Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 08/03/2024 06:22

I think it depends on what parents value as to which suit them better.

For me the following were important

  1. We have no family nearby and needed reliable childcare. Our nursery was open every day except bank holidays and the week between Christmas and New Year. And it had been running for years and had staff who had been there a long time. My kids went there from age 9 months to 11 years (the nursery did wrap around care for primary school) and there were many members of staff who were there the whole time.

In comparison childminders have their own holidays so you have to fit round those. They also don't always do the job for a long time, socially I know people who have done childminding for a few years while their kids were small then stopped when they got older.

  1. I wasn't bothered about a homely environment, they were at home with me and DH for 4 days a week and got that then. At nursery they mixed with other children, did loads of different age appropriate activities, had access to a gorgeous big child friendly garden with a big climbing frame, sand pit, water play, veg patch, tarmaced area that could be played on throughout the year etc etc. The babies had their own section of garden. They were outside most of the time and played traditional group games like 'What's the Time Mr Wolf' and 'I sent a letter to my love'. They did day trips to the local theatre and library. It was an excellent nursery (it was graded outstanding by Ofsted while my kids were there) and they were able to provide a range of activities that could stretch the more able kids, several of the staff were qualified teachers. For me the professionalism of the staff and the number of staff with different strengths was the important thing. A single childminder would struggle to provide such an enriched environment.

Nurseries and childminders obviously do vary and it's up to parents to choose the childcare that meets their needs. Both have features that will appeal to some parents more than others.

YenSon · 08/03/2024 05:17

I adored my childminder. I did put my eldest (an end of July summer born) in a school nursery at 3 because I could as was in Mat leave, but I kept my youngest with the childminder until he almost 5. I loved that he went to playgroup 3 mornings a week, that he went to the supermarket and ran errands, visited her grandma in the old people’s home, went to her children’s class assemblies and dental appointments, the farm, library, MOT, other childminder’s settings for celebrations like Polish Christmas. There were a couple of other children a similar age on various days and my sons adored her. My eldest still talks about his time with her and has written to her. He was with her for almost 4 years minus the school holidays. She looked after him with a broken leg and chicken pox. I was a reception class teacher and Early Years lead and he got everything he needed and more from her. It was right for him and my circumstances and aligned with my views. You need to do what’s right for you and your children.

Moreteaandchocolate · 08/03/2024 05:03

We use a nanny - much more homely (actually in our own home) and tailored completely to my own children’s needs (it’s cheaper too for 2 or 3 children).

Asher09 · 08/03/2024 00:14

For a small period of time my DD went to nursery 2 days and childminder other 2 days. DD loved both but they definitely provided 2 different types of experiences for her.

I was always under the impression that childminders gave a more tailored education and care for the child because of the group size... but I didnt find that to be the case. Though childminder took really good care of her, the 'curriculum' was very repetitive and basic. She wasn't really learning or doing anything new, a lot of that was coming from nursery. Though the childminder had a smaller group, there were varied ages, which meant acitivies were catered to all but at nursery shes in her own age group and is being taught accordingly. I also didn't really get that whole 'homely' feel but maybe that was just my childminder.

I think it really depends on the child and what their needs are.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/03/2024 00:05

There’s no simple direct comparison imo.

A childminder with a small number of mindees can be a much more homely environment than a large nursery with a high staff turnover.

Equally a struggling childminder with a difficult mix of ages will be less homely than a well staffed nursery who can devote time to each child.

Childcare settings vary one by one.

TeenLifeMum · 07/03/2024 23:57

Depends. Dd1 hated nursery and totally changed personality. We moved her to a cm 4 weeks later and she was back to her normal self. Cm had her own dc who was a year older and looked after dd and another dc the same age. Very homely and lovely. Some cms run things more like nurseries and some are awful.

bibbidiblobidyboo · 07/03/2024 23:50

My childminder is an extension of our family. My girls love her and she loves them. I would be completely lost without her. She used to take them to various groups when they were little. During lockdown she used to let my girls walk her dog with her. I could get some work done, they saw her and the dog.
She has driven them to dancing exams during the day and all sorts. We are very lucky to have her around!

user1492757084 · 07/03/2024 23:30

Homely, yes. Family like, yes.
Individual experience, not necessarily any different to nurseries.
The biggest difference is that often children play with, and have to consider the needs of, a broader range of ages.

