Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are not reducing your intake of UPF…

634 replies

maybein2022 · 06/03/2024 20:39

… with all the media attention on UPF at the moment and so much research coming out about it. Interested to know. If you’re NOT reducing your intake of it, is it because you’re not able to (finances/accessibility/time), because you don’t want to or don’t think it’s a problem, you and/or your kids are neurodivergent and a lot of ‘safe’ foods are UPF or other reasons.

YANBU: I am reducing mine/my family’s intake
YABU: I am not for reasons listed above (or other reasons)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
notacooldad · 07/03/2024 15:50

Exactly! Not everyone is aware of it. OP talks about "all the media attention". I don't see anything on this outside MN because I haven't gone looking for it.

It is one of these topics that unless you have shown an interest in it it doesn't appear on your media - social/news - streams

I disagree, I feel like I am being bombarded with info that I haven't gone looking for. There have been numerous tv programmes about it, radio shows, book recommendations in my news feeds etc People at work are talking about it.

I am getting really fed up with it, like it is a new concept but a lot of it is basically home cooking with single ingredient food and avoiding a lot of the snacks and drinks that are usually in bright packets trying to get your attention in the supermarket.

kidyounot2 · 07/03/2024 15:49

Yogatoga1 · 07/03/2024 13:08

The issue is these issues are on a population level.

you can say “I did A and X didn’t happen, therefore the research wrong”.

But that doesn’t change the fact that on a population level, if someone does A, they are more likely to experience X.

doesn’t mean they will, it means stats show they increase their risk.

any anecdote or personal observation doesn’t invalidate population wide studies.

epidemiologists don’t make this stuff up for shits and giggles you know.

https://www.nicswell.co.uk/health-news/evidence-of-breastfeeding-increasing-food-allergies-risks-not-clear-cut

Evidence of breastfeeding increasing food allergies risks not clear-cut | NICS Well

"Breastfed babies may face more than double the risk of developing food allergies," the Mail Online reports.

https://www.nicswell.co.uk/health-news/evidence-of-breastfeeding-increasing-food-allergies-risks-not-clear-cut

chaosmaker · 07/03/2024 15:46

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/03/2024 07:55

People keep on going on about bread. There is nothing wrong with bread, it has been a staple of human diets for millennia.

Homemade bread or a nice artisan loaf is nicer but bread generally is not bad.

Giles Yeo is very good on this. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/06/ultra-processed-food-healthy-diets-pr

Edited

It's because we've changed the structure of the grains or something to be able to farm it more intesively. It's not the same as it was millenia ago...

kidyounot2 · 07/03/2024 15:45

Yogatoga1 · 07/03/2024 13:08

The issue is these issues are on a population level.

you can say “I did A and X didn’t happen, therefore the research wrong”.

But that doesn’t change the fact that on a population level, if someone does A, they are more likely to experience X.

doesn’t mean they will, it means stats show they increase their risk.

any anecdote or personal observation doesn’t invalidate population wide studies.

epidemiologists don’t make this stuff up for shits and giggles you know.

So where are the studies that show that being formula led leads to an increase in food allergies? I'd like to know...

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:45

notacooldad · 07/03/2024 15:38

What’s “ultra”?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/what_is_ultra-processed_food
Read this.
The current advice is to eat food as close to it's natural state as possible.
Of course you can't eat a chicken that hasn't been processed for example but you can buy plain chicken breast. You don't need one that is ultra processed and has a list of 15 ingredients in.
The recommendation is to eat single ingredient food as much as possible. So Greek yogurt and you add your own berries, banana, whatever is good. Yogurt with fruit already in isn't that great once you read the label and see their is a list of ingredient's including a ton of sugar.

That BBC page is just a re-hash of unscientific ’foodie’ nonsense.

Calliopespa · 07/03/2024 15:43

daisychain01 · 06/03/2024 20:48

We mainly cook from scratch but the latest research into the effects of UPF and just how ubiquitous all those ghastly additives are, has made us rethink some of the choices we make.

Mainly it's about substituting some of the ingredients we have bought for convenience, rather than needing whole scale changes. Things like replacing the small pots of pasta sauce which are full of sugar and salt, with tomato passata and fresh mushrooms and olives. Porridge instead of Weetabix Minis, plain instead of fruit yoghurts etc.

it's evil what the food industry has done to the food in the supermarkets, and it's happened by stealth before our eyes.

I think this is a good approach and similar to what we do: eat the same but find simpler versions of the ingredients. Rude Health do some brilliant spelt cereal and puffed rice which our dcs have for breakfast and which has no additives. Many children go out the door already full of salt and sugar from their “ healthy” cereal breakfast .

Blanketpolicy · 07/03/2024 15:43

Panpastels · 06/03/2024 20:50

What is UPF?

Exactly! Not everyone is aware of it. OP talks about "all the media attention". I don't see anything on this outside MN because I haven't gone looking for it.

It is one of these topics that unless you have shown an interest in it it doesn't appear on your media - social/news - streams.

maybein2022 · 07/03/2024 15:42

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 15:15

Literally same.

Someone joked up thread about living on homemade cookies being okay, but I am on a diet and was really struggling with not binging on biscuits and chocolate bars.

I made banana bread today which I usually just make for the kids and avoid myself because I can't easily calorie count it (!) - I've had a chunk and my sweet craving is satisfied. I'm working in the kitchen rn and I feel no crazy urge to gorge myself on the rest of it.

If it was a pack of kit kats it would be long gone 3 hours ago 😅

This is exactly the same for me and I said a similar thing earlier on this thread. A homemade cake does not (for me) lead to binging/overeating. Having a twix probably would.

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 15:38

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:27

What’s “ultra”?

Wikipedia gives this basic definition of UPF:
‘Ultra-processed food (UPF) is an industrially formulated edible substance derived from natural food or synthesized from other organic compounds.’

A quick rule of thumb for spotting them is that they tend to contain ingredients you wouldn’t find in a normal kitchen. The ‘more than 5 ingredients’ thing isn’t a clear identifier, it’s just likely to be UPF but won’t always.

As I said upthread it’s hard to come up with a 100% perfect,foolproof, non culturally specific definition, but most of the time it’s fairly clear.

Organic compound - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_compounds

Gwenhwyfar · 07/03/2024 15:38

Can't organise myself / too lazy.

For example, on Tuesday I went out with friends so we eat out. The healthiest option was more expensive than less healthy. Not sure it was UPF, but it was probably deep fried.

Wednesday had an evening class at 5.30. Eat a banana on the way and then in the break a cake type thing from the machine. Yes, I could have pre-packed something but that would have been sandwiches with supermarket bread so ultra-processed anyway I suppose.

For work, I have a microwave where I could re-heat something I've cooked at home, but that means spending a couple of evenings a week peeling and chopping veg rather than relaxing so most days I just grab something.

notacooldad · 07/03/2024 15:38

What’s “ultra”?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/what_is_ultra-processed_food
Read this.
The current advice is to eat food as close to it's natural state as possible.
Of course you can't eat a chicken that hasn't been processed for example but you can buy plain chicken breast. You don't need one that is ultra processed and has a list of 15 ingredients in.
The recommendation is to eat single ingredient food as much as possible. So Greek yogurt and you add your own berries, banana, whatever is good. Yogurt with fruit already in isn't that great once you read the label and see their is a list of ingredient's including a ton of sugar.

What is ultra-processed food?

What is ultra-processed food?

BBC Food

https://www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/what_is_ultra-processed_food

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 15:28

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:21

There are some foods that certainly taste and look better if they’re eaten as they come. I always want some decent fat on a steak.

But most food is ‘processed’ in some way. We separate out fruits from stalks and tubers from leaves, etc. We grind flour and boil beetroot. We pluck, skin and butcher animals: a chicken curry is not a dead, feathered whole chicken stuffed in a pot with raw ingredients.

Mincing beef is no more ‘processing’ than is shelling peas.

Oh definitely I completely agree! I wouldn't call cooked potatoes ultra processed either.

I think there are 4 categories which seems sensible to me - unprocessed which is your raw apple, minimally processed which is your apple sticks, processed which is your pure apple sauce or even your home made apple pie, and ultra processed which is your long life ambient temperature apple flavoured fruit loaf.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:27

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 15:24

Yes most food is processed but nobody is saying we shouldn’t be eating processed food at all, they are saying we should be limiting ultra processed food.

What’s “ultra”?

SoOriginal · 07/03/2024 15:26

I have cut it down to almost zero for around the last 6 months. It has almost doubled my food shop cost and tripled cooking time. It really is unaffordable and impractical for many unfortunately.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 15:24

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:21

There are some foods that certainly taste and look better if they’re eaten as they come. I always want some decent fat on a steak.

