Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health support at Uni - social sports clubs would help not just for elite players

138 replies

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

OP posts:
ThePerfectDog · 07/03/2024 20:42

Ultimate frisbee, pole dancing, climbing, Zumba… there are loads.

inkblackheart · 07/03/2024 20:35

Why will nobody say which university this is? It’s impossible to comment without knowing it.

looking at recent universities of the year which are also “top” universities I’m guessing Warwick? Bath?

op could your daughter join something obscure? My DC is loving underwater hockey! Nobody is an expert at it since they’re all new to it.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 20:33

@Sunnnybunny72

It's a shame it's not like this everywhere given the benefit of sport for mental health.

this it’s so important for everyone esp young people

OP posts:
GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 20:20

Universities are not "money making machines" comparable with investment banks or oil companies. They are mostly running at a deficit due to the erosion of the real value of the student fee.

You come across as terribly naive and slightly entitled OP. Our actual healthcare system doesn't take a preventative approach to mental wellbeing, why would you expect a university to do so?

If your kid is too shy/introverted to able to make a good life for himself at uni then maybe he needs to take a gap year and grow up a bit.

itsnotallfunandgames · 07/03/2024 20:18

I think the OP is particularly disappointed about their DC's specific university and all the international-level sporting facilities and opportunities that seem hard to access unless the student is an elite sportsperson. This university does sell itself on the basis of these facilities, as well as the high academic standard. The fact that the university makes a big noise about the elite sportspeople who attend the university is in retrospect a red flag. It gives scholarships to elite sportspeople and attracts the best.

PPs who suggest lesser known sports as easier to get into have identified the problem indirectly. Avoid the elite sports and the focus won't be on elite sportspeople.

There are two walking clubs I think, one that is hard-core out in far-flung parts of the UK hiking and climbing at the weekend when your DC might want to study, but there is another lower key one that does local walks around the town apparently. Ditto taking dogs in the local shelter for walks gets a student some fresh air, unless your DC has a dog phobia like mine.

In my experience at this stage of the academic year everything student-related switches to exams and teaching stops in term 3. Maybe your DC should plan for social activities next year. There will be more options if they are living off-campus/in town.

As to the getting on with the degree part of it and not worry about social life, my DC has been crippled with loneliness, utterly desperately miserable and this has badly affected the degree part of it. Loneliness should not minimised or overlooked. It is very widespread, but can be invisible since many students simply go home at weekends to try to avoid the issue. That leaves campuses at weekends populated with the extroverts and the international students who can't go home, and the social/sporting clubs become dominated by both, which can mean a quiet introverted home student can become isolated.

TooBored1 · 07/03/2024 20:15

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 16:54

I hear the PP say it’s not the Uni admin team’s issue as they are already stressed. But it’s under the University name so would expect the Uni to work with each other as they advertise in the glossy brochures about sports facilities and student social satisfaction scores????

Is it ARU? They seem to have lots of non-elite sports.

Sunnnybunny72 · 07/03/2024 20:07

DS2 is at York. Has always played in a football team from being young (and been very average tbh) but he's joined his colleges team at uni and plays socially every week. It's been great I have to say. Really got him mixing.
DS1 played Basketball at Notts in year one having never ever played before. I think he made the 7th team!
It's a shame it's not like this everywhere given the benefit of sport for mental health.

Carriemac · 07/03/2024 19:58

Not my experience with 3 kids though uni - all did society / club/ department / college type sport - very social and not serious - and really enjoyed it . Oxford college and Leeds Uni - both brilliant for not 'serous ' social sport

Oblomov24 · 07/03/2024 19:55

"I’m soooo disappointed as is YP not to have got into any of the sports teams (they were very sporty at school) but the teams only interested in semi pro players. So the renowned facilities are out of bounds for them and a whole group of YP players who would enjoy the inclusion and interaction. "

I'm sorry but this sounds very naive. I was well aware that many unis are like this.

Oblomov24 · 07/03/2024 19:53

I have to say I see it totally differently to op. I disagree with what you are asking for.

Actually, I'm confused by what you are asking.

Loads of unis have loads of different clubs, different levels. Loughborough is the most sporty, so you are bound to struggle to get into any football team. Don't they have 6, and even county players can struggle to get into the 6th. But they have dept football teams. And ones just for fun where they just fancy a kick around.

At Nottingham, Birmingham and Durham they have tonnes of clubs, tonnes of sports, for serious players, and mucking about in canoes at the gym pool. Surely dc can find something?

If it's mental health issues, that's a totally different issue whatsoever. university student services, support groups, speaking to their tutor, going to the GP, booking online counselling. There's loads and loads of different options. Have you investigated every single avenue?

coureur · 07/03/2024 19:50

As others have pointed out student sports are nothing to do with the university. They are organised by the students themselves, via the SU. The university sometimes provides the facilities (although in some universities sports facilities are owned by the SU) but the organisation of clubs and societies is on the students.

