Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Garlicking · 08/03/2024 18:08

Menora · 08/03/2024 17:24

It’s concerning that anyone questioning the safety and ethics of the food industry and how our food is created and processed is seen as ‘a cult’. There is a lot of money holding up the economy in these companies so they will be going to extreme lengths to provide fund and promote to assist with debunking. It came out after the aspartame information that the American beverage association were paying health care professionals to ‘debunk’ safety concerns about aspartame in drinks. But hey, if you see big food as the good guys here crack on 😂

See, that's hyperbole. Fixating on something called UPF is not "questioning the safety and ethics of the food industry". It's a single, ill-defined part of it that's been puffed into - well, a belief system.

One of the reasons I was keen to stay in the EU was because of its food regulations. Like I said upthread, I'm a nutrition bore and very concerned about the safety and ethics of food production/manufacturing. I know so much about it that I could probably write a decent text book.

Back when I could afford to be a purist, my diet was 90% "real food": minimally processed, almost all organic. This is what some posters on this thread are aiming for. But latching on to a "bad food" acronym won't deliver. UPF is an ill-defined term that, on Spector's word, doesn't include all pre-sale processing. He hasn't offered a clear list or evaluation protocol saying what UPF is or isn't, however. It's smoke and incantations.

Remember all the panic about E numbers? This is worse than that - you can look up an E-number, but anyone can tell you any old shit about UPFs and there's no definitive source to check!

LasEva · 08/03/2024 18:04

Garlicking · 08/03/2024 16:58

I can see why you say that, but it seems to me that the Bible is an appropriate metaphor. The UPF thing, like most successful diet fads/movements, has quickly become cult-like.

Offering counter-arguments to factually questionable beliefs isn't an attempt to debunk the whole concept - that would be something like "there are no UPFs" or even "all UPFs are good for you". Nobody's said any of that here.

But it's a characteristic of cult members that they take any disparagement, of any aspect of their belief system, as a global attack on the belief and a personal attack on themselves.

Edit: changed 'incorrect beliefs' to 'questionable' because the science is woolly and very few outright falsehoods have been shared.

Edited

I don't see how you've arrived at 'cult-like' based on this thread, or are you referring to a wider notion?

Is your reference to 'questionable beliefs' referring to the afore-mentioned cult, or the entire body of research/data so far into UPFs?

I've worked in this area for years in the US, and I'm very familiar with societal attitudes towards the suggestion that people should eat/drink/live differently. I do find it slightly surprising to see it described as a 'diet fad' though.

Longlielover · 08/03/2024 17:48

Yes, reducing as much as possible. I’m doing Zoe and managed a week with 0% UPF. Kids though are ND and survive on very regimented “safe” beige tapas.

Sususudio · 08/03/2024 17:28

Really weird. Not eating Macdonalds or ready meals or pizza or nuggets often, or at least not making them half your diet, is not a cult. But you do you.
Personally, the NHS has already stopped functioning for me.

Allfur · 08/03/2024 17:28

The smoking lobby did the same back in the day

Menora · 08/03/2024 17:24

It’s concerning that anyone questioning the safety and ethics of the food industry and how our food is created and processed is seen as ‘a cult’. There is a lot of money holding up the economy in these companies so they will be going to extreme lengths to provide fund and promote to assist with debunking. It came out after the aspartame information that the American beverage association were paying health care professionals to ‘debunk’ safety concerns about aspartame in drinks. But hey, if you see big food as the good guys here crack on 😂

TorroFerney · 08/03/2024 17:12

MrsWhattery · 07/03/2024 11:46

Aside from the issue itself, Chris van blimmin tulleken drives me up the wall. He's one of those people who's never off Radio 4 and all the airing of dirty laundry about falling out with Xand and Xand being too fat (or is it the other way round) ugh I run run run to the radio to turn him off!

It's the other way round now. Xand is trim and just married and evangelical about exercise and the formally fit/lean Chris has stopped exercising and put a load of weight on - they've a new podcast out.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 16:58

IloveAslan · 08/03/2024 08:57

I live outside the US and the UK, and while I have read an article or two I literally have not heard one person discuss UPFs or say they are giving up eating them. In fact I probably wouldn't have given it a second thought myself if I hadn't read about it on MN. The supermarkets are full of them so I'm guessing people are eating them.

Where do you live because UPF consumption varies widely across Europe.

