend to be uber-competitive for the really keen/able people and a lot of the other clubs are mostly online.

Son ended up joining the frizbee club as that was really the only one where people seemed to go for a laugh and to meet people, but even that had different levels of ability and competed against other Unis in the frizbee league games!!

GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 16:18

As PP have said, your disappointment should be directed at the students union, which runs societies. SUs are independent organisations, with their own governance and Boards, so should respond to the needs of the student population.

I would also say that this is a problem in sport as a whole. Sport is largely funded to fuel the competition pipeline. NGBs are less interested in participation for health / wellbeing / inclusion and more interested in formal sports teams, winning competition, medals etc. Look at the horrific report to come out of Swim England today. I guarantee that's happening in many, many other sports.

In summary, please leave very stressed university administrators alone and speak to the SU.

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 16:11

My daughter's sport is provided far off campus, miles away and very late at night which means navigating deserted backstreets at nearly 11pm, whilst there is a kid's club fir the sport at the uni run by a non-uni sports club! Bonkers!
The sport thing she has enjoyed most is parkrun, which of course is nothing to do with the uni!
Her uni is all about appearances than substance, when it comes to wellbeing.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 14:11

That’s my point I think all that’s really needed for everyone is a reason to get out in the fresh air and play foottie and make some friends ie !!!

Before mental health support is really needed

yes it was the uni of the year !!!! But what the hell for ???? Oh top facilities but who for ??? Only the elites!!!! Ok what about the average students ???

I
think the uni says it has all theses clubs but it’s only on paper, and but not like Nottingham or Loughborough which actually has inter-house games and socials it’s like a holiday camp Nottingham and at Loughborough in comparison the cousins had fun there which I thought wouldn’t be the case at Loughborough is elite sports uni

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 07/03/2024 13:50

Not just at university level tbh.

Nobody had "forgotten their kit" when the weather was a total washout and we played dodgeball inside. All kids heartily involved, and it broke down social barriers as well with people getting behind team members they wouldn't normally be seen dead with.

For the vast majority of people it needs to be fun and energetic, not skilled.

Ezzee · 07/03/2024 13:48

All uni's have access to mental health support under the disability department for YP who are struggling.
They have access to specialist mental health mentors etc, although it is not widely known.

HollaHolla · 07/03/2024 13:47

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 13:22

Anyone who works in a uni on here ?

Yep. Scottish institution here. PM me if that’s of help.

titchy · 07/03/2024 13:46

The unis can't get involved in what the SU does or doesn't offer - yes they provide funding (who else would!) but the point is that they are independent of the uni. That independence should be a formal part of their constitution.

I sympathise though, really. Covid particularly has hit our young peoples MH hard. And sadly, unis have no money to invest in much needed MH support. Heck, we can't even break even these days, hence the large number of courses and depts closing and mass redundancies.

Are there non-uni sports clubs where she is?

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 13:43

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 11:35

thankyou everyone for posting. It is very difficult for a fresh faced 18yr to navigate along with everything else.
I’m sooo disappointed with the Uni response (effectively go to waiting list for counselling) atleast get some proper social sports going !!!!

After all the uni boast about it’s sports facilities Olympic pool, rugby etc so be it could be more inclusive learn from other universities that are also elite but have inter houses game and fun sports and care about their students

I don't want to out my dd ( coupled with other info i have posted) by saying which uni , but I wonder if it is the same one.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 07/03/2024 13:32

Universities are huge organisations and very varied in their approaches.
I can think of one that has wellbeing walks, one that has table tennis every Sunday, one that has decent availability of counselling.
It depends on how much money is available, the attitude of student services managers and as has been mentioned, students themselves setting things up.
Universities are really struggling for funding currently so I can't picture them setting new things up but a bit of research will show what already exists.
Libraries are often good places to relax. They have things like jigsaws or craft spaces