Sometimes they play the big sister, sometimes they are the little one and sometimes they see child minder's husband coming in for lunch etc. The set up is familiar but can offer surprises.

Activities are usually there to meet individual development levels. Kids hone a skill by teaching it to others so them choosing to play with a younger child, a game they liked years ago, is healthy.

Nurseries can offer continuity if the child minder is ill or has to attend a funeral etc. Do many child carers have backup, qualified carers to step in?

Whereisthesun99 · 07/03/2024 23:29

When I was a childminder, all my mindees were treated as family, I never maxed out on numbers the only school run was for my own children. We went out to various groups each week and meet up with other childminders daily. If I knew someone in their group was poorly I did not meet them as I did not want to get it plus did not want to expose my little ones to it either. All activities were based upon their interests. But if they were poorly and just wanted to sleep/ sit on the sofa all day then my stance was they were not well enough to attend so would need to stay at home. My policy’s stated they had to well enough to take part in day’s activities, I would not cancel my plans because xxxxx was not up to it / felt unwell as it would be unfair on the other little ones who would be looking forward to the activities to just cancel as xx was poorly.

Stopmotion24 · 07/03/2024 23:28

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:26

I think if you have nine children and three members of staff that’s less pressure on one person than one person and three children even though ratios are the same.

I agree, I felt more comfortable knowing there was a team of staff and they would not be going out and about in the car and also worried about being stuck if child minder was off sick or had an emergency. But the one I visited seemed lovely, apart from I wasn’t convinced by the setup of cots for naps but as many have said, it comes down to personal preference and circumstances. I don’t notice a perception of one being superior apart from a few parents that I’ve heard talk about them as if they were, but a small minority.

StaringAtTheWater · 07/03/2024 23:14

Our childminder was really good. She only took children for whole days, so no school runs to do, and all the children were under 4. Originally we had signed my son up at a local nursery, but he was a really slow crawler & walker - by the time I went back to work more than a year after his birth, he was still only commando crawling on his tummy. I was worried he would be stepped on in a busy nursery with lots of kids running around! 😂Childminder was definitely the right decision for him.

itsnotallfunandgames · 07/03/2024 23:13

My childminder looked after my DC while also looking after her own kids, so my DC fitted in with what she was doing for her family, or when her own kids needed more attention DC was in a playpen, being the youngest. My DC got ill when her DC were off school with illness. Not a great setup tbh, despite the childminder being very good and well-meaning. She got annoyed if she found out I'd popped out to the shops or an exercise class during the day while DC was with her (I was paying her in a professional capacity, she wasn't doing me a favour).
Nursery was much better. DC got more attention, even with lots of other children around because the staff weren't looking after their own kids and didn't have to ferry other kids around. The sessions were more educational, probably subject to early years guidance/curriculum. Monkey magic etc came to the nursery so DC didn't miss out on those things. Obviously nursery cost more. So it depends what you want.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 07/03/2024 22:59

I think it depends on the child, my dd was easily overwhelmed as a baby and I felt a nursery environment would be too full on for her.

She went to a childminder from 7 months and it worked really well, she was happy going, her routine stayed much the same and it was the right mix of going out to activities and being at home playing or napping!

From 3yo she went to nursery and was ready for it then.

TheTwirlyPoos · 07/03/2024 22:39

Loved our childminder so much. She was brilliant. We were very lucky that she didn't need to max out her ratio so she never had more than three. I never felt he was doing things too old or too young for his age, cooking was amazing, his relationship with her own older children... I always felt relaxed and happy leaving him. A nursery didn't fit what we wanted for our child.