But most food is ‘processed’ in some way. We separate out fruits from stalks and tubers from leaves, etc. We grind flour and boil beetroot. We pluck, skin and butcher animals: a chicken curry is not a dead, feathered whole chicken stuffed in a pot with raw ingredients.

Mincing beef is no more ‘processing’ than is shelling peas.

Yes most food is processed but nobody is saying we shouldn’t be eating processed food at all, they are saying we should be limiting ultra processed food.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 15:21

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 15:05

The point is, the more processed an ingredient is, the more rapidly it is digested. Think about how difficult a raw potato is to digest; we cook them to break down the strong plant cell structures and make them edible.

Even thoroughly grinding beef makes it more digestible than a whole cut. Even if you got fancy steak and ground it at home.

I don't know about McDonald's specifically, if they really do only grind their meet and they don't add any artificial ingredients, then that's lovely. I like a quarter pounder!

I think the point is, the large quantities of very easily eaten, very easily digested, very easily available highly processed foods are not good for people. And even if the ingredients sound similar, research is emerging that they're just not quite the same. Or more accurately, they don't have quite the same effect on our bodies as a less processed version of the same meal.

My personal theory is that we're not really designed to cope with the way UPFs digest in our bodies. I once read a study on hunter gather diets, and they actually get quite a large proportion of their calories through simple sugar (honey). But this would go along with lots of vegetable matter and minimally processed meat.

My own experience is that food that is highly digestible, quick and easy to eat and super palatable mainly falls into the UPF category. Even a delicious home made sandwich with homemade bread is not as soft and easy to eat as soft fluffy processed bread and soft chicken breast with added water etc. For some reason these foods do not really fill me up and I could (and do!!) eat sooo much of them.

Even if there is literally nothing else negative about them (which I personally don't believe), I would still move toward limiting UPFs because I they are so so likely to lead to weight gain.

There are some foods that certainly taste and look better if they’re eaten as they come. I always want some decent fat on a steak.

But most food is ‘processed’ in some way. We separate out fruits from stalks and tubers from leaves, etc. We grind flour and boil beetroot. We pluck, skin and butcher animals: a chicken curry is not a dead, feathered whole chicken stuffed in a pot with raw ingredients.

Mincing beef is no more ‘processing’ than is shelling peas.

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 15:15

79andnotout · 07/03/2024 15:12

we don't eat upfs at home (except baked beans and tofu which are fine) but I eat some proper shite when travelling for work, as it can be difficult finding decent stuff on the road and also I'm terrible at resisting temptation especially when hungry. The thing I hate about UPFs is the uncontrolled nature of eating - I can demolish a packet of biscuits in one go but i'm unlikely to eat more than one home made flapjack. It always scares me how little control I seem to have.

Literally same.

Someone joked up thread about living on homemade cookies being okay, but I am on a diet and was really struggling with not binging on biscuits and chocolate bars.

I made banana bread today which I usually just make for the kids and avoid myself because I can't easily calorie count it (!) - I've had a chunk and my sweet craving is satisfied. I'm working in the kitchen rn and I feel no crazy urge to gorge myself on the rest of it.

If it was a pack of kit kats it would be long gone 3 hours ago 😅

79andnotout · 07/03/2024 15:12

we don't eat upfs at home (except baked beans and tofu which are fine) but I eat some proper shite when travelling for work, as it can be difficult finding decent stuff on the road and also I'm terrible at resisting temptation especially when hungry. The thing I hate about UPFs is the uncontrolled nature of eating - I can demolish a packet of biscuits in one go but i'm unlikely to eat more than one home made flapjack. It always scares me how little control I seem to have.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2024 15:08

The Roasting Tin books by Rukmini Iyer are great for food from scratch that is also quick and easy.

A lot of people seem unsure of the difference between processed and ultra processed. Not all processed food is UPF. And the distinction referred to by a pp about UPF being made by a multinational is not a common one though it may well have been part of the original literature.
It’s always going to be a rough and ready distinction with some marginal cases and other elements that are subjective. For instance for most western cooks, MSG wouldn’t be an ingredient you find in a normal kitchen; for many Chinese people it’s standard. However for the most part it’s clear enough, and generally people advising the consumption of less UPF are saying you should eat mostly non UPFs, not that you must aim for absolute perfection.

SnowflakeSparkles · 07/03/2024 15:05

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 14:31

But what if you only mince the beef? Like McDonalds do? Do you think mince is ‘processed’?

And why is McDonalds bread any more UPF than anyone else’s?

The point is, the more processed an ingredient is, the more rapidly it is digested. Think about how difficult a raw potato is to digest; we cook them to break down the strong plant cell structures and make them edible.

Even thoroughly grinding beef makes it more digestible than a whole cut. Even if you got fancy steak and ground it at home.

I don't know about McDonald's specifically, if they really do only grind their meet and they don't add any artificial ingredients, then that's lovely. I like a quarter pounder!

I think the point is, the large quantities of very easily eaten, very easily digested, very easily available highly processed foods are not good for people. And even if the ingredients sound similar, research is emerging that they're just not quite the same. Or more accurately, they don't have quite the same effect on our bodies as a less processed version of the same meal.

My personal theory is that we're not really designed to cope with the way UPFs digest in our bodies. I once read a study on hunter gather diets, and they actually get quite a large proportion of their calories through simple sugar (honey). But this would go along with lots of vegetable matter and minimally processed meat.

My own experience is that food that is highly digestible, quick and easy to eat and super palatable mainly falls into the UPF category. Even a delicious home made sandwich with homemade bread is not as soft and easy to eat as soft fluffy processed bread and soft chicken breast with added water etc. For some reason these foods do not really fill me up and I could (and do!!) eat sooo much of them.

Even if there is literally nothing else negative about them (which I personally don't believe), I would still move toward limiting UPFs because I they are so so likely to lead to weight gain.

drspouse · 07/03/2024 15:00

IcedPurple · 07/03/2024 14:30

I think the 'definition' as given by Chris (or is it Zand?) Van Tullken is that UPF is any dish which contains ingredients which wouldn't be found in a household kitchen. So the likes of emulsifiers, preservatives, stabalisers and the rest.

I've also heard it being used for any dish with more than 5 ingredients, but that sounds daft. If we're including spices, I regularly cook 'from scratch' dishes with well over 10, let alone 5, ingredients.

That's ok then, I can just live on home made cookies!

BarrelOfOtters · 07/03/2024 14:57

I think focussing on UPFs in the way it is being done isn't necessarily helpful.

But was standing outside my local coop the other day watching the cages going in with the new deliveries and was really struck how much of it was high sugar/fat. Bottles of pop, Doritos, biscuits. Nothing fresh.

stayathomer · 07/03/2024 14:55

I think we have a decent balance, mostly home prepared food and then some days where we’d need something quick and easy. As someone said above you can watch these things, cut down if you need to but I know too many people who died way too early in life from a range of things, some so random that you’d never know ‘today could be my last day on earth’. Add to this people who were so healthy and died of cancer and heart attacks (sadly in 30s, 40s and 50s) and the range of people I know in their 90s who aren’t that healthy… there’s only so much you can worry in life

ChocolateCinderToffee · 07/03/2024 14:48

About 40 years ago I saw a documentary on the processed meat industry in the UK and I haven't eaten a burger since. I do eat some UPFs, but rarely meat ones except cured meat and fish (ham, smoked salmon and mackerel). Another thing that made a great impression on me and I can't remember who said it, was a quote I read on social media to the effect that supermarkets are full of things that aren't food but are packaged to look like it. For example, jars of sauces, cheap ready meals and so on. At the moment I am trying to lose weight by low carbing and the amount of hidden sugar in things is astonishing. If it's not hidden sugar, it's hidden sweeteners.

One issue with cooking from scratch is the amount of time and energy it takes. Another is, you find yourself shopping three times a week if you eat fresh veg and fruit. It is cheaper, but only if you don't get carried away by all the nice food for sale. I've always liked vegetables and there are few I don't like (hello sprouts!) so I have to be careful. Ready meals are full of bulking agents like sauces full of refined starch, so they look as though you are getting more food than you actually are. If you're replacing that bulk with fresh vegetables, you find yourself using a lot more.

Imfreetofeelgood · 07/03/2024 14:37

I've recently took early retirement, and I'm definately looking at this, now that I'm not stressed and snacking on rubbish all the time. I've always eaten loads of fruit and veg, but lots of UPF also. I was vegetarian for 25 years and cringe now at the meat substitutes I consumed. Absolute rubbish. My DS is ND and lives on UPF - I'm happy if he will eat ANY new food.