LaPalmaLlama · 07/03/2024 19:43

Tech doesn’t help tbh. In the old days you basically had to either socialise ( be it church, rugby or the satanist society) or be massively massively bored. I remember sitting in my room being utterly terrified but I basically had no choice but to go to the bar because there was literally nothing else to do. If I’d had a phone I’m pretty sure I wouldn’t have gone. A lot of things I got involved with at Uni were boredom busters more than things I was hugely passionate about.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 19:38

@TrouseredTed

its hard to appreciate that you can be lonely in a crowd if you try but no follow up. as you don’t see people regularly enough

OP posts:
Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 19:35

@TrouseredTed

yes agree there is a high expectation of the uni life, I feel sad for them not finding their tribe. It’s just an expensive experience!!! They did think about a Saturday job.

OP posts:
LaPalmaLlama · 07/03/2024 19:32

MargaretThursday · 07/03/2024 19:04

It can be difficult though to get people joining in if they're not team standard.

I played tennis, and the actual club you had to get onto the squad, which gave you access to the university courts and practice sessions. The practice sessions would have around 20 people regularly.

But I tried to organise a social just turn up for anyone group for a term (summer) and was lucky if we got three people, which was hopeless. Lots of people told me they were keen and would come, just never did.

Yeah- I think the issue is that everyone wants to do it…. in theory…. on their own terms and when they’re not too busy, but no one wants to organise it and no one wants to commit to turning up regularly. You do need some sort of commitment to get even a social kick about going. You can see why it gets annoying when you organise a social game but then you get six people flake on the day.

Collegiate universities have more social sport because it generally is a formal league- it’s not just random social games- Cambridge has an inter college league and “cuppers” which is a knock out but it’s all student run and organised. The college “management” aren’t involved at all.

OP I’d advise your dd to join a town team. I live in a Uni town and loads of students play in the local women’s netball league and for the local rugby clubs, either because they didn’t make thre cut for the Uni team, or they didn’t like the culture or the training schedule doesn’t work with their course commitments.

TrouseredTed · 07/03/2024 19:27

OP sorry your YP is going through this. I hope you find a resolution.

I actually think too high expectations are placed on uni social life.

If someone isn't naturally a joiner, or introverted, or their face doesn't fit (or not white or ND or circumstances are they've accidentally joined an unpleasant houseshare or year group) the whole thing often can be fairly strenuous experience.

There's a lot of adults who are doing incredibly well career and life wise who hardly engaged with "uni social life".

Of course some people meet their partners or friend group for life. Especially if they're super extroverted.

But a lot don't. Or they get on the graduate job path and start making money and that's when their life takes off. Not everyone enjoys a houseshare environment!

I'd say focus on the basics rather than trying to force social things. Especially as I assume they're on student loans.

Get the good degree, put work into the next career move, don't overspend, don't get into drama, stay healthy, learn basic housekeeping, see it as a means to an end.

They may meet people naturally so enjoy those ad-hoc interactions.

Like pps say, there should be some activity or environment they can just drop into for a cup of tea and a chat. Chaplaincy can be good for this.

But if they don't easily find a friendly group, then I wouldn't force things or spend ages looking for the right one. It doesn't make their uni experience inferior to anyone else's.

Most people lose touch. No one gives a shit if you had the most fun parties in your first year.

If they.get their degree, get on the graduate career path and stay healthy that's all that matters.

If they've got a full week of classes that should take up enough time.

Maybe you could sub them Netflix or something. Or pay for a monthly gym membership. Something to ease things a bit.

But I wouldn't overthink the social stuff

(obviously if they're specifically being bullied then that's another situation. But not finding their tribe isn't an immediate worry).

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 19:23

@itsnotallfunandgames

thankyou for getting it. Yes I talking about prevention of mental health issues as has been proven the social sports gives you, as advertised by said Uni !!!! With the great facilities
So things don’t escalate to needing mental health treatment/support due to isolation

OP posts:
itsnotallfunandgames · 07/03/2024 19:18

OP if your DC needs better counselling that the uni can't provide, they can also self-refer to the local mental health team. The uni medical centre might have the right number or just google it.

However, the university's own services will manage the waiting list based on urgency, so you should assess the urgency of your DC's mental health and if necessary any urgency should be communicated (any urgent cases will be seen quite quickly).

Aside from Bristol university's appeal so that universities have no legal duty of care to their students (shame on that university in particular, and all other universities that think it is right for universities not to have any duty of care to the young adults living in their accommodation and paying for their courses), I do believe that universities were told to have one named parent/guardian/other adult that could be communicated with directly by the university, although I know that my DC's university have not set this up yet. However, the student disability service at my DC's crap-for-mental-health money-obsessed university allow the DC to give permission for the student disability service to talk directly to a parent. If your DC gave this permission, you could raise your concerns directly with them.

Sorry you and your DC are going through this. There was a brief bit of media interest in high levels of loneliness among university students last year (it was even on the Jeremy Vine radio show) but it doesn't get nearly enough coverage or attention. Students are dropping out of university due to loneliness, and there are even worse outcomes.

