Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think children have a duty to help out elderly parents?

192 replies

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

OP posts:
SomeCatFromJapan · 06/03/2024 19:40

I haven't voted. It depends entirely on the individual relationships and the circumstances, I think.

BruFord · 06/03/2024 19:39

BeaRF75 · 06/03/2024 19:36

No they don't. We all have to take responsibility for ourselves, as already mentioned.

Ultimately, yes, @BeaRF75 but that doesn’t mean that we have to ignore or neglect someone. Regular phone calls, for example, can be a terrific boost for an elderly parent and it’s not a huge deal to have a 10-minute chat, is it?

Totally different if they’re abusive, of course.

takemeawayagain · 06/03/2024 19:37

No, no child asked to be born. They have no duty to do things for the people who chose to have them. If they want to then of course that's fine and lovely but 'duty'? No way. I will support and help my child for his whole life as much as I can - but I feel absolutely no duty towards my parents.

BeaRF75 · 06/03/2024 19:36

No they don't. We all have to take responsibility for ourselves, as already mentioned.

stayathomer · 06/03/2024 19:35

I think people have a duty to help out anyone they know who needs a bit of help. Given that your parents gave up so much for you, I can’t see why people wouldn’t want to help, but get that some can’t

Nottodaty · 06/03/2024 19:34

I do think it depends on the relationship.

My own Mum and I have an odd relationship. She isn’t maternal and isn’t so good with the grandchildren. Never babysat or offered financial help.
But I understand why she isn’t maternal due to her own upbringing and both my sisters and I can accept those ‘failings’ I know each of us would care for her when the time comes.

BUT I was very sick once and for a while I got to see she could be caring - she helped bath me, wash my hair and I could see the worry in her eyes. For those 6 weeks I knew she did care and for what ever reason she has a hard front on. Which is why I would care for her.

BruFord · 06/03/2024 19:32

i only have my elderly Dad now, he’s had lifelong MH problems and hasn’t been an ideal parent, but he’s not a monster.

I do feel that it’s my “duty” to support him from a humanitarian point of view. He’s a widower in his mid-80’s with multiple health problems, how could I not help him? We don’t all need to wipe bottoms, we can arrange care and support them emotionally, for example.

DH and I are involved with a homelessness charity and some people who need assistance have made unwise decisions and had their children taken into care. If we’re willing to support strangers, it would be illogical not to help our own parents!

Thelondonone · 06/03/2024 19:30

My mum was the best mum in the world but I won’t care for her and she’s in a residential home. I do live 5 hours away and would have done more if she was nearer but I don’t want to care for her. I also don’t want my kids to wipe my arse-but there will be more inheritance if they do-their choice 🤷‍♀️

BridieLand · 06/03/2024 19:30

It depends. My parents take an interest in our lives and help out with the kids. My DH's parents barely speak to him/us from one week to the next and don't help us out at all or even want to spend time with us/our kids. Will I help my parents when old? Sure. Will I help my in laws? I'll not rush to.

I hope to remain in my kids' lives when they grow up. If when they turn 18 I think all my responsibilities towards them are done and just leave them to get on with it without even a weekly phonecall I wouldn't expect them to drop everything to help me in my old age.

Relationships are a two way street - under 18s are exempt from this as they have no choice. Raising the kids you chose to have does not mean they have to help you in your old age, but if you treat them well they hopefully will want to.

RunnerDown · 06/03/2024 19:19

It obviously depends on your relationship with your parents. I brought mil to live with us for a short while( due to her having dementia and fil being in hospital). She stayed for around 5 months. I don’t think I could have done it for much longer. But we offered pil lots of support at home and I would absolutely do the same for my dm. But they were so supportive when dc were young and we have a good relationship.
I would really hope that my own dc would offer myself and dh support if we needed it in later life. ( and I know that they would). But I would never want them to do it to the level that it was a burden or it was destroying their own lives/ relationships. I would prefer to go into care than that happened .
There is a happy medium- sometimes family expect so much from the state without taking any responsibility themselves. I would exclude from this argument people who were abused by their parents . But I think if you have had a good upbringing you do owe your parents something

Milli0ns · 06/03/2024 19:19

I helped out my elderly parents because I wanted to. I felt no sense of duty or obligation. My parents made provision for when they were unable to care for themselves. They didn’t expect me to bear the burden of their ill health. I wanted to help them because I loved them. No other reason.

TooMuchJunkInTheTrunk · 06/03/2024 19:15

YABU

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/03/2024 19:15

Only on mumsnet do grandparents not babysit and people don't help out their family in general.

I suspect a lot of people on MN, like me, live nowhere near their families so babysitting isn't an option.

ungarden · 06/03/2024 19:14

I think of my friend's ds who is 33 years old and thinks it's his mum's duty to look after him - pay 10% deposit on his flat and always help when he asks. I am not that kind of mum. I expect help from them and they can expect help from me. I am not a servant. Adults need to adult. I do not plan on my kids looking after me in old age and they should not plan on expecting a healthy inheritance.

TheMushroomFamily · 06/03/2024 19:14

Wellhellooooodear · 06/03/2024 19:12

Only on mumsnet do grandparents not babysit and people don't help out their family in general. It's actually pretty depressing if this is really the case for some people and I would have to ask them what the fuck is the point of having a family it this is your attitude?

Oh please it’s not only a MN thing at all. Believe it or not there are grandparents that won’t help with their grandkids just because you are lucky enough to not have that experience doesn’t mean it’s made up 🙄

Goneback2school · 06/03/2024 19:13

Not a duty, especially if the relationship is dysfunctional. In normal healthy relationships the care and support should be reciprocal because both want to help out the other.

Ahugga · 06/03/2024 19:13

It depends entirely on the relationship. Aside from a complete lack of interest in my children, I don't think my mother has ever said a kind word to me. I certainly won't be doing much for her in her old age. I feel almost entirely indifferent towards my dad - he was absent growing up, he's absent now.
So no, I don't think children have a duty to care for elderly parents. But if there's a good relationship they would probably want to.

EC22 · 06/03/2024 19:13

My mum has supported throughout my whole life. Financially as well as emotionally and by providing childcare. When she needs me as she ages I will support her as much as I can.

Fernsfernsferns · 06/03/2024 19:12

I expect to help my own parents a bit.

they did not do childcare for us.

but they are planners. They’ve downsized already and thought fit and active have done all the power of attorney stuff and are taking with me about what they want.

one is telling which home they like if they need it. Though I will also suggest looking at ones closer to me and I’m considering the right time to do this.

i would not do care myself or have them live with me, though I know I’ll have to help organise and supervise third party care and run their finances etc down the line.

PIL have downsized but are in denial about the need to plan for care. They have funds but seem to think it’s only other people that need care or to live into a home.

But they live in another country so not my problem. DH has some tricky moments in the future

CountryMumof4 · 06/03/2024 19:12

I'd do absolutely anything for my parents, as they would for me. They're not in a position to do much to help with the kids these days, as they're older and not 100% well, but I don't view this as some kind of transaction. Just because they can't do much for me childcare wise, I'll do all I can for them. They've always been incredibly supportive and, despite the odd mini ruction, still very much my parents in the sense that they care enormously about us and our lives, and are kind and thoughtful.

As others have said, I suspect it possibly depends on the relationship you have with them though. There's probably no right or wrong answer.

Wellhellooooodear · 06/03/2024 19:12

Only on mumsnet do grandparents not babysit and people don't help out their family in general. It's actually pretty depressing if this is really the case for some people and I would have to ask them what the fuck is the point of having a family it this is your attitude?

Mumof2NDers · 06/03/2024 19:12

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 19:10

I was the same with both my parents. I won the parent lottery and I felt it was a privilege too.

Another parent lottery winner here!
My DM and late DF are/were the most amazing parents and grandparents.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/03/2024 19:11

No, I don't think children should automatically support their elderly parents, it completely depends on the individual relationship but my mum has been a brilliant mum so I help her when I can despite living about 300 miles away.

Me and DH are saving for our possible future care so that our DD doesn't have the dilemma.

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 19:10

Marblessolveeverything · 06/03/2024 19:04

Nobody should do things because of duty in my opinion.

I cared for my mum up to her death alongside my siblings, because she was our amazing mum. She always did what she could for us, while respecting us as adults. It was a privilege to look after her.

I was the same with both my parents. I won the parent lottery and I felt it was a privilege too.

TheMushroomFamily · 06/03/2024 19:10

No I won’t be