Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my hairdresser behaved unprofessionally?

132 replies

JasmineJewels · 06/03/2024 20:43

I went to the hairdresser for a half head of highlights this week. I am naturally dark blonde but like to brighten my hair up. For years I box dyed my hair with the baby blonde nice & easy kit and it looked fine but now I go to the salon a few times a year and do it myself in between.

This hairdresser has done my highlights a few times over the last year and half. It had been several months since I’d been to her and I’d been away on holiday so I’d used a box dye in the meantime because I wanted to blend the regrowth.

On the day of the appointment, I sat in the chair and she started looking through my hair and asked if I’d used something on it since the last time. I told her I’d used box dye but only on the hairline and roots and her whole manner changed. She became very irritable with me and started basically telling me off. She started saying things like ‘I wish you wouldn’t put box dye on it because it’s so hard to lift for me! You should always wait and have it done professionally.’

I was taken aback because the box dye wasn’t that apparent. It had faded a lot and to be honest, I don’t have the money to go to the salon every time I have some regrowth. She made me feel like a scolded child and I was upset because I get a bit anxious anyway when I go to the hairdressers and she made me feel like I did something wrong. I pay a lot of money to have my hair done and I expect to feel relaxed, not uncomfortable.

Do you think she was tone deaf to say this in the middle of a cost of living crisis? Not everyone has the money to pay £70+ for their hair every 6 weeks. I understand it can be frustrating when clients use box dye but I didn’t find her reaction very professional.

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 08/03/2024 09:28

My hairdresser is a friend. I do not pay for my hair to be done, so no matter of cost or them trying to drum up repeat business, yet their biggest fear is box dyes because if the uncertain results when they go over them.

MarkWithaC · 08/03/2024 09:06

mcmooberry · 08/03/2024 08:44

Glad to hear you aren't going back, she could have said the same thing but nicely and retained you as a customer.

Exactly this. It's not really about whether box dyes are bad/how much extra work it takes the hairdresser. It's the way she behaved.

As a professional you have choices: you can huff and puff and behave as if a client and their actions are a nuisance, or you can calmly and clearly make them aware of what the issues are and what fixing them might take/cost etc, then work with them to the best of your ability, for a fair and transparent cost, and with their ongoing understanding and agreement.

I don't spend money with anyone who is in the former category.

mcmooberry · 08/03/2024 08:44

Glad to hear you aren't going back, she could have said the same thing but nicely and retained you as a customer.

Pudmyboy · 08/03/2024 07:57

FleurdeLiane · 08/03/2024 03:17

It's hard to apply on yourself. You have more risk of getting on your scalp which is an allergy risk, and of going over the hair again and again creating dense matt colour on the ends which looks odd.

Newer dyes seem more gentle and they are getting easier to apply (thicker product, non-drip, pleasant smell, larger aftercare conditioner included).
Hairdressers need to do allergy tests too so should be getting you to pop in for a dab of colour behind your ear 48 hrs prior to the appointment. Though that has happened to me just once or twice!
I've been dying my hair at home for years and not had any problems as long as I pick a brand with no ammonia and follow the instructions

Padz · 08/03/2024 07:57

I hate going to the hairdressers for this exact reason.

JanewaysBun · 08/03/2024 07:18

Aveda salon made me sign a waiver that the colour might not come out as evenly as expected on the box dyed bits.

Tbf my friend usually does my hair and also really hates me putting box dye on, she prefers me to use that root spray that washes out so I have an even base.

mummyh2016 · 08/03/2024 07:17

Plus highlights normally means foils or cap. I presume you slapped it on your roots instead like an all over colour? Completely different look doing that compared to highlights so even if the colour matched she probably had to put more foils into break up the block caused by the box colour.

mummyh2016 · 08/03/2024 07:15

I'm a qualified hairdresser. You either need to use box colours all the time or get a hairdresser to colour all the time. You can't mix and match between the two, you're basically expecting your hairdresser to do a colour correction at every appointment, I presume you weren't charged for a colour correction?
I don't work in the industry anymore but the amount of work stylists had after lockdown was lifted due to box colours was ridiculous.

kalokagathos · 08/03/2024 07:15

Mine also tells me off ....

OooohAhhhh · 08/03/2024 07:02

I think she could have phrased it differently so as to not upset you.
To be fair my hairdresser also told me to stop using box dyes, as it's not the same as salon products and can interfere with their colouring process. I had an all over head colour a while back and because I'd been dying my own roots I had a halo effect because their dye never took to that part of my hair properly. I now use the L'Oréal temporary root sprays inbetween appointments.

Manthide · 08/03/2024 06:52

I had my hair dyed last week. I try and go as long as possible between visits as I can't really afford it and I didn't get on well with box colours during lockdown. This time I went 4 months which was a bit too long for me. I do get my hair cut in between. My hairdresser is always perfectly polite. Last week I mentioned dm had had to box dye her hair as she couldn't get an appointment (we have the same hairdresser) and she didn't bat an eyelash! She 'only' charges £62 for a cut and colour.

Beautiful3 · 08/03/2024 06:50

I agree with you. I've stopped getting highlights too. I dye it myself now. I supported a student at a salon. They did get annoyed when a client had previously used a box dye, when they wanted highlights. It's hard for them to lift and might not turn out blonde but red, also uneven. They use a stronger bleach and leave on for longer, while checking it. If it didnt lift right theyd have to put something in all over to lift out the colour. So it's more damaging for your hair.

FleurdeLiane · 08/03/2024 03:17

pootlin · 07/03/2024 10:56

Do box dyes really ruin hair? I'm getting a few greys so was tempted to try it but now not so sure.

