Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The ideal financial set up for married couple

58 replies

GingerLiberalFeminist · 06/03/2024 19:17

So Mumsnet, your wise input is required!

TL:DR should couple share finances but wife also put dosh away just in case?

If you read MN you'll see the view for women is to keep financial independence, but men should share their finances totally (!).

Our current set up is DH and I have a joint account into which goes 80-85% of our wages. Our household income is about £75k. This covers household bills etc. £250 goes into joint savings each month, every three months we chuck some in joint ISAs or DD's savings or ISA (she's 1).

The rest of our wages is "fun money" for us each.

I put a portion of my fun money into an ISA and savings each month, just in case the unlikely event that I get read The Script and find myself out on a limb.

DH knows I have some separate savings, but not really how much. I know he has a few personal pots but they don't exceed mine.

Have we nailed it? Have we got a MN approved way of splitting finances? 😁

IABU - we haven't nailed it.
IANBU - we've nailed it

OP posts:
TheFancyPoet · 07/03/2024 10:15

Each family has individuals living there and the one with the higher income always ends up paying mortgage and bills. Wether you pay this out of a shared account or a single account and what else, what does it even matter. If you stay together, it all going to be spent or inherited by the one outliving the other, if you divorce, it will be divided.

wombat15 · 07/03/2024 10:10

Just noticed you have different amounts in your own accounts so that is in theory different to my set up as we have the same amount of fun/saving money.

wombat15 · 07/03/2024 10:06

We do the same as you OP. I have a lot of savings now. No idea about DH savings or exactly how much he earns.
Regarding financial independence, I think people are referring to having a job rather than separate savings.

ancienticecream · 07/03/2024 10:04

Seems good to me! 👍 Do you both contribute to a pension, too?

LoubieIoo · 07/03/2024 10:00

@mirror245 makes sense in your situation then. We are very similar spenders, similar family size, not bothered if a treat comes from the joint etc so I can see that's where the differences are. I just wondered how you felt that financial independence was lost, and when you've explained your situation it makes sense.

piealhxiprshl · 07/03/2024 09:51

Not for me as you have a disproportionate amount of fun money (unless you earn the same). We pool everything into the joint (but have our own accounts too because I think it's weird for an adult to not have their own bank account!), and then take a set (equal) amount each for our fun money. We have each earned different amount over the years, supported each other's careers, and both pull weight at home, right now I earn substantially more, but it just doesn't feel right for one to have more money than the other. We've been together since we were young and have basically built everything we have together, it's possibly different if you met later in life.

Copelia · 07/03/2024 09:47

100% joint works for us. However within that we have savings and investments which are in one or other of our names. In the unlikely event that I had to leave DH and he cleared out the joint accounts, I’d have plenty of money to last me until a legal settlement, and vice versa (this wasn’t the purpose of having some individual accounts but I can see it would be a benefit).

I wouldn’t be happy with anything other than 100% joint- we are a family, we have children together and we both contribute both financially and in other ways. Maybe I’d feel differently if DH suddenly became a gambling addict, don’t know.

Geneticsbunny · 07/03/2024 09:46

That works brilliantly unless one of you ends up not being able to work long term for example because of an illness or a disabled child who needs care, then the whole thing would fall apart. @GingerLiberalFeminist how would you deal with something unexpected like that? Would you have enough in savings to tide you over long term?

Goldwork · 07/03/2024 09:45

These things are easy if there is plenty of money and you're reasonably similar spenders. We don't have allocated fun money we both just spend what we want on a join credit card which I pay off in full each month. I put £2500 a month into a joint account where the bills and mortgage come out of and save anything left over. DH has a very erratic income but usually about 10k or so a year he just saves all of that. We focus on my pension as it's massively more tax efficient than paying into one for DH.

mirror245 · 07/03/2024 09:40

@LoubieIoo
Dh and I like to spend our own money on things that the other may not always agree with. For example, I like to treat my mum, sisters and nieces (clothes, meals out, theatre) outside of normal birthdays etc. there's no arguments, just I'm closer to my family than he is to his, so he doesn't see why I do it. He also has only 1 family member he would buy gifts for whereas I have about 15, so it wouldn't feel fair him subsidising my choices. I'm more of a spender generally than him, but I can afford it so don't need to be answerable to anyone.

Dh and I like to treat each other too and him buying me a surprise bunch of flowers/ taking me on a birthday trip from a joint account wouldn't feel the same.

We have a great relationship and this set up works for us.

Muddywalks34 · 07/03/2024 09:18

We do everything paid into one account, from there we transfer to joint savings/investments and then have equal funds in sole investments (ISA’s premium bonds and most tax efficient way to do it) so on paper we both have access to equal amounts. Bar my husbands pension he is very high earning and I am not, that said I am comfortable with this he pays the max in he can before tax so it makes sense for our long term future - I also have no concerns we would ever split and if we did I would be entitled to part of his pension anyway. We also own our house jointly without a mortgage. I think you have to just do what works best for you and what sits comfortably, as soon as we moved on from being a couple to being a family we reorganised everything so that it was joint and balanced. We have annual reviews with a financial advisor and appreciate I maybe in a better financial position to many but even before we got to that point and finances could be a struggle it just would never have occurred to me to squirrel money away for myself “just in case”

Everydayimhuffling · 06/03/2024 20:12

We do similar, except our savings have always been separate. We're thinking of adding a joint savings account now though.

I think joint account plus separate accounts is by far the best option. Only separate seems incredibly complicated for keeping things fair in terms of who pays for what. Only joint really doesn't seem safe to me. Escape fund forever!

Charlie2121 · 06/03/2024 20:00

I think it is all down to personal preference. If it works then it’s a suitable solution.

We’ve been together for about 20 years and have never even given consideration to a joint account. I just don’t see the point. We don’t need it.

TheFancyPoet · 06/03/2024 19:56

Well, I do it this way, anyway. Whoever wants it any other way, is welcome. I won't be even around reading it

GoingUpUpUp · 06/03/2024 19:55

Sounds like it works for you, in which case YANBU.

In our case we both pay our full salary/wages into a joint account and I control it. I hold the savings/pensions/investments so it’s basically win/win for me! Good job he trusts me!

LoubieIoo · 06/03/2024 19:55

mirror245 · 06/03/2024 19:47

Dh and I have been married 15 years and never had a joint account. We both earn pretty similar- about 55k each. We've no mortgage and 1dc. Both own our cars outright and no other debts (apart from some CC that we each pay off). We are each responsible for certain bills that roughly amount to the same amount. We have our own savings and investments. If we need to purchase something big or do repairs or pay for a holiday a we just split it 50:50. Take turns in paying for meals out etc.

We'll never have joint accounts. We both value our financial independence. Wouldn't work for everyone but does for us.

Just curious as to how having a joint account means you don't have financial independence? We have joint accounts and we take what we want when we want and we earn the same. We set up joint accounts when we moved in together years ago, we've since more than doubled our salaries and are not dependant on each other whatsoever.

TheFancyPoet · 06/03/2024 19:55

HelloDarlingWhatAreYouDoingHere · Today 19:21

My Grandparents did the following, they lived off my Grandfather's wage and saved my Grandmother's. They were very smart with money and enjoyed their retirement together.

That's it. This is how clever women and loving men do it. Everything is to protect the children , therefore the wife needs to be able to have the security just in case he goes first

HoppingPavlova · 06/03/2024 19:51

Ours is and has always been really uncomplicated. Joint accounts and if we want to spend anything we just do without consultation. There was never need for an escape fund on either side, as worse came to worse and one of us left the other, we’d have just hot footed it down to the bank to open individual accounts and had our pay directed there instead. I guess we would have asked the joint account to be frozen pending legal hoo haa, but no idea if freezing accounts in this scenario is actually possible.

LoubieIoo · 06/03/2024 19:50

You've nailed it if it works for you. We have a joint bills account and a joint everything else account. We earn the same, we take what we want when we want. We don't have our own pots of money. I manage all the monies anyway he wouldn't even know log in details (his choice). Can't imagine either of us would ever attempt to screw each other over.

mirror245 · 06/03/2024 19:47

Dh and I have been married 15 years and never had a joint account. We both earn pretty similar- about 55k each. We've no mortgage and 1dc. Both own our cars outright and no other debts (apart from some CC that we each pay off). We are each responsible for certain bills that roughly amount to the same amount. We have our own savings and investments. If we need to purchase something big or do repairs or pay for a holiday a we just split it 50:50. Take turns in paying for meals out etc.

We'll never have joint accounts. We both value our financial independence. Wouldn't work for everyone but does for us.

missshilling · 06/03/2024 19:45

I don’t really know what we do. There’s never been any debt collectors banging on the door though.

ViciousCurrentBun · 06/03/2024 19:40

One reason we don’t have joint accounts is we both invest so make individual decisions on those investments. We were investing before we got together and from young ages.

ViciousCurrentBun · 06/03/2024 19:39

We have separate accounts but the Mother of all spreadsheets, that we both deal with.

We have one joint account, it has about £100 in it. It’s a historical joke as is the tiny remnant of our wedding fund and it’s our 25 year anniversary this year. Whoever outlives the other is to spend it on a very nice dinner for themselves and to toast the departed.

PipsHip · 06/03/2024 19:32

It's fine if you're both happy and have thought through all scenarios in the future (poss divorce, pensions, death etc).

It wouldn't work for me though. We're married, we share everything. Dreams, hopes, bodies, money. All of it.

(I realise this is too simplistic for couples on a second marriage or who have non joint children).

mynameiscalypso · 06/03/2024 19:31

We have similar-ish in that we put an amount into the joint account in proportion to earnings and that pays bills. My share into the joint account is lower than it would be because I buy food/stuff for DS on my credit card. We do whatever we want with the leftover. We pay a bit extra each month into the joint account but otherwise all of our savings are totally separate. I like having my own stuff in my name which DH can't access (although he knows where it is in case I die). If we pay for something out of savings, we pay from it proportionally from each of our savings.