How awful to think that at any university there are probably hundreds of lonely students feeling stuck in their rooms because social spaces like kitchens, lounges, sports clubs etc are dominated by the extroverted or elite.

Maybe your DC could try the student social club for their course/department, if there is one?

You are right that mental health is greatly helped by a bit of fresh air and exercise. It shouldn't be/feel so hard for a YP to access at a sports-focussed uni.

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 19:09

@itsnotallfunandgames

exactly spot on the “duty of care” at the uni is less than if they were in employment at 18yrs. Yet some simple steps could enhance mental health, so why not. Clearly money making machines, yes they do need to be enticed out of their cells for their own benefit.

lessons from previous years should be learnt to benefit all

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 07/03/2024 19:04

It can be difficult though to get people joining in if they're not team standard.

I played tennis, and the actual club you had to get onto the squad, which gave you access to the university courts and practice sessions. The practice sessions would have around 20 people regularly.

But I tried to organise a social just turn up for anyone group for a term (summer) and was lucky if we got three people, which was hopeless. Lots of people told me they were keen and would come, just never did.

Shiveringinthecountry · 07/03/2024 18:53

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 11:35

thankyou everyone for posting. It is very difficult for a fresh faced 18yr to navigate along with everything else.
I’m sooo disappointed with the Uni response (effectively go to waiting list for counselling) atleast get some proper social sports going !!!!

After all the uni boast about it’s sports facilities Olympic pool, rugby etc so be it could be more inclusive learn from other universities that are also elite but have inter houses game and fun sports and care about their students

I don't understand why you think it's the responsibility of the university to offer mental health support to your daughter, rather than that of the NHS via the GP. The university is an educational institution, not a health provider.

I don't mean that to sound unsympathetic, as it's very clear that there's very little assistance available to people of whatever age who have mental health issues. That's shocking and frightening. Ultimately, though, a university is never going to be the main provider of any kind of health assistance. The problem is the lack of adequate help available via the NHS.

PostItInABook · 07/03/2024 18:47

Definitely get them looking for community based clubs. When I played netball we always welcomed uni students into our team when they were about. I even gave lifts to some. There will be local leagues / opportunities they can get involved with. It also helps them build a support network that doesn’t just consist of other students.

MrsAvocet · 07/03/2024 18:45

The bottom line OP is that Universities run as businesses and they all have different "selling" points which they will stress in order to attract students. I'm generalising of course, but on the whole the establishments that find it easiest to fill their courses on their academic reputation alone don't need to be as concerned about the student experience as those who might need to work a bit harder to fill places.
I do sympathise. I know it is a worry when a student is slow to settle, that 18 or 19 doesn't really feel very grown up when it's your own child and that it can be difficult for them to be proactive when mental health is not great. But I think you need to encourage your DD to make the most of what is available rather than being upset about what she feels is missing. I know my DS found the change from school which was pretty much staff led to University where he needed to be a lot more self directed quite a challenge at first. As I said upthread his University does have good pastoral care but he still had to learn that he had to go and ask for any support he needed and to push himself out of his comfort zone to join in things - nobody was going to invite him.
There will be other people like your DD at the University and there must be something she can get involved with surely, either within the University or in the community? You've mentioned football a few times. If that is her thing, is there a grassroots women's football team within reasonable travelling distance - it's so popular right now there seem to be clubs popping up everywhere. Chances are they'd love to have another enthusiastic young player joining them.
I know it is hard for young people who are not naturally outgoing but it's not boarding school - things aren't always organised for them and students don't need anyone's permission to leave their "cells" as you said in a previous post. They are bright, able, young adults and, difficult though it can be, they need to work through these issues themselves. To be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if the University refuse to talk to you, as your DD is the "customer" not you, and she is over 18. In your shoes I think I would be focusing trying to support your DD to make practical steps to improve her situation, or if you think things are too bad then looking into more major things like changing accomodation or even moving University.
I don't want to sound unsympathetic but I think you will be banging your head against a brick wall as whilst there are no doubt some very caring individual staff members it is unlikely that "the University" as an entity will be particularly receptive to your concerns. I'm not saying that's right, but it is currently the way things are, and your energy is probably better directed elsewhere.

TooBored1 · 07/03/2024 18:41

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 18:05

But that’s the thing it is I heard good things about social fun at Nottingham and Loughborough they manage to have top teaching and the social sports for all !!! If they can do it why can’t the so called top uni ??

it just helps get everyone involved and a friendly atmosphere

I am surprised there's no social sport at all - most students' unions are very good at setting this up and many have sports reps etc who can help with set up costs etc.

Which uni is it? Have you looked at the student union page to see what's on offer?

TheFallenMadonna · 07/03/2024 18:33

Recommend lesser known sports for social stuff and welcoming beginners. Ultimate frisbee v inclusive, in my DC's experience.