Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
TorroFerney · 09/03/2024 07:12

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 21:31

I don't know how we got to this point where food has never been safer and yet everyone is convinced it is killing them, but here we are

Are you joking? We are in the midst of an obesity crisis, people are literally eating themselves to death.

But a lot of those people, who eat junk because it is cheap and haven't the headspace/education to think about what they are eating as they are just trying to survive are not the ones that will be listening to Dr Xand or buying the Zoe stuff. Worried well will - as someone else has said upthread.

Firethehorse · 09/03/2024 07:03

When I think back to my childhood food I think of Frey bentos pies in a tin, Brains faggots (both of which I hated) Findus savoury pancakes, Angel Delight, Mr Kipling cakes, Gold bars and Penguins. For sure I try to cook from scratch most of the time and try to have some organic now, but this is facilitated by having the time and financial resources. I do worry about what we, and others, are doing to ourselves with our food however I also see that many people are time and cash poor right now so it’s really hard.
For this reason I would like to see big supermarkets being pushed into providing better quality food, this would help people more in my opinion. A huge difference for us was adding a relatively cheap but very effective water filter to our kitchen tap and shower and banning fizzy drinks in the week. We also look closely at what is in all toiletries and cleaning products. I’m agreeing with all the other posters who say exercise is also key. So yes we need to reduce UPF but I applaud all the hard working parents who manage to provide healthy food for their families most or even some of the time.

Ukrainebaby23 · 09/03/2024 06:52

Not sure exactly what counts as UPF. I'd like to cook more but sometimes all we have time to do is open a can of beans and butter bread.

daisychain01 · 09/03/2024 05:53

While weight loss and gain may technically be possible with any food, we are seeing in real time that it is absolutely not easy to lose weight when surrounded by UPFs.

the nature of upf is that eating it is easier, it takes away the need for humans to bite and chew (digestion should start in the mouth). For example eating an apple takes more to bite off a piece of it, chew it, swallow it and digest it. A glass of apple juice or eating some apple purée takes away most of that process. Similarly a piece of meat v a burger. It doesn't satisfy the hunger.

Im not saying apple juice or puree are bad foods, but it illustrates the point. Modern manufactured food takes away that process.

it's all about balance, there's no need to completely eliminate every last scrap of foods classed as UP, reducing daily consumption, making substitutions where practical, is heading in the right direction, which many people are doing because of the awareness. Very similar to when the true impact of smoking because widely visible through science. My grandparents were told if you have a cough, have a cigarette it's good for you 😱

daisychain01 · 09/03/2024 05:40

Nothing has changed with UPF, it's just that the hype machine has found a new way to package up stories saying "Your food is killing you" because "Your huge portions of calorie-rich food and lack of exercise are killing you" is a lot harder to sell. I can guarantee you that within a couple of years there will be companies gaming the definition of ultra-processed (probably by paying Chris van Tullegen a lot of money) so that their high-fat stuff doesn't count as UPF because it has 0.1% organic lemon juice or some such bollocks.

this kind of misinformation is what does real harm to the debate around upf. Instead of sticking to the facts, to the science, you're making up hypothetical situations like "probably paying xxx scientist a lot of money to peddle lies" and words like "I guarantee..." ( you're talented, with your predictive powers you should do the lottery!) when that is not the actual situation, it's your personal take on things because of your personal axe that you're grinding.

why not just stick to accurate information and not conflate it by adding embellishments to bolster your point.

there are plenty of scientists out there who stick their head above the parapet in the interests of the science. They aren't being sponsored by the Food Industry, their scientific goal is to inform our society about the actions and choices that for-profit Corporates make that are harmful so people can make their own choices. We can choose to take on board the information or we can ignore it and add to conspiracy theories in the web if we want. The food industry gets away with a lot, despite legislative controls - and guidelines that many ignore when it doesn't suit them eg traffic light system (I have put back an item when I see Red fat, Red saturated fat Amber salt Red sugar so they do a good job in many cases) - and they're supported by government because their products create revenue and taxes.

samarrange · 09/03/2024 01:16

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 22:55

The sentence I quoted was not strictly to do with UPFs.

I know that obesity is caused by excess calories and that you may consume excessive amounts of food through whole foods or UPFs.

My opinion is that UPFs are much, much easier to consume in excess than whole foods, even with all else being equal. For the reasons already listed.

They don't have to be any worse than that, that's bad enough for people who struggle with weight control.

