Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
Looneytune253 · 07/03/2024 13:19

It depends what you mean by individual attention. I'm a cm and I know the children inside out, I know if they're feeling under the weather, know exactly how they like to be soothed and I also get very close to the families so you know what is going on at home. If there's a stressful situation I can reassure and help the family and offer advice. I can be flexible around the child's daily mood. I can chat with a parent during the day to find out how their child slept as they've been a bit cranky and be a bit more flexible than a nursery if they're under the weather or have a temp, runny poo etc. Wouldn't get any of that with a nursery. Obv there are decent nursery staff out there but you certainly wouldn't get that level of individual care.

Thingamebobwotsit · 07/03/2024 13:18

We opted for Childminder for a home from home approach. Has been brilliant. Each child treated as an individual, older children and younger children mucking in with each other and learning to get along regardless of age or ability, individual food requirements dealt with... and easy transition into nursery, then school and then secondary school as they all knew each other having grown up with each other.

I wouldn't swap it for the world. It isn't nursery but it is certainly a lot better for those children who need a more nurturing environment

Meadowfinch · 07/03/2024 13:16

I can only comment on my childminder who had been a CM for 37 years, and a regional ofsted supervisor.

She was fab. usually had 5 children and always managed to have age appropriate activities for all of them, but she had obviously spent a lot of time developing mixed-age activities where each child could take part at their own level.

She also provided a very personal kind of care, knowing her children so well that she could adapt as necessary. She was the kindest person I have ever met, even keeping ds with her until 9pm once when I got stuck in London when there was a terror alert.

As a single mum I would not have managed without her. ♥

saveforthat · 07/03/2024 13:14

HighonCatnip · 07/03/2024 12:59

How is a parent needing the reliability of childcare so they can go to work to earn money to feed and clothe their child not what's best for the child? Think a little.

Yep, I've thought. Still think the same.

DancingintheSpoonlight · 07/03/2024 13:14

Our Childminder is fantastic so in our circumstances we’re very happy with our decision. She has 3 children at most at a time, is flexible for us, and is able to get out and about with them to days out and trips a lot. Fewer children at a time mean they all get activities that work for their age.

Swings and roundabouts, I suppose.

I love that when DS is there, the whole family treat him as one of them. I have built up a friendship with the person who cares for my child at a young age.

Autienotnautie · 07/03/2024 13:10

More so than it use to be due to having to do the same planning, reviewing, developing paperwork as nurseries and preschool. Not to mention policies and risk assessments. There's definitely less opportunity to be spontaneous

Children do typically get more opportunity to visit different environments - groups days out etc. whereas in nursery they are largely stuck in one place.

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 13:09

It depends on the childminder. My mum was a childminder for many years and it wasn't like you describe at all. She didn't have a mix of ages so any activities/outings were suitable for all the kids.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out

But that would also be the case if a child was at home with siblings! The parent of an 'under the weather' two-year-old can't drop everything for them to take it easy if they also have a baby and a four-year-old.

If they're so under the weather that they're not well enough to go out, they shouldn't be in childcare that day at all really. Most childminders won't look after a sick child, any more than a nursery will.

SalviaDivinorum · 07/03/2024 13:08

Mine went to a childminder as I wanted them to have care from more of a "mum" like figure in a homelike environment than a nursery could provide.

They both thrived and adored my childminder. It did them no harm to have to fit in with the daily routine of a household and it would be my preferred form of childcare even now.

nokidshere · 07/03/2024 13:02

You know the wrong childminders then, or you have unrealistic expectations of childcare.

I've worked in childcare for over 40 years. The last 25 of them at home childminding. The only type of childcare which gives individual care and bespoke experiences is a nanny. Otherwise 'group care' is always going to be less geared to individual needs.

I've always had a range of ages from birth to 15. Most children have come to me for their whole lives until they go to secondary education. I'm definitely more flexible than a nursery and I work 50 weeks a year. I can count on 2 hands the amount of times I've had to close unexpectedly in the past 25yrs. I cook all their meals, we all eat together at the table, there are activities for every age range. I've had plenty of children having a 'sofa day' because they are under the weather. I've had teens wandering up to mine for dinner after school then taking themselves home or hanging about for the company. When they were smaller we went to a few activities that we all chose and all enjoyed, or we went for walks and activities on our own.

They are nearly all at college or uni now, they are still friends with each other and my sons, I am still friends with their parents. The parents who have met here are also friends. The oldest child I looked after is now 27, still in touch, still comes round regularly and refers to me as his second mum. The youngest is in yr 9 and often comes for dinner after school and hangs around for a couple of hours.

In addition to childminding I help the parents. I take in parcels for them, I make appointments, help with homework, pick up prescriptions, take their children to routine appointments, feed the children a 2 course home cooked dinner and often give the parents some to take home for themselves. I am very happy to try and help make their working lives easier with less to do when they get home.

And I'm not unusual in my holistic approach to childcare, plenty of childminders do the same.

You have to find childcare that suits your child and your lifestyle. It doesn't actually matter what type of setting it is as long as it's the best for your child. I hate these posts slagging off 'all childminders' because they once saw a childminder doing something wrong.

