Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Elphame · 07/03/2024 18:48

Garlicking · 07/03/2024 01:18

I've gone off Spector and the whole Zoe thing. I was very engaged with it during the Covid tracking and quite interested in the gut biota / diet initiative, but it's become increasingly like a cult. Zoe's all high-pressure selling and Spector's gone off the rails, imo.

I watched a couple of his recent videos last week. He was bullshitting. Enthusing all over the place about 'science' where the actual science doesn't back his statements, and misdirecting the scientists he interviewed so they never got to make their actual points. He only seems to like interviewees who reflect his bouncy, boyish, bullshit energy.

It happens. Again during the beginning of Covid, I was a big fan of John Campbell. He started off analysing the available data in sensible ways, maybe a little facile at times but basically solid and made things easy for people to understand. Then he went all anti-vax conspiracy theorist, getting more absurd as his YouTube revenues increased. I suppose it's unrealistic to expect people not to follow the money, even if it leads them on to treacherous ground.

Anyway: I'm a nutrition bore and no, I'm not fretting about UPFs. I make the vast majority of my food at home - and I use "scary" ingredients like flour improvers (wheat gluten, ascorbic acid), different sugars, citric acid, MSG and xanthan gum, plus anything else I think will get the desired result. I actually prefer supermarket multigrain bread to my own and, if I had the right machinery, would happily pump carbon dioxide through my dough to get an even crumb!

Practically all food is processed. Processing our food is what enabled humans to evolve and to develop communities that could sustain population growth. "Ultra" processing suggests a loss of nutrition: that is true of some things you already know are nutritionally impoverished, like cheese string. But what the hell's supposed to be wrong with pizza??

Here's the ingredients list for ready-salted crisps: Potatoes, Vegetable Oils (Sunflower, Rapeseed, in varying proportions), Salt, Antioxidants (Rosemary Extract, Ascorbic Acid, Tocopherol Rich Extract, Citric Acid).
Not evil. (Ascorbic acid = Vitamin C; Tocopherol = Vitamin E)
I love 'em!

Those crisps are far from squeaky clean.

Unless you are buying the super premium ranges, the oils will be produced industrially using a solvent (usually hexane) to extract the oil, as well as other chemical processes to remove the hexane and refine and deodorise the oil. Hexane is a petrochemical and a known neurotoxin.

There is a lot of ultra processing going on behind even the ingredients that sound natural. The rosemary extract - well that's made with acetone ( nail varnish remover) or a similar solvent.

I went right off chip shop chips when I discovered what they add to the water to stop the chips discolouring before cooking

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 18:45

Allfur · 07/03/2024 18:39

If upfs increase risk of obesity then it follows it increases risk of cancer

But again - which UPFs? The term covers a huge range of products. Which additives, processes, ingredients etc cause the risk?

Like I keep saying the advice to eat more fruit and veg, cook from scratch etc is good and long-established, but filing massive proportions of our diet under one term is something we should be careful about IMO.

bryceQ · 07/03/2024 18:42

I think I eat pretty low processed my fridge is literally just fruit, veg, meat and cheese / dairy.

The items I eat which are UPF I'm okay with allowing eg I often eat ramen noodles at lunch with some veg and a sauce I make from soy, chilli, miso and peanut butter. It's easy at lunchtime when I'm short on time.

On a sat night we might share some total rubbish crisps, again... I feel like this is okay. I don't drink alcohol, 90% drink plain water. I buy proper bakery bread. Cook mostly from scratch. Even our take aways are stuff like Vietnamese Pho rather than domino.

Allfur · 07/03/2024 18:39

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 18:03

Is it just "UPFs" though? Surely it's particular ingredients or processes - nitrates in processed meat being an obvious example that does have evidence showing we should avoid.

Just saying "UPFs increase the risk of cancer" is very very vague indeed and I'm sceptical about the evidence

If upfs increase risk of obesity then it follows it increases risk of cancer

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 07/03/2024 18:38

LasEva · 07/03/2024 18:25

Seriously, what's the point of engaging like this?

Who are the chunk you are describing then? Elaborate.

LasEva · 07/03/2024 18:32

As pp have pointed out, it's all the in detail. Headlines about UPFs are important: there has to be way of getting the message across, but it's down to the individual to get granular about it and do some research about individual foods. There are conflicting areas of interest that are muddying the waters in terms of published research. The advice about avoiding foods with long lists of non-domestic ingredients is sound, imo.