I believe that the unnatural ease with which UPFs are digested are not good for humans, and the hormonal spikes resulting from the consumption and rapid absorption of UPFs increase the likelihood of metabolic disease and promote obesity which also increases the risk of quite a lot of diseases. And that's without even considering the lack of beneficial elements of a diet that are missing if people consume largely highly processed foods.

While weight loss and gain may technically be possible with any food, we are seeing in real time that it is absolutely not easy to lose weight when surrounded by UPFs.

It's really not about "selling" what is already widely accepted knowledge. People are really, really struggling to lose weight. Even people who really want to. And I think in order to understand what's going on, we need a holistic approach, and that includes looking at our modern food environment and increasing peoples' understanding of how food quality, ingredients and processing methods actually do matter. And it's not just obviously "unhealthy" foods that could be contributing to peoples' struggles to maintain good health.

That's fair. We eat convenience foods/UPFs because they are easy, cheap, and "good enough" nutritionally. And being easy to eat perhaps makes it more likely that we will have another slice of Domino's than another slice of artisan sourdough bruschetta with home-chopped tomatoes.

But also, these foods have a much longer shelf life. I think that's a crucial point, and not necessarily negative. It reduces food waste (a good thing, I'm told) and it also allows for much more flexibility in time management for the people who buy the food (i.e. women mostly).

I am concerned about the messaging that unless you are taking your bicycle to the local food market every two days and eating only fresh seasonal produce, you are somehow failing yourself, your family, the nation ("all that money the NHS is going to have to spend to fix your heart") and the planet. To feed a family of four for a week requires at least 50,000 kcal of food, and most people would prefer to spend as little time as possible doing that. I know I do.

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 22:55

samarrange · 08/03/2024 22:43

But that's nothing to do with the UPF bogeyman. Obesity is about calories. If you drink 250ml of nasty UPF orange juice from concentrate or 250ml of lovely non-UPF orange juice not from concentrate, that's the same contribution to your daily calorie intake. Ditto for 100g of artisan sourdough with 20g of hand-churned butter versus 100g of Kingsmill with 20g of Flora.

Nothing has changed with UPF, it's just that the hype machine has found a new way to package up stories saying "Your food is killing you" because "Your huge portions of calorie-rich food and lack of exercise are killing you" is a lot harder to sell. I can guarantee you that within a couple of years there will be companies gaming the definition of ultra-processed (probably by paying Chris van Tullegen a lot of money) so that their high-fat stuff doesn't count as UPF because it has 0.1% organic lemon juice or some such bollocks.

The sentence I quoted was not strictly to do with UPFs.

I know that obesity is caused by excess calories and that you may consume excessive amounts of food through whole foods or UPFs.

My opinion is that UPFs are much, much easier to consume in excess than whole foods, even with all else being equal. For the reasons already listed.

They don't have to be any worse than that, that's bad enough for people who struggle with weight control.

I believe that the unnatural ease with which UPFs are digested are not good for humans, and the hormonal spikes resulting from the consumption and rapid absorption of UPFs increase the likelihood of metabolic disease and promote obesity which also increases the risk of quite a lot of diseases. And that's without even considering the lack of beneficial elements of a diet that are missing if people consume largely highly processed foods.

While weight loss and gain may technically be possible with any food, we are seeing in real time that it is absolutely not easy to lose weight when surrounded by UPFs.

It's really not about "selling" what is already widely accepted knowledge. People are really, really struggling to lose weight. Even people who really want to. And I think in order to understand what's going on, we need a holistic approach, and that includes looking at our modern food environment and increasing peoples' understanding of how food quality, ingredients and processing methods actually do matter. And it's not just obviously "unhealthy" foods that could be contributing to peoples' struggles to maintain good health.

samarrange · 08/03/2024 22:43

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 21:31

I don't know how we got to this point where food has never been safer and yet everyone is convinced it is killing them, but here we are

Are you joking? We are in the midst of an obesity crisis, people are literally eating themselves to death.

But that's nothing to do with the UPF bogeyman. Obesity is about calories. If you drink 250ml of nasty UPF orange juice from concentrate or 250ml of lovely non-UPF orange juice not from concentrate, that's the same contribution to your daily calorie intake. Ditto for 100g of artisan sourdough with 20g of hand-churned butter versus 100g of Kingsmill with 20g of Flora.

