Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health support at Uni - social sports clubs would help not just for elite players

138 replies

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

OP posts:
GinForBreakfast · 09/03/2024 10:21

My "find your tribe" comment wasn't particularly meaningful, I just meant that he would find people who he's comfortable hanging out with, to have lunch with etc.

Ellmau · 09/03/2024 10:20

OP: I know you don't want to name the uni, but could you say which sport or sports it is?

wombat15 · 09/03/2024 10:15

Northernparent68 · 09/03/2024 07:41

I think you’re trying to square a circle, sports are by nature competitive and selective.

Not all sports.

Northernparent68 · 09/03/2024 07:41

I think you’re trying to square a circle, sports are by nature competitive and selective.

missshilling · 09/03/2024 07:38

50% was a target set by Tony Blair in 1999. To the best of my knowledge it was never achieved.

The target was scrapped in 2020.

Edit: Apparently it was achieved in 2019

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-49841620

user73 · 09/03/2024 02:41

NewName24 · 08/03/2024 22:13

Now more kids go than don't go.

I don't think that is true by a long long way.

A quick Google suggests just over 1/3 go:

The higher education entry rate among UK 18 year olds increased from 24.7% in 2006 to 30.7% in 2015 and peaked at 38.2% in 2021. It fell back to 35.8% in 2023 (2 Jan 2024)

Ok well my Google from a new statesman article says that in the late 80s it was between 8 percent and 18 percent and it’s now 50 percent. Either way, far more kids now go and it’s unhelpful to continue the narrative that they will “find their tribe”.
Most will hopefully make new friends. Not everyone will and some people will get housed with others they have little in common with which can make life more challenging. They go with such massive expectation (which isn’t helped by social media) and this can make it even harder to settle. Lots of kids go and are quite lonely, particularly if they expected everything to automatically click into place for them.

NewName24 · 08/03/2024 22:13

Now more kids go than don't go.

I don't think that is true by a long long way.

A quick Google suggests just over 1/3 go:

The higher education entry rate among UK 18 year olds increased from 24.7% in 2006 to 30.7% in 2015 and peaked at 38.2% in 2021. It fell back to 35.8% in 2023 (2 Jan 2024)

NamechangeRugby · 08/03/2024 21:45

Would you YP consider Yoga/Pilates/Dance type classes? Even just for the next term? I realise they aren't team, but movement and breathing to music is (in my opinion) so much more effective than antidepressants, with the added benefit of a gentle and lovely way to meet like minded people. I know one of our local Uni's runs free sunrise classes on their rooftop etc and those chance encounters & conversations tend to lead to offers to come along to this, or that, in time.

I really feel for your YP & really hope things come right for them - be that staying at Uni or deciding to take a different tack - both very valid options.

user73 · 08/03/2024 18:47

MojoMoon · 08/03/2024 17:17

Because sometimes, particularly when you are suffering from depression and anxiety, it is much easier to make out that there is a unavoidable barrier to doing something (like playing social sports) than admit that you are feeling too sad or anxious to be able to seek it out, join in with strangers and interact with people.

It's not that they are lying maliciously about their uni. It's that sometimes their version of the truth is quite the reality.

For them, there are no social sports teams that they feel able to join. Maybe there is nothing in their immediate vicinity in halls or with people they already know participating? The idea of asking a bunch of strangers to join their social team in another department or hall might be too terrifying to contemplate. But saying that is also hard - easy to say there are no teams at all.

What they need is support in finding ways to be able to reach out and find their tribe - it might be via doing activities like scuba diving where almost everyone doing it at uni is new to the sport so all on equal footing.

If the important thing is finding their tribe rather than specifically playing football, doing new activities may be a better approach.

(Sorry @MrsAvocet for saying hockey was obscure. I've never met anyone who played it! Hopefully lacrosse works as a good example of the point I was making at least. )

It can actually be quite unhelpful to continue this narrative of "finding your tribe". Its an odd saying that has come about for no real reason but it can lead to massive expectation and then disappointment when a young person has read over and over again that they will go to university and have an amazing time and find their tribe.. but then they don't.

