Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sack her?

143 replies

Jemmy78 · 06/03/2024 20:14

Changed name as friends might recognise this situation if they're on here.

More of a WWYD.

I run a charity shop/centre. We're all volunteers. I don't get paid. It's a lot of work, and there are a lot of us putting in many hours of work every week. We do an amazing job and make a lot of money for our cause.

We've been running for a number of years. Some volunteers have been there since the beginning, and some have joined recently.

Some of the "old crew" don't like the "new crew." It's all a bit ridiculous, and I try to keep things upbeat and positive. Unfortunately, I find it tends to be something women do to each other—I'm a woman, by the way. There has been some fighting and snide comments. Not a lot. But it happens.

There's one woman in particular who's known for being nasty. It's just her way. I don't know whether it's misplaced humour or if she's just a piece of work.

She missed a big meeting we had a few weeks ago. No biggie. It wasn't compulsory. When I saw her later in the week, I said I'd go through some of the main points. She said, "Why bother? Nothing ever bloody changes?"

I let that one go. I was miffed because it had been a very positive meeting, but I didn't want the aggro. But I was cross that she'd been so rude and dismissive. We'd talked about a lot of important things in the meeting - finance, budget, projects for 2024...

Last week, I was in another meeting. I had to go into the main room to get a pen because mine had run out. I asked her if I could borrow one from behind the till.

The next day, a customer, who was in the shop at the time, contacted me and said that the woman working was very discourteous and rude and that she really shouldn't be working in the shop. I asked what she'd said, and apparently, she'd said - about me as I was walking away but out of earshot - "Jesus. Just look at the bloody arse on that,"

I'm very overweight. It sounds like something she'd say. There's no reason for this customer to lie.

Under normal circumstances, she'd be "sacked" or asked to leave. But, she's an old woman, lives on her own, no friends, has nothing except this charity work, her kids all live abroad... and I know I'd feel guilty if I got rid of her. At the same time, my mum died last year, and if she was still here, she'd be telling me not to take any shit off this woman and that I should never allow anyone to speak about me like that. Well, not in a professional setting, at any rate.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Popquizzer · 07/03/2024 15:22

I think drawing up a code of conduct is fine and advisable, but not if it you feel that gives you permission to ignore the current issue.

A customer rang up to make a complaint about what was said in her presence. At a minimum you need to discuss that with the volunteer in question. It's much easier to distribute new guidelines generally but that's avoiding your job as manager. Ask the volunteer to sit down with you, tell her about the complaint and consider what to do after you've heard her response.

Zyq · 07/03/2024 14:13

Can you appoint a deputy, even a volunteer deputy, whose specific role is managing volunteers? If it's someone with HR experience, even better.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 14:12

But hey, there are others paying me for my advice and I can see you all (think you) know better. So I’ll say adieu.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 14:10

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 13:50

Any place that I've volunteered in has had codes of conduct. It's the done thing.

They’ve gone way beyond a code of conduct though.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 14:10

steppemum · 07/03/2024 13:49

no, we have had legal advice

There is a clear difference between a voluntary worker contract (which is work, and maybe that some of OPs people need this) and volunteers, which are still allowed, but where it is fine to outline your expectations and theirs.

There is nothign wrong with volunteers having a code of contact, or needing training.

Obviously you have only given a snapshot here but your headlines fall into categories that others have fallen fowl of. Hence me providing you verified links.

Bunnyhair · 07/03/2024 14:04

I wonder if you are hesitant because it’s you she made the comment about, so you feel it’s within your gift, so to speak, to let it go.

But what if she’d made that comment about another volunteer, or customer, or member of staff - and had a customer complain about it? Presumably you’d feel that had to be dealt with.

Tough shit that she’s an old lady who lives alone, etc etc. Lonely old ladies don’t get a special pass to be offensive and obstructive.

I am sorry for the loss of your Mum. She sounds like a lovely person with her head screwed on.

Lurkingandlearning · 07/03/2024 13:55

Your description of her personal life makes me think she might be bitter and resentful. No excuse for her behaviour but sometimes it becomes habitual and the bitter person is barely aware of what they are doing, how it affects others. It’s a bit of a twisted way of getting attention they’re lacking.

I agree with @DatingDinosaur. Ask her what it is she likes about coming to the charity shop. Keep questions on the positives - her mind focused on the positives. She might say she does it to get out of the house, give something back.

Then say all the volunteers have similar reasons and want to enjoy the experience. Ask her if she is aware that her comments spoil it somewhat. She’s bound to ask for an example. Tell her what the customer said in a tone that suggests it’s a fact. That will make her less likely to deny it. If she does give other examples. Ask her if she can keep those sort of thoughts to herself. If she wants to stay at the shop she’s unlikely to argue. Say, If she can’t she’ll have to find something else that suits her better.

Then if she repeats sack her. But you’ll know you did all you could for someone whose personal unhappiness is spoiling something that could alleviate that unhappiness- cutting their nose off to spite their face.

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 13:50

steppemum · 07/03/2024 13:49

no, we have had legal advice

There is a clear difference between a voluntary worker contract (which is work, and maybe that some of OPs people need this) and volunteers, which are still allowed, but where it is fine to outline your expectations and theirs.

There is nothign wrong with volunteers having a code of contact, or needing training.

Any place that I've volunteered in has had codes of conduct. It's the done thing.

steppemum · 07/03/2024 13:49

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 13:45

no, we have had legal advice

There is a clear difference between a voluntary worker contract (which is work, and maybe that some of OPs people need this) and volunteers, which are still allowed, but where it is fine to outline your expectations and theirs.

There is nothign wrong with volunteers having a code of contact, or needing training.

OneMoreTime23 · 07/03/2024 13:45

steppemum · 07/03/2024 13:25

I manage a team of volunteers to run a kids camp every year.

They all have to sign a volunteers agreement.
That includes:
a clear statement about what a volunteer is
committment to the hours and days of work
code of conduct
agreeing to certain training, non negotiable (eg safeguarding training)
agreeing to certain tasks.
accountability (who is the boss etc)

I would say that you need this as a matter of urgency.

Volunteering is great, but it works much better when clear ex[ectations are laid down on both sides.

With your lady, give her a volunteer agreement, point out any parts that you think she particularly needs to see, and tell her straight, that you want her to follow this, because it matters to you and to the charity/cause. If she can't do it, then one written warning and then out.

You’re veering into worker territory there. That’s a tribunal case waiting to happen.

https://www.warnergoodman.co.uk/site/blog/news/when-will-a-volunteer-be-considered-a-worker#:~:text=For%20example%2C%20it%20would%20be,as%20they%20choose%2C%20without%20penalty.

When will a volunteer be considered a worker? - Warner Goodman LLP

Many businesses and charities have volunteers on staff to perform work for the business. Employers need to be careful however, that their volunteers do not gain...

https://www.warnergoodman.co.uk/site/blog/news/when-will-a-volunteer-be-considered-a-worker#:~:text=For%20example%2C%20it%20would%20be,as%20they%20choose%2C%20without%20penalty.

poetryandwine · 07/03/2024 13:29

@OneMoreTime23 Your perspective is that of a highly experienced professional.

I also volunteer, and the paperwork is of the same flavour as that of my relatively progressive public sector job. I have no idea whether our behavioural code carries any weight, but it sets expectations and I think it is a good idea. Knowing how to do this properly directly from a solicitor (or being advised not to) could be invaluable to the OP - she doesn’t have your experience, and surely you can appreciate that the anonymous assurances of a stranger aren’t as confidence inspiring.

Also if this woman acts up when OP talks with her, it will be good for OP to know what authority she has.

RB68 · 07/03/2024 13:29

yeah volunteer CoC and behaviour standards, bit of training and also being clear what consequences of 3 raised issues is - ie being asked to leave.

Old and Lonely doesn't mean nice, not nice doesn't really deserve empathy in this situation. One bad egg can cause significant issues for the rest of the team making it unpleasant and they are volunteers they don't have to come. Whilst they are volunteers it doesn't give them the right to bad mouth people or clients with impunity

steppemum · 07/03/2024 13:25

I manage a team of volunteers to run a kids camp every year.

They all have to sign a volunteers agreement.
That includes:
a clear statement about what a volunteer is
committment to the hours and days of work
code of conduct
agreeing to certain training, non negotiable (eg safeguarding training)
agreeing to certain tasks.
accountability (who is the boss etc)

I would say that you need this as a matter of urgency.

Volunteering is great, but it works much better when clear ex[ectations are laid down on both sides.

With your lady, give her a volunteer agreement, point out any parts that you think she particularly needs to see, and tell her straight, that you want her to follow this, because it matters to you and to the charity/cause. If she can't do it, then one written warning and then out.

