Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health support at Uni - social sports clubs would help not just for elite players

138 replies

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

OP posts:
Silvergreenblue · 08/03/2024 13:34

Sports aren't some sort of magical cure for depression. Not everyone even likes them.

march2 · 08/03/2024 13:09

However if I am right then Durham hardly sells itself on its sports. It's all about the academics with them.

Sorry, have to disagree, Durham's always been one of the big sporting unis, particularly for rugby and hockey. As I said upthread, there's also lots of social college sport for men and women.

MotherOfDragonflies · 08/03/2024 12:53

I'm guessing it's possibly Durham given they have a large box on their website saying they were sports university of the year. Durham is collegiate so I'm surprised but it's also non campus and any non campus university is going to require a bit more effort to get involved in things. However if I am right then Durham hardly sells itself on its sports. It's all about the academics with them.

OP I'd encourage your DD to join something unusual. Competition will be lower.

taxguru · 08/03/2024 11:53

@itsnotallfunandgames

How awful to think that at any university there are probably hundreds of lonely students feeling stuck in their rooms because social spaces like kitchens, lounges, sports clubs etc are dominated by the extroverted or elite.

That's exactly it. My son went to Uni in 2020 and his Uni did everything online for the first full year, so no opportunities to meet people via the course nor his lecturers. Sadly that set the scene for him. After a year basically stuck in his room, even when common rooms, lecture theatres etc opened up for his second year, he found the common rooms, bars, etc dominated by the extroverted and he couldn't get a look in. He went to his college bar/common room to watch premier league footie a couple of times, but he literally just stood in a corner as everyone else was in their own groups, getting more and more drunk and noisy, never bothered again. Same with the pool table, dart board, etc - groups always dominating them so he couldn't get a look in.

Unfortunately at his Uni, the kitchens were tiny with a tiny round "breakfast" size table and 3 chairs - for an 8 person flat! So not much opportunity there either as whenever he went in, there were already people parked at the table, so he had to make his meals and take back to his room.

It's really hard for the quieter, less assertive ones.

missshilling · 08/03/2024 11:49

What is a YP?

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 11:45

I don't think it's Bristol, but not far off. Bristol has been high profile in not supporting students' mental health, and most appallingly for fighting against universities having a legal duty of care to their students (so bizarrely universities have a higher duty of care to their staff than to their students).

But it may be that Bristol is actually trying to improve, whereas other universities where students quietly drop out in large numbers due to poor mental health outcomes from their experiences at university are complacently ignoring the fact that their practices/organisational management/exam system (some have gone back to antiquated, unnecessarily highly-pressurised, rote-learning exams in giant conference centres at the end of each academic year ffs, nothing was learnt from the pandemic at all) do not support students' mental health at best and at worst are harmful to their mental health.

Btw I don't think it is the responsibility of the individual lecturer, underpaid and unhappy, to sort out a student's sporting social life. But the university as a whole should take on more responsibility, maybe not palm off student well-being and mental health to separate student unions/disability departments that ultimately have little power or accountability.

And my guess at the uni in the OPs case paid a notoriously scandalous amount to top staff, not a good use of resources at all. Probably not the only uni to overpay those at the top.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 11:33

ilovebreadsauce · 08/03/2024 06:40

Are you hard of comprehension?
The op did not say they don't have clubs , or that her dc was too shy to go.She said the sports club was not appropriate for beginners/ intermediate players, and many of the advertised societies do not actually exist or at least meet.
I have a good idea which university it is. If I am right, the place has had negative publicity a few years back for having student mental issues, and is now looking to tick all the wellbeing boxes, without necessarily following through.

No my comprehension is perfectly fine. I am saying I simply do not believe that there is any top university in the UK where social sports are not offered hence asking her to name the uni.

If you believe you know then perhaps you should name them. I would also say if you think it is Bristol then you are very wrong as they have a myriad of clubs and sports for all sorts of levels.

TrouseredTed · 08/03/2024 11:22

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 10:51

"The op did not say they don't have clubs , or that her dc was too shy to go.She said the sports club was not appropriate for beginners/ intermediate players, and many of the advertised societies do not actually exist or at least meet."

Yes, my experience is that my DC's university says it has hundreds of clubs. Most of these are specific for students from a particular country/religion/language. Of course, no-one can stop my DC joining the Taiwan club, but that doesn't change the fact that my DC has no need of any of the country/religion/language clubs.

