Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
TheTwirlyPoos · 08/03/2024 21:38

Why are people so angry so much of the time?!

Our CM wasnt mythical. She did exactly as you so bizarrely describe but was a living, real person.

Her husband clearly earnt a decent wage so she didn't need to max out.

And obviously they charge less than nurseries, the overheads are somewhat different...

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:32

It’s amazing how all the childminders on MN only take 3 under 4s and no other children, spend all their time on wholesome outings and yet charge less than nurseries.

Yet all the childminders I’ve ever met in real life spend their days ignoring the children in the playground/soft play/toddler group and dragging the little ones on the school run twice a day because they make up the numbers with a load more older ones in the morning and at after school time. If I could have found one of these mythical childminders who are like a surrogate granny yet only charge 6 and ha’penny I’d have used one.

Luckyross · 08/03/2024 20:50

whay our health visitor in area says is newborn to 2 is good for a childminder as its nurturing froM 2 or 2.5 nursery is good as more children to “talk” to to learn speech. I don’t agree completely but I get where she is coming from but I’ve had a couple since 6m old and they’re all good talkers only some have been referred for speech and lang and again we do all that too we’re no diff to a nursery other than less of us. I work alone but hoping to get an assistant as so busy. My setting is a lot of outdoor play we are lucky to have a large garden and a lot of messy play and being kids I’m big on letting them be free wild and curious!

Luckyross · 08/03/2024 20:44

Agree with some of these too! I went to look round a nursery for my daughter I was gonna do an apprenticeship with one and decided not to as it was horrendous! The manager of the place even asked me when I set up as a childminder if I would be taking on as she wanted to leave 😂 I don’t think nurseries are any better I wouldn’t send mine. I had one leave me to go to our outstanding nursery and he couldn’t feed himself was severely autistic and she thought it was better as more kids to socialise and they wouldn’t feed him so he didn’t feed himself because they couldn and didn’t have the time to. She asked to come back and I filled space! I used childminders for my own children and wouldn’t change it.

Luckyross · 08/03/2024 20:39

I am a childminder and I go to our playgrounds in the area etc. how I get work alot of the time. We can only have 6 under 8 and usually only 4 max under 5 so it’s more personal. It depends what you want. I’ve had parents come to me as they don’t want a nursery as they’ve been to them and they’re too busy and feel like their child will get lost. It’s whatever you want and I think with this new funding alot of people gonna struggle to find places so may be stuck with something you don’t want I’ve had 8 enquiries for 2/3 year olds in last week as nurseries are full!

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 16:41

I agree the age rooms in nurseries are to make it easier for the nursery and staff. Nothing else.

jannier · 08/03/2024 16:33

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:26

I think if you have nine children and three members of staff that’s less pressure on one person than one person and three children even though ratios are the same.

In nursery the 2 plus ratio is 1 in England

jannier · 08/03/2024 16:30

Overthebow · 07/03/2024 09:34

I agree, one of the reasons we prefer nursery is that the rooms are tailored completely for their age group and all the activities too. A childminders with a range of ages can’t do that.

Rooms tailored to age do not meet the developmental needs of all the children the problem with the nursery room is some get held back from experience they are more than ready for. Language development isn't as good on the whole either as they are not exposed to as much variety. The room idea is about ratios and ease for staff not children's needs.

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 16:22

@BestBadger sorry I just read the article.
I agree early years education is not focused on what is best for children.

BestBadger · 08/03/2024 16:19

@BenefitWaffle

There were at least 3 pieces of research in what I posted and countless more available elsewhere. They're not clear cut at all.

I remember one which stated, up until three, in terms of child development it was in order of Mum, other parent/carer, childminder then nursery. But they don't all measure the same things or give the same weight to the same things. I can't find anything which shows anything other than moderate differences anyway, although I'd think there are some.

I remain unconvinced that early years (or later) education/care is really focused on what's best for the child anyway, rather than how we can service the economy. If it were surely we'd have professional childminders on a professional wage.

Pineapples198 · 08/03/2024 16:10

I disagree. I used to be a childminder. I had maximum 4 children a day, usually 3. I looked after babies to pre school so all around the same age. It is more individual as with 3 children we get to know them much better. Speech and language development is generally better as we are talking to 3 children all day instead of 30 children playing independently. Needs are better met as there is only 3. A clingy baby can be carried in a sling. A toddler who likes sand can have sand in the corner. A nursery isn’t going to change their routine for a poorly child anymore than a childminder is. A poorly child should be at home. The children in my care went on different visits and experiences instead of being in one room all week. They helped me look after my pets, we went on public transport, to museums, outdoor parks and special trips, to see Santa. We had a wonderful close relationship with every child we cared for.