Nothing has changed with UPF, it's just that the hype machine has found a new way to package up stories saying "Your food is killing you" because "Your huge portions of calorie-rich food and lack of exercise are killing you" is a lot harder to sell. I can guarantee you that within a couple of years there will be companies gaming the definition of ultra-processed (probably by paying Chris van Tullegen a lot of money) so that their high-fat stuff doesn't count as UPF because it has 0.1% organic lemon juice or some such bollocks.

Amybelle88 · 08/03/2024 22:40

Had pancreatic cancer - went absolutely nuts when it came to my diet to the point where it was forensic.

When I met my oncologist his advice was 80/20 for everything. I live by that and use common sense - should we eat UPF every single day? No. Have a balanced diet and allow yourself to have a treat here and there.

It's not rocket science that buying Asdas essentials cottage pie isn't the best dietary choice, most people know this and don't need the scaremongering.

Rhaenys · 08/03/2024 22:29

No. I’m just going to continue eating what I want.

Garlicking · 08/03/2024 22:19

Yep, @EilonwyWithRedGoldHair, the insomnia and stress, etc, are doing you more harm than a jar of pasta sauce could. Hope you get an easier time of it soon.

Garlicking · 08/03/2024 22:16

Oh, @Penguin779, nothing's rotting in your gut! It's fermenting - okay, you could call it rotting - exactly as it's supposed to. Worry not 🙂

(Caveat for perfectionists: I have zero knowledge about the biochemistry of impacted bowel disease and similar. I assume something different happens to poo that's been bunged up for months, but the PP wasn't talking about that.)

There are genuine forever chemicals in your food, drink, air and everything you touch, as others have mentioned. Food additives have been extensively tested and marked safe for human consumption at permitted levels: that means they'll pass through your system normally.

Worry about the microplastics instead. Or don't, as you're already full of them and nobody knows what to do about it.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/03/2024 22:16

Direct associations could be due to a number of confounding factors, for instance lifestyles that predispose consumers to use "UPF" foods being themselves injurious to health.

This is the big question isn't it. We take the easy option food wise too often because we're exhausted, with years of stress and disturbed sleep and little time for exercise. I worry about my long term health, but day to day the sleep deprivation, managing DS needs and keeping us afloat financially leaves me too exhausted to do anything about it. Plus it's just one of so many worries.

Penguin779 · 08/03/2024 22:08

Adds worrying about UPF to my bottomless Mother’s Load list

We eat fairly healthy meals or very rich, wholesome but mostly home-cooked food (eg roasts) - but DH and I love a UPF snack. I am addicted to chocolate. I do worry about it as I also get constipated (sorry!) so I worry about bowel cancer after reading a lack of fibre (which I do eat plenty of!) is in part causing the massive increase in this kind of cancer, along with the junk we eat that languishes in our gut, essentially rotting in it. I was much better at being quite disciplined pre-kids and jumped on the “clean eating” fad - still disordered eating… - but I find the increasingly fast pace of life for everyone and the rising stress means I often make less than ideal choices with food. It’s not a lack of education on the matter. So I suppose one of the things I find most frightening about UPF is just how addictive it is.

Moderating is key though. I grit my teeth when I read posts from parents who are really quite puritanical about UPFs. It’s a disaster waiting to happen, as a friend’s teen demonstrated when he started high school and guzzles fizzy drink now he can buy his own lunch. (Previously banned from drinking any of it) This is mild though when you think of how many young people are in the grips of eating disorders.

IloveAslan · 08/03/2024 22:05

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 18:30

Yeah that’s a good point. Must admit I roll my eyes a bit at people who are evangelising about cutting out all UPFs when I know they drive their kids the less than a mile journey to school every day in a massive SUV.

It also seems like the new way for some people to excuse disordered eating, hot on the heels of “clean eating”, going gluten free and dairy free etc.

Several years ago I listened to a lecture on the evils of white bread - from a man holding a glass of rum & coke in one hand and a cigarette in the other. True story.

Also, all those super heroes who eat nothing but 30+ vegetables and fruit a day, unless you are growing your own or buying everything organic do you ever stop to wonder about the chemicals used in their production?

daisychain01 · 08/03/2024 22:04

Obviously it’s an exaggeration to say that processed foods and ‘ultra’ processed foods are directly killing people

We firstly need to differentiate between processed and upf and not conflate the two as they are very different. Upf is the concern, not processed.

in scientific terms, correlation (as opposed to causation) describes the likelihood of one thing having an effect or effects on another. So, in the case of upf, there is a strong correlation between the consumption of upf and diseases such as cancer, diabetes, heart disease. So it isn't an exaggeration to create the link, it just isn't possible to isolate upf as the only cause of harm to humans.

it is very rare for any study to categorically state causation, because there are too many complex circumstantial factors at play to control for (eg: age, existing health conditions of study participants, socioeconomic and environmental factors, pollution, poverty, heredity). Instead they consider the likehood of a link. Upf is strongly linked to disease and poor health across society. There is too much evidence in hand from longitudinal studies to deny that harm.

cherish123 · 08/03/2024 22:00

Open food facts app is useful for scanning bar codes. It tells you if UPF or not.

