Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if the "Women take you for all you can get" thing is taking a deeper hold than ever?

130 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 07/03/2024 01:00

Two threads on MN in the last 24 hours about men out and out lying about bonuses or income. I have noticed a marked increase in this in recent months.

OK so there have always been men who will do this. Sadly financial abuse, selfishness and "whats mine is mine, whats yours is ours" has always happened but I cant help thinking that in recent years it has got worse. More men refusing to give the mother of their kids any sort of financial protection with marriage, shared home ownership or finances, etc yet slagging off a woman if she then in turn does the same.

My main hobby is playing poker, which is male dominated and there is one guy who I had quite a big row with when he said that his partner (refused to get married so he wouldnt "get taken to the cleaners") wouldnt share her significant inheritance with him and bought her own property with it because he wouldnt put her on the deeds of the home they live in (and that she has contributed to). Wouldnt see the double standard at all. He said that women have always done this so he was protecting himself, I said that its only because he wont give her anything that she has had to use her money to secure her future.

Has the "Andrew Tate" effect gone far further than is immediately obvious?

OP posts:
fabio12 · 07/03/2024 08:33

Mayorq · 07/03/2024 08:25

"More men refusing to give the mother of their kids any sort of financial protection with marriage, shared home ownership or finances, etc yet slagging off a woman if she then in turn does the same."

So exactly the same advice women on here with greater assets are given before cohabiting, buying a shares property or marrying

Who ends up with the kids and sacrificing their career though? I've not ever met a man who has been considerably put out by looking after his kids that he can't continue to work. There's a reason women will still need financial input from a man if they separate.

fabio12 · 07/03/2024 08:30

Tate does have a lot to do with it - I heard a stat that over half of young people didn't realise you can be raped within a marriage. I realised that it was actually Eastenders in the late 90s (?) that really bought it to the fore. I haven't watched that for years but those shows don't appear to be tackling societal topics any more, or maybe everyone's viewing is so fragmented with the internet it has little impact.

However I think this idea women take stems from child maintenance. It was a complete shock to me how few fathers do actually pay for maintenance for their children once things go sour. Gingerbread when I had DC showed that over two thirds of parents left with children (98% mums) had zero maintenance. Those figures have changed, but as someone who was pushed out by what became the CSM - they said I couldn't get my maintenance unless I did face to face mediation with my ex who was aggressive - I don't believe the figures have changed much, merely they've cut out a lot of women who weren't willing to endanger themselves for a pittance. Men magically go self employed when they don't want to pay for their kids and earnings drop considerably. Bosses allow them to hide money and far too many people pay cash in hand without considering they're taking food out of a child's mouth. It's always been there in a large section of society, but if you're lucky enough not to have had a relationship breakdown with kids and maintenance woes, it's been quite well hidden.

Mayorq · 07/03/2024 08:25

"More men refusing to give the mother of their kids any sort of financial protection with marriage, shared home ownership or finances, etc yet slagging off a woman if she then in turn does the same."

So exactly the same advice women on here with greater assets are given before cohabiting, buying a shares property or marrying

AuntieJoyce · 07/03/2024 08:22

I’ve also seen a few threads recently around older women and the men that are looking for a “nurse with a purse”. I suppose that’s the later in life equivalent. These women seem to be resisting marriage anyway because it’s not in their best interests financially. It’s just that the tables have turned.

I’m always surprised by the number of posters who bang on about how women should educate themselves that common law marriage doesn’t exist. When the men they are trying to marry who are resisting seem to know their rights perfectly well. Surely both had access to the same education. People hear what they want to hear, whether that’s Andrew Tate or the ticking of their biological clock.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 07/03/2024 08:21

I suspect it's simply that for most marriages, the husband is the higher earner, often because even when the wife earns similar amounts, it's the wife's career and earning potential that takes a hit when kids come along. Marriages rarely break up amicably, and there is often resentment on both sides - the higher earner at having to lose assets/income and the lower earning/SAHP who is now upset that the "agreement" of "you stay home and care for the kids/home, and I'll make sure that you are looked after financially" is broken.