Ultra-Processed food as % of household purchases in Europe : r/ireland (reddit.com)

Garlicking · 08/03/2024 16:58

LasEva · 08/03/2024 16:40

The 'UPF fad' and the science behind it need to remain separate really, despite one feeding the other. I know people love to do the "Gotcha! Debunked THAT one!" stuff, but the 'nonsense' is not one homogenous Bible of scientific fact waiting to be 'shot down' by 'proper argument.'

I can see why you say that, but it seems to me that the Bible is an appropriate metaphor. The UPF thing, like most successful diet fads/movements, has quickly become cult-like.

Offering counter-arguments to factually questionable beliefs isn't an attempt to debunk the whole concept - that would be something like "there are no UPFs" or even "all UPFs are good for you". Nobody's said any of that here.

But it's a characteristic of cult members that they take any disparagement, of any aspect of their belief system, as a global attack on the belief and a personal attack on themselves.

Edit: changed 'incorrect beliefs' to 'questionable' because the science is woolly and very few outright falsehoods have been shared.

LasEva · 08/03/2024 16:40

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 16:17

The only trouble with this is that the posters who have pointed out the fallacy and baselessness of the anti-UPF fad haven’t ‘scored points’. They’ve shot down the nonsense with proper argument.

Hear, hear, indeed.

The 'UPF fad' and the science behind it need to remain separate really, despite one feeding the other. I know people love to do the "Gotcha! Debunked THAT one!" stuff, but the 'nonsense' is not one homogenous Bible of scientific fact waiting to be 'shot down' by 'proper argument.'

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 16:17

Franker · 08/03/2024 16:11

Hear hear.

The only trouble with this is that the posters who have pointed out the fallacy and baselessness of the anti-UPF fad haven’t ‘scored points’. They’ve shot down the nonsense with proper argument.

Hear, hear, indeed.

Franker · 08/03/2024 16:11

LasEva · 08/03/2024 16:09

Yes, absolutely our viewpoints differ. I'm always happy with different views on a subject, and the matter is closed on that aspect.

But this: "people who post on AIBU threads have no cause to complain of ‘point scoring’" is plain wrong, imo.

AIBU is not about point scoring for most posters. People use AIBU for all kinds of reasons. It's never good to read the relative handful of AIBU Gurus who insist on perpetrating the 'Ha! It's AIBU! Get used to it!' lines. It closes down meaningful debate, puts people off posting and reduces countless threads to a stupid scrap.

Hear hear.

LasEva · 08/03/2024 16:09

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:28

I think it would be best if we agree to differ.

Personally, I find pseudoscience tedious. It’s also alarmist. In which case it’s reasonable to debunk it.

You don’t mention any of the argument that went before, about organic chemistry, the detailed explanation of why UPF scare stories are wrong that was linked-to, or the entire muddle-headed concept of food ‘processing’.

I also think that people who post on AIBU threads have no cause to complain of ‘point scoring’.

But let’s just disagree and leave it there.

Yes, absolutely our viewpoints differ. I'm always happy with different views on a subject, and the matter is closed on that aspect.

But this: "people who post on AIBU threads have no cause to complain of ‘point scoring’" is plain wrong, imo.

AIBU is not about point scoring for most posters. People use AIBU for all kinds of reasons. It's never good to read the relative handful of AIBU Gurus who insist on perpetrating the 'Ha! It's AIBU! Get used to it!' lines. It closes down meaningful debate, puts people off posting and reduces countless threads to a stupid scrap.

kalokagathos · 08/03/2024 16:06

Am reducing UPFs massively, how did we get duped so easily? I follow this plane talking 66 year old, love him. I send his vids to my dad (same age) who is very lazy at making his own food but has loads of time on his hands yet expects to be healthy? Anyhoooo, here is the link: www.instagram.com/reel/C4OOie0iDuA/?igsh=MWgwcmRqa3pjY2x6Zg==

samarrange · 08/03/2024 14:13

SnakesAndArrows · 08/03/2024 07:01

No that’s not true. Ascorbic acid (vitamin C) degrades by oxidation. This is accelerated by heat, but the amount of oxidation is mostly affected by exposure to oxygen during the process and subsequent storage. Cartons of long life juice are packed with hardly any head space so there’s minimal oxygen/juice interface until they are part used.

Plus nobody in the entire western world needs to consume more vitamin C. The NHS says that 40mg per day is enough for an adult (https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-and-minerals/vitamin-c/). You will get that comfortably even if your diet consists literally only of chips, as potatoes have quite a lot of vitamin C in them.