Then there are many that only exist on paper, usually ones that sound good on a CV: multiple permutations of business/finance/consulting/economy clubs etc. My DC is a member of several, has only been to one once because the purpose they serve is to look good on a CV.

Then the sports ones, which the OP has mentioned. btw it is very obvious which uni it is if you look at the details of the sports/facilities involved. And the circumstances of that uni also make some community involvement tricky. My DC's uni sold/cold almost all its sports facilities, and as PPs have said, at these types of unis the sporting opportunities exist relatively far from uni facilities/accommodation and attendance often involves transport/walking streets late at night or long transport that adds too much time or is too restricted in capacity to be of use to a casual participant, so tend to attract only elite participants.

The fact that funding of universities in the UK is totally messed up and home students are underpaying for their courses (but not their accommodation - my DC's accommodation is fully funded by the rents paid with no uni financial support), is not really relevant to whether a student is entitled to feel lonely or have their mental health made worse by their experience of uni in the UK. There are alternative funding options (e.g. graduate tax) that the current government is not brave enough to implement, and that is not the students fault. Universities should still have a duty of care to their students not to make their mental health worse, and many are failing at this. It is also not the fault of the students that all non-academic activities are separated out to a student union, which also does not have a duty of care, or that mental health support is separated out to a student disability service, which often has no power to ensure that faculties are responsible with students' mental health. An employer of an 18 yo does have a legal duty of care (as it does to all its employees) not to cause their mental health to deteriorate due to the employment, and an employee is not obliged to stay for 3/4/5 years if the employment is detrimental to their mental health or just an unpleasant place to be.

This.

I've heard senior academics admit the system is screwed up and tense and they wouldn't genuinely advise many YP to go UNLESS they're super focussed and pragmatic and see it as a "means to an end".

All the news stories about bullying, the students not even getting their degrees in the strikes...that's the tip of the iceberg.

The time of it being about personal growth and chilling down the bar and meeting new people from different backgrounds (whilst on full grants) is over.

Universities are doing the "hard sell" to get the numbers up (targeting fairly aggressive, dishonest outreach at POC and women, all to get more money for old white men).

But often the social mobility can be incredibly low once the students have actually signed up and are in the system. You see all the people from similar backgrounds flocking together and quietly excluding anyone else.

(You also frequently see "non-traditional" people being manipulated into paying massive amounts for Masters degrees as if that will make them "fit in" - but they're just treated like cash cows with no good job at the end).

I agree with the take that a lot of non-international students have opted out in terms of going home for the weekends, and not having a campus social life beyond the minimum.

Pragmatically as I said, I'd focus on getting that 1st or high 2:1 and utilising any opportunities for placements or resources.

Either get into the graduate corporate milk round or use the time to upskill/build a side-hustle (university is the ideal time to do this, as they're living on a shoestring anyway so don't need to bring in extra income immediately).

Make allies and find people who can be references. Or use the time to pick up AI skills and get a grip on investing and financial planning and what's happening there.

I wouldn't throw good energy in places where nothing is coming back.

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 10:59

And the OP's DC might be an international student who is paying a lot of fees (as many as 60% of students at UK universities are international), so the comments about students not paying enough for their courses would not apply (and are entirely irrelevant to whether universities should support students in maintaining good mental health).

And the situation of a lonely miserable teenager probably quite from home on their own in an environment that is not supportive of their mental health would still apply.

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 10:51

"The op did not say they don't have clubs , or that her dc was too shy to go.She said the sports club was not appropriate for beginners/ intermediate players, and many of the advertised societies do not actually exist or at least meet."

Yes, my experience is that my DC's university says it has hundreds of clubs. Most of these are specific for students from a particular country/religion/language. Of course, no-one can stop my DC joining the Taiwan club, but that doesn't change the fact that my DC has no need of any of the country/religion/language clubs.

Then there are many that only exist on paper, usually ones that sound good on a CV: multiple permutations of business/finance/consulting/economy clubs etc. My DC is a member of several, has only been to one once because the purpose they serve is to look good on a CV.

Then the sports ones, which the OP has mentioned. btw it is very obvious which uni it is if you look at the details of the sports/facilities involved. And the circumstances of that uni also make some community involvement tricky. My DC's uni sold/cold almost all its sports facilities, and as PPs have said, at these types of unis the sporting opportunities exist relatively far from uni facilities/accommodation and attendance often involves transport/walking streets late at night or long transport that adds too much time or is too restricted in capacity to be of use to a casual participant, so tend to attract only elite participants.

