Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sack her?

143 replies

Jemmy78 · 06/03/2024 20:14

Changed name as friends might recognise this situation if they're on here.

More of a WWYD.

I run a charity shop/centre. We're all volunteers. I don't get paid. It's a lot of work, and there are a lot of us putting in many hours of work every week. We do an amazing job and make a lot of money for our cause.

We've been running for a number of years. Some volunteers have been there since the beginning, and some have joined recently.

Some of the "old crew" don't like the "new crew." It's all a bit ridiculous, and I try to keep things upbeat and positive. Unfortunately, I find it tends to be something women do to each other—I'm a woman, by the way. There has been some fighting and snide comments. Not a lot. But it happens.

There's one woman in particular who's known for being nasty. It's just her way. I don't know whether it's misplaced humour or if she's just a piece of work.

She missed a big meeting we had a few weeks ago. No biggie. It wasn't compulsory. When I saw her later in the week, I said I'd go through some of the main points. She said, "Why bother? Nothing ever bloody changes?"

I let that one go. I was miffed because it had been a very positive meeting, but I didn't want the aggro. But I was cross that she'd been so rude and dismissive. We'd talked about a lot of important things in the meeting - finance, budget, projects for 2024...

Last week, I was in another meeting. I had to go into the main room to get a pen because mine had run out. I asked her if I could borrow one from behind the till.

The next day, a customer, who was in the shop at the time, contacted me and said that the woman working was very discourteous and rude and that she really shouldn't be working in the shop. I asked what she'd said, and apparently, she'd said - about me as I was walking away but out of earshot - "Jesus. Just look at the bloody arse on that,"

I'm very overweight. It sounds like something she'd say. There's no reason for this customer to lie.

Under normal circumstances, she'd be "sacked" or asked to leave. But, she's an old woman, lives on her own, no friends, has nothing except this charity work, her kids all live abroad... and I know I'd feel guilty if I got rid of her. At the same time, my mum died last year, and if she was still here, she'd be telling me not to take any shit off this woman and that I should never allow anyone to speak about me like that. Well, not in a professional setting, at any rate.

WWYD?

OP posts:
FloofCloud · 07/03/2024 12:37

I'd pull her into a formal meeting. Set out your expectations, no bullying, no nasty comments and absolutely no nastiness in front of any one, staff or customers. Tell her there's been a very serious complaint made about her, and under normal circumstances you'd have to fire her, but if you want her to have a chance then give her a one off chance to prove she's changed (doubt she will!) .
Personally I'd say that her bullying and this disrespectful behaviour isn't going to be tolerated as she's the cause of unrest for others.
Its the affect it may have on the charity that would bother me

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 12:34

Charity shops put too much pressure on the managers.

Charity shops usually work with a system of having one paid manager, and then a team of volunteers.

This then puts a lot of pressure on the manager, as obviously you can't depend on volunteers to cover all of the hours. People often only volunteer for two hours a week, and they often cancel.

This then leads to the manager being under a lot of stress.

I used to volunteer in a charity shop. Very sadly, my very lovely manager ended up killing herself, because of the stress that the charity shop put her under.

She used to work five days a week. Her manager told her that she would have to start working six days a week, as she didn't have enough volunteers to cover thw hours.

She killed herself. To this day I wish she hadnt let them get to her that much, i wish she had got another job. But her mother told me that the charity organisation had broken her down so badly that her mental health was really badly affected.

I'm still anoyed and upset about It Rip Trudi.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 12:31

I don’t care if she goes or doesn’t go.

Volunteers aren’t employees. There are no laws governing the use of volunteers (other than H+S) and they can’t take you to a tribunal/court for telling them to stop so I don’t see the value.

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 12:26

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 12:21

Of course legal advice isn’t needed to draft something that basically says “don’t be a twat”.

She's drafting a document for all future volunteers coming into her organisation.

She says there is an office that gives free legal advice to charities, near her, and she wants to go.

Why do you want her not to go?

5128gap · 07/03/2024 12:25

Her personal circumstances are irrelevant. Her volunteering should be terminated because of her remark, as not only has she subjected you to behaviour you shouldn't be expected to tolerate, she also brought the charity into disrepute in front of a member of the public. You should however check your own attitudes as your own post contains remarks that could be taken as both sexist and ageist, and once you start (correctly) operating a zero tolerance approach, you will be expected to lead by example.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 12:21

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 11:55

I've worked in a lot of charities. Every charity that I've worked in, had the volunteers sign a code of conduct.

Of course legal advice is needed to draft a code of conduct.

Op needs to have herself covered.

Of course legal advice isn’t needed to draft something that basically says “don’t be a twat”.

Growlybear83 · 07/03/2024 12:19

The OP said "There's a quorum and a committee. We have an AGM and all that jazz". I assume 'a committee' is a management committee?

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 12:17

Growlybear83 · 07/03/2024 12:01

As a volunteer yourself, OP, do you have the authority to tell the woman that her services are no longer required? Would it not have to be agreed by your management committee?

She said she doesn't have a management committee.

It seems to be a strange way of running a place. It's too much responsibility on one person.

I used to volunteer in a charity shop, and they had a management committee.

Spuddy58 · 07/03/2024 12:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Growlybear83 · 07/03/2024 12:01

As a volunteer yourself, OP, do you have the authority to tell the woman that her services are no longer required? Would it not have to be agreed by your management committee?

sweetgingercat · 07/03/2024 11:55

You are not responsible for her personal situation and the decisions she has made in life that mean she has few friends / relatives around. She is not relying on you for income and presumably there are other volunteer opportunities around for her.

You are responsible for your shop, your team of volunteers and your customers. She is a member of the team and she needs to respect you as her manager, her co-workers and her customers. This is what you need to focus on. She seems disruptive at all levels. I would take her aside, list the issues and ask her why she is not pulling her weight and contributing as a member of the team.I would list the things that have happened that are unacceptable - her treatment of co-workers, her unprofessionalism in front of clients - and explain these will not be tolerated in the future. Set out suggestions as to how she needs to become a better team member and charity representative - coming to meetings, adopting new policies, helping new volunteers - with concrete examples and measurable goals and tell her you will be monitoring her progress with a view to meeting in one month to review her progress. After the meeting send her a letter to document your concerns and the changes she needs to make. If she makes them, then good. If she doesn’t, then she needs to go.

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 11:55

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 10:28

There is no volunteering contract that is legal. So what legal advice would be needed to remove a volunteer?

(Again, I was a HR Director for a large national
charity (tens of thousands of volunteers) until recently.)

I've worked in a lot of charities. Every charity that I've worked in, had the volunteers sign a code of conduct.

Of course legal advice is needed to draft a code of conduct.

Op needs to have herself covered.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 11:47

voluntary employees

Volunteers. Not employees. Important distinction.

penjil · 07/03/2024 11:33

TeenLifeMum · 06/03/2024 21:49

I’d start calling her out every time “Mabel, don’t be rude!” Repeat, repeat, repeat.

The OP isn't managing a care home!

She's managing voluntary employees in a retail setting.

This lady's attitude is appalling, she's been rude about management in front of customers, and is a bad penny.

I'd be having a meeting with her, and telling her enough is enough, and she is on her final warning. Any more off-hand remarks or poor behaviour, and she can find somewhere else to volunteer at!

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 07/03/2024 10:43

I think it’s the combination of OP phrasing it as “sacking” this woman and people not reading the updates.

OP does not have to follow any kind of disciplinary process here. She could make it as simple as not rostering this woman on for any shifts and saying “I have all the volunteers I need, thank you”. The OP doesn’t owe this woman anything other than basic courtesy (and of course vice versa - there’s nothing to stop her saying she doesn’t want to volunteer anymore, and no need for a notice period).

However, if OP did want to take it further than simply saying “Don’t come in anymore” - even just to make a statement to the other volunteers about how such behaviour will be dealt with - she could follow the advice in the link shared by @Fluffygoon, which also makes clear there is no obligation:

https://www.ncvo.org.uk/help-and-guidance/involving-volunteers/supporting-and-managing-volunteers/dismissing-a-volunteer/

Dismissing a volunteer

https://www.ncvo.org.uk/help-and-guidance/involving-volunteers/supporting-and-managing-volunteers/dismissing-a-volunteer/

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 10:28

poetryandwine · 07/03/2024 09:16

I agree with this. It could be that for a first offence of this nature a warning is required, and you would get in trouble for sacking her.

Do you have the contact details of the woman who made the complaint? Otherwise it is your word against the volunteer’s and she sounds possibly like someone who would make trouble for you.

To be clear, I think her comment is completely unacceptable and it might be time for her to go. But it doesn’t always work that way.

There is no volunteering contract that is legal. So what legal advice would be needed to remove a volunteer?

(Again, I was a HR Director for a large national
charity (tens of thousands of volunteers) until recently.)

CantDealwithChristmas · 07/03/2024 10:14

Absolutely sack her. She's bullying you. Also, if she carries on like that she's going to put customers off coming to the shop, which would defeat your charitable purpose.

I certainly wouldn't continue to patronise a shop in which a member of staff spoke about another member of staff like that.

PinkIcedCream · 07/03/2024 09:58

I think you need to step up your people management skills rather than going straight to getting rid of her. You could alienate the other volunteers for one thing. They might not like her but the lack of steps being followed would worry them.

If you’re not cut out to manage staff (and it’s not that easy to do it well), appoint someone else who has the ability to calmly manage a difficult situation and turn things around.

poetryandwine · 07/03/2024 09:24

Jemmy78 · 06/03/2024 22:50

Yes, there's a centre in the next town that gives free legal advice for charities. I will contact them about a code of conduct and anything else I might be missing. That's a good idea. I need a bit of back up.

Sorry, OP. I have just seen thatvyou have no HR or code of conduct. So yes, taking legal advice for the reasons I mentioned is a great idea.

I think you need a code of conduct, also.

poetryandwine · 07/03/2024 09:16

Zone2NorthLondon · 06/03/2024 22:24

Your organisation will have HR policies, you need to be briefed on those
Take internal advice

I agree with this. It could be that for a first offence of this nature a warning is required, and you would get in trouble for sacking her.

Do you have the contact details of the woman who made the complaint? Otherwise it is your word against the volunteer’s and she sounds possibly like someone who would make trouble for you.

To be clear, I think her comment is completely unacceptable and it might be time for her to go. But it doesn’t always work that way.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 07/03/2024 09:09

NoTouch · 07/03/2024 08:18

You need to be professional about it and prioritise what is import to you. The charity its customers and beneficiaries could suffer due to her attitude.

Have a meeting with her. Layout out the facts without emotion - what she said, the impact on the customer, the impact on the team (you), and state it is behaviour that will not be tolerated, ask her if she has anything she wishes to say and take note of her responses (don't debate them), give her a written warning and lay out what will happen if there are any further complaints or similar behaviour.

Hopefully it will be enough of a slap on the wrist to make her think.

You can’t apply a formal disciplinary process to an informal environment. “Give her a written warning” - for what? A breach of policy? There IS no policy. We can argue about whether OP and others involved in the charity should have implemented a code of conduct, but for now, OP can only deal with things as they are, not how they should have been.

All applying a formal process here can do is convince this woman she has the same rights as an employee - meaning she’ll continue to be a nuisance. She doesn’t have those rights. I personally would get rid of her now, but if OP doesn’t want to, she needs to talk to her in very firm terms about how she will not put up with it and that she won’t get another chance (no talks of official warnings or similar).

I’d then take an immediate opportunity to let all volunteers know that, due to recent issues, you are instituting a code of conduct, and that anyone not willing to abide by it is no longer welcome as a volunteer. They will all know it’s her and will hopefully realise you won’t put up with it any longer.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/03/2024 09:01

BMW6 · 07/03/2024 08:16

You're overthinking this.

She's plain Nasty. She'll spread misery like a fart under a duvet.

Tell her she is no longer wanted because her attitude and behaviour is detrimental to the shop.

I've never heard that expression before and it's absolutely brilliant!
Spreading misery like a fart under a duvet!!! 😂

LookItsMeAgain · 07/03/2024 08:58

Jemmy78 · 06/03/2024 22:48

The two people she usually volunteers with have English as a second language, so I don't think they really understand what she's like. But the customers do. And other volunteers if they cross her path at events. She's also always bought my kids birthday and Christmas presents. She really has got nothing else and I know I'd feel bad for her. I know it's her own fault for being such a bitch - and she really is a piece of work - but the idea of her (or anyone[ having nothing and nobody is kind of upsetting.

I think you need to take her personal situation out of the equation.
What she may or may not have outside of this particular role is not your concern in order to get this issue resolved.

Keep her age and situation out of the conversation and keep it as factual as possible, thanking her for what she has done up to now but you need to have a word with her about what she said recently.

Perhaps this is the perfect time to do a rejig of who does what in the team? That way it could be seen as a general rejig of the team and she isn't the only one being affected by what is going on.

Do you have any roles that are not customer facing that she might be able to do? If you do, I'd have a chat with her and tell her that due to her behaviour and her personal comments that a customer raised in complaint to you about, she is being moved to a non-customer facing role.

If she doesn't want that unfortunately, you no longer have a role that she can fulfil and she might be better off finding volunteer work with another charity or somewhere else but you cannot use her any more.

That would be my advice.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 07/03/2024 08:49

MumblesParty · 07/03/2024 07:29

If I heard a member of staff being rude like that in a shop, it would put me off going to the shop. At the end of the day, the purpose of your shop isn’t to provide an activity for volunteers. It’s to provide money for your charity. And if the behaviour of a staff member is reducing the amount of money made, then surely action has to be taken.

This is it in a nutshell. By volunteering, she is supposed to be there for the charity; the charity isn’t there for her. If she wants a hobby, she can join a book club or a knitting circle, or play bridge. The rules may be unwritten here, but she’s clearly broken them, and in the absence of any hierarchy, OP can and should take action to get rid of her.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 08:19

You can’t sack a volunteer, but you can absolutely end their volunteering opportunity. (Was HR Director for a very large national charity until recently.)

What you walk by you accept. Don’t accept any more of this.