It's hard to apply on yourself. You have more risk of getting on your scalp which is an allergy risk, and of going over the hair again and again creating dense matt colour on the ends which looks odd.

Scorchio84 · 08/03/2024 01:29

I'm a brunette so maybe this doesn't really affect me as much than if I was a blonde but honestly I don't think in all my years paying (with time as well as money) I've ever had a good hairdressing experience? Never the right shade, told many times Ombre or Balayage couldn't be done this time with no alternative suggested, the cut inevitably ends with layers despite my aversion to them, lots of judgy comments, getting the head pulled off me & then always the hard sell of some wonder product... massive pain in the arse & so stressful

My sons nana goes to a lovely hairdresser who works from home & despite the "middle aged MIL hair" connotations I'm tempted to go to her next time

PawsisShady · 08/03/2024 00:54

Humptydumptybounced · 07/03/2024 07:16

Your hairdresser has a point (but could have been more tactful).

I have a friend who is a Podiatrist and they tell me that they get fed up with people using corn paste/razor blades/woodwork rasps etc on their feet, making a right mess and then expecting it to be put right in one treatment!

These clients want to save money bit it costs them more in the long run because they need more treatments to sort it out.

"Pay cheap, pay twice" as they say....

I went for an appointment after my dad. Explains why she was so impressed with my feet. I got "you put foot cream on every night?!" and lots of praise on my no hard skin

End of the appointment she says "now can you have a word with your dad and tell him what to do because you didn't get your foot care advice from him" Grin

Blondiegirll · 08/03/2024 00:53

Just don’t go back. I can understand why they don’t want you to use box dyes as they then have to put chemical on top of the chemical that you’ve used and the outcome may not be as good as expected. Having said that you are not paying for a lecture and being made to feel small.

I recently had my colour done, cost me £107. I mentioned that it was a bit dark. They said fine, we’ll put a few more highlights through when you come back for a cut and mentioned it may cost about £20. When I went back they charged me £75! So all together I paid £182. I was shocked as they know that I try and keep the price down even having the cut done by a junior. I didn’t say much except when they tried to book me in again I said that I needed time to recover from this one! It’s a shame as I am happy with my hair but definitely won’t be going back and will be looking for a new hairdresser.

PlumbersWifey · 08/03/2024 00:49

Crazycrazylady · 06/03/2024 20:56

To be fair my hairdresser hated it when I use box dye as well. She huffs and puffs and tells me it's really bad for my hair
Think it's fairly standard that hair dressers hate them tbh .

Nope. We just want you to pay us instead to be honest. Same stuff we use.

mkwar · 08/03/2024 00:47

I'm a hair dresser myself and yes she could have worded it better, but box dye is incredibly temperamental and can be hard to lift or can cause lasting damage to your hair, it's frustrating for hairdressers as it can put our quality of work at risk meaning you could leave unhappy as we can't achieve the colour you would like sometimes due to previous colour you might have applied to your hair, which could result in you spending more money. It's not always about getting the repeat custom. That's in my opinion and experience anyway x

Sleepydoor · 08/03/2024 00:04

Everyone who is saying they get great results with box dyes ABU -- because you're not leaving details about what you are using. Spill please.

Brand, colour/number, pics...

tattygrl · 07/03/2024 23:04

I think this was rude of her, yes. You're right to pick up on how it made you feel, and that that's not how you want to feel at a (luxurious, non-essential) salon visit. The science of hair dye and treatment is by the by to be honest. If working on box-dyed hair is a dealbreaker for that stylist she needs to say so, not admonish and tell off her clients.

My hairdresser is fantastic and just takes my hair as it is, and we work together to formulate a plan for the result I want. He explains if it will take longer for any particular reason, and treats me with respect and the appropriate level of light-heartedness. It's hair, not anything essential! They need to appreciate that they've got people willing to come to them and lay out hundreds of quid on something we could definitely get by without.

RebeccaCloud9 · 07/03/2024 22:51

Ugh, hairdressers make such a big deal of it. I'm sorry but if you're charging me £40 for a semi permanent toner every few weeks, I've got no other choice if I want to cover my greys! It's always felt like a sales tactic to me, to shame me into going back more regularly.

Grimchmas · 07/03/2024 22:46

Using box dyes complicates the chemistry for the hairdresser, particularly when lightening the hair is involved. You'd blame them if what they did on top of the unknown box dye product damaged your hair or made it a horrible colour.

I'd either do 100% box dye or 100% hairdresser dye whoever cuts your hair for you, to be honest.

Nigglenaggle · 07/03/2024 22:42

She was a bit direct but honestly, this is a small thing. Why get yourself worked up about it? Let it go and move on!

Wobblysausage · 07/03/2024 21:35

Box dye is really unpredictable and difficult to remove plus using a block colour on highlights creates a band that’s hard to rectify. Some stylist charge for colour correction in these situations and that’s expensive so you’re lucky she still does it as highlights and doesn’t charge you extra.

Also people mentioning they say box dyes are bad because they want to make more money, that’s bull shit. They’re doing extra work and it takes up more of their time so essentially losing money! Why should they lose out because you’ve messed about with your hair.

Mememe9898 · 07/03/2024 21:21

It’s not ideal but that’s up to you what you want to do. I rarely colour my hair because I refuse to have to pay over £100 on a regular basis to get my hair done. Not that I can’t afford it but I just don’t find the point of spending that much money on my hair.
Ive managed to find a home based hairdresser to do my hair these days who’s so much cheaper than the salon