Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health support at Uni - social sports clubs would help not just for elite players

138 replies

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Neapolitanicecream · 10/03/2024 17:54

@TrouseredTed very enlighten post. It certainly puts things into perspective about uni life which I did not realise.
yes to other posters it is upto YP ultimately, but mumsnet is also shared wisdom for supporting YP as well.

And there alot invested

OP posts:
stormywhethers321 · 10/03/2024 13:45

I don't think a university can be reasonably expected to provide something like this.

This student wants a league for a particular sport at the exact right level for them. Maybe another student wants a film club that focuses the films of a certain director. A third student wants a gluten-free cooking club and a fourth wants a society that combines feminism and crafting. All of these things would be nice to have. They may be beneficial for the mental health of those who take part. But a uni cannot create a tailored program of extracurriculars to suit the wishes of each of its thousands of young people. It's not an elite summer camp.

Once people are at university, they need to take some responsibility for their own entertainment. In this case, it's going to mean either starting their own sports league at a level appropriate to them or joining in another activity that's more accessible. It may mot be exactly what they want, but it's not a bad idea to learn that wanting something doesn't necessarily mean you get it.

missshilling · 10/03/2024 12:44

Bath was 'Times university of the year' last year

This just shows how confusing all the various university ranking tables are. When I looked it was Anglia Ruskin in 2023. At least, that was in the Times Higher Education Awards.

itsnotallfunandgames · 10/03/2024 11:43

missshilling · 09/03/2024 14:59

I doubt that it's UEA

I must admit it sounds unlikely.

The only other “number one” uni boasting about an Olympic sized pool is Cambridge, and it hasn’t been built yet.

Bath was 'Times university of the year' last year, has a 50m pool, has a high-profile elite athlete programme (incl. swimming, triathlon). A lot of the facilities use will be prioritised for the competitive and Olympic athletes, the paying clubs in the local area, local elite sportspeople, paying customers etc.

Interestingly, it performed very badly on the Guardian student satisfaction during the lockdown/pandemic years (down in the rankings below number 50 on list), despite scoring highly in other respects and maybe has improved since then. There was also some bad publicity about how students joining in Sept. 2022 were still being taught mainly online, the course in the news was Economics, but it may have applied to others. It is also in a relatively isolated self-contained location, and first years on campus might feel little connection with the town, which would affect community involvement.

Of course, I may be wrong and maybe it's something less obviously 'top' which might include e.g. Surrey, which also has a 50m pool. It is less isolated, and the sports vibe is not as 'elite' imho.

Loneliness is not a problem to be minimised. People take it seriously when older people are affected, but not so much when younger people are affected. Severe loneliness can also aggravate social anxiety and make it even harder to get out and join in, which some people don't appreciate. It's hard when everyone else seems to have a big circle of friends and having a wonderful time. This is incredibly isolating. OP mentions a waiting list for counselling. There are other more immediate sources of help - telephone helplines and online chat can help. The uni will most likely have a support line run by students, which might feel more approachable. Then there is studentminds, youngminds, etc.

RedHelenB · 10/03/2024 10:14

Which uni? All this I know have " fun" sports clubs not just elite.

Oakbeam · 10/03/2024 10:09

it’s taken effort to go out and find other people - mainly through societies

I would have thought that they would meet people on the same course too.

ThePerfectDog · 10/03/2024 08:26

You’re right about the going out, because for each of those people there are hundreds of others like them. Societies are a brilliant way to connect with people, it’s worth saying that you don’t have to join at the beginning of the year, you can join at any point. Some people think they’ve missed the boat if they don’t join in September and they really haven’t

user73 · 10/03/2024 08:00

I simply meant there are more kids who go so a much wider type of personality.

anyway the overall point was that they might not immediately find people who are similar to them. In DCs first year corridor they have 2 overseas students who only socialise amongst themselves and speak little English, one older fourth year who doesn’t mix with the first years, one who DC would refer to as a “jock” very loud, very sporty spends a lot of time out with the footballers and comes back with mates and trashes the kitchen, one trans child with some very significant mental health issues who mainly wants to talk about the fact that they are trans and how persecuted they are, one who I think would be described as “emo” who is also a gamer and mainly stays in their room, one who goes home every single weekend, one who has a group of friends from school at the same university so mixes mainly with them.

it’s taken effort to go out and find other people - mainly through societies.

NewName24 · 09/03/2024 23:19

Agree @MrsAvocet

MrsAvocet · 09/03/2024 18:36

user73 · 09/03/2024 02:41

Ok well my Google from a new statesman article says that in the late 80s it was between 8 percent and 18 percent and it’s now 50 percent. Either way, far more kids now go and it’s unhelpful to continue the narrative that they will “find their tribe”.
Most will hopefully make new friends. Not everyone will and some people will get housed with others they have little in common with which can make life more challenging. They go with such massive expectation (which isn’t helped by social media) and this can make it even harder to settle. Lots of kids go and are quite lonely, particularly if they expected everything to automatically click into place for them.

