Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of MIL

191 replies

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 09:22

4 years ago, when our oldest was a baby, we moved an hour away to be closer to MIL. One of the big pulls was that she said she wanted to spend more time with her grandchildren, felt jealous her friends had theirs just down the road and would be very happy to help us out with DD one or two days a week so we could keep childcare costs down.

So we moved and… crickets. She took DD for about an afternoon a week initially, then just stopped replying to texts when we messaged to ask about DD going over.

Since then (2 years later) a pattern has developed which is really pissing me off. I (against my better judgement) have continued to invite them for Sunday dinner every few weeks, which they always seem to be available and well for. They’re also always well and available on special days such as birthdays and Christmases, and make sure they ‘get their photos’ with the kids then. They’ll also randomly drop in, with no notice, every few weeks and grumble if we’re busy WFH (they still don’t seem to understand it doesn’t mean dossing about) or if we are about to go out somewhere. If I let them in they wind the kids up for an hour then leave after a cup of tea.

But whenever I message asking if they can watch one of the kids (we also now have a 1 year old) they either don’t reply at all or say they have a cold.

To pre empt the inevitable questions, no I don’t ask much maybe once every few weeks or so at most, I’ve gone a couple of months at a time not asking. They live a 7 minute drive away. They’re both retired and in good health - still doing sports, nights out, cruises etc. They ask for favours with DIY and lifts which DP usually does. When I ask if they can watch one of the kids it’s ALWAYS because I have something I need to do, I’ve never asked them to watch both kids at once, and by watching I mean literally sitting in the lounge playing with them for 1/2 hours after I’ve fed/changed them.

WIBU to just detach from them at this point and stop messaging, stop the Sunday lunch invitations and basically just go very very LC? We’ve had a really hard few weeks, and as usual my message asking if they could have DS for a couple of hours yesterday went ignored. However they’ve asked for an airport lift next week.

OP posts:
Caroparo52 · 07/03/2024 14:45

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 09:22

4 years ago, when our oldest was a baby, we moved an hour away to be closer to MIL. One of the big pulls was that she said she wanted to spend more time with her grandchildren, felt jealous her friends had theirs just down the road and would be very happy to help us out with DD one or two days a week so we could keep childcare costs down.

So we moved and… crickets. She took DD for about an afternoon a week initially, then just stopped replying to texts when we messaged to ask about DD going over.

Since then (2 years later) a pattern has developed which is really pissing me off. I (against my better judgement) have continued to invite them for Sunday dinner every few weeks, which they always seem to be available and well for. They’re also always well and available on special days such as birthdays and Christmases, and make sure they ‘get their photos’ with the kids then. They’ll also randomly drop in, with no notice, every few weeks and grumble if we’re busy WFH (they still don’t seem to understand it doesn’t mean dossing about) or if we are about to go out somewhere. If I let them in they wind the kids up for an hour then leave after a cup of tea.

But whenever I message asking if they can watch one of the kids (we also now have a 1 year old) they either don’t reply at all or say they have a cold.

To pre empt the inevitable questions, no I don’t ask much maybe once every few weeks or so at most, I’ve gone a couple of months at a time not asking. They live a 7 minute drive away. They’re both retired and in good health - still doing sports, nights out, cruises etc. They ask for favours with DIY and lifts which DP usually does. When I ask if they can watch one of the kids it’s ALWAYS because I have something I need to do, I’ve never asked them to watch both kids at once, and by watching I mean literally sitting in the lounge playing with them for 1/2 hours after I’ve fed/changed them.

WIBU to just detach from them at this point and stop messaging, stop the Sunday lunch invitations and basically just go very very LC? We’ve had a really hard few weeks, and as usual my message asking if they could have DS for a couple of hours yesterday went ignored. However they’ve asked for an airport lift next week.

How bloody annoying. I would be pissed off too. You took them at their word and they haven't followed through.
Although I presuming you did your homework that it would make sense financially to move nearer dPil everything else being equal.
Don't cut off your nose etc. Your kids will learn how to treat their own elderly parents from how you treat yours...
I would cut down the free sunday dinner invites and call them out on the lack of help forthcoming from them.
DPIL
I am confused why our infrequent requests for your help are not responded to in a timely manner.
You seem competent enough in technology when we invite you over for dinner or you need a favour, but you are very slow to respond or ignore us completely when we need you to do something for us...
This doesn't seem well balanced especially as you initially enthusiastically offered to help out with the children etc and that was a big factor in our decision to move here.
I thought it best to air this in the open because it's been on my mind and thought you should give your side of the situation...
Good luck.
If nothing changes then
definitely cut down the invites and don't rush round to help so quickly.
Obviously you have less spare time to help them as you are so busy sorting out arrangements in your own life and have no reliable backup...

hairbrush1234 · 07/03/2024 14:38

Just ignore the message asking for an airport lift, as she ignores your messages asking for help.

NoCloudsAllowed · 07/03/2024 14:37

By way of contrast, my grandmother was pushing 100 when she died. Right up to the end, she'd want to contribute what she was able to the family - she obviously got too old to do childcare but would knit cardies, save coupons for little toys, bake cakes for family gatherings etc.