Actually back in the day it was probably more likely. Those who went to university were in the minority. So it was probably more likely to be the case that they had more in common with others who also went to university than perhaps some of their school friends who had left education at 16. Now more kids go than don't go. As such the variety of kids at university is far greater. Its actually important that kids go with the expectation that they will need to get along with a very wide variety of kids many of whom won't be "their tribe" and will have nothing at all in common with them.

MojoMoon · 08/03/2024 17:17

ilovebreadsauce · 08/03/2024 16:35

I feel that the student , there on the ground, has a much better idea of the reality of what is actually available, than you tapping away on your computer's search engine.
I see no reason why a person who enjoys playing social football , would lie about their experience??
Also if footie is his thing, why are you suggesting he should play mixed netball or go scuba diving as a substitute???

Because sometimes, particularly when you are suffering from depression and anxiety, it is much easier to make out that there is a unavoidable barrier to doing something (like playing social sports) than admit that you are feeling too sad or anxious to be able to seek it out, join in with strangers and interact with people.

It's not that they are lying maliciously about their uni. It's that sometimes their version of the truth is quite the reality.

For them, there are no social sports teams that they feel able to join. Maybe there is nothing in their immediate vicinity in halls or with people they already know participating? The idea of asking a bunch of strangers to join their social team in another department or hall might be too terrifying to contemplate. But saying that is also hard - easy to say there are no teams at all.

What they need is support in finding ways to be able to reach out and find their tribe - it might be via doing activities like scuba diving where almost everyone doing it at uni is new to the sport so all on equal footing.

If the important thing is finding their tribe rather than specifically playing football, doing new activities may be a better approach.

(Sorry @MrsAvocet for saying hockey was obscure. I've never met anyone who played it! Hopefully lacrosse works as a good example of the point I was making at least. )

AlohaRose · 08/03/2024 17:10

I don’t know why there is such a reluctance to identify the university on this thread. It’s not particularly helpful when the names of lots of other unis are being thrown around and people skimming will inevitably identify some of those uni clubs as being unwelcoming or inaccessible to non-elite sports people.

MrsAvocet · 08/03/2024 17:00

It probably is rare for there is be social teams in more obscure team sports like hockey or lacrosse? There probably aren't enough interested social players to sustain a social league so the uni will just have a first team.
Not the point of thread I know, but the "obscure" sport of hockey is the second largest BUCS team sport with over 550 teams competing across multiple leagues.My DS is a fairly serious hockey player and the hockey provision is something he's looked at in some detail during his research about which Universities to apply to.Far from having only a first team the majority of Universities will have several mens and womens teams competing in BUCS leagues and the best also play in the highest level club leagues. But there are frequently also less serious teams within Universities that play each other and/or lower level local club teams. If anything, it's one of the sports that is more likely to have a wide range of participants and there's lots of variations on the theme such as mixed hockey and walking hockey - it's generally a very inclusive sport.

ilovebreadsauce · 08/03/2024 16:35

MojoMoon · 08/03/2024 16:18

I am very sceptical indeed that there is no non-elite sport at the uni at all.

Quite normal and common for an intramural league in football and netball to exist between hall/uni departments etc. or any group that wants to join tbh.

Or for there to be things like touch rugby, ultimate Frisbee, mixed netball and non conventional team games being offered. Plus activities like scuba diving, sky diving, caving, hiking which aren't team sports but team activities.

It probably is rare for there is be social teams in more obscure team sports like hockey or lacrosse? There probably aren't enough interested social players to sustain a social league so the uni will just have a first team.

However if your young person simply doesn't want to join/doesn't feel able to join in anything, that is more the issue. It's a lot easier to tell your mum that there are no clubs to join rather than say "i can't/won't/don't want to join in"

I feel that the student , there on the ground, has a much better idea of the reality of what is actually available, than you tapping away on your computer's search engine.
I see no reason why a person who enjoys playing social football , would lie about their experience??
Also if footie is his thing, why are you suggesting he should play mixed netball or go scuba diving as a substitute???

MojoMoon · 08/03/2024 16:18

I am very sceptical indeed that there is no non-elite sport at the uni at all.