A good childcare facility will allow your child to thrive and you to work without the worry of what your child is doing or how they are being cared for.

Mrsbeauxjingles · 07/03/2024 12:59

I have seen a lot of childminders in my area because I attended lots of groups with my son before he started nursery. I was seriously unimpressed.

Lazy, not watching what children were doing at playgroups, relying on other adults in the room to look out for them, and worst of all seeing a few of them roughly handling children or talking to them in a manner I would never talk to my child.

HighonCatnip · 07/03/2024 12:59

saveforthat · 07/03/2024 11:55

That's all about you, not what is best for child.

How is a parent needing the reliability of childcare so they can go to work to earn money to feed and clothe their child not what's best for the child? Think a little.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/03/2024 12:50

Really really depends- I had an amazing one when my son was under 2 but it was almost like having a much cheaper nanny as she had 2 school age children pre and post school plus my son ( from 5 months) and the other mum was a teacher , so she only had them in drive and drabs in holidays too. She totally adored him and treated him like her own- did more with him than I would have done in all honesty too - she was a 40 odd year old Spanish mum and weaned him too all on hand blended food!

However I've known friends have some not great ones who it seemed a bit like a battery farm with, not always that reliable too - and in those situations I would rather they were at nursery.

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 07/03/2024 12:45

My DC went to a childminder for a while. I liked how small-scale it was: just the lady and a few kids. The nurseries we looked round felt too big and I thought they might be overwhelming, although the facilities were way better.

It was a pain though, because when she was ill or one of her own children was ill she cancelled, which was a lot. So I think it is more family-like in the sense it is a smaller setting but a mixed blessing IMO.

hookiewookie29 · 07/03/2024 12:44

I'm a childminder of 24 years. I'm home from home- which means I don't set up activities for the children to do, I follow their interest and we do things accordingly. I'm not a nursery and I don't set my rooms up like one. We go with the flow,and I follow the childrens lead. We're busy all day, we have outings and school runs, however some days we may have more chilled days, with a film and popcorn.....all depends on the children. Any activities we do are adapted to each child's age and ability. A lot of children prefer my setting to a nursery because they don't like bigger groups of children and get more one to one care.

LBOCS2 · 07/03/2024 12:41

Fluffyc1ouds · 07/03/2024 12:22

Our childminder definitely offered a homely and relaxed experience for the kids in her care. They'd go off out to the beach, zoo, muddy walks, activity groups, etc but would also stay in her home baking, doing crafts, playing in the garden, etc. If a child was ill she'd tuck them up on a sofa with a blanket and the tv and give them lots of cuddles. Over the years as the children changed, grew up, etc I noticed she'd tailor the activities to the ages of the kids so none of them were ever bored or left out. I'm sure not every childminder is like her but she was absolutely amazing and felt like part of our family for those years.

Absolutely this. Our childminder only ever had two at home with her during the day and they were around the same age so she could do age appropriate things with them - playgroups, rhyme time etc but also things like walking to the postbox and posting a letter. She was friends with another childminder down the road so they'd occasionally all have play dates together.

My youngest, who was with her before starting school and then for wraparound care once she did, still misses her - we go and visit for a cup of tea during the holidays and there is still so much affection between them. The kids did get that down time after school if they needed it and they felt part of the family. If you get the right childminder for you it can be brilliant. I never cared about having their EYFS book filled in - I wanted them to be able to have a cuddle if they needed it, and feel like they were at home - with access to a climbing frame, and to help feed the chickens, and a sofa to chill out on if it had been a long day. That's what we got, in spades.

BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 12:39

I used to work in nurseries. I would not use nurseries.
There are good and not good childminders. But I think a good childminder is always the best option.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/03/2024 12:38

I used to see a brilliant childminder at a playgroup. I had a young baby and a toddler, and she helped me so much... for example in baby needed a feed, she would take my toddler off with her charges for the activities, and make sure she got snack at snack time. Or she would keep an eye on the baby toddler needed the toilet or so I could do an activity with the toddler. That woman was amazing. It was obvious her charges loved being with her.

HighonCatnip · 07/03/2024 12:34

Having seen childminders at our rhyme time groups... I would never, ever put my child in with a childminder when they're tiny. Maybe when they're bigger for a couple hours after school. But never when they're small.

The childminders I've seen really shocked me. Very little supervision of the kids, even when they're 18m old and on the top of a climbing frame with an open side. Shushing and shaming crying kids "come on now, enough of that, stop being a baby". Outright failing to even know where they are (the time when a little one, just started walking, had wandered away and was literally sat outside the building on the pavement chewing on a toy they'd picked up and left with, door was open as it was sunny, took a solid two minutes to find who'd brought them, anything could have happened). They tend to just sit on their phones or gossip with each other and ignore the kids. And that's in public. Goodness knows what happens in their homes.

Nursery might not be perfect, but at least there are more people around and more accountability, which I believe leads to higher standards.

