Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Sususudio · 07/03/2024 11:48

So again I come back to the age old dietary advice of eating more fruit and veg, cooking from scratch, choosing healthy snacks, minimising junk etc. I don't need a buzzword like UPF to know what's a healthy diet.

Agree with this, if at all possible.

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 11:48

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 11:34

Well I would rather take my cues from those with an academic interest in the area (same for any other advice I take in life). She doesn't actually appear to be in any way qualified to analyse or interpret academic research in this area (nor am I, but I'm not promoting myself as someone to listen to).

There doesn't appear to be any one accepted definition of UPFs, nor any research that demonstrates UPFs are harmful while also controlling for other confounding factors.

Even those on this thread who've said they have benefited from cutting UPFs have just described moving to a diet that would have been recognised as a healthier option for as long as I can remember.

I'm very very sceptical about the UPF labelling. I'm even more sceptical about unqualified influencers portraying themselves as experts in any field. I'm not at all sceptical about eating a diet with lots of fruit and veg, meals cooked broadly from scratch and minimal junk food. There's nothing new in that.

Fair enough.

I think it's fairly clear and obvious that food that has been heavily broken down is not good for people, and feel studies do support that, including the ones which show that all else being equal (as in calorie content and macronutrient composition being matched), UPFs cause people to gain weight more than less processed counterparts.

I don't think it's a coincidence that the obesity crisis exists in a time post the creation of ultra palatable, highly processed foods.

I am open to the possibility that there is nothing wrong with UPFs even though currently I do not believe there is a shred of evidence to support that, and I am open to the possibility that we will continue to discover more reasons why UPFs negatively affect our health.

I'd find it really interesting if you have any academic insight to any studies to support the idea that UPFs are not harmful for our health? I can't find any so far.

MabelMaybe · 07/03/2024 11:47

I was surprised at the range of UPF. Chicken nuggets and sausages you'd know are UPFs, but cereals and bread feel sneakier. Then you look at the list of ingredients in a commercially baked loaf.

I would have said that we don't eat many UPFs, as we tend not to get burgers, nuggets etc. but we do use the "sneakier" ones - granola, bread etc. I've started making some bread at home, in a bread maker, but the loaves aren't big enough to compete for family sandwiches etc. and historically, UPF was less prevolent when women were at home to cook meals from scratch. There is something in this about them tracking how society has changed and responding to that. I'm not going to make home made shepherd's pie when I walk through the door at 5.45pm.

MrsWhattery · 07/03/2024 11:46

Aside from the issue itself, Chris van blimmin tulleken drives me up the wall. He's one of those people who's never off Radio 4 and all the airing of dirty laundry about falling out with Xand and Xand being too fat (or is it the other way round) ugh I run run run to the radio to turn him off!

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 11:45

Menora · 07/03/2024 11:40

@ColleenDonaghy I think there is enough evidence to show the basics of what makes an UPF. It is very obvious that a meat slurried reformed chicken nugget is UP. The grey area comes with processed foods that have elements of UP in the processing. Baked beans are a good one. Part of them is not UP at all, but part is. So we are faced with trying to decide which ones are ‘good’ or ‘bad’ or ones we just have to use moderation with. I would eat baked beans but I wouldn’t eat reformed meat.

But how do I as someone with qualifications in maths and finance know which processes make a UPF bad, and which have value?

A tub of formula powder bears no resemblance to milk (cow or human) but it is nutritionally complete for an infant and by far the best alternative to breast milk that we have.

Overarching definitions like UPF don't seem to have any scientific grounding to them. The truth will be more nuanced than that.

So again I come back to the age old dietary advice of eating more fruit and veg, cooking from scratch, choosing healthy snacks, minimising junk etc. I don't need a buzzword like UPF to know what's a healthy diet.

inkblackheart · 07/03/2024 11:45

It is definitely more expensive. I can buy a factory made chocolate cake full of stabilisers and emulsifiers and artificial sweeteners which probably has an extremely long shelf life for about £3.

I can't buy all the ingredients for that. The butter is going to cost me close to £2 on its own and I then need eggs, sugar, flour, cocoa etc

So it's most definitely more expensive to make from scratch. But not all processed foods are UPF. As I mentioned upthread we use some ready made pasta sauces (lloyd grossman bolognese and a heinz one) and neither are UPF. Lidl do a few types of biscuits with no artificial ingredients in them, there are ready made pizzas with no artificial ingredients in them etc

Menora · 07/03/2024 11:44

I will absolutely stand by my own experience that I had IBS predominantly triggered by eating a heavy UPF diet and I have not had any IBS flares in a whole year, from over 20 years of chronic issues.

For anyone else who does, it’s worth investigating it. If you are otherwise healthy you might have no reason to make changes and that’s fine.