Quite normal and common for an intramural league in football and netball to exist between hall/uni departments etc. or any group that wants to join tbh.

Or for there to be things like touch rugby, ultimate Frisbee, mixed netball and non conventional team games being offered. Plus activities like scuba diving, sky diving, caving, hiking which aren't team sports but team activities.

It probably is rare for there is be social teams in more obscure team sports like hockey or lacrosse? There probably aren't enough interested social players to sustain a social league so the uni will just have a first team.

However if your young person simply doesn't want to join/doesn't feel able to join in anything, that is more the issue. It's a lot easier to tell your mum that there are no clubs to join rather than say "i can't/won't/don't want to join in"

genegeniusjeanjeanie · 08/03/2024 16:16

The very good uni I went to, albeit a very long time ago, had lots of social sport on offer alongside the teams for good player. I also find it odd that others wouldn't and agree it's an issue for the students union, not the university.

wombat15 · 08/03/2024 16:10

It is a shame that they don't have non competitive sports groups. They certainly did at the university I went to years ago and I think they still do. The society was divided into two for the sport itself with some of the competitive team Olympic standard. I was in the non competitive group so just for fun. Social events were together.

GinForBreakfast · 08/03/2024 16:04

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 14:34

The whole 'don't go to/stay on at university if your mental health isn't good' is discriminatory and illegal. Would the same be said for someone with impaired physical health? Would be same be said for staff employed there?

If DC with subpar mental health shouldn't go to/stay on at university because it's an adverse environment for them and universities should not have any duty of care, does that apply to staff too? Could it be said that a staff member with subpar mental health should not be working in a university because it is not a suitable environment and universities don't have any responsibility to staff members who have/develop mental health problems? No, that would also be illegal.
Universities should be places that all young people can attend, their mental health should be supported, and definitely it should be not worsened by their experience of university. So many students experience worsened mental health at university.

If increased opportunities for exercise, whether team-based or use of existing facilities, would help support mental health, why shouldn't a university as an organisation (not individual lecturers or course admin) ensure that these opportunities are available to all students?

btw the detail I picked up on is the Olympic-sized pool, only a couple of unis have these and only one is rated as a best university.

I fundamentally disagree with your post and it illustrates everything that is wrong with the system.

Everyone should have the opportunity to go to university, that's not even a question. But you need a certain set of skills - academic, social, life etc. to go. That's not because universities are "adverse environments", they are not. They are incredibly supportive. I wish you could sit in the meetings that I sit in that shows how staff are utterly dedicated to helping every student succeed. Some students need more support to succeed and that support is absolutely there. I'm talking about students with care experience, students with disabilities, older students etc.

However, universities are training programmes for professional careers. They are graded and ranked in part by the career outcomes of their students, so they are incentivised to get students ready for graduate level jobs. They will do this in part by setting expectations like meeting assignment deadlines, delivering presentations, working in teams.

If you can't deal with that then university is not for you. That's not discrimination in the same way as not employing me as a catwalk model is not discrimination. There are some people who are so smart they could pass an undergraduate degree at 13, they don't tend to go to university until later. Again, that's not age discrimination, it's a recognition that they are likely to have to develop other skills before they will succeed.

NewName24 · 08/03/2024 15:31

inkblackheart · 08/03/2024 14:38

The whole 'don't go to/stay on at university if your mental health isn't good' is discriminatory and illegal. Would the same be said for someone with impaired physical health? Would be same be said for staff employed there?

Actually it's very sensible advice. If your child is vulnerable it isn't a great idea to take away their entire support network and put them into an environment where they know nobody and are having to face all sorts of new challenges alone. Far better to take a gap year to try to address some of the mental health issues and then go when they are able to cope and less at risk of wasting the thousands and thousands of pounds in fees/living costs when they have to drop out.

Agreed.
University is something that some people choose to do. It is an 'opt in'.

What seems apparent to me is that you opt in to things that are going to enhance your life. It is a higher education which is optional, and in not for around 55-60% of 18 yr olds (happy to be corrected on this year's %, but you get the point).
Even if you choose to study a degree (and more of the population won't than will), you can do that without leaving home in various ways.