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 13:22

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 07/03/2024 13:20

OP. Sack the person
I've been to a chairty/hopice shop near us a few times over the years and give them items we don't want and some still in their original packing. We went over one Sunday morning to see if they would accept cushin covers, ost of them were in their packing - two of them were talking behind the counter so after about 40/50 seconds (we were in a hurry) asked if they would accept items and wanted to tell them they were brand new as IMO get them a bit more money - the look I got. However, I would still gift items but there was no need for that

Also, I feel it's not fair on OP to run a charity shop and working all of these hours for nothing. Charities should pay at least the expenses of of all volunteers and the volunteers decide if to accept or opt out The heads of charities and their commanders get paid, so why not you and your staff?

Edited

I absolutelt agree with your last part. I think that charities (at the very top)can be very cruel to their staff.

They often over over work the staff, and don't pay them at all all, or pay them very little.

They don't seem to think of paid employees wellbeing, or the volunteers wellbeing much.

Yet of course, at the top of a lot of the big charities, the ones at the very top get paid huge salaries. They definitely need to be regulated more

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 07/03/2024 13:20

OP. Sack the person
I've been to a chairty/hopice shop near us a few times over the years and give them items we don't want and some still in their original packing. We went over one Sunday morning to see if they would accept cushin covers, ost of them were in their packing - two of them were talking behind the counter so after about 40/50 seconds (we were in a hurry) asked if they would accept items and wanted to tell them they were brand new as IMO get them a bit more money - the look I got. However, I would still gift items but there was no need for that

Also, I feel it's not fair on OP to run a charity shop and working all of these hours for nothing. Charities should pay at least the expenses of of all volunteers and the volunteers decide if to accept or opt out The heads of charities and their commanders get paid, so why not you and your staff?

Kjones27 · 07/03/2024 13:09

Crikeyalmighty · 07/03/2024 12:41

@Kjones27 that is truly awful.

It was awful because she was truly so lovely. And she was only in her forties when she died. Her mother told me that oxfam completely broke her.

She definitely taught me a lesson of-

that i don't ever stay in a job that is abusing me.
It's not worth.your mental health . Or your life.

Stopwiththedamnrain · 07/03/2024 13:01

If she has no filter that may be why she has no friends and family keep a distance. Maybe she needs a period of self reflection.

Mels8 · 07/03/2024 12:59

It's a working environment, you have to abide by the law and or policy, for example the health and safety act which includes psychological safety for all as well as physical safety. Plus don't you have SOPs guide/policy to refer to such as conduct or behaviour policy?
There is also other statute law at play here to consider, not only to protect members of the public, but also everyone volunteering.
When taking on volunteers are they required to sign some type of agreement or is it completely informal?

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 12:55

If you don't get rid of her, I suspect you'll soon find that you'll lose a lot of your other volunteers (and probably customers) who don't want anything to do with her.

It would be perfectly reasonable to tell her you don't want her volunteering with you any more. Her personal circumstances are irrelevant (and in any case, if she wants to find another charity shop to volunteer at, she can).

RatatouillePie · 07/03/2024 12:46

Jemmy78 · 06/03/2024 23:13

Yeah, if she'd said it about someone else, and I'd heard it... it would be a different story. But it's not a different story, is it? I need to stop feeling sorry for her. If my kids had heard her and I'm pussyfooting around the issue, I'm not setting them a good example either. She's awful. I'll go the official route. We're closed for holidays at the moment, so it makes sense that this code of conduct could come in after the holidays. Fresh start. A bit more direction and authority from me. I'm such a wuss. I think the problem is that I'm more interested in the cause than the shop. And most volunteers are more interested in the shop.

She was rude and needs pulling up over it, and perhaps even a written warning.

I would call her into a meeting (have someone else with you), explain that you've had a complaint from a customer about her making rude comments about other people, and that it is not acceptable. If she asks what, then tell her what was said. I'd then explain that this is a warning, and any further misconduct will result in dismissal. I'd then hand her a letter with the warning in writing and expectations of how to conduct herself in the shop.

Is there anyone else within the charity you can take to the meeting with and discuss this with before hand?

Crikeyalmighty · 07/03/2024 12:41

@Kjones27 that is truly awful.

Applescruffle · 07/03/2024 12:40

Sack her. It's not you doing it to her, she's done it to herself. She shouldn't be allowed to get away with being so nasty to everyone just because she's older. It's completly unacceptable.

At the VERY LEAST speak to her about the arse comment. Its a rude and unnecessary comment and it made a customer feel uncomfortable. Don't let her get away with it.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/03/2024 12:39

Personally I don't feel obliged to keep people on regardless of their personal situation if they are that rude - even if volunteering . Let her go and be rude in someone else's outlet. She only has herself to blame. You are there to manage, so manage her out