Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
terrimom · 10/03/2024 01:46

Koo47 · 06/03/2024 21:45

We have a cow too.

lmao

samarrange · 09/03/2024 23:04

Springsombrero · 09/03/2024 22:38

I think my UPF intake is low anyway but that’s because I’m lucky enough to be relatively well off. I wouldn’t read too much into nutrition research though, as it’s notoriously difficult (because you can’t randomly assign people to eating UPFs vs not) - this is why we regularly see silly findings such as “red wine reduces X” or “dark chocolate reduces X” in the news.

Yep. A diet that includes 100g of foie gras per day would probably kill you, but people who report eating foie gras regularly live longer than those who don't because the negative effect of the foie gras is more than outweighed by the longevity benefits of being wealthy, which is the reason you can afford to eat fois gras.

You also get situations like this, where both of the following are true:

  • Obese people eat more biscuits than non-obese people
  • Obese people drink more diet soft drinks than non-obese people
One of those is a direct cause of weight gain and the other is a change of behaviour (from full-fat Coke to Coke Zero) resulting from it. But you can't tell that from just looking at the associations.
Springsombrero · 09/03/2024 22:38

I think my UPF intake is low anyway but that’s because I’m lucky enough to be relatively well off. I wouldn’t read too much into nutrition research though, as it’s notoriously difficult (because you can’t randomly assign people to eating UPFs vs not) - this is why we regularly see silly findings such as “red wine reduces X” or “dark chocolate reduces X” in the news.

BobnLen · 09/03/2024 22:22

No, I eat what I want, I'm elderly now anyway so past caring

BeretRaspberry · 09/03/2024 22:15

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:32

The third largest cause of cancer in the US is being overweight/obese.
4-8% of cancer is linked to obesity.

Linked doesn’t mean caused by

followmyflow · 09/03/2024 21:58

i have read the "famous" upf book by the doctor/researcher. to be honest, i didnt find it very convincing.
the most convincing parts of the book were about upf vs satiety, as in the nature of most upf, because it makes us feel less satiated, will cause us to eat more, and that increase in calories will cause weight gain and health problems down the road.
but there was nothing particularly convincing about the idea that upf ITSELF is evil and killing us. there was even a part in the book where the author's brother looked at a ready meal, which didnt have any of the upf ingredients in it (hydrogenated fats, chemical ingredient extracts and the like) and the author STILL said that was upf........just because!
i admit im biased against the idea because it makes me remember the "fat is evil and killing us" and then the "sugar is evil and killing us" phases...

Hickorydickorydock123 · 09/03/2024 21:53

IloveAslan · 09/03/2024 21:50

the nature of upf is that eating it is easier, it takes away the need for humans to bite and chew (digestion should start in the mouth). For example eating an apple takes more to bite off a piece of it, chew it, swallow it and digest it. A glass of apple juice or eating some apple purée takes away most of that process. Similarly a piece of meat v a burger. It doesn't satisfy the hunger.

I do agree with you that foods should be bitten and chewed, but what gives you the idea that UPF foods don't require that? We are constantly being told UPFs are bread, sausages, ready meals, shop bought biscuits, cake etc., all of which require biting and chewing?

Generally they are a lot softer to chew. For example, a slice of shop bought cheap white sliced bread is a lot softer, quicker to eat, can get stuck to the roof of your mouth etc than a homemade sourdough which can make your jaw ache from chewing and you probably eat a lot less of!

IloveAslan · 09/03/2024 21:50

the nature of upf is that eating it is easier, it takes away the need for humans to bite and chew (digestion should start in the mouth). For example eating an apple takes more to bite off a piece of it, chew it, swallow it and digest it. A glass of apple juice or eating some apple purée takes away most of that process. Similarly a piece of meat v a burger. It doesn't satisfy the hunger.

I do agree with you that foods should be bitten and chewed, but what gives you the idea that UPF foods don't require that? We are constantly being told UPFs are bread, sausages, ready meals, shop bought biscuits, cake etc., all of which require biting and chewing?

IloveAslan · 09/03/2024 21:48

Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2024 09:20

You gave no idea where you lived so I had no way of knowing you weren't in Europe and there is no need for your nasty tone.

Well in my opinion someone who, when they hears someone lives outside of the UK immediately jumps to the conclusion that they must live in Europe, is rather ignorant. If you didn't know where I lived there was no need to write a comment to lecture me on what happens in other parts of Europe - you could have just kept quiet.