I'm sure there are great ones, I came across one, but I wouldn't take the risk of someone caring for my kid in their home while having no idea what was going on. I'd have been heartbroken if my child was treated like the ones I saw with their childminder, week after week after week.

namechangedtemporarily123 · 07/03/2024 12:29

Not my experience. Sometimes there was a large group, sometimes just the childminder and DD. On days like those she met up with other childminder friends or took DD when she was out running errands, or doing things just for DD. I was fine with that, normal life, and the ability to tailor it to DD's specific needs. DD got to hang out with kids of all ages, and as a result is particularly good with little kids, like having siblings.

Fluffyc1ouds · 07/03/2024 12:22

Our childminder definitely offered a homely and relaxed experience for the kids in her care. They'd go off out to the beach, zoo, muddy walks, activity groups, etc but would also stay in her home baking, doing crafts, playing in the garden, etc. If a child was ill she'd tuck them up on a sofa with a blanket and the tv and give them lots of cuddles. Over the years as the children changed, grew up, etc I noticed she'd tailor the activities to the ages of the kids so none of them were ever bored or left out. I'm sure not every childminder is like her but she was absolutely amazing and felt like part of our family for those years.

Yourauntfanny · 07/03/2024 12:20

We chose a childminder rather than a nursery, our reasons below:

  1. we are lucky that we had some flexibility in both our jobs so although we need childcare, the odd day where she’s not available isn’t a problem (about 4 days a year)
  2. our child was cared for at home by his dad until he was 2.5, so we wanted a smooth transition and when we did a ‘hello session’ at nursery he was like a rabbit in headlights and totally overwhelmed and just looked like a little dot amongst the chaos. so we tried it but for him it wasn’t a good fit
  1. We felt given he is quite a quiet child, a nursery setting would be too busy and noisy for him, and he wouldn’t get the 121 adult attention he really enjoys and is used to.
  1. We chose a childminder who goes out into nature every single day, rain or shine and does a lot of walking/ exploring with the kids. This is something my disability disallows me from doing more often than not, so I like that he gets this time and he loves it.
  1. Our childminder has max 4 children at a time, our child is 3 and most of the children are between 2 and 4 and she does activities all of them can enjoy. So for example the older children might be drawing and using scissors while the younger ones finger paint, or when they’re out and about they all enjoy nature to different levels of understanding.

I will say though we chose our specific childminder based on her fit to our specific child. She had no space when we first enquired and we waited about 6 months for a place before DH could go back to work and he went back the days that worked around childminder days so this is an incredibly privileged position to be in with regards to childcare arrangements and won’t work for everyone.

MichaelAndEagle · 07/03/2024 12:20

Talipesmum · 07/03/2024 10:40

Homely for a mixed age group isn’t the same as exactly right for a single child. It all depends on how the childminder manages it and the logistics.

We were happy for ours to take our kids on school runs when they were under 3’s because the school was a 5 minute walk away, and it was the school they were going to go to.

It was homely in that my 7 month old and my 2.5 year old were being looked after together, and when my 2.5 year old was old enough for school, his little brother would be there for drop off and collection, playing with other little ones in the playground as he waited.

They would come home full of excitement that one of the littler ones had just started walking, or had pronounced something in a cute way. They’d be all proud that they could help our CM push one handle of the pushchair to “help her with the little ones”.

When they got older, they could do their homework quietly in the next room while she got the little ones tea ready. They wouldn’t go if they were poorly, but they could curl up on a comfy familiar sofa and last the rest of the day out till we could get them. The same childminder looked after them from babies up till the end of junior school. That is what made it homely for us. They knew all about her older boys, her family etc.

This is ideal, and I feel really lucky my children experienced that type of setting too.

Stompythedinosaur · 07/03/2024 12:19

My childminder was honestly a home away from home for my dc.

It was a family experience, but a family with multiple dc to balance the needs of. You'd be foolish to expect the experience of a family with a solo dc, and if you want that you need a nanny.

KomodoOhno · 07/03/2024 12:14

A family member of mine was a childminder. She had about 5 kids at a time. It was very homey and loving. When she passed away about 20 different adults spoke who had been kids she took care of thanking her for helping to raise them

nevergetusedtoit · 07/03/2024 12:04

Overthebow · 07/03/2024 09:34

I agree, one of the reasons we prefer nursery is that the rooms are tailored completely for their age group and all the activities too. A childminders with a range of ages can’t do that.

I completely disagree that this is better.

It is absolutely of benefit to children to be in mixed age groups. Its how humans evolved to do childhood after all! Younger ones and older ones benefit from this. Younger ones from learning how older ones behave and do things, older ones learn how to explain things to younger ones and how to be supportive and caring. It also means siblings can be together if they want to and this is obviously of huge benefit to their relationship.

Good nurseries are completely capable of providing a rich and engaging environment for all ages. MY children went to one. Children of all ages ( babies to five years) had access to the whole nursery and outdoor space. They all played together.

Nurseries where children get 'bored' in their age room and need to be moved up are actually evidence, in my view, of the failure of the nursery to provide a rich and stimulating environment, and a failure of the concept of 'age segregating' rooms. Children should not need adults to endlessly supply them with ' activities' for their age. The nursery should provide a rich environment where children can engage themselves, and then follow the lead of where children's interests are showing.

That's how a child centred approach works.