Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 09/03/2024 08:37

Horses for courses. I just think you choose what suits you. There are lovely nurseries and bad ones same as childminders. Personally didn't want my child being dragged out to playgroups. They did the odd trip out at nursery but it was big enough that dc had nice variety in one place.

My suspicion is childminders will often feed slightly more wholesome food rather than the mass catering the bigger nursery groups manage but it's not a big deal.

AmusedMaker · 09/03/2024 08:25

A really good childminder is the best form of formal childcare for under 3’s - a nursery is just the bland middle ground that many parents have to use because they haven’t got any back up for when the c/m is on holiday.
i don’t get the hatred on here for childminders ( and that’s not too strong a word from what I read on here sometimes ) the childminders I have met over the years were ex teachers, nurses, and police officers. Of course I only saw snippets of their day, but the children always looked happy enough.

Althenameshavegone · 09/03/2024 08:20

I know this is just one example, but there’s a childminder at a playgroup I go to who has minimal interaction with the children in her care. I find it quite upsetting as she just stands around and chats, totally ignoring children who are often crying or looking for a bit of help to do an activity.

OnceinaMinion · 09/03/2024 08:19

jannier · 08/03/2024 23:12

Confused....your plan to pick up early went wrong because it took you hours and hours???? Don't you think if you were that much later than planned the cm would be concerned? Was your lo expecting you early? Loads of parents say to their children I'll be early today and are not yet even under 2s know who goes home next and get upset when the order is wrong so 3 and 4 year olds know your not early. ...that's horrible to deal with.

DD was 8 so she was just annoyed, she knew I was doing an hours drive that day so assumed I’d left late, it ended up taking me 3. The CM said her husband had ‘said something about crashes on the motorway’ and that was it. She was annoyed and not concerned. I did say I would be there before 4, I am shocked CM didn’t ring tbh.
She was very focused on the kids all going home by 4 on a Friday though.

PuttingDownRoots · 09/03/2024 08:16

I think with most things... you notice poor examples more than good ones! Like I notice the parents (and what I think is a childminder just due to the number of children) dangerously parking outside the school... loads are parking safely. Which probably includes childminders as well, or they are walking.

Which is why you need to keep an open mind when chosing childcare... it might be the nursery is better locally, or there could be a fantastic childminder with space. Or ot could be your schools wrap around is more appropriate than the childminder when at school. You just need to look at whats available locally.

Looneytune253 · 09/03/2024 08:07

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:32

It’s amazing how all the childminders on MN only take 3 under 4s and no other children, spend all their time on wholesome outings and yet charge less than nurseries.

Yet all the childminders I’ve ever met in real life spend their days ignoring the children in the playground/soft play/toddler group and dragging the little ones on the school run twice a day because they make up the numbers with a load more older ones in the morning and at after school time. If I could have found one of these mythical childminders who are like a surrogate granny yet only charge 6 and ha’penny I’d have used one.

I'm presuming this is one or two individual childminders tho if you've seen them on school run and at soft play etc? You can't honestly believe that's the majority of cm. Most of us are quietly getting on with it. Your dramatic wording makes it sound much worse than it is too. I've literally never seen anyone 'dragging' kids on a school run. Most of the time it's just a nice short walk (with some fresh air, and picking up their older friends who they're very excited to see. It also gets them used to the school playground for when they go to school. Better getting out and about than in the same 4 walls surely. There may be times when a school run looks stressful if there's a child having a meltdown or whatever but that could happen to anyone. I have seen cm ignoring the children in soft play etc but again this is the minority of cm. Most of us sit in with the children or watch from afar while grabbing a cuppa, but you won't notice these. It's also good to give children a chance to play freely but as long as you're WATCHING them.

Muddyfun62 · 09/03/2024 05:08

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:32

It’s amazing how all the childminders on MN only take 3 under 4s and no other children, spend all their time on wholesome outings and yet charge less than nurseries.

Yet all the childminders I’ve ever met in real life spend their days ignoring the children in the playground/soft play/toddler group and dragging the little ones on the school run twice a day because they make up the numbers with a load more older ones in the morning and at after school time. If I could have found one of these mythical childminders who are like a surrogate granny yet only charge 6 and ha’penny I’d have used one.

Have you ever heard of uninterrupted play.

Children need the opportunity to play, unrushed, unguided, and free of external interruption whether that is solo independent play or play with a group of children.
During play, children develop fine and gross motor skills, executive functioning skills, emotional regulation, and so much more.
Play helps children to become self-reliant while learning about the world around them and coming up with creative solutions to problems. It also helps children communicate and learn how to solve conflict.

My childminder very much uses the Scandinavian approach to childcare. She stands back and watches them learn, never hovers over them or trys to interrupt them unless invited.

I think there is great childminders and great nurseries. I'm a teacher and a mum of 3 and personally find a childminder the best fit for us.