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 11:42

I'm not reducing my intake of anything, because I'm pretty happy with my current diet and I'm not paranoid about every crumb of food that passes my lips.

Also, some of the 'advice' given on UPFs is, quite simply, total bollocks.

Caravaggiouch · 07/03/2024 11:40

For those who are more interested in the scientific studies than the people making lucrative careers off this, there are a couple of good episodes of The Studies Show podcast - one on UPFs and one on the microbiome. Worth a listen IMO in breaking down which claims are supported by high quality evidence and which are not.

Menora · 07/03/2024 11:40

@ColleenDonaghy I think there is enough evidence to show the basics of what makes an UPF. It is very obvious that a meat slurried reformed chicken nugget is UP. The grey area comes with processed foods that have elements of UP in the processing. Baked beans are a good one. Part of them is not UP at all, but part is. So we are faced with trying to decide which ones are ‘good’ or ‘bad’ or ones we just have to use moderation with. I would eat baked beans but I wouldn’t eat reformed meat.

BigSkies2022 · 07/03/2024 11:37

SnakesAndArrows · 07/03/2024 10:17

Can anyone define UPF? I don’t mean give me a list of supposedly UPF food types, I mean an actual definition? And then explain exactly how they are harmful backed up by real evidence.

Association/correlation does not prove causation. Of course people eating lots of low nutritional value food are going to be short on essential nutrients which will have adverse health effects.

It does not necessarily follow that the “chemicals” in ready meals are themselves causing problems. I mean, why are my burgers made of pea protein harmful and my peas that I just shelled out of the pods not harmful? Yes I get it that there’s fibre and more vitamins in the whole peas, so they are better nutritionally, but that doesn’t make my burger bad and somehow cancer-causing. If I eat 17 burgers and no veg, that’s what causes the harm.

The whole thing is a fad and someone’s making a lot of money out of the worried well. Again.

Read Chris van Tulleken's book. In all libraries. Or listen to the BBC series A Thorough Investigation by CVT if you prefer to listen than read. There's plenty of scientific evidence cited there, and it will be much more informative and accurate than someone off MN posting in a hurry.

And yes, it is the 'chemicals' in ready meals that are part of the problem. The gums, the emulsifiers, the long-chain/short-chain stuff that isn't food, but mimics food, so distorts brain to gut signals. Read up.

BobbyBiscuits · 07/03/2024 11:36

Some stuff like sliced bread and baked beans are UPFs, but not really unhealthy as part of a balanced diet. I do love my coca-cola. Full sugar version...not sure if the diet one is any worse in terms of UPF-ness?
It seems like ready meals and Mcdonalds come under this, and I do eat those as well sometimes. The Charlie Bigham's ready meals aren't so bad are they?

So I feel like I know what I'm doing when I consume these things, but not in excess and my weight is very low. I guess I feel it's a bit of a trendy way of telling people to eat healthier, which seems pretty obvious.

BeretRaspberry · 07/03/2024 11:35

Sususudio · 07/03/2024 11:33

As for poor people elsewhere who eat whole foods being malnutrioned, sure, because they often can't afford enough protein. But eating chicken nuggets and chips daily isn't exactly nutrition either.

Right now, of course, there is a lot of confusion about what is UPF and what isn't. I think the sugary cereals have been sold as health food for years, and it is going to take some time for people to find out they are not.

But it offers SOME nutrients, is easy to prepare and will fill hungry tummies.

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 11:35

maybein2022 · 07/03/2024 11:32

Interesting- this is definitely a step too far for me! I love vegetables and they form a big part of my diet. With fruit I am mindful of portion size as I agree it can hinder weight loss.

I also love vegetables

The carnivore approach is that the health benefits of vegetables are largely overstated

Eg: Spinach has iron, but meat has more iron

Plants have defence mechanisms (toxins) to stop us eating them. They don't just exist for us to eat. This is why children are taught not to eat strange plants/berries.

But when it comes to toxic animals that will kill us if we eat them, we can name most of those on one hand, even here in Australia!

Menora · 07/03/2024 11:35

I don’t eat a huge amount of fruit as it’s not filling. I eat more veg.

I do eat foods that have emulsifiers in them I am sure, I’m not that intense, I just try to avoid things I know have been predominantly formed from a disgusting vat of slurry paste. The meat is the worst for me in my mind

ColleenDonaghy · 07/03/2024 11:34

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 11:22

You don't need to be qualified to find factual sources that show how food is processed?

Or look up the studies that investigate UPFs?

She's a good middle man of knowledge, she hasn't made up how UPFs are made! For goodness sake.

Well I would rather take my cues from those with an academic interest in the area (same for any other advice I take in life). She doesn't actually appear to be in any way qualified to analyse or interpret academic research in this area (nor am I, but I'm not promoting myself as someone to listen to).