Here on MN, a higher earning woman is urged by about half the posts "don't get married, he will be entitled to take your hard earned cash/a share of your house", yet it's viewed as a dreadful thing when a man does that.

If there were equal amounts of high earning women or the positions were reversed, I bet there would be a female equivalent of AT, sadly, because we are humans with all the failings and imperfections that result.

AstralSpace · 07/03/2024 08:20

What I see is women doing everything to keep the family together if things aren't going well in their relationship.
They often put up with a lot but usually won't put up with a betrayal where the husband has an affair.
The men are often the ones responsible for the breakdown of the marriage and the women initiate the separation or divorce because it has become literally unbearable for them.
It's actually quite easy for men to 'not be taken to the cleaners'. Be a responsible and considerate husband and father and keep sex within the marriage.

Zaxi · 07/03/2024 08:11

Sparklfairy · 07/03/2024 04:11

Why does the man automatically have to buy first?

Partly to show they're not the kind of man the OP is talking about.

Or rather, if he suggests or assumes we're going halves for a drink that cost a fiver or less, they're exactly the kind of man the OP is talking about.

As I said, dinner is different.

Is that clearer for you?

I'm going to say no, it's not clearer why does the man have to buy the first drink?

JudgeJ · 07/03/2024 08:11

Sparklfairy · 07/03/2024 04:11

Why does the man automatically have to buy first?

Partly to show they're not the kind of man the OP is talking about.

Or rather, if he suggests or assumes we're going halves for a drink that cost a fiver or less, they're exactly the kind of man the OP is talking about.

As I said, dinner is different.

Is that clearer for you?

As clear as the fog outside my bedroom window! If a woman buys first she is showing she is not the kind of woman men moan about, or are men not entitled to have an opinion?

Goldenbear · 07/03/2024 08:11

Goldenbear · 07/03/2024 07:58

You old romantic you! I feel very old reading that as yes, marriage is precisely about relinquishing control over your assets, as it is about uniting your lives, if a couple doesn't want to do that don't get married, it is not the commitment for them!

DH and I are early - mid 40s, when we met, mid twenties, I was visiting a friend and I lived 3 hours away. DH saw me out with said friend, he was with friends and asked me if I wanted a Mojito, he bought it, he asked! We all (his friends and mine) went back to his house share for more drinks, he persuaded me to stay for another day at my friends so that we could go out for dinner the next night, he bought the dinner and insisted on that, he then persuaded me to stay another day and another, he took me out for dinner every night! He had a good income but not very wealthy or anything. The rest is history, he has always been really generous though, his brother is younger, late 30s and is the same. We have both had inheritance, him slightly more than me but I sacrificed my career for a bit to care for our DC as he was still taking exams to qualify as an Architect, so working in the day, studying at night and the weekend. We saw this as all for each other, for our DC, it is a unit.

BellatrixLestranger · 07/03/2024 08:10

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 04:37

Equality goes both ways & it is interesting to see how women will pick & choose which aspects of equality are favourable & those which do not suit

Let's say a single woman with a career owns her home & had a good nest egg/pension

& she falls in love with a man with no assets or career

She may likely be advised by other women to not get married or have a watertight pre-nuptual agreement so as to protect her assets

It is not so uncommon in these modern times for women with a good career & husband who earns less to find themselves shocked that they will be owing maintenance to a man

It is also not so uncommon for a woman going through a divorce to be encouraged by other women or joke about taking her spouse "to the cleaners"

If women fought for equality, yet continue to fight beyond what is actually fair for both sexes

Then it stands to reason that we will see the emergence of men's rights activists as well

One could argue that the emergence of figures like Andrew Tate who speak about men's interests is true equality

And this is a perfect example of the lack of basic understanding of what equality actually means.

The reason women need more protection than men to even attempt to move towards equality is that we live in a patriarchal world where women are in constant danger (I know people do not like to accept this but it's true). Add to that the fact that women who have children then need even more protection as it impacts their health, their earning potential etc etc., plus the fact that there is still a significant sex pay gap, lack of adequate healthcare for women's health and so on, women need more financial protection than men.

