Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think children have a duty to help out elderly parents?

192 replies

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

OP posts:
ExPostFacto · 06/03/2024 21:38

Misthios · 06/03/2024 21:10

These threads always make me laugh. All the people saying that of course they’d “care” for a parent as to them care means popping to Tesco, picking up a prescription or running the hoover round. Helping out things which don’t impact at all on their lives. They don’t mean that they are prepared to be 24/7 carers for a parent who has some sort of condition which requires personal care with washing and toileting. They haven’t a clue.

Are we reading the same thread? Most people have acknowledged the difference!
The title is about helping. Not caring the way you describe it.
The grandparent equivalent would be providing frequent childcare vs taking the kids once in a while to give their parents a break, or in an emergency. Avoiding the former is OK, but it'd be IMO quite selfish to not do the latter, if able.
I won't be able to provide a high level of personal care should the worst happen but I'm not just going to leave it all to to social services. Visiting them, organising care, interacting with services etc on their behalf all of these are helping too.

SultanOfSwing · 06/03/2024 21:30

People have a duty to each other. Especially families.

Growlybear83 · 06/03/2024 21:29

I meant to say that my mother in law never helped out with childcare for us and it was never expected. My mum was always willing to help out with looking after my daughter if necessary m, and of course I was happy to support her in whatever way I could when she got older and when she also developed dementia.

BruFord · 06/03/2024 21:28

@Misthios Yes, and to clarify what I said upthread about feeling a duty to support my Dad, I wasn’t talking about moving him into my house and doing day-to-day caring. I did once when he was recovering from an operation, I.e., in an emergency, but I wouldn’t do it for years. I agree with the many posters saying that adult children shouldn’t be expected to upend their lives unless they actually want to.

Adult children can be supportive in small ways that make their elderly parents’ lives easier-regular phone calls and visits; helping them do things online if they’re not confident with computers; arranging help if they need it, such as a cleaner.

You don’t need to be a martyr, just do a bit more than visiting them once a year at Christmas, for example!

Growlybear83 · 06/03/2024 21:26

I suppose I don't think it's necessarily a duty to help out your parents, but unless there are very exceptional circumstances, I think you would have to be incredibly hard hearted and inhuman not to help a parent when they are old and in need of support, and I really wouldn't want to know anyone who could ignore an elderly relative in their time of need.

My mother in law has done some terrible things over the 50 years that I've known my husband and has been a truly horrible woman for much of her life, but once she began to really need help, particularly once she began to develop dementia, I couldn't have ignored her and left her to fend for herself. She's now bedridden in a nursing home , completely incontinent, can't feed herself, and has very advanced dementia but I couldn't mine myself if I didn't visit her regularly and advocate for her as much as possible.

FinallyFeb · 06/03/2024 21:21

My DM didn’t do any childcare for me, I paid a local person to babysit in the evenings if I went out.

For the past five years I’ve cared for her, she’s in a nursing home now.

Londonrach1 · 06/03/2024 21:20

No they don't. You no idea of previous history. Without going into past history my parents were ...ok..it's hard to explain..but even aged 15 I got beaten by a slipper and had things stabbed into me so hard I bleed. I felt I deserved it at the time as I was hungry and eat the last bit of bread it's only later I realized I didn't. If you ever meet my parents you never image it and you think I'm cruel for not visiting them weekly. I visit every month of so for a day. I made peace with what happened but I never want a duty to them. I know others who say the same.

Notchangingnameagain · 06/03/2024 21:17

My parents were/are good parents.

They provided zero childcare due to other commitments.

I would, without doubt, provide them with all the care and support they need as they age. As would my siblings.

I don’t think children who don’t provide care and support signify that their parents weren’t/are good parents.

Some people don’t want too, can’t or just don’t have the skills or the capacity. That too is absolutely ok.

Misthios · 06/03/2024 21:14

I also very much resent the implication that for people who are not prepared to move mum into the spare room or do all the toileting for dad, it’s because their parents were a bit rubbish and they just don’t love them enough.

SailingStormyWaters · 06/03/2024 21:12

My Mum has been a complete let down yet l couldn't see her struggle. She hasn't helped me at all, yet l don't have it in me not to help.

Lostatsea10 · 06/03/2024 21:11

I would move heaven and earth when/if my DM needs care. Nothing will be too much trouble, nothing is too much trouble now and would always drop everything to help her. She can live with us, I will advocate for her, administer personal care and all she needs. She was and remains to be an incredible mother and I’m blessed to have her.

DF, couldn’t care less who cares for him or what happens to him. Not my problem.

blueyblankets · 06/03/2024 21:10

No one asks to be born but if you had good parents who loved and willed you into the world then yes, I think you have responsibility toward them. The relationship might have broken down or one or more parents have become a closet narcissist (a MN favourite) but if you loved your mum or dad then yes, I think you have a duty of care to make sure they are ok.

We don't necessarily have to do the care ourselves but overseeing the care, alongside making sure they're safe is important

Misthios · 06/03/2024 21:10

These threads always make me laugh. All the people saying that of course they’d “care” for a parent as to them care means popping to Tesco, picking up a prescription or running the hoover round. Helping out things which don’t impact at all on their lives. They don’t mean that they are prepared to be 24/7 carers for a parent who has some sort of condition which requires personal care with washing and toileting. They haven’t a clue.

Meadowfinch · 06/03/2024 21:09

It depends. I have raised ds alone. We are very close. I expect him to head off to university soon. I'll retire.

I shall be very hurt if he can't manage a weekly phone call but it will be his decision. I hope he still wants to spend time with me. I don't think I'll have done a very good job at parenting if he can't be bothered with me.

I won't expect him to look after me though. I have made as much provision as I can for old age and would hate him to feel restricted. He might have to be a trustee but hopefully, not too tough.

Cyclebabble · 06/03/2024 21:09

So I am ethnically Indian. We tend to have stronger support bonds. Culturally we support our elders and there is support for young mothers. Mostly this works well for us and support comes from wider family (so Aunts and Uncles will also be part of the care provision). On occasion it can cause some tension. Lots of relatives in your house at short notice would not suit everyone, but I like it.

Universalsnail · 06/03/2024 21:05

Yes unless there's good reason. I think it's part of being a family. I find there's a real common thing at the minute where older people are insisting they do not have to care for Grandchildren ever despite having often received the help from their parents I know so many people whose parents won't help and yet their parents helped them. My grandparents looked after us regularly and my parents will help me out once in a blue moon. I have to be honest it makes me want to help them in old age less but I will still do it because I think family are meant to help each other. I think the increased idea that families do not care for each other pretty toxic.

And when I say help out I don't mean so everything or he main caregiver. It's unreasonable to expect grandparents to have their grand kids all the time and it's unreasonable to expect a child to become your carer when you are ok but yes I do think we should help where we can.

SD1978 · 06/03/2024 21:04

No they don't. Nobody owes anyone anything- your parents don't owe you childcare, and you don't owe them end of life support. However you would hope that you have a relationship where to an extent you're both willing to support each other in stages in your life where you need it.

1960swhatshappened · 06/03/2024 21:02

Mumof2NDers · 06/03/2024 19:09

It totally depends on the family dynamic surely?
My DM looked after mine when they were little while I worked FT, I’ll be eternally grateful to her for it and will drop anything and everything if she needs me to.
My late DF was ill for a while before he passed, I’ve done stupid o’clock in the morning rushes to their house when he’s hypo’d and my mum panicked. I’ve spent all night with him in A&E and then gone straight to work. During lockdown I took him for cancer treatment every day for 5 weeks.
My DM doesn’t even need to ask, if she needs to go somewhere I’ll take her.It’s just what we do in our family but I appreciate not every family is the same.

Exactly how I feel. I dropped everything to help my Mum because she was the most selfless lady ever !

canttellyouwhereorwhatido · 06/03/2024 21:01

For example my mother and step dad were excellent in all ways .. so providing help in their older age was an honour .. if they were nasty abusive arsed then ..no

You reap what you sow..

Skibbidino · 06/03/2024 21:00

Families should help each other
But not when there is abuse

Justcallmebebes · 06/03/2024 20:59

Wellhellooooodear · 06/03/2024 19:12

Only on mumsnet do grandparents not babysit and people don't help out their family in general. It's actually pretty depressing if this is really the case for some people and I would have to ask them what the fuck is the point of having a family it this is your attitude?

This. This thread is really depressing

ALunchbox · 06/03/2024 20:59

No, I absolutely do not expect my DC to look after me in my old age. They're free to live their lives. I will not be a burden.

I will help my parents if they need me. Not because I have to or because they want me to, but because I want to.

canttellyouwhereorwhatido · 06/03/2024 20:58

If they were good to you then be good to them .. only you know where that line lays

millymoo1202 · 06/03/2024 20:58

I won’t be, my Mum wasn’t interested in us as children and showed zero interest in us as adults. Often wonder why she had 3 children, she wonders now why no one bothers with her, quite sad really. I do my duty visit every few months but that’s it, sounds harsh I know but yju can’t write off 50 years of being a ru bush parent

singleagainn · 06/03/2024 20:57

Noicant · 06/03/2024 19:01

I think it’s more whether they were good parents to you that matters. Thats what would motivate me, not whether they babysat for me.

I agree with this, it’s how your parents brought you up, nothing to do with childcare. My mum was always clear that she had done her childcare and didn’t want to be childcare for grandchildren. That didn’t mean that she didn’t enjoy being a gran and having a lovely relationship with them. When she was ill, I took care of her and it was a privilege to do so. I really don’t understand the entitlement of some people, particularly on mumsnet, believing that GP owe them childcare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread