Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think childminders don’t really offer a more homely and individual experience?

191 replies

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Glassshouldbehalffull · 11/03/2024 11:04

@LucyLaundry you sound like a great childminder!

TotoroElla · 10/03/2024 20:38

LucyLaundry · 07/03/2024 09:39

I'd say it's homely in the sense that it's like being part of a family, with siblings etc. No everything can't revolve around one child the whole time but largely the experience is more tailored to the children attending rather than a generic nursery experience.

I'm not working today but tomorrow I'm taking 2 little boys on a train ride as they love trains and nect week ŵe're going to a rabbit rescue as the little girl I have is obsessed with rabbits. She's not fussed about trains and the boys aren't bothered about rabbits but we are a little 'family' and do things together.

That sounds lovely!

jannier · 10/03/2024 20:20

Reugny · 10/03/2024 05:53

It's changed with nurseries due to staff shortages.

We met a couple of people we know whose children had random weeks off nursery due to staff being sick. The nursery couldn't find staff cover so closed the nursery down completely. (There are threads on MN of well children being sent home were the staff claim the child is sick. It's suspected there are not enough staff.)

The childminder we used was never sick herself.

With holidays we got loads of notice and to be fair once DD started nursery which also had holidays, one provider generally made up for the other apart from Christmas week.

One local nursery cancelled 18 funded sessions this year due to staffing and one boiler repair.

jannier · 10/03/2024 20:18

Eatingmybiscuits · 10/03/2024 03:28

It’s not the point Jannier.

One of my children went through a (thankfully very brief phase) of being distressed at drop off. It was horrible and the idea that someone would be sniffy about having to work or being stuck in traffic or yes wanting a break, is awful.

It's not about being sniffly about working it's about parents not thinking that telling a child they will go home early then not updating the carer so they can distract the child with activities or feed them to reduce the child's upset. Most of us don't care what you do in paid hours as long as your contactable in an emergency but don't say to the child your coming early then not at least let us know things have changed....ideally keep it a surprise if this could happen.
How can you say your upset about difficult drop offs but the cm can not be upset about dealing with a distressed child who's parent didn't turn up when they said? .....I've known parents decide just to pop to the nail shop rather than the promised early collection thinking the child won't notice ....they notice.

changergranger · 10/03/2024 17:01

@May487 This is really helpful thank you for this! Flowers

Rollinroller · 10/03/2024 07:05

Eatingmybiscuits · 07/03/2024 09:24

Just musing over childcare options and this comes up a lot on the debate - that a childminder is more individual to the child’s needs and can offer a home based approach.

But when I think about it in practice, the childminders I know don’t, because they can’t. So for example they attend a little music group we go to in the morning, it’s really aimed at ages 18 months to two and a half but there are children ranging from 9 months to 4. The older ones are bored and the little ones can’t really engage.

Then if a child is feeling under the weather they can’t really just take it easy as the minder has to tend to other children and take them out.

I am not saying there aren’t advantages to this sort of childcare but AIBU to say this isn’t one of them?

But what you’ve described is an experience more akin to home - being in age appropriate groups with activities set accordingly is absolutely a hallmark of more institutional care. You also only have one main carer.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 10/03/2024 06:15

I struck gold with my childminder but I think that is because she operates a bit like a nursery. She doesn't take the kids out at all (which I like) and has a lot of kids. Obviously it isn't just her, she has about 3 members of staff who work there too and they do loads of activities throughout the day. If a child isn't feeling it, they can just go and chill on the sofa.

Reugny · 10/03/2024 05:53

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 09/03/2024 21:09

The only thing that really put me off was that most childminders have a few weeks off a year and so they basically determine when you go on holiday. And the sickness. At a nursery, that’s their problem. With a childminder, it’s your problem. Not helpful if you’ve got a job you need to be at!! I’m also not a huge fan of my kid spending a lot of their day on someone else’s school run. It wasn’t for me.

It's changed with nurseries due to staff shortages.

We met a couple of people we know whose children had random weeks off nursery due to staff being sick. The nursery couldn't find staff cover so closed the nursery down completely. (There are threads on MN of well children being sent home were the staff claim the child is sick. It's suspected there are not enough staff.)

The childminder we used was never sick herself.

With holidays we got loads of notice and to be fair once DD started nursery which also had holidays, one provider generally made up for the other apart from Christmas week.

Eatingmybiscuits · 10/03/2024 03:28

It’s not the point Jannier.