So if a woman then enters a relationship with a man who has significantly fewer assets than she does, she absolutely should protect it at all costs, because let's face it, statistically speaking, the person who is most likely to abuse (including financial abuse) and kill her is her partner. Those are the facts.

AgnesX · 07/03/2024 08:02

Everyone, especially men, need to realise that once children enter the equation the goalposts change in terms of financial and physical effect and in the long run.

A family is the definition of a team yet so many think and do continue as they did before they were childless and then wonder why they're on the receiving end of a divorce.

A lack of generosity of spirit at the dating stage should be a warning bell. It works both ways though.

Starseeking · 07/03/2024 08:00

Sparklfairy · 07/03/2024 03:36

That thread the other day about stingy men on first dates was quite eye opening.

The majority of women don't want dinner in a flash restaurant for a first date. It's supposed to be quick so you can get out if there's no spark, with potential for a second coffee/drink or even date if you get on.

But a lot of posters were bleating about equality and going halves even for coffee. I mean ffs. If a man can't spring for a £3 americano or a (now £5 ugh) pint for me then he is not the man for me. It's a friendly gesture. I'll buy the next one, but if he doesn't buy the first, then nope, he's tight.

To be clear, dinner would be going halves. It's more unreasonable to expect a stranger to stump up £30/£50 or whatever, but £3?

They set the tone by expecting 50/50 from the start. That's not actually equal. Because there's give and take all the way through relationships, sometimes you're up, sometimes you're down. Theyre the sort that still want 50/50 when the woman is on maternity, or earning half his wage. If a man expects a woman to buy her own fucking drink but is still, let's face it, hopeful for her to put out at some point soon, then he's the one gaining.

All of this.

It's not unreasonable for women to enjoy a man spending £10 on a couple of coffees or whatever. It's 10!!! Or £20 or £30 or whatever. That's not breaking anyone's bank, or you shouldn't be dating. A man being willing to treat a woman does show a certain level of care.

One guy I went out for a drink with insisted on going for dinner as he hadn't eaten (the plan was only for drinks). At the end of the evening he'd "forgotten his wallet". There was no mention of him even paying me back half, yet he wanted to go for another date! I was so turned off by that behaviour.

Women are the ones having babies, and in a lot of households take on most of the domestic load. Women can't also be expected to bring 50% to the finances as well, so of course women should be looking for signs that a man is prepared to look after her, at least to some extent.

I say all that as a high earner, so it's not like I'm expecting anything I can't provide for myself, but a lot of women aren't in that position.

Humanswarm · 07/03/2024 07:58

You can't scream for equality and then bemoan someone not paying for a first date. It's that simple. Lines are blurred, and until people see the light, we're stuck with this them versus us narrative.

Goldenbear · 07/03/2024 07:58

Sunflowergirl1 · 07/03/2024 04:11

Ii will only comment on the reluctant marriage but and this applies increasingly to women as well, as evidenced by increasing threads of women refusing to marry partners, especially when they already have children with an ex.

What has driven this was a punitive divorce regime that developed in the 1990s/2000 whereby nearly all men where being left financially destitute by divorce, increasingly with large capital amounts including inheritance being handed to the ex (wife). I know of several such examples, but the system is evolving over years and now inheritance can sometimes be excluded, prenups developing etc. what is wrong is that the govt hasn't legislated (as encouraged to do so) and leaving it to judges to work through an unfair regime. England is the divorce capital of the world..why.

But hence this punitive regime drives behaviour. Exactly the same as the current existing punitive tax rates are driving behaviour of people cutting working hours, moving from Scotland to England etc. people put their head in the sand it doesn't happen and it very well does.

My cousin is one such point. High flyer, very well paid and significant assets now. His friend as a lawyer has over night out chats confirmed that getting married is akin to signing over assets within two years. A prenup helps but given disparity is limited protection...and basically advised the only protection is not to get married....which then leaves a partner (if they have kids) more vulnerable.

Create shit, punitive unfair divorce regimes that cost a fortune and only benefit lawyers and this is what you get.

