Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of MIL

191 replies

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 09:22

4 years ago, when our oldest was a baby, we moved an hour away to be closer to MIL. One of the big pulls was that she said she wanted to spend more time with her grandchildren, felt jealous her friends had theirs just down the road and would be very happy to help us out with DD one or two days a week so we could keep childcare costs down.

So we moved and… crickets. She took DD for about an afternoon a week initially, then just stopped replying to texts when we messaged to ask about DD going over.

Since then (2 years later) a pattern has developed which is really pissing me off. I (against my better judgement) have continued to invite them for Sunday dinner every few weeks, which they always seem to be available and well for. They’re also always well and available on special days such as birthdays and Christmases, and make sure they ‘get their photos’ with the kids then. They’ll also randomly drop in, with no notice, every few weeks and grumble if we’re busy WFH (they still don’t seem to understand it doesn’t mean dossing about) or if we are about to go out somewhere. If I let them in they wind the kids up for an hour then leave after a cup of tea.

But whenever I message asking if they can watch one of the kids (we also now have a 1 year old) they either don’t reply at all or say they have a cold.

To pre empt the inevitable questions, no I don’t ask much maybe once every few weeks or so at most, I’ve gone a couple of months at a time not asking. They live a 7 minute drive away. They’re both retired and in good health - still doing sports, nights out, cruises etc. They ask for favours with DIY and lifts which DP usually does. When I ask if they can watch one of the kids it’s ALWAYS because I have something I need to do, I’ve never asked them to watch both kids at once, and by watching I mean literally sitting in the lounge playing with them for 1/2 hours after I’ve fed/changed them.

WIBU to just detach from them at this point and stop messaging, stop the Sunday lunch invitations and basically just go very very LC? We’ve had a really hard few weeks, and as usual my message asking if they could have DS for a couple of hours yesterday went ignored. However they’ve asked for an airport lift next week.

OP posts:
Scaffoldingisugly · 07/03/2024 10:46

My ils never had my mobile number. Honestly it made life so simple... She used the house phone. Gave it to dh every time. Or the dc!! She came every Monday (big groan).. 8.20 am. If she came other times I kept to my schedules even if that meant I took the dc out and she was stuck with dh... Your dc honestly won't miss out... The ils will.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 07/03/2024 10:44

@Pleasehelpimexhausted , have you tried talking to them about this?
You clearly moved with the expectation of regular free childcare and if they led you to believe that you could expect this and then changed their minds that would be super frustrating. Was the free childcare the only reason you moved to where you are, were there other considerations?
My husband and I are recently retired and loving our new life free of the responsibilities we once had, we adore our grandchildren and are delighted to look after them on an ad hoc basis but wouldn’t want to commit to a regular arrangement. It sounds like your P’sIL are making the most of their retirement too, one becomes very aware of the ticking clock at our age and that at any time some illness could befall either one of you and that would be the end of your blissful new found freedom.
I’m guessing but perhaps they are concerned about getting involved in commitments that would negatively impact their retirement plans.
If you and importantly your husband could talk to them and ask what level of help they would be happy to provide and be accepting of their response, you may find they become more willing to help.
It could just be that they are utterly ghastly and promised childcare to lure you close to them so they had people to call upon to help them….
Please remember they’ve raised their family, they’ve potentially sacrificed what they wanted to do and now feel they have a small window of freedom before ill health or old age gets them.
I feel very strongly that families should be there for each other but it should definitely be a give and take transaction. Try talking and understanding their perspective, I hope you can sort this out amicably; family fracture is so sad. Good luck!

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:42

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/03/2024 10:41

Things change. Personally, I wouldn’t have moved.

Yes, upon reflection it was the wrong decision.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 07/03/2024 10:41

Things change. Personally, I wouldn’t have moved.

Scaffoldingisugly · 07/03/2024 10:39

Stop communicating with them op. If they need anything they can ask dh. Any nurse maid duties in the future can be at his descretion..

forrestgreen · 07/03/2024 10:38

Next time you need something ask dh to message instead to see if anything different happens.

If they do end up babysitting then repay them with a lovely Sunday lunch that weekend.

If it's crickets from them then repay their energy. I wish I'd learned years ago that it's ok to match someone's energy.

Keep the door locked, answer over a ring doorbell 'oh sorry I wish you'd messaged, we're off to the park in a minute. Or sorry we're actually working'

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:36

Tumbler2121 · 07/03/2024 10:30

They sound like selfish users, but just one thing ... you say that if you message for help they don't answer. How about phoning them? With an alternative day if they can't make the day you're asking for?

Think that way you will have a very, very clear idea whether they have any willingness to help. Also, do they ever invite you all over as a family? Just wondered!

I do phone as well sometimes but it always, always goes unanswered. I could suggest an alternative day but I have a strong inkling she’ll say about checking the calendar then never get back to me, or say she has something on. The thing is I only usually ask when something happens (ie one of the kids has an appointment) so an alternate day wouldn’t really work if you see what I mean.