AlltheFs · 08/03/2024 22:00

I’m not interested in living for a year or two longer by sacrificing eating what I like.

We don’t eat badly, but we do love some UPF and I’m cracking on with them.

Quite frankly I love a cheese string.

Garlicking · 08/03/2024 22:00

daisychain01 · 08/03/2024 21:34

The effects of upf are cumulative, long term and over decades not weeks or months.

the BMJ has done a peer-reviewed umbrella study which is meta-analysis of numerous research data and identifies 32 health impacts linked to consumption of upf - correlation not causation - using the recognised Nova classification for upf:

https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-077310

Good find, thanks.

"22 pooled analyses were rated as low quality, with 19 rated as very low quality and four rated as moderate quality." They assessed 45 pooled analyses, none were rated as god or high quality.

The conclusion was that there's a case for better research to be conducted, in order to evaluate whether UPFs present an actionable risk.

"The strongest available evidence pertained to direct associations between greater exposure to ultra-processed foods and higher risks"

Direct associations could be due to a number of confounding factors, for instance lifestyles that predispose consumers to use "UPF" foods being themselves injurious to health.

Still hoping for an accepted definition of UPF. I'm not saying junk food isn't worse for your health than non-junk food but, if we're going to adopt a new metric, we need to know what it is and how it differs from food quality factors that are already well understood.

IloveAslan · 08/03/2024 21:55

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 16:58

Where do you live because UPF consumption varies widely across Europe.

Ultra-Processed food as % of household purchases in Europe : r/ireland (reddit.com)

I'm nowhere near Europe - there is a whole world out there you know,

IloveAslan · 08/03/2024 21:52

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 10:09

I do find these and the "omg naughty machines" responses so cringe and immature.

Nobody is trying to get one over on you or make you feel bad or make you change your habits.

Some people are changing their own eating habits and discussing the reasons behind it, and whether other people feel the same or are not bothered.

Edited

Oh do get over yourself and lighten up! Obviously you were absent the day a sense of humour was being handed out. Hmm If being "mature" means turning into someone like you I'm out thanks.

Good on those who want to obssess over their eating habits and deny themselves any pleasures - frankly I find them boring as hell. As are those who must rush onto MN to prove their superiority to us mere mortals who simply use food as fuel but want to make it enjoyable at the same time.

As for your next comment: You don't get to dictate what counts as cringe or immature thanks, it's completely subjective addressed to another poster. That's interesting - so you are allowed to say other posters' comments are cringe and immature but no-one is allowed to say the same thing to you???? Rather shot yourself in the foot there haven't you?

Btw, I'm just back from Maccas and enjoyed my breakfast very much.

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 08/03/2024 21:49

Honestly.. I haven’t heard anyone I know in real life mention UPF.. I kinda see it as part of the whole mumsnet middle class orthorexia thing we see so often on here. I try to eat as healthily as I reasonably can, most of the time. And like most people I’m limited by time, budget, circumstances, other factors. I also occasionally just really fancy McDonald’s!

daisychain01 · 08/03/2024 21:47

the BMJ has done = has published

daisychain01 · 08/03/2024 21:34

The effects of upf are cumulative, long term and over decades not weeks or months.

the BMJ has done a peer-reviewed umbrella study which is meta-analysis of numerous research data and identifies 32 health impacts linked to consumption of upf - correlation not causation - using the recognised Nova classification for upf:

https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-077310

Ultra-processed food exposure and adverse health outcomes: umbrella review of epidemiological meta-analyses

Objective To evaluate the existing meta-analytic evidence of associations between exposure to ultra-processed foods, as defined by the Nova food classification system, and adverse health outcomes. Design Systematic umbrella review of existing meta-ana...

https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-077310

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 21:31

I don't know how we got to this point where food has never been safer and yet everyone is convinced it is killing them, but here we are

Are you joking? We are in the midst of an obesity crisis, people are literally eating themselves to death.