It’s fine to prefer a nursery - everyone is entitled to prefer one or the other. But childminders are a good and flexible option

TheBumblebeebuzzing · 08/03/2024 14:44

Childminders have 3 children to 1 adult under 5
Nurseries have
3 under 1s
5 under 2s
8 under 5s per adult
13 under 5s if a registered teacher is working
Much smaller setting with a childminder

MummyJ36 · 08/03/2024 13:26

My old childminder used to encourage all
parents to send their kids to nursery once they hit 3. My daughter found the transition to nursery hard however it set her up so well for school I’m always glad I did it.

My DC2 initially attended a nursery from 1 year and has ended up leaving and going to a childminder and he is so much happier. We’ll re-look at childcare again when he’s 3 but a good childminder is worth more than any good nursery for children under 3 (in my opinion).

BertieBotts · 08/03/2024 12:45

Actually I agree with a PP that I think you're thinking of the experience an only child would have when you're thinking "homely".

I always thought it was a bit sad and artificial for the first child because what they really want to do at that age is understand the world and it's much more rich and interesting for them to be out and about and doing normal everyday things. To the point that the activities for babies that replace that have to be so much more stimulating to make up for it. But I think I'm in a minority here.

BertieBotts · 08/03/2024 12:41

I think your definition of homely is a bit different to the one people are thinking of when they say this - you are thinking about it being more tailored to the child, which is closer to a nursery setting really which will have set ups for each age range, or a nanny who is caring for the child in the child's home.

When I think of a childminder being more homely, I'm thinking big busy family with children of different ages, everyday sorts of activities like school run or going to the shops, playing at home in the garden, there might be pets around maybe. It's a bit less formal so you won't have as much documentation and procedures, you might get things that happen which are totally down to the CM's discretion rather than a set policy.

I really valued that and liked it better than nursery but did use nursery for my younger two DC, mainly because we are now living abroad and I wasn't confident in my ability to communicate, so set procedures etc was more reassuring.

May487 · 08/03/2024 12:35

I have worked in nurseries. Very good ones are few and far between. Many are average. Quite a lot are downright bad, not somewhere I’d ever want to send my own under 2.5yo. Many early years practitioners would say the same.

If you can find a decent childminder you are on to a winner! Much better set up.

BenefitWaffle · 08/03/2024 12:32

@BestBadger that research is based on asking parents if their children have developed certain skills such as cutting up paper, and then talks about the benefits of various activities that nurseries often do.
Children from about 3 need to be around other children. And children need to develop physical skills and other skills. But the conclusion this means children are better off at nursery is not true.
It is true where parents are neglectful or overwhelmed then nurseries are often recommended for children.
For under 2.5/3 the research shows a good childminder is better.

I also wonder if the not so good childminders are the ones going to every parents and toddler group every day as it is easier?

Sturnidae · 08/03/2024 11:54

It depends massively on the minder IMO. I went to groups with my lot but did a lot of other bits depending on the day/kids/individual needs. The minder I used for mine when I relocated and switched jobs was amazing and didn't attend any groups, they were mostly out in the community, hanging out with other minders out and about and being in nature most of the time. But I wouldn't have used the minders I knew when I was minding as the vast majority of them just went to the same toddler groups 5 days a week, morning and afternoon before going on the school run and heading to their houses.

OnceinaMinion · 08/03/2024 11:42

I was put off childminders when I was on maternity as well, some were okay but some were awful. I had a friend who was a CM for a few years, she was extremely popular and had a big waiting list. She disliked the children enormously. Im sure the same could be true in a nursery, it was just knowing it.

I did use a CM for wrap round for the last few years of primary. DD hated it because of the small ones and endless baby films and she couldn’t get away from them. She was great in lots of ways but she never ever took the children anywhere apart from the school run. She did do flexible care for a nurse including overnights which was nice.

She also really pushed for you to pick children up early, I had aimed to get DD early once but there was a major crash and it took me hours and hours to get there and I got there at 6 on the dot and she was very unhappy because she wanted her ‘weekend to start’. Nursery wouldn’t have had an issue - you pay for the time it’s yours!
I also left DD there late when I was painting her room and she was rude about that too. Luckily we left shortly afterwards

seasaltbarbie · 08/03/2024 11:22

I wouldn’t go to a childminder, I go to playgroup and the childminders there are really not nice, I hear them gossiping and talking about kids mums, also not very patient with the children. Out of 4 or 5 of them that go to the playgroup there is only 1 lady who I would trust, she’s lovely and you can tell how good she is at her job. I can’t believe the others, they sit on their arse drinking tea with poison oozing out their pours. Honestly just not nice people. All middle aged woman who just seem fed up of their jobs.