They invite us over very very very rarely, perhaps once or twice a year at most.

OP posts:
Tumbler2121 · 07/03/2024 10:30

They sound like selfish users, but just one thing ... you say that if you message for help they don't answer. How about phoning them? With an alternative day if they can't make the day you're asking for?

Think that way you will have a very, very clear idea whether they have any willingness to help. Also, do they ever invite you all over as a family? Just wondered!

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:25

Mnk711 · 07/03/2024 10:10

I'd be annoyed with this. As a pp said have a conversation with them about it feeling one sided. If they still won't help stop agreeing to help them, mirror their lack of response to your messages. As you say it's not that you will only help them if they help you, it's about feeling like someone cares enough to want to help. It's hurtful if they don't, particularly if they've said they would. Have you asked before about why MIL won't have DD any more and said you were relying on the help?

No, to be fair I haven’t directly asked. I have asked how she is in general because I wondered if she was feeling more tired, but she said she’s fine and they’re out and about more than ever so I believe her. They’ve also just started a house renovation.

I think it’s one of 2 things; either she’s just realised sitting and playing with small children is quite dull sometimes and she simply can’t be bothered. Or actually she never really intended to see her promise through and wanted to get us down here knowing they would need care at some stage and they would have us close by for that. Given some pointed remarks she’s made lately about how ‘people are too lazy to care for their old folk and that’s why the hospitals are full’, I suspect the latter. It didn’t actually occur to me until I started writing this thread actually.

OP posts:
Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:21

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:17

Hey it was you that had the clear understanding that you moved as she said she'd have DC once a week, sorry she reneged on that but as said, people can change their minds and are perfectly entitled to. When given suggestions as to why that might have happened you dismissed them saying that your DC are NT so struggling to look after them would be impossible and they're fit and healthy so it shouldn't be an issue. That and the fact that the thread is literally about you being annoyed they won't babysit shows that that does seem to be the attitude you have

They’re entitled to but that wasn’t my question was it? I’m entitled to cheat on my DP, but is it kind or fair? 90% of the votes seem to see things from my point of view so your opinion seems to be very much the minority.

OP posts:
YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:17

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:14

But your narrative is I went ‘Yay MIL we are going to move down the road from you so you can take our kids and save us some cash! How great is that! And as their Nana, you have to do it! Happy days’

Rather than how it was, which was MIL actually suggesting it, saying she wanted to do it then simply not bothering once she had got us down here.

Unless you’re the sort of person who thinks promises mean nothing and you never have to keep any commitments?

Hey it was you that had the clear understanding that you moved as she said she'd have DC once a week, sorry she reneged on that but as said, people can change their minds and are perfectly entitled to. When given suggestions as to why that might have happened you dismissed them saying that your DC are NT so struggling to look after them would be impossible and they're fit and healthy so it shouldn't be an issue. That and the fact that the thread is literally about you being annoyed they won't babysit shows that that does seem to be the attitude you have

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:14

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:10

"promising to have DD 1 day a week if we moved closer to them?"
"They didn’t though because we had a clear understanding that part of the reason we were moving was because she offered 1 day a week"

IT'S WHAT YOU SAID, going by the narrative YOU provided

But your narrative is I went ‘Yay MIL we are going to move down the road from you so you can take our kids and save us some cash! How great is that! And as their Nana, you have to do it! Happy days’

Rather than how it was, which was MIL actually suggesting it, saying she wanted to do it then simply not bothering once she had got us down here.

Unless you’re the sort of person who thinks promises mean nothing and you never have to keep any commitments?

OP posts:
YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:10

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:06

No, I moved because she asked us. Saying she was sad that she didn’t see enough of her granddaughter and was jealous of friends who saw and looked after theirs regularly. Big difference. You’re trying to spin a narrative that doesn’t exist.

"promising to have DD 1 day a week if we moved closer to them?"
"They didn’t though because we had a clear understanding that part of the reason we were moving was because she offered 1 day a week"

IT'S WHAT YOU SAID, going by the narrative YOU provided

Mnk711 · 07/03/2024 10:10

I'd be annoyed with this. As a pp said have a conversation with them about it feeling one sided. If they still won't help stop agreeing to help them, mirror their lack of response to your messages. As you say it's not that you will only help them if they help you, it's about feeling like someone cares enough to want to help. It's hurtful if they don't, particularly if they've said they would. Have you asked before about why MIL won't have DD any more and said you were relying on the help?

Daffodildilys · 07/03/2024 10:09

As a gp I think they’re being mean. Absolutely don’t do the airport lift and stop the Sunday lunch invites.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/03/2024 10:09

Say that you're busy and you'd recommend that they get a taxi (i.e. pay someone to bring them) to/from the airport.