DisabledDemon · 09/03/2024 13:28

Panpastels · 06/03/2024 20:50

What is UPF?

Ultra Processed Foods.

Non or minimally processed foods include fruit, veg, fish, meat, eggs, nuts, milk, pulses.

Processed ingredients - eg, salt, sugar, oils, butter, vinegar - are items that you would tend to add to other foods, rather than eating them by themselves (although, obviously, there are people who swear by taking a tablespoon of olive oil a day).

Processed foods are generally created by combining groups 1 and 2 and can be made by home cooks - jam, pickles, bread, preserved fruit. It also includes tinned fruit and many cheeses.

Ultra Processed foods typically have five or more ingredients, which may include additives, artificial flavours, emulsifiers, preservatives, artificial colours and sweeteners and have a long shelf life. Industrial food, you might call it.

Obviously, this isn't a comprehensive list. Unfortunately, the UPF list tends to have the 'fun' stuff - sausages, biscuits, crisps, fruit-flavoured yoghurts, a lot of fizzy drinks, ice cream - but there's no reason (unless you have really strict dietary needs), that you can't have the occasional treat from the naughty shelf.

If you can get them, gluten-free sausages made by your local butcher are a much better option and usually taste much nicer.

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 11:15

AlltheFs · 09/03/2024 08:29

So what? I don't care.
We are all going to die. I’d still rather eat the cheese strings. And I’m already middle aged FWIW.

I have a lovely life and I’m going to continue eating bacon and chocolate etc. if that knocks me off my perch and 70 instead of 90 that’s fine.

Happy life more important than a long life.

So it was 2 years and now it’s 20. You’re not likely to do much harm eating a bit of bacon and chocolate. (Choc doesn’t have to be UPF anyway).

The point about obesity is a. I don’t think it’s making anyone very happy and b. Society bears the cost of this type of “happiness”. Currently costing society around £55-8 billion - 2-3% of GDP.

Sususudio · 09/03/2024 10:26

Well, my DD is now eating left over Five Guys chips for breakfast so that will teach me to be overly sanctimonious, which I think I was a bit after reading my posts back!

We have a genetic disease in the family, so that is why I am a bit overcareful. Also, because I grew up in a different country, I didn't eat junk food growing up, so I don't have much of a taste for it. The only junk food I had as a child was crisps, biscuits and chocolate; there were no canned foods or readymeals or ketchup. DC definitely have a taste for it though but they eat in moderation.

@ErnestCelendine what you are doing sounds doable and sensible for most.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2024 09:22

"I don’t know anyone who was educated to avoid processed food in childhood who “guzzled” crap food as a result, quite the opposite."

Growing up in the 80s, I had a couple of friends who were mad about sweets because they were restricted at home.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2024 09:20

IloveAslan · 08/03/2024 21:55

I'm nowhere near Europe - there is a whole world out there you know,

You gave no idea where you lived so I had no way of knowing you weren't in Europe and there is no need for your nasty tone.

HowhardcanitB · 09/03/2024 08:58

Too much going on to add another thing I need to do.

Penguin779 · 09/03/2024 08:48

Should have added the crucial detail I grew up with my mother talking about food which were bad for us.

Penguin779 · 09/03/2024 08:45

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:28

Moderating is key though. I grit my teeth when I read posts from parents who are really quite puritanical about UPFs. It’s a disaster waiting to happen, as a friend’s teen demonstrated when he started high school and guzzles fizzy drink now he can buy his own lunch. (Previously banned from drinking any of it) This is mild though when you think of how many young people are in the grips of eating disorders.

I don’t know anyone who was educated to avoid processed food in childhood who “guzzled” crap food as a result, quite the opposite.

In fact I’d say the vast majority of people who “guzzle” crap ate it in childhood, making it a hard habit to break.

I think there’s a huge difference between educating a child about UPF and taking a fizzy drink off them (and cutting the already small birthday cake slice in half 🙈) in a children’s party. There’s middle ground between the two extremes of what is, in my opinion, unhealthy disordered eating. I’m not saying focusing on UPFs is - of course it isn’t. We all clearly need to do this but I personally will be teaching this lesson to my own DC carefully and in not such a polarised way. I say this as someone who suffered with hypothalamic amenorrhea in my twenties as I was obsessed with “clean” eating.