NuffSaidSam · 07/03/2024 22:35

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 11:57

But there’s no criticism, is there? There are some good things about home based childcare but I don’t think individual attention is one of them 🤷‍♀️

You're not going to get 100% individual attention unless you have a nanny per child.

A childminder can generally offer more individualised attention than a nursery, but obviously not completely individual attention which would only be available in a setting where the ratio is 1:1.

NuffSaidSam · 07/03/2024 22:28

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

More homely and individual than what?

Than a nursery? Yes, a childminder is more homely and individual than a nursery (generally speaking).

Than a nanny? No, a childminder is not more homely and individual.

Overloadimplode · 07/03/2024 22:28

That is exactly what you describe though. A home from home experience means fitting in with the family. I loved the fact mine had to walk along to the school run when they were tiny. The childminder knew them all individually. It wasn't like nursery at all. It was much more like being with siblings of different ages at home. It was good for them, in my opinion.

Muddyfun62 · 07/03/2024 22:24

I disagree, we love our childminder, she is amazing when she does activites she provides for all age groups, she is very flexible and it's definitely like a home from home. She takes them to restaurants, national trusts, nursing homes, farms, zoos, shops and community events/groups.

We went with her after a bad experience with a nursery.

Our nursey never let a child sleep/chill on a sofa if they were not themselves they would just send them home.

Our childminder offers a holistic approach, baby wears and excepts reusable nappies. She also recently received outstanding on her recent inspection.

I would be without her and she has a long waiting list, so others obviously think the same.

Thekidsarealright2 · 07/03/2024 21:56

Depends what you want out of a childminder. I used one because I wanted my kids to go to groups, have fun days out and enjoy the nice homely feel while i was at work. They were always crafting, playing outside and doing messy play. They started preschool at 3 to get all the educational bits, i would rather they had some lovely experiences before they’re plunged into the world of education for the next 15 years.

Beachywave · 07/03/2024 21:55

Completely depends on the minder - my son’s childminder was the absolute best, she was like a second mum to him and a big sister to me… she didn’t go to any toddler groups, every day was either at home or occasionally park/coffee shop.

My youngest is now in nursery and although they’re great, it’s not a second home for him at all, more like a school for toddlers.

BenefitWaffle · 07/03/2024 14:20

@Eatingmybiscuits I would not be keen on kids watching TV, but plenty of nurseries do this too. I would be fine with popcorn though.
If there are enough childminders in your area though, you can choose someone who is closer to how you want to parent.
So I hate the over involved parenting that does not leave children to play without constantly being followed about and interacted with. I do not think it is good for children. I would not want a childminder that does this, and nurseries never will as they can't.

Caravaggiouch · 07/03/2024 14:13

I suppose it’s more homely in the sense that they do day to day stuff like the school run twice a day. But I agree, much preferred nursery where they could do activities tailored to their own age group. Different things suit different people.

bombastix · 07/03/2024 13:24

I had a terrific childminder. She used to run a trading floor in the City. Extraordinary woman and she made a wonderful place for the children she cared for. It was better than a nursery, imo.

audweb · 07/03/2024 13:21

Mine did. She was amazing, and years on we still maintain a close friendship with her. She juggled the kids needs like you would in a family of children, and my child adored her and loved spending time there. She was reliable, and great with the children. It's possible, and I would have chosen her over a nursery anytime. It was the best experience of early years child care for us, so it's possible to do.

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 13:20

HighonCatnip · 07/03/2024 12:59

How is a parent needing the reliability of childcare so they can go to work to earn money to feed and clothe their child not what's best for the child? Think a little.

MN childminders put me off using them. They always insist they are amazing and fabulous. So much better than those nasty nurseries.

Like the above childminder who has ‘chilled days with films and popcorn’ - sounds lovely doesn’t it? Until someone chokes on the popcorn and you rephrase it as kids stuck in front of the TV all afternoon.

OP posts: