Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
changergranger · 09/03/2024 18:56

May487 · 08/03/2024 12:35

I have worked in nurseries. Very good ones are few and far between. Many are average. Quite a lot are downright bad, not somewhere I’d ever want to send my own under 2.5yo. Many early years practitioners would say the same.

If you can find a decent childminder you are on to a winner! Much better set up.

Sorry to derail the thread but I think it's somewhat relevant.

As you are someone with experience in several nurseries of varying quality, would you please mind sharing what clues one might be able to look out for to get an idea of how good a nursery is when deciding where to send your child?

I know a lot of it is just perhaps a general vibe you get but are there any specific red / green flags you'd be looking out for yourself that parents might not think of?

phlebasconsidered · 09/03/2024 18:43

I love our childminder- years after they left! She still sends them birthday cards. They went to her from 6 till 13. Her home was a home, but her I suppose dining room space was a craft and play area. Her garden had allotment areas and they could garden as well as play.

She understood how kids work. Picking them up from school she knew they'd be tired and she let them decompress. She taught them how to make samosas and how to make origami storks.

But for me, the benefit of a childminder over nursey or after school club was that they grew up with her, near our home. My daughter went on to do work experience with her in year 10. Both children pop over regularly to say hello because they love her. I can't think of a higher accolade than a 16 and 17 year old still popping in to have a cup of tea with their childminder.

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 18:37

jannier · 09/03/2024 18:06

Why not answer the question? Basically you were later than you told her, left your child unhappy and didnt support your child by updating the cm on your delay so she could distract her and offer her comfort that annoyed your cm and your annoyed because you have paid for the hours but can't understand the upset you caused in simply calling to say I'm delayed. And by the sound of it you also send in sick children. Get a grip and work in partnership rather than against your cm ....I've had parents arrive 2 hours after their contracted time but as they updated me they arrived to a fed happy child and a meal to take home.....but I guess you will say I'm lying because CMS are evil.

You do know that was another poster? She told you what happened. She’d paid until 6, but the CM had a go at her for picking up after 5. You think that’s acceptable. I don’t 🤷‍♀️

So, you are the perfect childminder, providing perfect care for all ages and stages. It just becomes a bit hard to believe. I’m definitely not perfect at all times in my role.

I don’t even use childcare at the moment so I don’t know why you’re accusing me of sending in ill children. This is where I wonder. You’ve made up a load of stuff following my posts. How do I know you’re not making up what the reception teachers say too? (And how do you even know …?)

OP posts:
jannier · 09/03/2024 18:27

When I go to a toddler group it's the one time in a week for me to stand back and observe the children in a setting I have not controlled. I watch what they do and how they interact. I will give support if it's needed but it's important to give them space and to allow some conflict resolution as well as for them to trip and get up just as they will at school.
So many adults helicopter their children not allowing any physical space stepping in to every activity especially craft telling the child stick that their, hold it like that etc. so no learning is happening. If you have a 3 year old in one area and a 4 year old in the other there maybe times you need to call out be careful etc....just like they do at Nursery.

LucyLaundry · 09/03/2024 18:24

Ultimately, it's a good thing that we have a variety of childcare options in this country. Different things suit different parents, children and lifestyles/work patterns.

It's no different to me meeting a family sometimes and deciding that they wouldn't be a good fit for me or the children I look after, possibly due to different parenting styles or expectations.

It doesn't need to have a whole thread slagging of one type, whether that's childminders or nurseries. We can only select from the options local to us so it doesn't really matter what others choose.

Just pick the option that you like best and be happy.

Hufflemuff · 09/03/2024 18:17

Oh I much preferred a CM for my son. It was like leaving him with a family member. He was 9mths when I went back to work so I wanted a more homely setting, the CM I picked had 4 grown up children and had been doing CM professionally for years. I was more reassured by that than letting a spotty teenager with just a childcare BTEC look after my baby.

She took him to the beach, to farms, to adventure playgrounds etc... whereas the local nursery just have inside and outside the nursery to explore.

She was better and more sensible with sickness too, my nephew was constantly being sent home from nursery at the first whiff of illness but my CM was like a propper mum and would give him calpol and see how he felt.

jannier · 09/03/2024 18:15

thesleepyhoglet · 09/03/2024 13:01

I much prefer a nursery setting. The routines suit my DS. I can't comment for all nurseries or all childminders but a few childminders I know of are also doing school drop offs so the smaller ones are bundled up and taken off. There is only the one adults caring for them so they don't get to know other people. My DS bonded well with his key worker but also had a very special relationship with one of the other adults at nursery. Nursery has more time to set up various varied play settings too.