Not because anyone demanded it but because the principle of giving as well as getting is important. In return, she got a stream of calls, visits, letters etc from grown up GC who she'd bothered to build a proper relationship with. And to see great GC as well.

mrsdineen2 · 07/03/2024 14:34

Kindly OP, I think you need to stop explaining yourself on this thread. It's clear that you were misled into a move with false promises and you've every right to be angry.

But I can guarantee you that up until this thread hits page 40, you're going to be plagued by arseholes throwing stones at you about "feeling entitled" who have either not read your posts, or have read it and are just miserable. Don't waste any more of your time repeating the same answers.

In the meantime, just ignore the airport text. Bonus points if you come up with an excuse linked to yesterday - e.g. The airport run clashes with the now rearranged appointment that you couldn't make yesterday.

OneSpunkySnake · 07/03/2024 14:29

Question: when you do ask for the occasional childcare, how much in advance do you ask?
To take it to extremes: if you ask just a few hours beforehand, they might indeed not be checking their phones.

If you ask weeks in advance and they respond to other things but not this, thats a whole different story.

And then there’s several intermediate shades in between.

Ariona · 07/03/2024 14:28

What does dh say to this?

OneSpunkySnake · 07/03/2024 14:26

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/03/2024 14:19

Maybe you should wait till they make a request for help and counter with your own? Or ask for help and offer Sunday lunch as thanks? Not quite tit for tat but reinforce that all one way is not acceptable.

Sounds like a very good idea:
“Oh you want X?
I’m totally tied up at the moment but if you could help with Y that would free up some time and I could do X for you”

TheDefiant · 07/03/2024 14:22

The flip side of this is I'm totally jealous of the amount of time your DCs grandparents spend with their DGC!

My own Dad (no Mum) lives minutes away from his grandchildren but barely sees them or speaks to them.

He's ill now but even when fit and healthy he made little or no effort.

Can you look at this positively about the good things for your DC while making some boundaries and also making sure the no care in future message is heard?

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/03/2024 14:19

Maybe you should wait till they make a request for help and counter with your own? Or ask for help and offer Sunday lunch as thanks? Not quite tit for tat but reinforce that all one way is not acceptable.

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 14:15

Zyq · 07/03/2024 14:07

OP, why is this all on MIL? Why does FIL get a free pass?

Because he never offered. Which is fair enough.

OP posts:
Starspangledrodeopony · 07/03/2024 14:12

It was an extraordinarily clear from the OP that the MIL had offered to provide childcare. So why do some posters deliberately pretend they haven’t seen that so they can lay into the OP for ‘expecting’ an ‘elderly’ woman to provide childcare. It’s so irritating.

Zyq · 07/03/2024 14:07

OP, why is this all on MIL? Why does FIL get a free pass?

thecatsthecats · 07/03/2024 14:04

Caveat emptor applies here.

My ILs talk a big game about helping with our son for childcare, but we know that really they would only want to do things on their own terms. (This is already evident whilst he's a baby - they say they want to fit in with us, but then when we say what works, they have other plans or don't want to meet so "early" - aka 11am!) Which is fine, but it doesn't suit us.

We'd much rather stick to paid childcare and a social grandparent relationship than be trapped in a cycle of resentment.

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/03/2024 13:59

Pleasehelpimexhausted · 07/03/2024 10:03

I doubt it, DD is NT, easy and the kind of kid who just wants to sit and colour. MIL hikes 1 day a week and FIL still does his sports so if sitting on a sofa with a cup of tea and occasionally saying ‘yes, very good, brilliant octopus’ is too much to handle I would be surprised.

When did I say they were automatically free babysitters out of interest?

Gosh, sounds so much easier than our 4 year old grandchild wants to play vets/doctors/zoos! Constantly! But we'll miss our day a week with them when they start school

pasturesgreen · 07/03/2024 13:55

They ignore your messages, you ignore theirs, easy. It can't always be on their terms only.

If DH wants to give them a lift to the airport, he can crack on if it suits. I'd put a stop to the Sunday lunches pronto.

Kim0566 · 07/03/2024 13:48

@LookItsMeAgain I was agreeing with PinkIceCream that it might be best to clear the air by talking.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/03/2024 13:42

Ah here they come now, not in their single spies but in battalions!

@MorningSunshineSparkles - the OP and her DH and then baby moved to be closer to his parents because his parents informed them that they would be willing to look after their grandchild but then, once they did move closer, that willingness disappeared.
@PinkIcedCream & @Kim0566 - As MiL, I'm guessing you never made a promise to your adult children and/or their spouses and then declined to follow through on those promises? That, and other things are happening to the OP. They played on the heartstrings of the OP and her DH saying that they were jealous that their neighbours had their children & grandchildren nearby and were more involved in those lives. However when the OP and DH moved nearby they weren't interested in being part of those lives. They also offered to look after their grandchild (as it was at the time) in order to help their son and his wife with childcare costs. This wasn't put forward by the OP or her DH as "Hey, if we move closer to you will you help us with childcare?".
They are also available for the "Disney Grandparent" stuff - the birthdays, celebrations but not available for an afternoon or a day to spend actual time with their grandchild??
They are fit and well for Sunday dinner but not for taking their grandchildren out for an hour?