You old romantic you! I feel very old reading that as yes, marriage is precisely about relinquishing control over your assets, as it is about uniting your lives, if a couple doesn't want to do that don't get married, it is not the commitment for them!

Olderthanthetrees · 07/03/2024 07:52

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 06:00

If a high earning man marries a woman who earns less & they divorce

Then a settlement in the wife's financial favour is not necessarily dependent upon having children in the mix

In many cases women will choose not to climb the corporate ladder & have high flying careers because of a preference to have a work life balance & be at home at home more with our children

In situations where wives do have well paid careers and the husband is an even higher earner

Does this mean those wives should not be financially compensated at the expense of the husband in a divorce?

Times have changed and in the courts increasingly, settlements that are favourable to women from high earning men, are indeed geared towards children. It depends on the individual situation.

By saying women choose not to climb the corporate ladder you blithely ignore years of misogynistic business practice and the glass ceiling. Thankfully things are improving but to assume both sexes have an equal playing field in 2024 is nonsense.

You also ignore the fact that women are still doing far more child care and domestic work in the home than men, even when both parties work the same hours, in every earning situation. Work in the home is necessary and under valued precisely because it is viewed as women’s work. As is the mental load of running a home and managing children’s activities.

wherethecrawmumsings · 07/03/2024 07:49

araiwa · 07/03/2024 05:26

Many mnetters seem to have swallowed the red pill too

Any post regarding any sort of domestic disharmony will result in many posts suggesting to stop sex and take him for every penny

I've never, ever seen a post suggesting this.

Only ever LTB.

Moobz · 07/03/2024 07:48

The men that are talked about on MN are not the type of men at all that I know in real life. All the men I know are good decent hard working family men who love their wife and kids. I mean I know anything can be going on in the background with regards to cheating etc, but that's not what this post is about. I dont know anyone who refused to marry, or is a dickhead over finances etc.

Bumpitybumper · 07/03/2024 07:41

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 07:08

We are indeed increasingly lacking the value of real human connection,

Many women are being told that careers are the key to happiness & that children are a burden, rather than being told about the joy & meaning there is in having a family.

In regards to capitalism, most people are not entrepreneurial capitalists, but are just trying to cope financially

Cost of living is putting pressure on people, causing them to focus much more on money as it brings day to day stress

Those that are doing OK financially understandably still want to still do better to enjoy a comfortable life in retirement

Your grandparents lived in an era where marrying their high school sweetheart was a social norm

Grandads were expected to work hard & support their wives financially

Grandmas were expected to take pride in home + family & support their husbands domestically

Many women in Grandma's era also worked, but it was not a social expectation for women to act like men, to be the primary earner & focus on making her own money the way women are expected to support themselves financially now

Society was once structured so that the average family could get by on one income & men + women had different, complementary roles so that they could win at life as a team

The foundation of such long partnerships was built on mutual respect & trust

If men were traditionally the primary income earners & women now expect to compete with men

Then it stands to reason that as a society we will both become increasingly competitive, more focused on finances & obsessed with protecting our own independent wealth

I agree with you but I think it's sad that the emphasis on the individual seems to be engrained in society now. If it's dog eat dog, even when it comes to your spouse then there isn't really a concept of partnership or cooperation at all. It is simply more efficient and easier to work together towards shared goals and it is really difficult to do this effectively whilst still guaranteeing your individual financial position. This is why marriage can be helpful as it's a legal recognition that resources and finances have been pooled and it is a great springboard to roll with the changes that life brings. Children, ill health, aging parents... All of these can be prioritised at different times with the knowledge that you have the security of someone else having your back.

I fear we will all be sadder and poorer as a society of individuals. People will be reluctant to take on any dependents so they won't have much longed for children or be able to care for the old and vulnerable in society because it is too financially risky to do this. We can optimise finances as a team and maximise strengths and weaknesses. Everyone will plod along doing everything exactly equally just in case it all goes wrong .