I'd also get DH to do all of the communications going forwards. If MiL or FiL contact you directly, just pass the phone/forward the email to your DH and say "Your parents have been in touch" and nothing more.
This is what some people call FAFO (fuck around and find out). Well they fucked around by promising the sun, moon and stars and being available and they got their son and his wife and their children to move closer to them. However they have reneged on their end of the deal, so you should be under no obligation to hold up your end of the bargain.

It would be possible to move, but disruptive and it's whether you would all agree to that disruption or not (I think it would be worthwhile asking your DD who has settled in school if this would be something she would be interested and open to doing).

The key thing here would be for you to begin the withdrawal of you being the de facto liaison between the in-laws and your family. That's what your DH is for.

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:06

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:05

A child doesn't have to be neurodivergent for someone to find them hard work to care for. You said you moved so she could have them once a week to save on childcare... So free babysitting

No, I moved because she asked us. Saying she was sad that she didn’t see enough of her granddaughter and was jealous of friends who saw and looked after theirs regularly. Big difference. You’re trying to spin a narrative that doesn’t exist.

OP posts:
YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 10:05

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:03

I doubt it, DD is NT, easy and the kind of kid who just wants to sit and colour. MIL hikes 1 day a week and FIL still does his sports so if sitting on a sofa with a cup of tea and occasionally saying ‘yes, very good, brilliant octopus’ is too much to handle I would be surprised.

When did I say they were automatically free babysitters out of interest?

A child doesn't have to be neurodivergent for someone to find them hard work to care for. You said you moved so she could have them once a week to save on childcare... So free babysitting

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:03

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 09:55

People have a right to change their minds. Maybe they had them and realised it was too much for them to handle? Grandparents aren't automatically free babysitters

I doubt it, DD is NT, easy and the kind of kid who just wants to sit and colour. MIL hikes 1 day a week and FIL still does his sports so if sitting on a sofa with a cup of tea and occasionally saying ‘yes, very good, brilliant octopus’ is too much to handle I would be surprised.

When did I say they were automatically free babysitters out of interest?

OP posts:
Planetbippop · 07/03/2024 09:55

How does DH feel about it all?

I think you've 2 options. 1) you accept the situation & review your input/support of them. On the very next occasion care in their later years is mentioned, be clear you won't be taking that on.
2) chat to her & let her know you feel let down. Sometimes there's glaringly obvious reasons that have been missed. Say you welcome them popping in but if you're heading out, they need to accept it. If DC are getting wound up, then tell them all to calm things down.

You have a say in everything that's going on 😊

WestendGrrls · 07/03/2024 09:55

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 09:41

They didn’t though because we had a clear understanding that part of the reason we were moving was because she offered 1 day a week (tried to offer more actually but we said let’s see how you find it), and said she wanted to do this. We didn’t ask, it she offered, saying she was sad she didn’t see more of her grandchild.

She probably found it hard work or decided that she didn't want to commit anymore, for whatever reason. Weekly childcare is a big ask for anyone, and I guess now you have seen how she found it. It is a great pity you can't call on them in an emergency though. Still I don't think it's good enough reason to cut them out.

I invite family over and I don't get much in return, apart from the pleasure of their company and a relationship between them and my kids, which I find really important.

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 09:55

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 09:48

Have you read my post? The part about them
promising to have DD 1 day a week if we moved closer to them? I suspect if you moved in part because somebody promised something then rescinded it you would be very upset too. All very well being detached and objective on here.

People have a right to change their minds. Maybe they had them and realised it was too much for them to handle? Grandparents aren't automatically free babysitters

WestendGrrls · 07/03/2024 09:51

SmokedPaprikaPuffs · 07/03/2024 09:43

So odd that they just ignore messages instead of replying to say no. I'd find that really awkward.

My mum is a bit like this. I think she thinks the greater ill is saying anything remotely disagreeable or confrontational, so would prefer to be really rude and yes it is rather awkward.

Sotired22 · 07/03/2024 09:51

My in laws are similar and I get your frustration. Although in our case we didn’t move but get a lot of sly digs about us living sooo far away (about 45 minutes!). We live near my parents as they are very proactive in helping with the kids and are happy to do it. In laws couldn’t be less interested in helping, we get maybe one evening of babysitting a year and that feels like they don’t really want to do it. But lots of comments about us looking after them in old age….

I’ve backed off on making much effort with them and no I won’t be going out of my way to care for them in old age because they never go out of their way to help us now. I don’t expect regular childcare, just a willingness to help out a bit in the holidays or actually wanting to spend some time with their grandchildren, offer to babysit a few times a year so we can have an evening out, that’s all.

Crazycrazylady · 07/03/2024 09:49

Honestly I'm not someone who believes that grandparents should be on hand to babysit, mind kids at drop of hat. But this relationship seems to be all one way traffic. They only contact ye when they want something or to accept dinner. I'd still do thr occasional dinner invite but less often for your husbands sake but every time she dropped a hint about old age , I'd be dropping equal hits that it won't be happening .