The fact that funding of universities in the UK is totally messed up and home students are underpaying for their courses (but not their accommodation - my DC's accommodation is fully funded by the rents paid with no uni financial support), is not really relevant to whether a student is entitled to feel lonely or have their mental health made worse by their experience of uni in the UK. There are alternative funding options (e.g. graduate tax) that the current government is not brave enough to implement, and that is not the students fault. Universities should still have a duty of care to their students not to make their mental health worse, and many are failing at this. It is also not the fault of the students that all non-academic activities are separated out to a student union, which also does not have a duty of care, or that mental health support is separated out to a student disability service, which often has no power to ensure that faculties are responsible with students' mental health. An employer of an 18 yo does have a legal duty of care (as it does to all its employees) not to cause their mental health to deteriorate due to the employment, and an employee is not obliged to stay for 3/4/5 years if the employment is detrimental to their mental health or just an unpleasant place to be.

GinForBreakfast · 08/03/2024 08:27

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 23:35

When a uni has 40+ % of first year students with mental health problems PRE-PANDEMIC I don't think it is the student that is at fault!

I don't know the source of your stats and I don't recognise this in the universities I've worked in. But, I would suggest that many students of those students arrived with MH problems. They are not caused by the university, who generally trying their best under very difficult circumstances.

It's well known that MH issues in all young people have been on the rise. And that CAMHS is not fit for purpose. There are threads on these themes on here all the time. Universities are there to provided higher education (and support in pursuit of that education). They are not therapy centres.

If your mental health is not strong enough for higher education, you shouldn't go to university. You're wasting everyone's time and money, including yours.

march2 · 08/03/2024 07:16

The opportunity to play social sport was high on my list when I was at uni so I chose Durham and my son has done the same. He plays uni hockey (of which there are six teams I think) but there's two or three college teams for some sports and everyone can play something if they want to. From memory, Nottingham and Exeter have a similar set-up but around halls of residence.

Without wishing to be harsh, if that was a key factor, it could have been considered when your daughter was making her choices. But it's not the job of the university. And to echo other posters, it's not hard to set up a team (I started a women's college cricket team which was a lot of fun). A few notices up/posts on social media and she might find a group of others feeling the same way.

user73 · 08/03/2024 06:56

If it's bristol I know various kids who've gone there and been really unhappy. I also know a couple who have been fine but have heard more tales of kids being disappointed and unhappy.

ilovebreadsauce · 08/03/2024 06:40

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 04:01

I can only assume you won't name the uni because you don't want anyone to link you to the social sports clubs they do have at that uni because if you genuinely though they don't exist you would name and shame them.

Are you hard of comprehension?
The op did not say they don't have clubs , or that her dc was too shy to go.She said the sports club was not appropriate for beginners/ intermediate players, and many of the advertised societies do not actually exist or at least meet.
I have a good idea which university it is. If I am right, the place has had negative publicity a few years back for having student mental issues, and is now looking to tick all the wellbeing boxes, without necessarily following through.

inkblackheart · 08/03/2024 06:26

Of the top universities-
Oxford and Cambridge clearly have loads going on and surely aren’t basing their marketing on sports.

St Andrews is known for being small and dominated by oversea students (mainly Americans hoping to meet a royal) but has lots of clubs afaik
The top london universities - well they are always going to require the student to make much more of an effort because they’re city based so that was predictable.
Loughborough - clearly attracts the sports elite and often the moderately good sports kids don’t pick it for the very reason you’ve outlined but you seem to like Loughborough so it can’t be there.

Lancaster is full on sports/social opportunities since it’s both campus and collegiate and they have inter college stuff plus annual Roses war with York university.
Durham also collegiate so I’d imagine there’s intra and inter college stuff (it was DSs second choice and he didn’t express any concern about their offering)
Warwick is well known as being a little staid and reserved with a large international body so could be Warwick. I know a student there who ended up joining the maths departments football team because he couldn’t get into any of the various main teams.
Bath - see pp links above
Bristol known for not being great on the pastoral side but I know nothing more about them.
edinburgh - see comments re london

WandaWonder · 08/03/2024 04:14

It is also up to the student to seek out things to do either uni based or in the local area of where they live, unis cannot do it all and I presume sports/clubs run with some volunteers so they would need all these run by people willing, also enough of an interest

Or they can see about running them themselves?

