Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think children have a duty to help out elderly parents?

192 replies

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

OP posts:
Startingagainandagain · 06/03/2024 20:13

No.

Kids don't ask to be born, you don't choose your parents and there is no duty to care for them.

I completely understand though that some people choose to help as much as they can especially if they have a loving relationship with their parents.

But it should be a personal choice, not something that you are guilt tripped into doing or something that society automatically expects, especially of women.

I am no contact with my mother, never had any love for her due to her controlling and abusive behaviour and her failure to protect me from my father's violence. No intention of caring for her or to ever see her again.

mano24 · 06/03/2024 20:13

Yes - In our culture we are expected to look after our elderly when they are old. However, Grandparents will help out as much as they can with their Grandkids too.

SallyWD · 06/03/2024 20:11

As long as your parents were loving and good parents then why on earth wouldn't you want to help them when they're old and frail?
Of course you don't have to but it's not about doing it out of duty. It's about wanting to do it out of love.
A loving family help each other out in their hours of need.
Of course I didn't ask to be born but that doesn't mean I don't love my parents and appreciate all they've done for me. I simply couldn't ignore them when they need me because of love. Nothing to do with obligation or duty.

EarringsandLipstick · 06/03/2024 20:07

AuntieMarys · 06/03/2024 19:07

Not at all. They are adults and should have made provision for themselves

God, that's harsh.

YireosDodeAver · 06/03/2024 20:06

They don't have a duty to. Some do and if that works for that individual that's great.

Grandparents are not obliged to provide babysitting, some do and some don't.

I'll be happy to go round with a toolkit and do odd diy jobs about the home if my dad gets too frail to do it but I think he'd rather pay a professional.

When needs get more difficult, I think both my parents would prefer to keep the undignified aspects of personal care (eg bottom wiping and dealing with other unpleasantness) done by someone whose job it is to deal with those things and is paid appropriately, and not have those grim moments be part of the parent-child interaction. Much nicer for us to spend what time we have together unshadowed by such things.

Crunchymum · 06/03/2024 20:05

I'd be very interested to hear the relationship dynamics for the people who said an emphatic no?

I can't imagine people who have a loving, healthy relationship with their parents not wanting to help them as the age. Obviously logistics play a part (you can to be expected to relocate if you live a distance away for example) and once care needs reach a certain level then professional help needs to be put in place but the outright no's on this thread are surprising.

I only have my dad but I'll happily help with any care needs that arise and the same for my FIL and MIL. They've been such supportive and positive influences in my life, I couldn't imagine not being around to help.

Caveat to say I live close and both myself and DP have big families so I know any caring responsibilities in the future won't fall 100% to me.

Mary46 · 06/03/2024 20:05

Depends where people live too op. 24/ 7 care is alot different to calling in. We help our mam but have our own lives too...

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 06/03/2024 20:04

I had an abusive mother. I am still just sorting through my emotional responses to her and im 58.
When she was very ill and then in hospital I had to do caring and it was very hard. I couldn't leave things to my cousins and aunts. But I tell you what when I had news she was dead I felt happiness. Parents and children have different relationships depending on how the adults parented.
I would never tell anyone they had to look after a parent. You don't know how that person treated their children when they were dependent and vulnerable.

mouse70 · 06/03/2024 19:58

I cared for and supported both my parents ,together with my brother ,as their health and abilities declined until they died.It was our way of showing our love for them. We were lucky that we had wonderful parents and happiest upbringing and lived close by.BUT had they been terrible parents no way would I have cared for them. In my opinion you reap what you sow.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/03/2024 19:57

So the obligation of parents to their children never ends? I can’t agree with that, once they are independent adults I have no responsibility for them. Love, care and concern absolutely and I’d want to help them out of love rather than duty and I hope they’ll feel the same way about me if I need help.

Thepossibility · 06/03/2024 19:57

My dad is an abuser so he will get nothing.
I personally think my DM two golden children should take care of her in her old age, because she's done so much for them over the years.
They won't though, it will fall to my other sister. She's already planning a granny flat in her garden for DM and her MIL. DM did fuck all for her growing up as well.
I've told my MIL we will care for her because she was an excellent and doting mother.

Wellhellooooodear · 06/03/2024 19:55

TheMushroomFamily · 06/03/2024 19:14

Oh please it’s not only a MN thing at all. Believe it or not there are grandparents that won’t help with their grandkids just because you are lucky enough to not have that experience doesn’t mean it’s made up 🙄

My parents live 200 miles away so I've never had help although my mum would have helped if we lived close by. Maybe it's not just on mumsnet, but certainly on here there are a lot of people who just come across as selfish, inflexible and plain weird. I can understand if someone has a bad relationship with their parents obviously, but most people I know would put themselves put for their loved ones.

TorroFerney · 06/03/2024 19:55

Wizzadorra70 · 06/03/2024 19:50

Looking after my Dad while he was dying wasn't a duty. It was a privilege. He wasn't perfect by any stretch but he was my Dad and I loved him unconditionally.

I think it's about you as a person, not what someone has done for you.

So if you've been born into an abusive family and suffered because of that, and that means you don't want to help say the father who sexually abused you - that says something about you? I don't understand, the inference usually when someone says that is that the "you" they are referring to is wrong/lacking but you can't mean that? But that can't be what you mean ?

coldcallerbaiter · 06/03/2024 19:54

I do not believe in giving up your life to look after parents, but I would keep an eye out for their interests once vulnerable and would expect the same of my children. Parents should put aside funds for care and security but if they cannot manage their arrangements or lose marbles, I would want to make sure that the practicalities are covered.

Thighdentitycrisis · 06/03/2024 19:53

There’s different kinds of helping.
I would like to think my DC is a person who helps others by nature but I don’t think they are

my parents never wanted to ask for help, they never expected it. I wouldn’t expect it either

So YABU no, they don’t

echt · 06/03/2024 19:51

As usual, the first reply nailed it.

Wizzadorra70 · 06/03/2024 19:50

Looking after my Dad while he was dying wasn't a duty. It was a privilege. He wasn't perfect by any stretch but he was my Dad and I loved him unconditionally.

I think it's about you as a person, not what someone has done for you.

HeddaGarbled · 06/03/2024 19:50

I don’t see it as duty. I help because I love them and don’t want to see them inadequately cared for or at risk of harm.

Babysitting so that two competent adults can work or go on holiday or have nights out, is not comparable, IMO.

RickyGervaislovesdogs · 06/03/2024 19:50

Noicant · 06/03/2024 19:01

I think it’s more whether they were good parents to you that matters. Thats what would motivate me, not whether they babysat for me.

This^ I love my mum (dad too but he passed away from cancer) So just DM left. She’s 82 and would do anything for me/us. Of course occasionally things get on my nerves a bit, but I’d never say it. (I work full time and she needs help with a few things, plus loves a pub lunch once a week- bit samey).
She has babysat, including overnight but I do feel it’s a bit much and don’t put on her. (She says she wants to).

She lives alone, does alot for herself, she’s on the internet! She doesn’t put on me, tries not to. Recently the G.P ran some tests which point toward cancer, I may not have her much longer.

BruFord · 06/03/2024 19:50

@MintyCedric Your balanced approach sounds very healthy. I have to keep some boundaries with my Dad, he views me as his emotional rock and dumps all his problems on me, which can be hard. He’s elderly and not very well though.

LovelyTheresa · 06/03/2024 19:49

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

It entirely depends on circumstances, but I do not think that children have an inherent obligation to care for elderly parents. I think that in loving families, it is a question of love rather than obligation. In a less loving family, where parents have been cold and unsupportive, I see no reason why their children should look after them. One shouldn't have children as a de facto retirement home. Parents have an inherent obligation to care for children, as those children did not ask to be born. The same is not true the other way, although a loved child usually wants to look after their parents.

ViciousCurrentBun · 06/03/2024 19:45

As long as no abuse then I think families should help each other. It seems pretty obvious you don’t like your parents. Whether that’s because they were abusive or a personality clash is your business. I assume you will be fine with your children doing zero for you when you are elderly.

Bex5490 · 06/03/2024 19:44

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:59

My view - children owe their parents nothing. The children didn't ask to be born, parents didn't have to have them, they chose to bring more human beings into the world just because they wanted to. But parents do have a duty to their children and this doesn't just end at 18. This isn't to say GP should give up work to be full time carers for GC either, just that things are much harder for young people now so we should help them were we can.

My age, for context, mid 50s, young adult/late teen children, elderly parents. I never recieved a single day of help with my children from my parents (nor would I have left my children with them though if they had offered). I don't/won't help my parents. They live other end of country anyway.

You don’t feel responsible for helping your parents because I’m guessing they haven’t been particularly supportive to you over the years.

If your parents have been loving good parents then yes I think we owe it to them to look after them.

If you have had a healthy relationship with parents I don’t think you feel like you owe it to them, I think you want to do it because you don’t want them to suffer.

Dacadactyl · 06/03/2024 19:44

Yes I think children should help their elderly parents. What this looks like in practise will depend on a number of factors.

I do not however think parents owe their children childcare.

I'm 38 and don't anticipate needing to help my parents for a while yet. My kids are 17 and 11 so I will likely be working FT by the time they have children.

MintyCedric · 06/03/2024 19:42

Honestly I think it’s nice if it works both ways but there are a million and one factors as to why it might not be feasible and you can only call it based on your own experience.

My parents have always been practically and financially supportive. My dad was basically my soul mate…we had virtually everything in common and never had a cross word. My mum is great in many ways but emotionally needy and quite challenging. Our relationship is good in that we will always have one another’s backs but there is not the same level of connection or understanding there.

I cared for my dad on end of life for 15 months, I would have done even more for him if I could have done but as mum was next of kin I wasn’t able to do things as I would have wanted to in different circumstances.

I will do as much as I can for my mum for as long as I can, but I will not sacrifice my physical or mental health to do so and if I have to put boundaries in place I will, although I hope we never reach that stage.