One of my children went through a (thankfully very brief phase) of being distressed at drop off. It was horrible and the idea that someone would be sniffy about having to work or being stuck in traffic or yes wanting a break, is awful.

OP posts:
Youcannotbeseriousreally · 09/03/2024 21:09

The only thing that really put me off was that most childminders have a few weeks off a year and so they basically determine when you go on holiday. And the sickness. At a nursery, that’s their problem. With a childminder, it’s your problem. Not helpful if you’ve got a job you need to be at!! I’m also not a huge fan of my kid spending a lot of their day on someone else’s school run. It wasn’t for me.

Meem321 · 09/03/2024 21:09

Our childminder (18 yrs ago) was a pain in the arse. Had her own toddler at home too, was not flexible, went on holiday when she knew I couldn't (I'm a teacher) etc etc. Was delighted when she got pregnant again and we had to put ours in nursery.

Myotheripodisayoto · 09/03/2024 20:56

Also im pretty rational about things.

In a nursery, a hell of a lot of the fee you pay is going to paying for an owner to make a return on their investment, for the rent or mortgage of a building, for furniture and toys. That means what's left over to actually pay staff is less, than compared to a childminder working from their own home, with the furniture they own anyway, and usually the toys they have from their own kids. This is why nurseries often have a lot of younger less experienced staff, because once those staff have a few years experience and their own home, they can earn far far more as a childminder.

Wenttomowameadow · 09/03/2024 20:53

We went with nursery because I felt there were more checks and balances with more key workers and management in the room. I'd heard very bad things about several local childminders, like having screens on all day, feeding children food they were allergic to, being aggressive with the children and I couldn't afford to try 5 or so before setting on one. My DC have loved nursery, they've both had the same key workers 4 years apart and consider them like family, they're closer to the key workers than their grandparents who they never see and the key workers now babysit for us regularly.

TheFormidableMrsC · 09/03/2024 20:48

I used a childminder for my firstborn. She had the best time. Childminder was absolutely wonderful. I have absolutely no regrets. It was the right setting for her.

Myotheripodisayoto · 09/03/2024 20:47

I wanted a family type experience for my child. Its normal for a child to be one of maybe 3 of different ages and not always get the "perfect" activity for their age. I was happy for them to be taken on school run and enjoy having the bigger kids around after school.

I didn't want them going to a nursery where my 3.5 year old was put in a different room to the 1 year old.

I wanted one caregiver. Its worked perfectly for us.

BeretRaspberry · 09/03/2024 20:47

Our childminder was amazing. And the kids loved going there. She used to take them all to groups, had a massive garden and a room in her house that the could chill in. They used to snuggle up on the sofa at chill time.

pinkhousesarebest · 09/03/2024 20:43

My childminder only had three dcs ( my 2 and one other) and didn’t do school runs etc. It was a lovely home from home for them and she is still part of our lives as are her children. She took them even when they had chickenpox. My friends had their children in a nursery and were called so many times to come and pick up sick kids that it became unsustainable for them to work full time.

jannier · 09/03/2024 20:40

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 19:37

You obviously have decided for your own reasons that any nursery would be better than any childminder regardless

No. I’ve said throughout there are brilliant childminders. But there are downsides, just as there are to nurseries.

I would be really upset to be judged for collecting my child on time.

But you've ignored the suggestion that it wasn't about collection time but about seeing the de-stress of a child expecting being collected early and not knowing if they should be fed, start an activity etc I bet the poster would have been mad at being made to wait while child spent 30 minutes finishing say or had been fed if she were planning a dinner.
Your thread does not read like you think there are any good sides

Reugny · 09/03/2024 19:43

Taylormiffed · 09/03/2024 19:30

Yanbu. The childminders I saw at baby classes and toddler groups really put me off. I used to have a weird neighbour who was a childminder with giant dog and seriously dodgy boyfriend.

Kids get far more attention and support at a good nursery. They can have 1 to 1 time when needed.

Nope.

Depends on the childminder and nursery.

My DD had her CM to herself for about 3 months on one day she attended. The reason was that the space was filled but there was a delay in the kids starting. (In fact she waited 6 weeks before my DD started. )

The CM would wait longer than she was legally required to before she took on another under 1 when she had the space.

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 19:37

You obviously have decided for your own reasons that any nursery would be better than any childminder regardless

No. I’ve said throughout there are brilliant childminders. But there are downsides, just as there are to nurseries.