People complain alot about things but what effort do thet put in themsleves to help?

Oblomov24 · 08/03/2024 04:08

I don't think there's any need to name the uni. As many other pp's have said OP is maybe deluded, entitled and naieve. This isn't a fault of the said un-named uni. It's OP's viewpoint.

What is the real issue here? Child very shy and not engaging? MH issues? Not being able to get onto the team for a super deluxe Uber sporty uni.

pp's have given solutions to all of he above.

But if you are still going to insist : x uni is rubbish. (zero information about the course, the teaching, the student uni life generally, the campus facilities, the catered accommodation) etc etc. solely based on : my kid can't get into the football team. Then quite frankly you'd be laughed out of court. As a fool.

If it's a different issue. Then please say. Mn is incredibly supportive for most issues.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 04:04

inkblackheart · 07/03/2024 20:35

Why will nobody say which university this is? It’s impossible to comment without knowing it.

looking at recent universities of the year which are also “top” universities I’m guessing Warwick? Bath?

op could your daughter join something obscure? My DC is loving underwater hockey! Nobody is an expert at it since they’re all new to it.

It can't be BAth because here is their social offering https://www.thesubath.com/sport/join/

Join a Sports Club

https://www.thesubath.com/sport/join

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 04:01

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 19:23

@itsnotallfunandgames

thankyou for getting it. Yes I talking about prevention of mental health issues as has been proven the social sports gives you, as advertised by said Uni !!!! With the great facilities
So things don’t escalate to needing mental health treatment/support due to isolation

I can only assume you won't name the uni because you don't want anyone to link you to the social sports clubs they do have at that uni because if you genuinely though they don't exist you would name and shame them.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 03:54

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 23:35

When a uni has 40+ % of first year students with mental health problems PRE-PANDEMIC I don't think it is the student that is at fault!

It would be good if you would disclose which uni this is so people can avoid it.

Spirallingdownwards · 08/03/2024 03:53

Name one top uni that does not have intra mural sports leagues? I am unaware of any that do not offer all kinds of sports at all kinds of levels.

youhavenoidea123 · 08/03/2024 02:51

Has your DD tried cricket. My DD plays at uni and is very average. She is ant uni of Manchester and they have lots of girls join who have not played before.

They might not play in the 1st team, but they join in the training and social activities.

NewName24 · 08/03/2024 00:26

GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 20:20

Universities are not "money making machines" comparable with investment banks or oil companies. They are mostly running at a deficit due to the erosion of the real value of the student fee.

You come across as terribly naive and slightly entitled OP. Our actual healthcare system doesn't take a preventative approach to mental wellbeing, why would you expect a university to do so?

If your kid is too shy/introverted to able to make a good life for himself at uni then maybe he needs to take a gap year and grow up a bit.

This.

UK student fees only cover 60p in the pound of what the actual costs are.

Then this idea that adults need the University to provide their entertainment is just bizarre.
As you don't want to identify the University (fair enough) then no-one can show you all the opportunities they are there, but what is clear are there are so many opportunities (both within the University and within the towns and Cities in most places) available but the adult has to be prepared to go along and literally say 'can I join?' or, go to the SU and say 'can I start a {whatever the interest is} club.
These are 18 or 19 yr olds, not 11 yr olds.

ErrolTheDragon · 08/03/2024 00:06

This is where unis with a collegiate system may be beneficial. I just had a quick look at the ones I could think of ...York, Durham, lancaster all seem to have various college sports teams /intercollegiate sports as well as obviously Oxford and Cambridge.

ilovebreadsauce · 07/03/2024 23:35

GinForBreakfast · 07/03/2024 20:20

Universities are not "money making machines" comparable with investment banks or oil companies. They are mostly running at a deficit due to the erosion of the real value of the student fee.

You come across as terribly naive and slightly entitled OP. Our actual healthcare system doesn't take a preventative approach to mental wellbeing, why would you expect a university to do so?

If your kid is too shy/introverted to able to make a good life for himself at uni then maybe he needs to take a gap year and grow up a bit.

When a uni has 40+ % of first year students with mental health problems PRE-PANDEMIC I don't think it is the student that is at fault!

Swipe left for the next trending thread