AlltheFs · 09/03/2024 08:29

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:38

The ailments associated with being overweight/obese don’t only hit you in old age, they can appear at any time eg - diabetes, fatty liver, gall bladder disease, heart disease, cancer etc. These are not necessarily geriatric diseases, they tend to come on in middle age, for some even earlier.

So what? I don't care.
We are all going to die. I’d still rather eat the cheese strings. And I’m already middle aged FWIW.

I have a lovely life and I’m going to continue eating bacon and chocolate etc. if that knocks me off my perch and 70 instead of 90 that’s fine.

Happy life more important than a long life.

ErnestCelendine · 09/03/2024 07:50

I'm trying to reduce upfs but it's hard (energy/finances/habit wise). I work full-time, have children with additional needs and am a terrible cook!

Last night we had sausages but with kale and carrots. Movie night snacks are doritos but with melon and pineapple too. And breakfast is supermarket granola but with fresh berries and Greek yoghurt.

I'm trying to be kind to myself rather than think I'm a terrible person for letting the kids have a pre-packed croissant. See also plastic waste and air miles to worry about.

SnakesAndArrows · 09/03/2024 07:49

the nature of upf is that eating it is easier, it takes away the need for humans to bite and chew (digestion should start in the mouth). For example eating an apple takes more to bite off a piece of it, chew it, swallow it and digest it. A glass of apple juice or eating some apple purée takes away most of that process. Similarly a piece of meat v a burger. It doesn't satisfy the hunger.

Totally agree with this. Eat real food.

But adding half a jar of Aldi pesto sauce to your broccoli and pasta is not going to be any less safe compared to adding an equal amount of homemade pesto.

Vegetus · 09/03/2024 07:48

People like being told things aren't their fault and I believe that's why this new fad has taken roots.

Oh poor you, you're not fat because you eat too much it's those rascal big food companies using soya lecithin and seed oils.

Bullshit. I could happily sit down and eat a kilogram of mini eggs a day but I don't because I use a bit of restraint.

SnakesAndArrows · 09/03/2024 07:43

in scientific terms, correlation (as opposed to causation) describes the likelihood of one thing having an effect or effects on another.

Correlation tells us precisely nothing about the likelihood of there being a causative relationship. It tells us we should investigate further to discover whether there is any causation.

The displacement of high nutritional value food by essentially junk is fairly obviously causative of obesity and all the problems associated with obesity, as concluded by the BMJ study. Evidence of harm caused by consumption of the “unnatural” ingredients in processed food is for the most part weak, as concluded by the same study.

It’s almost as though pointing to obesity itself as being the root cause of a good deal of poor health is no longer allowed. We have to point to the food as the direct cause of the poor health, not as the cause of the obesity.

There are posts on here every day from people saying they and their children “eat healthily and cook from scratch” but they can’t understand why they are overweight. With the exception of some people with metabolic disorders it’s all down to portion size, with the wrong balance between broccoli and Asda cottage pie.

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:38

AlltheFs · 08/03/2024 22:00

I’m not interested in living for a year or two longer by sacrificing eating what I like.

We don’t eat badly, but we do love some UPF and I’m cracking on with them.

Quite frankly I love a cheese string.

The ailments associated with being overweight/obese don’t only hit you in old age, they can appear at any time eg - diabetes, fatty liver, gall bladder disease, heart disease, cancer etc. These are not necessarily geriatric diseases, they tend to come on in middle age, for some even earlier.

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:32

SnowflakeSparkles · 08/03/2024 21:31

I don't know how we got to this point where food has never been safer and yet everyone is convinced it is killing them, but here we are

Are you joking? We are in the midst of an obesity crisis, people are literally eating themselves to death.

The third largest cause of cancer in the US is being overweight/obese.
4-8% of cancer is linked to obesity.

Mirabai · 09/03/2024 07:28

Moderating is key though. I grit my teeth when I read posts from parents who are really quite puritanical about UPFs. It’s a disaster waiting to happen, as a friend’s teen demonstrated when he started high school and guzzles fizzy drink now he can buy his own lunch. (Previously banned from drinking any of it) This is mild though when you think of how many young people are in the grips of eating disorders.

I don’t know anyone who was educated to avoid processed food in childhood who “guzzled” crap food as a result, quite the opposite.

In fact I’d say the vast majority of people who “guzzle” crap ate it in childhood, making it a hard habit to break.