Mothership4two · 07/03/2024 18:30

There is growing concern about UPFs and so I have been happy to cut them out of our diet. It wasn't hard and we feel/look better.

LasEva · 07/03/2024 18:25

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 07/03/2024 16:20

That ‘chunk of the population’ - are they the thick, poor people?

Seriously, what's the point of engaging like this?

nightmareXmas · 07/03/2024 18:06

Regarding the cancer risk, it may be because a diet high in junk food is more likely to lead to obesity and be associated with other bad habits. But the messaging is usually over-simplified, much as it is with alcohol.

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 18:03

Mothership4two · 07/03/2024 17:53

@ColleenDonaghy

Is it proven that UPFs cause an increase in cancer?

I'm not saying that it won't ultimately be proven to be true, but I'm sceptical that it has already been proven.

No, you are right it hasn't. There is a growing body of evidence that it does and it is still early days in this area. Several studies have shown a link between higher rates of cancer and UPF. I am sure manufacturers who supply UPFs aren't happy about this being exposed.

Having lived through many health risks that later become proven (usually after rumbling on for several years), I choose to avoid these. I do understand that some people may prefer to wait until it is categorically proven to be the case.

Is it just "UPFs" though? Surely it's particular ingredients or processes - nitrates in processed meat being an obvious example that does have evidence showing we should avoid.

Just saying "UPFs increase the risk of cancer" is very very vague indeed and I'm sceptical about the evidence

Mothership4two · 07/03/2024 17:53

@ColleenDonaghy

Is it proven that UPFs cause an increase in cancer?

I'm not saying that it won't ultimately be proven to be true, but I'm sceptical that it has already been proven.

No, you are right it hasn't. There is a growing body of evidence that it does and it is still early days in this area. Several studies have shown a link between higher rates of cancer and UPF. I am sure manufacturers who supply UPFs aren't happy about this being exposed.

Having lived through many health risks that later become proven (usually after rumbling on for several years), I choose to avoid these. I do understand that some people may prefer to wait until it is categorically proven to be the case.

Allfur · 07/03/2024 17:43

So what's the answer then? A bit of everything? Less upf, less junk food, more exercise, more active travel, fewer cars etc

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 17:40

Mmm fudge.

samarrange · 07/03/2024 17:39

Well spotted. Lovely faux-science fudging there 😂

@Garlicking You know those bunches of perfect organic green beans that come in from Kenya in the (UK) winter? A few years back some CO2-conscious people said, er, well, maybe they are organic but they're being flown in by air, so we're trading one form of environmental damage for another. So the CO2 people and the organic people sat down and decided that these beans could be sold as organic, but only if they were also Fairtrade certified. Now there are lots of political arguments that can be made for this, but it's nonsense as science.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 17:28

Garlicking · 07/03/2024 17:20

producing cheap food by making basic ingredients into slurry’s which can be manipulated to make any shape, taste any way, look like anything you want, are cheap, affordable and convenient

you don’t get this in rural countries which have poor infrastructure

Let me introduce you to dhal 😂

😂
Has anyone invented Dhal Dinosaurs and Dhal Twizzlers yet?

Garlicking · 07/03/2024 17:20

Menora · 07/03/2024 17:11

I will say it again, obesity is high because manufacturing processes evolved very rapidly mass producing cheap food by making basic ingredients into slurry’s which can be manipulated to make any shape, taste any way, look like anything you want, are cheap, affordable and convenient

you don’t get this in rural countries which have poor infrastructure because the food cannot easily be transported there

The huge industrial machinery put landowners and farmers, pickers, factory workers, shop workers etc out of work. They all went to work with the machines or driving the goods around instead of the jobs they used to do which were far more physical.

They go together

Edited

producing cheap food by making basic ingredients into slurry’s which can be manipulated to make any shape, taste any way, look like anything you want, are cheap, affordable and convenient

you don’t get this in rural countries which have poor infrastructure

Let me introduce you to dhal 😂

Dal - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dal

Waittobeconnected · 07/03/2024 17:15

I have come across a lot of publicity and information on UPFs and I have not gone looking for it.

I have been a bit more aware when I’ve been buying food and trying to make an effort to cook more and add fresh veg to meals for example.

I watched a feature on This Morning some time ago (Holly was on it) and the ‘expert’ said, if you eat one piece of bread every day, take it down to one piece once a month 😐. I was horrified as I love bread and generally eat it every day. Anyway I have tried to cut down my bread intake as it doesn’t always agree with me and I think it’s a good thing for my health.