There is also the quackery around massive doses of vitamin C for colds, which was promoted by a Nobel Prize winner (Linus Pauling), so "It must be right" even though he was a theoretical physicist and, like quite a lot of Nobel winners, a bit of a crank.

The portrayal of orange juice as a daily health necessity is a triumph of marketing over science. It's just as bad for your teeth as most soft drinks and it's full of sugar, albeit "natural" sugar, as opposed to the "UPF" sugar that [checks notes] grows as sugar beet.

nhs.uk

Vitamins and minerals - Vitamin C

Find out about vitamin C (also called ascorbic acid), including what it does, how much you need, and good sources of it.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-and-minerals/vitamin-c

Wenttomowameadow · 08/03/2024 13:09

I'm on a couple of upf reduction Facebook groups and the amount of butter and sugar being consumed is quite something.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:30

Franker · 08/03/2024 12:27

Squabbling like arsey 14 year olds isn't debate.

Agreed. That’s why ‘cringe’ and ‘immature’ were so out of place.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:28

LasEva · 08/03/2024 12:14

Saying that people who choose not to eat 'UPFs' because they believe pseudoscience or have fallen victim to fear mongering isn't debate, nor is it a counter argument. You're using typical MN reductive and infantilizing speak, which is not offering a counter argument at all.

I've been on MN for 17 years, I know how it works. It would just be enjoyable and more enriching to genuinely debate something, without the constant snapbacks and point-scoring. It is tedious.

I think it would be best if we agree to differ.

Personally, I find pseudoscience tedious. It’s also alarmist. In which case it’s reasonable to debunk it.

You don’t mention any of the argument that went before, about organic chemistry, the detailed explanation of why UPF scare stories are wrong that was linked-to, or the entire muddle-headed concept of food ‘processing’.

I also think that people who post on AIBU threads have no cause to complain of ‘point scoring’.

But let’s just disagree and leave it there.

Franker · 08/03/2024 12:27

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:04

It’s an AIBU. People debate things in AIBU.

There’s nothing tedious about countering arguments of harm from food.

Squabbling like arsey 14 year olds isn't debate.

LasEva · 08/03/2024 12:14

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:04

It’s an AIBU. People debate things in AIBU.

There’s nothing tedious about countering arguments of harm from food.

Saying that people who choose not to eat 'UPFs' because they believe pseudoscience or have fallen victim to fear mongering isn't debate, nor is it a counter argument. You're using typical MN reductive and infantilizing speak, which is not offering a counter argument at all.

I've been on MN for 17 years, I know how it works. It would just be enjoyable and more enriching to genuinely debate something, without the constant snapbacks and point-scoring. It is tedious.

OneTC · 08/03/2024 12:12

Not reducing mine because I don't want to. I am fit and eat a healthy and varied diet and that includes UPF.

I reckon the fags, booze and drugs might get me first if I'm ranking threats to my health.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 12:04

LasEva · 08/03/2024 11:54

Just to add balance to your last point, there are also people - including posters on this thread - who have cut out certain foods, now labelled UPFs, because they are persuaded by the evidence.

That's not 'buying into a lot of pseudoscience' or being victims of 'fearmongering.' It's just arriving at a different POV. The need on these threads to judge, be reductive and take swipes is tedious.

It’s an AIBU. People debate things in AIBU.

There’s nothing tedious about countering arguments of harm from food.

LITLINAWIS · 08/03/2024 11:56

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 11:51

You don't get to dictate what counts as cringe or immature thanks, it's completely subjective.

Neither do you - you were the one that threw the comment into the thread in the first place! 🙄

Oakbeam · 08/03/2024 11:55

I’m not reducing mine because I don’t eat much of it anyway. Apart from the odd slice of bacon or a couple of sausages on Saturday morning, that is it.

LasEva · 08/03/2024 11:54

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 08/03/2024 10:16

I can’t speak for the Maccies lovers. Though since it’s perfectly good food I can’t see why you’d regard it as ‘immature’ to want one.

As for the machines, it’s pretty obvious that some posters, including me, are just pointing out that the UPF avoiders have bought into a lot of pseudoscience and fearmongering. Making that point is not ‘cringe’ or ‘immature’ either.

Just to add balance to your last point, there are also people - including posters on this thread - who have cut out certain foods, now labelled UPFs, because they are persuaded by the evidence.

That's not 'buying into a lot of pseudoscience' or being victims of 'fearmongering.' It's just arriving at a different POV. The need on these threads to judge, be reductive and take swipes is tedious.

Swipe left for the next trending thread