BenefitWaffle · 09/03/2024 00:15

I also do not think children should be engaged with the whole time. It is fine for children to play without a staff member engaging with them all the time.

Cattenberg · 08/03/2024 23:58

When DD was one, she enjoyed going out to baby classes and toddler groups, but found them very tiring. I thought that spending whole days in a nursery wouldn’t suit her. The childminder often took DD and the other little ones out to groups, then they went back to her house, which was a lovely calm, home-from-home. It’s true that the childminder did school runs and often looked after a couple of older kids after school, but I don’t think this was an issue.

jannier · 08/03/2024 23:46

Eatingmybiscuits · 08/03/2024 23:24

BINGO.

The perfect saint of a childminder vs the nasty nursery with young girls.

As I said there are good bad and brilliant in all settings my point being that nurseries are easier to hide bad practice when it happens. But as your real aim is just childminders are awful you won't read that bit.

Starlightstarbright3 · 08/03/2024 23:37

I was a childminder for a decade .

yes care is more individualised .
if we had children going to a farm we might use that as themed activities , the activities are age related so how a 12 month old would play with an activity would be different to a 3 year old .
we attended a drama group when I had a couple of preschool for a term . I never had the right group that would enjoy that again .
As for under the weather days yes - we have cancelled a group because children are all struggling with colds and done home based activities.

saraclara · 08/03/2024 23:31

Eatingmybiscuits · 08/03/2024 23:19

See Jannier this is the thing. You’re just a little bit too good to be true.

I would be far more impressed with a childminder who said ‘yes, there are disadvantages to this type of childcare - but look at the great things we can offer!’ than this saint like stance which just isn’t realistic.

I've not seen you refer to the disadvantages of nursery care, either.

If you start of a thread by saying that childminders aren't all that, how do you expect them to respond?

jannier · 08/03/2024 23:28

Eatingmybiscuits · 08/03/2024 23:19

See Jannier this is the thing. You’re just a little bit too good to be true.

I would be far more impressed with a childminder who said ‘yes, there are disadvantages to this type of childcare - but look at the great things we can offer!’ than this saint like stance which just isn’t realistic.

I'm 4 times outstanding, an assessor, a buddy, quality assured and lead practitioner in my borough.
I've given up my Saturday to tell children a parent had died, sat with mums at hospital with their sick children, raised EHCPs, gone to homes at night to help sleep train and to sit while mums got ven birth. Had professional visits to my home in my time to learn physio, tube feeding and more.
I'm portage trained, do signing, I'm ecat and elkan trained and more......but now apparently I'm a liar too.
Today 2 parents have driven 3 hours to attend my conminders funeral the child is now 32, others took days off to attend to because we do such a bad job. ....

Eatingmybiscuits · 08/03/2024 23:24

jannier · 08/03/2024 23:21

How many nurseries have you spent time in watching the apprentice feeding 4 babies in a row, the girls gossiping about boyfriends or the staff doing daily diaries including food and sleep at 10 am? The worker in the nappy room doing a conveyor belt nappy time? The staff doing learning journals in the corner while children get on? The don't answer the door until we're all back in our rooms?
I've seen more over my time assessing than I'm happy with.
There are good, bad and fantastic in all types of setting.

BINGO.

The perfect saint of a childminder vs the nasty nursery with young girls.

OP posts:
TempestTost · 08/03/2024 23:24

I do think it's more homey, because of the mixed ages, and I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing for kids to sometimes have to be patient at a thing for older or younger kids. In fact I think overall it's good.

I don't know that I'd necessarily say it's more individualized, but it is almost always less institutional.

jannier · 08/03/2024 23:21

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:32

It’s amazing how all the childminders on MN only take 3 under 4s and no other children, spend all their time on wholesome outings and yet charge less than nurseries.

Yet all the childminders I’ve ever met in real life spend their days ignoring the children in the playground/soft play/toddler group and dragging the little ones on the school run twice a day because they make up the numbers with a load more older ones in the morning and at after school time. If I could have found one of these mythical childminders who are like a surrogate granny yet only charge 6 and ha’penny I’d have used one.

How many nurseries have you spent time in watching the apprentice feeding 4 babies in a row, the girls gossiping about boyfriends or the staff doing daily diaries including food and sleep at 10 am? The worker in the nappy room doing a conveyor belt nappy time? The staff doing learning journals in the corner while children get on? The don't answer the door until we're all back in our rooms?
I've seen more over my time assessing than I'm happy with.
There are good, bad and fantastic in all types of setting.

Copperoliverbear · 08/03/2024 23:21

Don't assume everyone is the same, if one of mine was ill I'd stay home. ( but parents should try to keep them home, so everyone else doesn't get it.)
Also if you do a group for the younger children in the morning you might go to one more age appropriate for the older ones in the afternoon while the younger ones have a nap in the pram.

Eatingmybiscuits · 08/03/2024 23:19

See Jannier this is the thing. You’re just a little bit too good to be true.