There doesn't appear to be any one accepted definition of UPFs, nor any research that demonstrates UPFs are harmful while also controlling for other confounding factors.

Even those on this thread who've said they have benefited from cutting UPFs have just described moving to a diet that would have been recognised as a healthier option for as long as I can remember.

I'm very very sceptical about the UPF labelling. I'm even more sceptical about unqualified influencers portraying themselves as experts in any field. I'm not at all sceptical about eating a diet with lots of fruit and veg, meals cooked broadly from scratch and minimal junk food. There's nothing new in that.

justteanbiscuits · 07/03/2024 11:33

I really enjoy cooking from scratch, but I must admit, highlighting the issues around UPF has caused me to cut down using them a bit more. I'm not perfect, and still use some things - things like stock pots etc for ease and things I really can't easily make. But I don't use jar sauces etc anymore.

Sususudio · 07/03/2024 11:33

As for poor people elsewhere who eat whole foods being malnutrioned, sure, because they often can't afford enough protein. But eating chicken nuggets and chips daily isn't exactly nutrition either.

Right now, of course, there is a lot of confusion about what is UPF and what isn't. I think the sugary cereals have been sold as health food for years, and it is going to take some time for people to find out they are not.

maybein2022 · 07/03/2024 11:32

JordanPeterson · 07/03/2024 11:25

I did introduce zucchini (courgette) & broccoli again during that time & the sweetness of them was incredible.

It is wild how the tongue can adapt to no sugar & then taste it in tiny amounts

I remember drinking a different brand of aspirin & knowing straight away it had sugar added ! You wouldn't think to check aspirin for sugar...

No fruit as it's sugar - It does seem that many people stall with weight loss due to replacing other treats with unlimited serves of fruit a day

Back in the day fruits were grown seasonally & a still a treat but now fruit is seen as the go to healthy option

Now treat fruit the same way I would chocolate

Interesting- this is definitely a step too far for me! I love vegetables and they form a big part of my diet. With fruit I am mindful of portion size as I agree it can hinder weight loss.

OP posts:
RedDuffle · 07/03/2024 11:30

NoFunNoFrills · 06/03/2024 23:39

I want to reduce UPF but struggle. Most of my main meals i cook from scratch, but then binge on things like biscuits when stressed/bored/sad. I need to reduce for weight as much as health, but I struggle long term.

For example, I was doing really well since Jan, with 6 weeks of no alcohol or UPF. But then had a stressful period where I ate comfort food and drank some alcohol. Then went on holiday and ate out most days, plus more alcohol.

Now I'm back home I've kept eating UPF snacks - mostly biscuits and then having a homemade sandwich for lunch (upf bread) instead of a salad. I also had a takeaway. This tends to be my life... I'll try to get back on the wagon again by Monday, but I don't imagine it will stick for more than a month or so.

Yoyo

Similar here. I know what I need to do but it's hard to stick by it, especially when things are busy/stressful.

I am making an effort to eat more fresh food but once you have one takeaway, for example, it's hard to get back into the mindset. But then they say that's one of the consequences of UPF don't they, addiction!

Sususudio · 07/03/2024 11:28

People keep saying it's a "new" way of eating ,but it really isn't. It may be new to the UK.

Wenttomowameadow · 07/03/2024 11:28

Usernamen · 07/03/2024 11:19

The people saying “where do you find the time?!” - how much time do you spend on Mumsnet every day?

This is a bit like the exercise threads. Pages and pages of a handful of users spending hours arguing about how their life is so busy they can’t possibly do a 20-minute YouTube workout.

I look at Mumsnet when I'm supposed to be working in the office. I suppose I could whip out a food processor but not sure my colleagues will appreciate it.

Menora · 07/03/2024 11:27

It’s more expensive to not eat UPF’s and this is why no one is going to act and do anything about it. Big profits, cheap food. All we can do is make decisions for ourselves based on information and the resources we have

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 11:27

It's definitely more expensive to eat healthily and to cook from scratch. Also factor in the energy cost, not just the ingredients cost. It's eyewatering - I've just cooked a home made banana bread and will be cooking chicken for dinner and it shows on my smart meter how much energy this uses!

I do think though that there is nuance and room to evaluate UPFs. Like, soy milk and baked beans count, but with baked beans, it's not like they've slurried and reformed the beans.

There is just so much evidence out there now though to show that all the crisps, biscuits, cakes etc are so universally bad for us in so many ways - addictive, devoid of nutrients, unsatisfying, full of stuff we shouldn't be eating.

I haven't cut out UPFs btw yet, but the more I learn about them, the more irresponsible it feels to eat them.

Sususudio · 07/03/2024 11:25

ah so @LuckySantangelo35 I don't go to the gym ever! That's where the time comes from. I am a healthy enough weight.

I don't bake either. No one in the house is that keen on sweets.

Swipe left for the next trending thread