@Pleasehelpimexhausted - pull back. Pull right back. But have that conversation with your DH before making some bigger moves.

whynotwhatknot · 07/03/2024 13:40

what does your dh say about all tis-does he feel obligated to help tem out or would consider cutting it down

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 07/03/2024 13:21

NoCloudsAllowed · 07/03/2024 10:52

So your oldest is about 5?

I'd move away to somewhere else before you're too settled in schools and friendship groups etc, you're sailing right into a big red trap labelled 'skivvy for elderly parents who couldn't be arsed helping you out when they were perfectly able'.

I can see why regular childcare might have fallen through, this can be much harder than people imagine with rosy-glow memories of what babies and toddler are like.

However, an hour with GC now and then shouldn't be too much, my PIL are not especially active or physically able but come and take GC for an afternoon, they bring lego sets and colouring books etc that they can do together without the need to be on the floor or jumping around.

I'd also make DH the main point of contact for them. They're taking the piss with airport lifts and DIY etc when they're perfectly able. A friend's ILs were like this, they became incredibly dependent and getting friend's DH to do things they could easily do themselves, eg to do online shopping they'd ring him, read out their shopping list and he'd have to choose the items for them. Or if a very simple job needed doing they could have called someone for, they'd call him instead and make him do it.

This! I’d move away quick sharp, they sound like they just want to lean on you more and more. Your eldest will be fine changing schools this young.

Also62 · 07/03/2024 13:19

Another one saying move further away again if you can/feel this would improve your lives. Looking ahead, they're only going to get more demanding.
What does your DH say?

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 07/03/2024 13:17

YeahIsaidit · 07/03/2024 09:46

I'm going to go LC with my inlaws because they won't babysit for me, lovely

They offered to do it, before they moved, likely to persuade them to move closer, now they refuse to do it for no other reason than they can’t be bothered. I would say that’s a good reason to be annoyed!

LocalHobo · 07/03/2024 13:16

You need to be clear, it is far better than fannying around and reaching stalemate with everyone unhappy about the situation.

"Can we have a lift to the airport please?"
"I think I will be able to give you a lift next Thursday provided you can have the DC on Wednesday so I can get on top of my admin"

"Is lunch still on for Sunday?"
"We'd love to see you. If it's ok I'll drop the DC in to you at 11 on Saturday on the way to purchase the ingredients. I'll only be a couple of hours"

I think they are self absorbed and probably see you seemingly managing without them. Tell them you need help.

it's usually children who have received support with their own childcare from GPs who become carers. But I don't have to worry about being a carer because you've had no support with childcare tinkly laugh"
Even this ^
It isn't tit for tat, it's caring, sharing and encouraging good relationships.

MikeRafone · 07/03/2024 13:14

before when they need your help - move away

Kim0566 · 07/03/2024 13:13

PinkIcedCream · 07/03/2024 12:58

From a MIL perspective…

It’s all well and good moaning on here (especially if it helps), but do you ever actually sit and have an honest talk with them about how you feel about the whole situation? I read a lot of MIL threads on here which I suspect could be solved if people actually talked to each other properly, instead of making assumptions based on their own take on life.

I have 2 DIL’s who have very different personalities, so I tend not to assume I know what they want from me. However, I don’t expect communication to come solely from the lads. They’re just as unlikely to know what DILs want sometimes when we’re trying to arrange things. 😂

Re: the text messages. Have you asked them why they don’t reply straightaway? My DH is not keen on technology so rarely bothers replying to people and never answers the landline phone. I usually reply pretty instantly assuming I’ve seen it.

Would MIL prefer telephone chats? I still have 1 hr weekly phone chats with my sister and SIL. It’s probably a generation thing as I don’t think either DIL has ever phoned for a chat although I don’t know if they ring their own mums regularly. The lads are not ones for phone chats but will do the occasional FaceTime. 🤔

Must admit the Sunday dinners at yours sound fabulous and I’m very envious. Is MIL a crap cook and too embarrassed to reciprocate? I do think they’re taking the piss a bit there unless they take you out for lunch occasionally.

I don’t blame you for wanting to reduce contact with them on your terms but I think you should at least try to talk to them both about why it’s come to a head. They could well be completely oblivious that you’re feeling so frustrated with them.

As a MIL I agree with this.

Also OP, where are your DH and FIL in all this? The men have some responsibility too in making sure messages are responded to etc.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 07/03/2024 13:03

You moved to be closer to your PIL, you see them regularly and your only gripe is they won’t watch the kids every few weeks. None of that is a reason to go NC or even LC. Your entitlement is staggering. People are allowed to change their minds on the amount of childcare they provide you and grandparents aren’t automatic babysitters, even if it’s only once every few weeks you ask them.