I would be far more impressed with a childminder who said ‘yes, there are disadvantages to this type of childcare - but look at the great things we can offer!’ than this saint like stance which just isn’t realistic.

OP posts:
jannier · 08/03/2024 23:12

OnceinaMinion · 08/03/2024 11:42

I was put off childminders when I was on maternity as well, some were okay but some were awful. I had a friend who was a CM for a few years, she was extremely popular and had a big waiting list. She disliked the children enormously. Im sure the same could be true in a nursery, it was just knowing it.

I did use a CM for wrap round for the last few years of primary. DD hated it because of the small ones and endless baby films and she couldn’t get away from them. She was great in lots of ways but she never ever took the children anywhere apart from the school run. She did do flexible care for a nurse including overnights which was nice.

She also really pushed for you to pick children up early, I had aimed to get DD early once but there was a major crash and it took me hours and hours to get there and I got there at 6 on the dot and she was very unhappy because she wanted her ‘weekend to start’. Nursery wouldn’t have had an issue - you pay for the time it’s yours!
I also left DD there late when I was painting her room and she was rude about that too. Luckily we left shortly afterwards

Confused....your plan to pick up early went wrong because it took you hours and hours???? Don't you think if you were that much later than planned the cm would be concerned? Was your lo expecting you early? Loads of parents say to their children I'll be early today and are not yet even under 2s know who goes home next and get upset when the order is wrong so 3 and 4 year olds know your not early. ...that's horrible to deal with.

saraclara · 08/03/2024 23:00

My youngest went to a childminder (though it was some time ago) and absolutely loved having a second family and a 'big brother' who turned up after school and played with her.

Her minder had her own child, mine and another, and the childminder lived her life just as I did when I was at home. They'd go to Tesco, they'd go to a childminder friend's for coffee and play (that childminder would step in if ours was ill) and generally have an un-institutionalised and homely day.

jannier · 08/03/2024 22:59

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 13:20

MN childminders put me off using them. They always insist they are amazing and fabulous. So much better than those nasty nurseries.

Like the above childminder who has ‘chilled days with films and popcorn’ - sounds lovely doesn’t it? Until someone chokes on the popcorn and you rephrase it as kids stuck in front of the TV all afternoon.

So you moan a child can't have a relaxed day if feeling off colour then moan that they are on a sofa watching TV .....what should they do a bit of yoga?
The cm maybe talking about school children who have had a busy week if activities in a school holiday and hit Friday afternoon...

jannier · 08/03/2024 22:48

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 11:18

Tbf I don't know many childminders who have 10 year olds. Most go to holiday clubs by then.

I have an 11 year old been with me since 9 months, she treats it like a visit to aunties. If she's worried she talks to me and we've talked through periods, skin care, braces and bullying. She loves the babies and asks to help ....obviously with limits ...she's seeing that babies are hard work and what they need. In the past some have come to me for their work experience. Once I care for them they are my childminding family and can knock on my door anytime even at 15 if they have had a bad day and don't want to be home alone.

jannier · 08/03/2024 22:37

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 10:07

I also felt there was more individual attention with the 3:1 nursery ratio (for under 2s) than a childminder with a baby, two toddlers/preschoolers

I guess this is my feeling which is why I’m not sure why childminders are automatically seen as superior to nurseries for this age group.

How does a nursery worker with a 13 month old, 16 month old and 18 month old as her key children give them undivided individual attention while taking their turn in the nappy room doing 9 nappies?
As a cm I'm doing storytime with baby on my lap and a toddler either side they are all engaged. If I'm doing a nappy I'm still talking and singing so the others feel involved ...baby out of their view. We do craft together baby adapted for safety and needs but all doing it. The older children show care to the babies the babies learn from them speaking earlier copying what they see. On school runs we play hunt a colour, shape or number and will stop to look at things. The little ones call out stop, go and laugh getting excited.
On arrival the children run into each others arms and will call each others names even the 18 month old.

Icantbedoingwithit · 08/03/2024 22:07

I did both. Childminder was better by a mile! She was amazing!

LucyLaundry · 08/03/2024 21:41

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:32

It’s amazing how all the childminders on MN only take 3 under 4s and no other children, spend all their time on wholesome outings and yet charge less than nurseries.

Yet all the childminders I’ve ever met in real life spend their days ignoring the children in the playground/soft play/toddler group and dragging the little ones on the school run twice a day because they make up the numbers with a load more older ones in the morning and at after school time. If I could have found one of these mythical childminders who are like a surrogate granny yet only charge 6 and ha’penny I’d have used one.

Yes but you're not likely to bump in to me on the school run are you if I don't do them? I used to, but my children are older now and it's lovely having the freedom of no school runs. I get to do things without clock watching.

I also don't need to advertise (or very rarely) as most of my work is from word of mouth so possibly why you don't hear from them local to you too.