Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 11:57

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 10:37

Except you started a thread inciting exactly this debate??

But there’s no criticism, is there? There are some good things about home based childcare but I don’t think individual attention is one of them 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
saveforthat · 07/03/2024 11:55

MumHereAgain2023 · 07/03/2024 10:49

I prefer nursery. Not worried if staff are sick as they will still have your child. You aren't dictated holidays.

That's all about you, not what is best for child.

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 11:18

WhereIsMyLight · 07/03/2024 11:13

I had 3 childminders when I was growing up. The first two were homely experiences. The childminder had kids a similar age to me, we walked to school together and played together in the school holidays.

My final childminder when I was about 10 wasn’t a homely experience and I didn’t enjoy it to the point I don’t want a childminder for our DC. I was the oldest and she had a lot of toddlers so it was naturally more balanced to them. I had siblings on my dads side that were a baby and toddler so it wasn’t that age gap but I was expected to help more at the childminders with the little ones. I would help at my dad’s but I could also go to my room and play by myself, I had toys that were suited to my age. I didn’t have that at the childminders.

Ideally, you would pick a setting that works for the child and your values. However, realistically it comes down to what is available in your area and what you can afford. Then you hope your DC can adjust to that environment and it works well for them.

Tbf I don't know many childminders who have 10 year olds. Most go to holiday clubs by then.

Glassshouldbehalffull · 07/03/2024 11:16

Childminders can be amazing imo. I think the homely welcoming environment is part of the reason why my two did well before going to school.

WhereIsMyLight · 07/03/2024 11:13

I had 3 childminders when I was growing up. The first two were homely experiences. The childminder had kids a similar age to me, we walked to school together and played together in the school holidays.

My final childminder when I was about 10 wasn’t a homely experience and I didn’t enjoy it to the point I don’t want a childminder for our DC. I was the oldest and she had a lot of toddlers so it was naturally more balanced to them. I had siblings on my dads side that were a baby and toddler so it wasn’t that age gap but I was expected to help more at the childminders with the little ones. I would help at my dad’s but I could also go to my room and play by myself, I had toys that were suited to my age. I didn’t have that at the childminders.

Ideally, you would pick a setting that works for the child and your values. However, realistically it comes down to what is available in your area and what you can afford. Then you hope your DC can adjust to that environment and it works well for them.

Dotdashdottinghell · 07/03/2024 10:50

I think some CM settings are bit like small nurseries, there are helpers, multiple school runs etc, and it can feel less homely.

My gorgeous CM was with us 5 years and she was just amazing, she had 2 dc the same age as mine, and they were like cousins. They hit all their milestones together, they are 2 sets of best friends still, my children call the CM aunty and just bloody adore her. She treated my children like her own, or like nieces and nephews at least, they were always invited to her children's celebrations, and her children to mine. We exchange gifts, even have the odd glass of wine together.

It's about finding someone who matches your values and nurturing the relationship.

Thedance · 07/03/2024 10:49

It depends on the childminder but for a good childminder yes I think they do offer a more personalised and homely approach especially for babies.
Nurseries have a mixture of staff who change so the child won't necessarily have the same person caring for them all the time. Also understandably In a nursery different ages are in different rooms something that wouldn't happen at home where all ages mix . Personally I find nurseries to be much more institutionalised and the care a childminder provides to be more natural .
A good childminder will take children out as a parent would so they are part of the community mixing with different people and seeing different things.

MumHereAgain2023 · 07/03/2024 10:49

I prefer nursery. Not worried if staff are sick as they will still have your child. You aren't dictated holidays.

museumum · 07/03/2024 10:48

We used nursery but the childminder I saw every morning on the school run (walking) had 1-2 little children in the daytime and a gaggle of young primary school kids. That sounds quite “homely” to me.

ShesGotAHeartOfGold · 07/03/2024 10:47

Depends on the children and the circumstances massively, but having made the change from nursery to childminder we much prefer it, as do our kids, and it's cheaper. We have children of different aged (2-8) and they are now all in the same place rather than some at after school club and one at nursery.

Our childminder takes the bigger ones in the holidays for hardly any charge. They love it. Yes there's quite a lot of telly, screens, biscuits etc but they do lots of other things too and they are happy there and have a close bond with the childminder who clearly adores them.

89redballoons · 07/03/2024 10:45

It just depends on the CM and the nursery.

My DS1 goes to a nursery that takes children from the term after they turn 2 to just before school, they're not segregated by age into different rooms, and they all access the same activities just differently. It's been great for him, he has friends across the three year groups and his skills at things like drawing, writing, balancing, using cutlery have developed really well.

DS2 is still too young for the nursery and so he goes to a childminder who only has two other mindees, also in the 1-2 age bracket. She doesn't do any school runs. He is also doing really well in that setting. The activities they do are things like gardening, nature walks in the park, music sessions, crafts etc that again can be accessed by small children of a fairly wide range of ages and abilities.

Morewineplease10 · 07/03/2024 10:43

Hugely disagree based on my experience of our wonderful childminder but obviously it depends on the childminder and the nursery!

givemushypeasachance · 07/03/2024 10:41

Once kids hit three the ratio in a nursery is 1 adult to 8 children so good luck with individualised care with that! Maybe a slightly bigger childminder setup (where two childminders work together, often husband and wife or mother and daughter) or a smaller home-like nursery is the best compromise. But if there are 80 or 100 kids on-site at the same time like you can get with larger nurseries, and there are maybe a dozen babies in the baby room and several dozen children together in the pre-school room, it's clearly not going to be able to offer a home-based environment.