Lovingthegrungerevival · 07/03/2024 07:41

If these men don’t want to give assets to the mother of their children upon divorce why don’t they marry women with equal earning power who don’t become SAHMs?

From what I see, more men are doing this or at least intending to do so.

Beefcurtains79 · 07/03/2024 07:40

C1N1C · 07/03/2024 06:55

I think it's because there's no guarantee in marriage anymore, it's so fluid. Women initiate the majority of divorces, is it any wonder why men want to protect themselves?

In the past, marriage meant together forever with a difficult divorce process. It made sense to share finances.

Nowadays, a woman can marry someone rich, get divorced five minutes later and get half. It's even worse if the husband is super rich (say, Paul McCartney) where a massive fortune is hers for simply existing as a wife. Is she 'more' of a wife than Mary down the road?

“Nowadays, a woman can marry someone rich, get divorced five minutes later and get half.”

No they can’t! Did you read that on Reddit? 😂

FOJN · 07/03/2024 07:38

C1N1C · 07/03/2024 06:55

I think it's because there's no guarantee in marriage anymore, it's so fluid. Women initiate the majority of divorces, is it any wonder why men want to protect themselves?

In the past, marriage meant together forever with a difficult divorce process. It made sense to share finances.

Nowadays, a woman can marry someone rich, get divorced five minutes later and get half. It's even worse if the husband is super rich (say, Paul McCartney) where a massive fortune is hers for simply existing as a wife. Is she 'more' of a wife than Mary down the road?

Your contempt for women is evident throughout your post.

How dare women initiate divorce. Poor men, they really should plan to protect themselves from women who aren't prepared to put up with a bad marriage.

You contradict yourself in your last paragraph. You say women get half of man's assets even if the marriage is short (they don't) and then use the example of Paul McCartney to prove it's even worse for very rich men. Paul McCartney had a net worth of hundreds of millions (about 750 iirc) and Heather Mills got 20 million. Now I don't have a degree in maths but that is not even close to 50%. She also didn't "simply exist as a wife", they had a child together.

Begsthequestion · 07/03/2024 07:37

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 06:00

If a high earning man marries a woman who earns less & they divorce

Then a settlement in the wife's financial favour is not necessarily dependent upon having children in the mix

In many cases women will choose not to climb the corporate ladder & have high flying careers because of a preference to have a work life balance & be at home at home more with our children

In situations where wives do have well paid careers and the husband is an even higher earner

Does this mean those wives should not be financially compensated at the expense of the husband in a divorce?

What country are you referring to?

Alimony is a US thing. Doesn't exist in the UK.

Beefcurtains79 · 07/03/2024 07:35

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 04:37

Equality goes both ways & it is interesting to see how women will pick & choose which aspects of equality are favourable & those which do not suit

Let's say a single woman with a career owns her home & had a good nest egg/pension

& she falls in love with a man with no assets or career

She may likely be advised by other women to not get married or have a watertight pre-nuptual agreement so as to protect her assets

It is not so uncommon in these modern times for women with a good career & husband who earns less to find themselves shocked that they will be owing maintenance to a man

It is also not so uncommon for a woman going through a divorce to be encouraged by other women or joke about taking her spouse "to the cleaners"

If women fought for equality, yet continue to fight beyond what is actually fair for both sexes

Then it stands to reason that we will see the emergence of men's rights activists as well

One could argue that the emergence of figures like Andrew Tate who speak about men's interests is true equality

What about when they have children?

anothernamitynamenamechange · 07/03/2024 07:29

But also the attitufe of:

"Woman are naturally homemakers. There is nothing wrong with this. In fact, it is just as noble and important as going out to work. If ONLY women hadn't been conned into wanting careers/not valuing their role of homemakers"
turns into
"Waaaah, the wife wants 50% of the man's assets despite the fact that he did all the work and she stayed home"

And no, going back to a world where the woman just stayed home will not magically lead to "women's work" being just as respected (it never was in reality). That makes as much sense as the theory that just defunding the police will naturally bring down crime. Its magical thinking.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/03/2024 07:27

He's a shit poker player if he couldn't work out that his girlfriend had the better hand.