Passivelypresent · 08/03/2024 10:04

I think it all depends on your opinion.
I'm a childminder. I offer home from home care. Yes, sometimes the points you raise around activities not being solely for the age is correct but generally we only have 2-4 children a day and most of them are between 9 months and 3 turning four.

Personally I design my week with certain days I've got bigger kids we go to a soft play, if I've got mainly smaller ones we might go to a role play center. We go out every day and there's always a way to include everyone.

I don't take poorly children probably on similar guidelines to a nursery but I'm probably less strict around temperatures, teething and general low level unwell than a lot of the nurseries I know locally.

The plus points are I know my children inside and out, I know their behaviour, their way of communicating, they see me as an aunty. I get face times and phone calls when they aren't with me to show me things they're doing, calls from parents for advice late at night if something is wrong, we become a little community and form strong bonds that stay long after the child has left me. In my opinion it's so much more than the activities and education side, and that's the main difference to me.

And I'm much cheaper than my local day nurseries 🤣

BusseyH · 08/03/2024 09:10

I have been a childminder for 20 years and I can absolutely confirm that for very young babies and children, we are the perfect choice of childcare for families.
Smaller ratios, out and about every day at group sessions, community events and activities, woodlands, parks, local places of interest, our allotment, visiting residents of a local care home, forest school activities etc, close working relationships with families so that each child has the best individual care based on their interests and age and stage. We follow the same curriculum as nurseries and preschools, have professional training, are sometimes more qualified than nursery nurses and many are mothers ourselves so have added experience of understanding child development. We are key adults in the children’s lives, providing a constant for them, not ever changing key workers. We are able to offer a home from home environment which is cosier, more relaxed, less busy and chaotic and much more condusive to allowing the children to learn through play and prepare the them to be lifelong learners at school and beyond.
They will have plenty of years within a classroom environment when they go into the education system. Childminders can offer an extension to home for little people and with much more ability to manage the children in smaller groups.
I could go on and on, but hopefully you get the jist! 😁
I have to say that I am very lucky that in my area, we have a very strong childminding group and so I have access to all of the activities that we organise for the children, meeting up with at least one other childminder every day so that the children are able to form social circles of friends in larger groups and I have support when needed.

Underestimated4 · 08/03/2024 08:57

I’ve done both and now my girls are at school I see no difference in there learning to any other children.

Their happiness and if they enjoy going somewhere is more important.

pumpkinpiee · 08/03/2024 08:34

HighonCatnip · 07/03/2024 12:34

Having seen childminders at our rhyme time groups... I would never, ever put my child in with a childminder when they're tiny. Maybe when they're bigger for a couple hours after school. But never when they're small.

The childminders I've seen really shocked me. Very little supervision of the kids, even when they're 18m old and on the top of a climbing frame with an open side. Shushing and shaming crying kids "come on now, enough of that, stop being a baby". Outright failing to even know where they are (the time when a little one, just started walking, had wandered away and was literally sat outside the building on the pavement chewing on a toy they'd picked up and left with, door was open as it was sunny, took a solid two minutes to find who'd brought them, anything could have happened). They tend to just sit on their phones or gossip with each other and ignore the kids. And that's in public. Goodness knows what happens in their homes.

Nursery might not be perfect, but at least there are more people around and more accountability, which I believe leads to higher standards.

I'm sure there are great ones, I came across one, but I wouldn't take the risk of someone caring for my kid in their home while having no idea what was going on. I'd have been heartbroken if my child was treated like the ones I saw with their childminder, week after week after week.

Completely agree! Most childminders I’ve seen out and about at rhyme time/soft play have been like this. It’s worrying that this is how they are happy to be in public! I dread to think how some of the ones I’ve witnessed speak to children in their own homes. Last week at rhyme time I witnessed a childminder shouting (at no one in particular) for someone to watch three of their children (all 2+) whilst she changed one of the children’s nappy. Nobody responded (as we were all looking after our own children - I did signpost her to a member of staff to help) and she left them unattended in the soft play area anyway!! One 3 year old dived headfirst, shoes on, into the baby ballpit where under 1s were playing.

That’s not to say you can’t get good childminders but I do feel like there is more accountability at nurseries. I would only personally use a childminder if I knew them myself or they came from a close family/friend recommendation.