You can get CMS who work with assistants or cominders with up to 4 adults. You can also get ones who network my charges have 16 close friends they see 3 times a week at least and 3 other adults. We have group story and singing, meals, outings to woods for forest school that we do ourselves. In my home there is a home corner, reading den, light table, access to drawing, painting, cutting, glue etc. I always have a tough tray. When we are out the children take photos of things that interest them which we use in crafts, make puzzles, put into tough trays etc rather than a theme planned months in advance that all must follow regardless of interest.
My children normally stay to reception age and teachers comment how well prepared they are.

Tahinii · 09/03/2024 18:11

Around here, quite a few childminders run like small nurseries. They certainly charge similar amounts. They’re very popular with long waiting lists so I guess people like that sort of set up.

jannier · 09/03/2024 18:08

OnceinaMinion · 09/03/2024 12:44

I was in a car, driving, I don’t use my phone when driving. I could have taken the call through my car but wasn’t good at making calls out on it, especially scrolling for her number whilst driving, even slowly.
And honestly it was a constant issue of paying for her to be there until 6 (I almost never left her there till then) and being pressurised to pick her up much much earlier all the time, especially when I couldn’t leave work until 5.

Next time pull over and call....I'm sure in 2 hours there was an opportunity

jannier · 09/03/2024 18:06

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 10:22

It’s weird stuff like this Jannier.

Why not just acknowledge that it’s unprofessional and say you’d never do it? Why try to make our it’s acceptable? It’s not.

Why not answer the question? Basically you were later than you told her, left your child unhappy and didnt support your child by updating the cm on your delay so she could distract her and offer her comfort that annoyed your cm and your annoyed because you have paid for the hours but can't understand the upset you caused in simply calling to say I'm delayed. And by the sound of it you also send in sick children. Get a grip and work in partnership rather than against your cm ....I've had parents arrive 2 hours after their contracted time but as they updated me they arrived to a fed happy child and a meal to take home.....but I guess you will say I'm lying because CMS are evil.

thesleepyhoglet · 09/03/2024 13:01

I much prefer a nursery setting. The routines suit my DS. I can't comment for all nurseries or all childminders but a few childminders I know of are also doing school drop offs so the smaller ones are bundled up and taken off. There is only the one adults caring for them so they don't get to know other people. My DS bonded well with his key worker but also had a very special relationship with one of the other adults at nursery. Nursery has more time to set up various varied play settings too.

AmusedMaker · 09/03/2024 12:46

Ikwym op, but c/m’s will definitely offer a daily experience closer to a ‘home from home’ type thing. Ratios are smaller, most c/m’s go out with the children everyday to a playground or soft play. My c/m took the children to the city farm once a month, she also took them to museums a couple of times a year, it was a fantastic service I must admit 😄 Yes some do school runs but the parents who moan about that will need that service in a couple of years.
Having a child surrounded by 10 other children, in the same room ( no matter how big it is ) & hardly ever going out is not natural. But of course some parents prefer that nursery experience.
No one will ever know exactly what goes on all day every day at a c/m’s or a nursery - some children will be left to cry for longer than they should be yes, I’m sure that happens, but unless you stay at home with your kids until they start school you just have to accept that.

OnceinaMinion · 09/03/2024 12:44

jannier · 09/03/2024 10:14

Lots of parents promise their child an early pick up then come on time (even on the child's birthday) it is distressing to watch and annoying as we care for the children and hate for them to be upset plus dealing with the behaviour that results from the child's emotions ..none of which needs to happen if the parent just leaves early pick up as a last minute suprise messaging the cm half an hour before.
Your cm is only human and anybody after a long typically 44 to 55 hour week expecting to actually finish at 4 on a Friday being left waiting not knowing what's going on is going to be a bit peed you say she didn't call you but in that case why didn't you call her so she could get out activities to do with her....I'd be getting her doing some cooking, making playdo or jewellery if I had an 8 year old one to one for 2 hours

I was in a car, driving, I don’t use my phone when driving. I could have taken the call through my car but wasn’t good at making calls out on it, especially scrolling for her number whilst driving, even slowly.
And honestly it was a constant issue of paying for her to be there until 6 (I almost never left her there till then) and being pressurised to pick her up much much earlier all the time, especially when I couldn’t leave work until 5.

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 12:19

TheTwirlyPoos · 09/03/2024 11:43

So you have a blanket ban on cms?

But you shout bingo when someone says that in their experience nurseries are negative?

OK then...

It isn’t my ban. The groups are nothing to do with me other than I sometimes go to them 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 12:17

AmusedMaker · 09/03/2024 11:34

Op: you do seem to have a real grudge against c/m’s.

Not intentionally. I’ve said that there are some great ones and some real advantages to this type of childcare. I just think the downsides aren’t acknowledged.

@TheTwirlyPoos huh? Sorry?

OP posts:
TheTwirlyPoos · 09/03/2024 11:43

So you have a blanket ban on cms?

But you shout bingo when someone says that in their experience nurseries are negative?

OK then...

AmusedMaker · 09/03/2024 11:36

There’s great childminders & not so great ones. Just like nurseries or any other profession for that matter.
nothing is ever 100% perfect.

AmusedMaker · 09/03/2024 11:34

Op: you do seem to have a real grudge against c/m’s.

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 11:17

I don’t particularly want to prove a point: there are brilliant things about home based childcare and brilliant childminders.

But it does have downsides and that’s something that’s rarely acknowledged by some MN childminders. If anyone dares say a nursery works better for them it’s straight to the ‘underage girls’ comment (ageism is fine this way round) and it’s funny how all MN childminders and all parents who use a childminder are adamant that children ignored in group settings would never happen but the rest of us see it a lot (to the point where some groups by me won’t allow childminders in at all!)

OP posts:
Blushingm · 09/03/2024 11:16

I used a childminder - my dc became like part of her family. They'd do different activities at home as well as going out to parks and groups

TheTwirlyPoos · 09/03/2024 11:14

@Eatingmybiscuits you seem to want to really prove a point and the whole bingo thing is really strange. That poster acknowledged there are good and bad about each type of setting. You see to be encouraging the 'bingo' repsindsd for cms though...

Just do what you want to do, stop worrying about why other people like other things, surely?

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 10:22

jannier · 09/03/2024 10:14

Lots of parents promise their child an early pick up then come on time (even on the child's birthday) it is distressing to watch and annoying as we care for the children and hate for them to be upset plus dealing with the behaviour that results from the child's emotions ..none of which needs to happen if the parent just leaves early pick up as a last minute suprise messaging the cm half an hour before.
Your cm is only human and anybody after a long typically 44 to 55 hour week expecting to actually finish at 4 on a Friday being left waiting not knowing what's going on is going to be a bit peed you say she didn't call you but in that case why didn't you call her so she could get out activities to do with her....I'd be getting her doing some cooking, making playdo or jewellery if I had an 8 year old one to one for 2 hours

It’s weird stuff like this Jannier.

Why not just acknowledge that it’s unprofessional and say you’d never do it? Why try to make our it’s acceptable? It’s not.

OP posts:
LyndaSnellsSniff · 09/03/2024 10:19

I used a nursery for DS1 and then, due to circumstances, a childminder for DS2. I far preferred the nursery because I felt happier knowing where DS 1 would be all day whereas, with the childminder, DS 2 seemed to spend most of his time in a car doing school runs.

The childminder was absolutely lovely, but I just felt a bit uneasy.

jannier · 09/03/2024 10:14

OnceinaMinion · 09/03/2024 08:19

DD was 8 so she was just annoyed, she knew I was doing an hours drive that day so assumed I’d left late, it ended up taking me 3. The CM said her husband had ‘said something about crashes on the motorway’ and that was it. She was annoyed and not concerned. I did say I would be there before 4, I am shocked CM didn’t ring tbh.
She was very focused on the kids all going home by 4 on a Friday though.

Lots of parents promise their child an early pick up then come on time (even on the child's birthday) it is distressing to watch and annoying as we care for the children and hate for them to be upset plus dealing with the behaviour that results from the child's emotions ..none of which needs to happen if the parent just leaves early pick up as a last minute suprise messaging the cm half an hour before.
Your cm is only human and anybody after a long typically 44 to 55 hour week expecting to actually finish at 4 on a Friday being left waiting not knowing what's going on is going to be a bit peed you say she didn't call you but in that case why didn't you call her so she could get out activities to do with her....I'd be getting her doing some cooking, making playdo or jewellery if I had an 8 year old one to one for 2 hours

OCDmama · 09/03/2024 09:17

I love our childminder. We wanted a home environment, and she keeps below the ratios to make sure she can care for the children in a loving way. I am so happy my kids have someone who holds them and gives them lots of cuddles. We started with my daughter at 1, and she's now taken on my son too.

It's been an absolute excellent step for us. My 3 year old does a school nursery in the morning and my minder does wrap around my working days, and has the baby. My daughter adores the our childminders daughters too - she loves the big girls.

Absolutely best decision ever. She's only term time but I would make the sacrifice of scrambling for holiday cover every time to have that quality of care.