It makes sense to eat more fresh food and my teen dc would live on takeaways if they could so eating less processed food at home will definitely help them.

nightmareXmas · 07/03/2024 17:14

I've just been reading on Sky News about the microplastics that have apparently found their way into all of our food and water (and air), thereby significantly increasing the risk of death from stroke and heart attack.

Somehow I think my tofu habit is going to be the least of my problems in terms of living a long and healthy life.

Menora · 07/03/2024 17:11

I will say it again, obesity is high because manufacturing processes evolved very rapidly mass producing cheap food by making basic ingredients into slurry’s which can be manipulated to make any shape, taste any way, look like anything you want, are cheap, affordable and convenient

you don’t get this in rural countries which have poor infrastructure because the food cannot easily be transported there

The huge industrial machinery put landowners and farmers, pickers, factory workers, shop workers etc out of work. They all went to work with the machines or driving the goods around instead of the jobs they used to do which were far more physical.

They go together

BarrelOfOtters · 07/03/2024 17:11

UPF's have been around since the eighties - as have lots of other things that have a negative impact on people's health.

Ooh Findus crispy pancakes...😍Misses point of thread.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 07/03/2024 17:10

Allfur · 07/03/2024 17:01

You are right, there are other factors but my lifestyle is as active as it was 20 years ago, if not more so

But society as a whole has become much less active. It's not about individual people, it's about entire countries.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 07/03/2024 17:08

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 17:05

It won’t be solely, but the obesity rates rising do track the introduction of UPFs very convincingly. That’s what they found in the Brazilian studies.

UPF's have been around since the eighties - as have lots of other things that have a negative impact on people's health. Things like more working parents, longer working hours, the increased use of cars, the fact that people do less exercise etc.

Saying "it's all down to UPF's" is too simplistic and ignores all the other negative changes in the society in the last forty odd years.

Garlicking · 07/03/2024 17:06

kikisparks · 07/03/2024 08:36

Interesting that that article says “But from a processing standpoint, there is really no difference between oat milk creme fraiche and your standard dairy ice-cream, or a frozen beef burger patty and a burger made from soy protein.”

Yet this article from the Guardian (backed by research) says

“plant-based alternatives to meat products also got the all-clear. They are “not associated with risk of multimorbidity”, said the authors.”

but

”regular consumption of meat products – such as sausages – and sugary drinks make it more likely that someone will get those diseases.”

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/nov/13/some-ultra-processed-foods-are-good-for-your-health-who-backed-study-finds

So health wise plant based UPFs are better than animal based UPFs.

Edited

Well spotted. Lovely faux-science fudging there 😂

Oat milk's as good as milk milk, factory-created = very bad.

Here are the ingredients of Alpro oat milk:
Oat base (96.6%) (Water, Oat (9.8%)), Soluble corn fibre, Sunflower oil, Calcium (Tri-calcium phosphate), Sea salt, Stabiliser (Gellan gum), Vitamins B2, B12, D2.

Ingredients of milk milk:
Milk.

”Regular consumption of meat products – such as sausages – and sugary drinks make it more likely that someone will get those diseases.”

See how they put MEAT AND SUGAR in the same category? They're not the same category, are they. Well, not unless the only thing you eat is gammon cooked in Coke.

You could just as easily say "Regular consumption of water - flat or fizzy - and heroin makes it more likely that someone will get diseases."

Also, have you noticed that "meat" is usually followed by "such as sausages and bacon"? That's because both are processed (even traditionally) using ingredients that might be harmful if taken to excess over a long period, and are very fatty if you fry them. Basic raw meat doesn't contain anything odd (in the UK/EU; some US meat does).

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 17:05

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 07/03/2024 17:02

I agree, but I don't think it's solely down to UPF.

It won’t be solely, but the obesity rates rising do track the introduction of UPFs very convincingly. That’s what they found in the Brazilian studies.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 07/03/2024 17:02

Sususudio · 07/03/2024 17:00

Supermarkets across the world may now be full of them. But I don't think too many Koreans or Japanese eat UPF as 56% of their calories. And of course, there are complex reasons for that. Fewer women working full time, etc etc. But still.... I think there is a reason obesity is so high in the UK, US and Australia.

I agree, but I don't think it's solely down to UPF.