Talipesmum · 07/03/2024 10:40

Homely for a mixed age group isn’t the same as exactly right for a single child. It all depends on how the childminder manages it and the logistics.

We were happy for ours to take our kids on school runs when they were under 3’s because the school was a 5 minute walk away, and it was the school they were going to go to.

It was homely in that my 7 month old and my 2.5 year old were being looked after together, and when my 2.5 year old was old enough for school, his little brother would be there for drop off and collection, playing with other little ones in the playground as he waited.

They would come home full of excitement that one of the littler ones had just started walking, or had pronounced something in a cute way. They’d be all proud that they could help our CM push one handle of the pushchair to “help her with the little ones”.

When they got older, they could do their homework quietly in the next room while she got the little ones tea ready. They wouldn’t go if they were poorly, but they could curl up on a comfy familiar sofa and last the rest of the day out till we could get them. The same childminder looked after them from babies up till the end of junior school. That is what made it homely for us. They knew all about her older boys, her family etc.

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 10:37

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:06

To me, homely doesn’t literally mean in the home - it’s about a chilled, comfortable sort of environment.

If you know what you prefer, use it, no one is criticising your choice(s) (although you are criticising others, I wonder why it’s acceptable this way round?)

Except you started a thread inciting exactly this debate??

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 10:33

PuttingDownRoots · 07/03/2024 10:02

There's good childminders, so-so childminders, overwhelmed childminders and bad childminders
Good nurseries, so-so nurseries, overwhelmed nurseries and bad nurseries

Theres personal preference and what is more suited to an individual child.

There is no definitive answer over what is better. It might change at different ages.

I was put off childminders because of time spent in the car for example, for school runs... whereas the local nursery took them out for daily walks. Other childminders do the school run on foot, but that wasn't possible for the local one as the local school was a mile along a road with no footpath.
I also felt there was more individual attention with the 3:1 nursery ratio (for under 2s) than a childminder with a baby, two toddlers/preschoolers, plus the wrap around children. But personal preference.

Or even childminders that don't do school runs like me!

UsernamePain · 07/03/2024 10:27

I do think it varies on the childminder and the temperament of the child.
My daughter has always been overwhelmed in big groups and loud environments so I felt a childminder would suit her better.
I’m very lucky that the childminder we have is amazing- goes above and beyond for me and my family. She has 3 children per day, and they are all in the same year as my daughter so all trips and activities are age appropriate. I do appreciate that this is due to luck and timing though!

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:26

Moobz · 07/03/2024 10:19

What's the difference in 3:1 under 2s, and a baby + 2 toddlers? Isn't that the same?

I think if you have nine children and three members of staff that’s less pressure on one person than one person and three children even though ratios are the same.

OP posts:
Moobz · 07/03/2024 10:19

What's the difference in 3:1 under 2s, and a baby + 2 toddlers? Isn't that the same?

Mumof2teens79 · 07/03/2024 10:16

Homely yes
Individual no

I used (at various times, for logistical reasons)
3 different private day nurseries
A child minder - full time and also wrap around.
A school nursery class
And later after school club.

The nurseries were variable to be honest, but I felt my daughter got the best and most individualised care and 121 time at our first nursery.
The child minder was great, and she did have several children that ended up in the same school year group, and she had an assistant so they could split the group, so that probably helped but there is a degree of fitting in with that days plans.

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:07

I also felt there was more individual attention with the 3:1 nursery ratio (for under 2s) than a childminder with a baby, two toddlers/preschoolers

I guess this is my feeling which is why I’m not sure why childminders are automatically seen as superior to nurseries for this age group.

OP posts:
Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:06

saveforthat · 07/03/2024 09:43

Well you have said it's not homely but then just said it is like a home but not like paid child care. Well I know which I would prefer. Nurseries are a completely unnatural environment.

To me, homely doesn’t literally mean in the home - it’s about a chilled, comfortable sort of environment.

If you know what you prefer, use it, no one is criticising your choice(s) (although you are criticising others, I wonder why it’s acceptable this way round?)

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 07/03/2024 10:02

There's good childminders, so-so childminders, overwhelmed childminders and bad childminders
Good nurseries, so-so nurseries, overwhelmed nurseries and bad nurseries

Theres personal preference and what is more suited to an individual child.

There is no definitive answer over what is better. It might change at different ages.

I was put off childminders because of time spent in the car for example, for school runs... whereas the local nursery took them out for daily walks. Other childminders do the school run on foot, but that wasn't possible for the local one as the local school was a mile along a road with no footpath.
I also felt there was more individual attention with the 3:1 nursery ratio (for under 2s) than a childminder with a baby, two toddlers/preschoolers, plus the wrap around children. But personal preference.

saveforthat · 07/03/2024 09:43

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:37

I know, it’s the same in my own family! But I’m not paid childcare.

Well you have said it's not homely but then just said it is like a home but not like paid child care. Well I know which I would prefer. Nurseries are a completely unnatural environment.

Deadringer · 07/03/2024 09:43

I took the children when they were sick too if their parents were stuck, there were days when they just lay on me on the sofa, I know that's probably not the norm though, I could do it because I only looked after children from one family.