It's not discriminatory to offer optional things that not everyone is going to be able to access. I could never run a marathon, but it's not discriminatory for thousands of marathons to be organised up and down the country. It's just something that goes on that's not for me. If living away from home is not for you, then follow a path in life that means you don't have to live away from home.

NewName24 · 08/03/2024 15:24

Oblomov24 · 08/03/2024 04:08

I don't think there's any need to name the uni. As many other pp's have said OP is maybe deluded, entitled and naieve. This isn't a fault of the said un-named uni. It's OP's viewpoint.

What is the real issue here? Child very shy and not engaging? MH issues? Not being able to get onto the team for a super deluxe Uber sporty uni.

pp's have given solutions to all of he above.

But if you are still going to insist : x uni is rubbish. (zero information about the course, the teaching, the student uni life generally, the campus facilities, the catered accommodation) etc etc. solely based on : my kid can't get into the football team. Then quite frankly you'd be laughed out of court. As a fool.

If it's a different issue. Then please say. Mn is incredibly supportive for most issues.

Great post

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 15:03

@inkblackheart I see your point, but mental health conditions are not all temporary and transient, or even fixable. The same applies to physical disabilities and no-one expect people to take a year out and get better. They are supported and no-one thinks it's OK for the university environment to make their disabilities worse or for the student to be told that a university education/environment is not for them.

Many conditions are on-going and long-lasting, and people who have them should not be denied opportunities or held back. There are employers who pride themselves on being 'disability aware/positive', which includes mental health. But no such scheme/mentality exists for students paying to go to university, paying for university accommodation. It is seen as a 'you problem', as the yp apparently say these days.

The answer is not either do nothing or do everything. There is much that universities can and should do to ensure that their students don't suffer worse mental health due to their university experience, which from the perspective of the OP is to ensure that all students can use the advertised sports facilities in an user-friendly accessible and welcoming manner.

Cushionsandcaramel · 08/03/2024 14:41

I don't work at a uni but live in a city with more than one. I agree with PPS that local non uni sports might be a good option. There are park runs here and lots of opportunities to do other sports like 5 aside football.

I hope your young person can find something that suits.

inkblackheart · 08/03/2024 14:38

The whole 'don't go to/stay on at university if your mental health isn't good' is discriminatory and illegal. Would the same be said for someone with impaired physical health? Would be same be said for staff employed there?

Actually it's very sensible advice. If your child is vulnerable it isn't a great idea to take away their entire support network and put them into an environment where they know nobody and are having to face all sorts of new challenges alone. Far better to take a gap year to try to address some of the mental health issues and then go when they are able to cope and less at risk of wasting the thousands and thousands of pounds in fees/living costs when they have to drop out.

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 14:34

The whole 'don't go to/stay on at university if your mental health isn't good' is discriminatory and illegal. Would the same be said for someone with impaired physical health? Would be same be said for staff employed there?

If DC with subpar mental health shouldn't go to/stay on at university because it's an adverse environment for them and universities should not have any duty of care, does that apply to staff too? Could it be said that a staff member with subpar mental health should not be working in a university because it is not a suitable environment and universities don't have any responsibility to staff members who have/develop mental health problems? No, that would also be illegal.
Universities should be places that all young people can attend, their mental health should be supported, and definitely it should be not worsened by their experience of university. So many students experience worsened mental health at university.

If increased opportunities for exercise, whether team-based or use of existing facilities, would help support mental health, why shouldn't a university as an organisation (not individual lecturers or course admin) ensure that these opportunities are available to all students?

btw the detail I picked up on is the Olympic-sized pool, only a couple of unis have these and only one is rated as a best university.

itsnotallfunandgames · 08/03/2024 14:26

@missshilling my understanding is that OP means 'young person' by 'YP'

MotherOfDragonflies · 08/03/2024 14:16

march2 · 08/03/2024 13:09

However if I am right then Durham hardly sells itself on its sports. It's all about the academics with them.

Sorry, have to disagree, Durham's always been one of the big sporting unis, particularly for rugby and hockey. As I said upthread, there's also lots of social college sport for men and women.

I’m not saying they’re not sporty. I’m saying it isn’t their headline USP.