I can't quite understand why the fact that more people go to University would make it harder to make friends? I was the in the first generation of my family to go to University in the early 1980s and both on my course and in my hall I was very much in the minority as an ex comprehensive school working class student. I felt distinctly out of place at first and would have been a lot happier if there had been a wider range of people to mix with.
I think that lots of people are trying to make the point that the idea that everything instantly falls into place is unrealistic and that most people do have to work at it, step outside their comfort zones and put effort into building relationships. Never mind sharing a flat with strangers in first year, as was common at my University at the time, I had to share a room with a complete stranger with whom I didn't have a lot in common. Very few people I knew hit it off instantly with their room mates but most learned to get along ok and had each other's backs after a while. But it took time and effort - nothing magic happened to make us best buddies then any more than it happens now.
Things have changed a lot since then it's true, but people are fundamentally the same surely? It seems highly unlikely that there is nobody at all at the OP's DC's University that would like to befriend them or that there are absolutely no activities in or out of the University that would interest them. Posters have made a variety of potentially helpful suggestions of things that the student could do to help themselves but the OP seems fixated on the idea that all this is the responsibility of the University. And ok, maybe they could do better, but students are to at least some degree masters of their own fate too.

inkblackheart · 09/03/2024 18:30

Trying to be practical can she join a different type of club if she’s insistent there are no sports options? How about one of the political societies or a crafting one or an environmental one or a film society or a music one etc. If it’s a top university it will have literally dozens and dozens of options. My friends dd chose her 5 potential universities based on whether they had a Taylor Swift society. Surprisingly most did!

NewName24 · 09/03/2024 15:28

my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV

This doesn't make sense.

As pps have pointed out - "Top" for what ?
A good marketing department can find an area that their University is 'top' for.
If you went out and asked the public at large which the 'top; universities are, people would generally list the most academic.
If you were looking for a "top" university for pastoral support of the students, then most of those Universities wouldn't feature in the list of "the most academic" universities.

Then what does this mean ?
A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV
Confused

When you look around, the University can tell you what clubs and societies are running that year, or that ran the previous year, but, clearly as that cohort of students move on, it will happen that some clubs close (as the enthusiasts that ran it graduate and leave) but there is no guarantee a particular club will run 2 years later. What you can do is ask the students there on the open day details about your particular interest, or about how many teams there are in a particular sport.

What are you talking about CVs for ?
An employer isn't really interested if you played dodgeball with your mates at University.
Of course, they might be interested in some of the skills you've gained in setting up and running a club / team - which all students are able to do.

Ponderingwindow · 09/03/2024 15:10

Not just sport

i played an instrument all through childhood. I was never going to be good enough to play professionally or even at the university level, but I still really enjoyed it.

when I went to a different university for my graduate degree, that school had an all-levels music program. We had a funded conductor and met once a week in small skill appropriate groups to play. We even had recitals It was a wonderful social activity and definitely good for mental health.

GinForBreakfast · 09/03/2024 15:08

Neapolitanicecream · 09/03/2024 13:14

Very interesting to note

that another thread today, also saying that young people are being prescribed exercise by Doctors for mental health issues and to also get them back to work.

Because exercise is so important for mental health,

you would expect this to be encouraged where there are alot of young people to help connect them ?

“to think the government are on a hiding to nothing with their drive to get people back to work? “

So many things contribute to mental wellbeing, including a good diet, sleep, reduced screen time, social connections, time in nature and laying off the drink and drugs. You are focused on sport because that's what your kid is aggrieved about.

Universities don't check that students are eating well. They're not checking up on their bedtime or the number of hours they're clocking up on snapchat. They're not bussing them out to the countryside on a Wednesday afternoon or patrolling the pubs and nightclubs reminding students that 4 or more drinks per day constitutes binge drinking.

We all know how to protect our MH. It's up to us to deal with it. I'm a swimmer and now there is no community pool in my town, it closed down two years ago. I don't wail on Mumsnet that the town should build me a pool, I go for a run or a walk instead.

I used to work in sports development so I am absolutely passionate about exercise and wellbeing, but you are just coming across as a slightly whiny, overly precious parent now.

missshilling · 09/03/2024 14:59

I doubt that it's UEA

I must admit it sounds unlikely.

The only other “number one” uni boasting about an Olympic sized pool is Cambridge, and it hasn’t been built yet.

Aviee · 09/03/2024 14:16

Exeter?

Zanatdy · 09/03/2024 13:42

My son’s uni (Warwick) has a society football league (probably does for other sports too) so the different societies play each other. He’s in the stats society and the Asian society. So you don’t need to be elite for these teams.

Neapolitanicecream · 09/03/2024 13:14

Very interesting to note

that another thread today, also saying that young people are being prescribed exercise by Doctors for mental health issues and to also get them back to work.

Because exercise is so important for mental health,

you would expect this to be encouraged where there are alot of young people to help connect them ?

“to think the government are on a hiding to nothing with their drive to get people back to work? “

OP posts:
TrishTrix · 09/03/2024 13:10

Surprised to hear of this situation. Non club sport was a big thing at my University. But you did need to have people to play with. And the ability to put yourself out and go along to matches/ practices the first few times.

I got a lot out of it and played hockey for two separate teams (academic and another sports society - the sailing club hockey team caused a lot of confusion over the years). Fortunately the two teams never met in a match! I also used to see quite a lot of other people I knew through other routes down at the pitches on a Sunday morning playing for the opposition. Academic grouping also participated in a national intra-university competition which was always fun. And boozy. We hosted in my final year and I accommodated something crazy like 6 players from one of the London universities in my flat.

However, this wouldn't help if you were a bit socially isolated as trying to find a team to join might be difficult. Especially for more minority sports that people aren't exposed to at school. Just had a look at my Universities website and they now do a "matching" service for teams so this is being addressed.

boys3 · 09/03/2024 12:46

@Seeline agree. 😀Have had a DC there at undergrad and now finishing off masters. Only mentioned it due to the 50m pool. I very much doubt it’s Aberdeen either or Brum.

another DC at another Uni, pool only 25m ☹️, where there seems to be plenty of social sport opportunity. Though he plays BUCS level at another sport, he enjoys casual footballl and there seems to be fairly regular 5 or 6 aside opportunities with varying groups of people, and where the final score really doesn’t matter. Then again he also has a beach literally on his door step for just fun kick abouts, frisbee etc with friends.

Seeline · 09/03/2024 12:30

I doubt that it's UEA - my DD is there and they seem very inclusive for sports and wellbeing. Taster sessions for most things at the beginning of each semester, sessions where different clubs invite other clubs for taster sessions, good support services, things like a wellbeing dog walk every fortnight, Try Something Different events for crafts and social things like pool and darts.
My DD is into dance and most of the dance firms run classes at beginner, intermediate and advanced levels. I've just looked at the mens football social media - trials for 12 teams including a development league at the start of the second semester.

My advice for anyone looking at unis where sports and social activities are important is to check the SM channels for the different clubs and societies. You can see which ones are active and what they offer.

GinForBreakfast · 09/03/2024 11:26

Also "university of the year" awards are pretty subjective and made up to sell newspapers. A bit like those "best beaches" articles.

boys3 · 09/03/2024 11:22

Pretty sure it’s not ARU, given the high league table ranking alluded to, and more specifically the presence of an Olympic sized swimming pool within the facilities. Which I’d interpret as a 50m pool. There are very few unis in the UK with a 50m pool in their sports centre. ARU does not have one. Loughborough does but has already been ruled out. I think Birmingham Uni has one, likewise the sportspark at UEA. One at Aberdeen Uni apparently. However I’m leaning more towards Bath. Then again Bath does seem to have a wider offering for social football.

missshilling · 09/03/2024 11:12

yes it was the uni of the year !!!! But what the hell for ????

Anglia Ruskin was voted “University of the Year” last year.

”Anglia Ruskin was named University of the Year in recognition of its role as a hub for skills and innovation in multiple centres across the east of England. The judges were particularly impressed by its development of a new Peterborough campus on an accelerated timetable in partnership with local authorities and industry.”

https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/times-higher-education-awards-2023-winners-announced

Times Higher Education Awards 2023: winners announced

Anglia Ruskin and Dame Nancy Rothwell take top prizes at ‘Oscars of higher education’

https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/times-higher-education-awards-2023-winners-announced

Soundofshuna · 09/03/2024 10:51

Neapolitanicecream · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hello all my YP is struggling with loneliness at a Uni that was considered top last year !!!! A lot of the clubs are on paper only so it looks good on someone CV 🤔

her cousin at a very sporty uni is thriving at a midlands uni renowned for sports, (so he thought he wouldn’t get into any clubs) but the uni have inter-houses social football…. Brilliant idea to support YP mental health.

please please so called top unis with amazing sports facilities please introduce social sports and not just for the elite

If she’s at Bath and it’s hockey Buccs is a great club. Based at the uni but a town club. Also team Bath AS for swimming likewise.