I would be really upset to be judged for collecting my child on time.

OP posts:
Taylormiffed · 09/03/2024 19:30

Yanbu. The childminders I saw at baby classes and toddler groups really put me off. I used to have a weird neighbour who was a childminder with giant dog and seriously dodgy boyfriend.

Kids get far more attention and support at a good nursery. They can have 1 to 1 time when needed.

jannier · 09/03/2024 19:25

Eatingmybiscuits · 09/03/2024 18:37

You do know that was another poster? She told you what happened. She’d paid until 6, but the CM had a go at her for picking up after 5. You think that’s acceptable. I don’t 🤷‍♀️

So, you are the perfect childminder, providing perfect care for all ages and stages. It just becomes a bit hard to believe. I’m definitely not perfect at all times in my role.

I don’t even use childcare at the moment so I don’t know why you’re accusing me of sending in ill children. This is where I wonder. You’ve made up a load of stuff following my posts. How do I know you’re not making up what the reception teachers say too? (And how do you even know …?)

I apologise for mixing you up with the other poster.
I know what the teachers say because the parents tell me and the teachers tell me when we are working in partnership.
Obviously over the years there have been times when as part of my self reflection I decide I could have done better but I'm telling you how my days in general work.
You obviously have decided for your own reasons that any nursery would be better than any childminder regardless. People have their own reasons and that's fine. As I said there are good bad etc in all types of settings the only difference is nurseries are hidden behind doors so can be harder to spot and people assume that a ratio applies to each room not over the building thinking 3 members of staff will always be working in each room for example or that the 17 year old apprentice who left school last month will have a pair of eyes on her constantly.
You have to have trust in your setting and select it carefully not just by a lable.

TheolderIgetthelessIknow · 09/03/2024 19:21

Ex-early years inspector here. If I had my time all over again, I'd always 100% opt for a childminder.

Reugny · 09/03/2024 19:13

Thanks to where I live I've seen poor nurseries in action and outstanding ones. I also know parents who used one of the poor ones.

I managed to find a good CM for my DD and also used a good nursery for her. She went part-time to the childminder starting as a baby, and then went part-time to both from age 3.

The childminder cared for children from babies to 11. She had her own grown up large family of children. The nursery only had children 2-4 years old. The nursery staff were all over 21. There was a high turnover of those under 40 but luckily most of the staff were older than that.

It is interesting to see what different skills and learning experiences they both gave DD.

The downside of nursery was the large number of sickness bugs they gave DD. At the CMs even though there were children who attended school present after school she was sick about once a year.

My DD also found nursery boring after a year of attending. However she never complained of being bored at the CMs.

Both providers were good at not instilling gender stereotypes into DD. The nursery had male staff and the CM is good at fixing things.

As my DD is now at reception I think going to the CM helped a lot in allowing her to relate and play with children younger and older than herself. Part of the ethos of my DD's school is they help others including those who aren't in their age group. DD is one of the few who instantly doesn't have a problem with this.

May487 · 09/03/2024 19:06

changergranger · 09/03/2024 18:56

Sorry to derail the thread but I think it's somewhat relevant.

As you are someone with experience in several nurseries of varying quality, would you please mind sharing what clues one might be able to look out for to get an idea of how good a nursery is when deciding where to send your child?

I know a lot of it is just perhaps a general vibe you get but are there any specific red / green flags you'd be looking out for yourself that parents might not think of?

Of course.

Your instinct will more often than not be correct. I would visit at multiple times of day. A good nursery should allow it. Go in the morning, go in the afternoon.

  1. Staff turnover. How long have the staff been there? Do they seem happy? Look for a mixture of ages

  2. Do the adults wear outdoor shoes inside, or do they change to slippers? Much better if everyone has ‘indoor shoes’ as outdoor shoes are unhygienic for crawling babies.

  3. Listen to how the manager talks. Do they seem to really know the staff and children?

4). Ask how often the babies go outside, and what kind of trips they go on.

  1. Did I say visit? Visit, visit, visit. Visit each potential setting 3 times if you can at different times of day.

I would pick a smaller setting over a bigger one if possible for a young child. Busier ones can be quite overwhelming and overstimulating. OFSTED ratings can be accurate but you conversely find that the ones that have got required improvement or good (depending on what for) are often the ones trying the hardest. Outstanding ones can sit back on their laurels and become quite unpleasant cultures. Not always, but sometimes. Hope this helps. Xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread